While the existing scholarship on Uncle Tom's Cabin has provided a variety of close-up examinations of the play's impact at a specific time or place, few studies attempt a survey of the full history of the countless iterations of the dramatization of Stowe's novel. John W. Frick's “Uncle Tom's Cabin” on the American Stage and Screen accomplishes this task admirably while maintaining the fine-grain detail typical of other more close-up examinations. Covering major theatrical and cinematic adaptations from the 1850s to the early twenty-first century, Frick deftly mixes primary source detail, historical context, and critical insights from contemporary scholars. In his opening, he outlines his three goals for the book: first, to create a narrative of each major production; second, to place that production within the historical and social contexts of its era; and third, to consider the production within the larger landscape of American entertainment history. The result is an accessible, straightforward account of Uncle Tom's Cabin filled with both broad observations and small details.
Chapter 1 begins with an overview of the social and historical underpinnings of “Tom Mania,” including the release and impact of Harriet Beecher Stowe's novel as well as the early manifestations of the story on the American stage. It is here that Frick does his heaviest theoretical lifting, analyzing the moral, religious, racial, and economic implications of Uncle Tom's Cabin and its journey from page to stage. These investigations are well supported by the work of numerous contemporary scholars, who are thoroughly referenced and quoted throughout. Ultimately making use of Bruce McConachie's genre of “moral reform melodrama” (24), Frick's first chapter lays the groundwork for the chronologies to come, demonstrating the ideological qualities—potential and realized—of Uncle Tom's Cabin in its many early performed iterations.
Chapters 2 and 3 focus on the two foundational 1852 dramatizations: the Aiken–Howard version, more faithful to Stowe's abolitionist intentions, and the watered-down Conway–Kimball–Barnum version. In these chapters Frick demonstrates an impressive and relentlessly thorough eye for detail. Quotes from various contemporary reviews give a clear flavor of the reaction to each production, and other historical tidbits such as cast lists, run dates, actor biographies, various regional opinions, and even set design details paint a clear picture of the production from numerous perspectives. Additional secondary scholarship fills in vital historical and critical perspective such as audience composition, adaptation methodologies and results, financial realities, and broad impacts on or reflections of American theatregoing. The narrative of these two chapters demonstrates how the theatrical version of Stowe's story captured the public imagination in a way that the novel never could have. Additionally, Frick accurately addresses the broader impact of the play, as “Uncle Tom on stage instantly became the site of competing sectional interests, [. . .] one in which two diametrically opposed positions on slavery squared off against one another” (105).
With this groundwork thoughtfully laid, Frick's final three chapters continue on with similar methodology and analysis, examining a staggering variety of productions in three different eras and contexts. Chapter 4 considers the numerous touring productions of Uncle Tom's Cabin throughout the remainder of the nineteenth century. Sections in this chapter mainly examine specific manifestations of the play and draw historical conclusions from these, as in “Dan Rice and Uncle Tom in New Orleans.” Other sections compile numerous examples of various production trends. “Seeing Double,” for example, briefly chronicles the fashion for productions with double characters—“Two Toms, two Topsys, two Legrees, two Marks” (131). Chapter 5 covers major twentieth-century stage productions, further tracking the ever-expanding variety of alterations to—and in many cases parodies of—the original story. Additionally, this chapter traces the show's gradual fade out of the spotlight of the American consciousness. Chapter 6 tracks the show's history on film, from its earliest manifestations as a silent movie to a $2.6 million 1927 version and beyond. Frick makes excellent use of film historians to analyze the importance of each production and place it within its greater entertainment context. As with the early parts of the book, Chapters 4–6 are extremely well supported with a variety of primary source materials including production photos, posters, and reviews, as well as recurring secondary analysis regarding the historical and cultural import of the various trends and intentions of each era, trend, or individual production. Frick's post-1850s history of Uncle Tom's Cabin not only sheds light on this country's ever-shifting opinions regarding slavery and racial politics, but also paints a wonderfully detailed picture of the almost absurd number of variants on the original story. Essentially, if there is an interpretation, spin-off, imitation, parody, or outright mutilation of Stowe's story that can be imagined, it has been seen on the American stage or screen.
Frick closes his book with a brief examination of a handful of twenty-first-century stage productions of Uncle Tom's Cabin, which, though lacking the detail of his previous examinations, serves to demonstrate that the issues raised by Stowe's story are still compelling stage material today.
In addition to the tremendous detail provided throughout, “Uncle Tom's Cabin” on the American Stage and Screen as a whole illustrates the degree to which “Tom Mania” pervaded American popular culture. The on-the-ground detail of the volume as well as its clear situation of the play in a variety of historical and entertainment contexts make it essential reading for anyone who teaches this play or who seeks to make new historical or analytical investigations of the relationship between Uncle Tom's Cabin and American culture.
