What is the connection between slavery's undoing and the construction of citizens’ rights in the creation of republican states? How did abolition and slave emancipation shape citizenship, and in what ways was freedom's normative role affected by social and economic pressures in nineteenth-century Latin America? Jason McGraw addresses these core conceptual questions in The Work of Recognition through a deep and multi-faceted historical study of Caribbean Colombia in the second half of the nineteenth century.
McGraw's study is aptly framed by questions of Atlantic historiography that have, up to now, been mostly explored from the perspective of Haiti and Cuba. By focusing on another site of decolonisation and abolition, Colombia, McGraw brilliantly expands our knowledge of both processes. He shows how looking beyond the better-studied plantation societies, and extending the time frame into the post-emancipation years, brings another layer of complexity to our understanding of the diversity of experiences involved in the abolition of slavery and state formation.
For its deep exploration of the connections between race and citizenship, The Work of Recognition is also a very welcome contribution to Colombian historiography. In recent years, scholarship produced in the United States on the Caribbean region of Colombia has seen important developments in the works of Aline Helg and Marixa Lasso, which focused on the independence process. McGraw takes us into the formative period following independence, when tensions heightened as the transformative role of emancipation produced a potent mixture of the value of freedom and the institutional construction and expansion of political rights. In other words, McGraw does not believe that the aftermath of abolition should be regarded as unimportant because of the assumption that racism's legacies curtailed liberty's promises. His study shows how free people of African descent shaped national politics in deep and profound ways.
One of McGraw's fascinating accomplishments is the combination of multiple perspectives on the processes within which tensions for and against inclusion evolved. He recognises the contending views and practices of a multiplicity of actors, arguing that they all shared the principles of freedom and citizenship, and shows how and when alliances among them became central to evolving political dynamics in the Caribbean and beyond. Simultaneously, McGraw paints a dynamic picture of those changing attitudes and opportunities in a long frame of 50 years. Indeed, throughout that time the contest for power among liberals and conservatives, as well as the different paths of the Caribbean and other regions of Colombia, were determined by racial politics in a crucial way.
Through the lens of race, McGraw reveals the importance of two dimensions of the contest over democracy and constitutional guarantees of equality in Colombia during this period: first, the symbolic yet strongly ingrained lettered construction of the nation and rights and, second, labour practices as political spaces.
In post-emancipation Caribbean Colombia education played a role as a means both of inclusion and exclusion. McGraw's study focuses on the strategic role of the ‘lettered republic’ in protecting the status of elite men who based their pre-eminence on the production and control of an expanding print culture. From that platform letrados debated the project of school reform (some held roles in the state and could influence national laws) with a language of equality that was aligned with republican principles. Though race was officially erased and silenced as a language, at the same time these men were ambivalent toward the inclusion of the lower classes, and that ambivalence was implicit in their influential writings. These writers could either condemn illiterate citizens or create them as interlocutors; either way, as McGraw states, ‘rarely did they discuss how the equivocal growth rates in education and literacy continued to produce exclusions at the heart of the public sphere’ (p. 117).
There were, however, important exceptions such as Candelario Obeso, whose role and literary production McGraw thoroughly explores. He shows how Obeso produced work that could be defined as countercostumbrismo literature. Costumbrismo, as is well known, was a literary genre that depicted the lower classes as part of the nation, especially people of colour, while portraying them as unfit for citizenship. Obeso, who was of African descent, wrote and disseminated texts with a clear potential to disrupt ingrained social hierarchies. He did this through a critique of the civilisation–barbarism dyad that structured social understandings of difference and inequality, implicit in costumbrista texts. Obeso further sought to recover orality and illiteracy as loci of vernacular post-emancipation visions and practices of citizenship.
McGraw also details the labour practices of people of African descent, as well as their involvement in political parties and war. Both were spheres where they sought to be recognised as active citizens. The most visibly successful economic group in the Caribbean countryside were the bogas, boatmen who worked along the Magdalena river, which, at that time, was the main link between central New Granada and global trade. Elites sought to harness the bogas’ labour, as well as limit their control of that strategic trading space, and set out on a campaign to regulate their capacity for movement, labour and production. The elites justified their attempt to subordinate these rural populations in terms of their vision of a national goal to develop industry and expand the market economy.
Most of these confrontations involving elites and the popular classes did not benefit the latter, since the elites progressively relied on a vast criminalisation of the growing mass of disenfranchised people, labelling them as insurgents. This ultimately rationalised state violence and undermined the poor's potential requests for economic and political recognition. Even liberals, who had initially relied on the support of people of colour, distanced themselves from them fearing what they saw as the dangers of democracy. In response to this social crisis – which became more acute through the decades – even conservatives demanded social harmony; but they did so without acknowledging that the dispossession of the majority was the source of unrest (pp. 200, 213).
In Colombia, the lower classes reacted to this process by attempting to escape –sometimes literally, in a geographical sense – the consequences of their exclusion from voting and civil guarantees, their displacement from land and autonomous spheres of labour, and their daily oppression, which translated into poverty and hunger. McGraw points out that, even from their marginal positions, these popular sectors claimed their own definition of citizenship. They searched for justice and the rearrangement of the social order by refusing to pay taxes or by holding on to religious practices.
Most remarkably, in this work McGraw's deployment of the concept of recognition as a lens through which to analyse the struggle for citizenship among people of African descent in Colombia engages contemporary political theory that has shown how social justice, aside from being grounded in struggles for redistribution, has historically also been sought in the arena of the recognition of difference. The Work of Recognition is a sophisticated, original contribution to the political history of Latin America, the Atlantic world, and the African diaspora.
