Sir Martin Gilbert, the prodigious author of both popular and academic works on modern European and Jewish history, is best known for his multivolume biography of Winston Churchill and its numerous companion volumes and abridgments. His latest book, In Ishmael's House, is a cross-over work that falls between the scholarly and the popular. As with most of his books, this one is written with clarity and felicity of style. It is well annotated with footnotes that refer to most of the significant secondary literature and published primary sources. It is also graced with some good illustrations and includes a superb section of maps (pp. 356–74), most of which are drawn from his previously published, excellent historical atlases. That being said, In Ishmael's House is somewhat uneven, and it is my distinct impression that the final manuscript may have been put together in haste and without sufficient editing.
The first nine chapters in particular (pp. 1–126) are peppered with careless errors that could have been avoided with a modicum of fact checking. The very first page, for example, states that the “Babylonian Talmud was compiled more than two thousand years ago,” whereas it is generally dated from the first half of the third century of the Common Era. A few lines later, mention is made of Jewish gravestone inscriptions in Carthage from 813 bce. Although Carthage was indeed founded in that year, there is no evidence of any Jewish presence prior to 146 bce. On page 3, he has Josephus recounting the fate of Jews “after Bar Kokhba's failed Jewish revolt in 136 ce.” But Josephus died sometime after the year 100, and the passage to which Gilbert is referring deals with the aftermath of the first revolt against Rome, which was put down in 70 ce. On page 45, he states that in North Africa, Yaʿqub ibn Killis, the Fatimid vizier who helped plan the conquest of Egypt, “returned to Judaism,” which he certainly never did, though he maintained contacts with his former coreligionists and appointed a number of them to administrative positions in the bureaucracy. On pages 46 and 47, the Andalusian chronicler Abraham ibn Daʾud's romantic fantasy of the so-called “Four Captives” in his Sefer ha-Qabbala (Book of Tradition) is recounted as if it were actual fact, although it has been shown by Gershon Cohen and others to be an artistic creation to bolster Ibn Daʾud's historical vision of Divine Providence at work in Jewish history. On page 48, it is stated that in the early 11th century “the caliphate, that had ruled Spain from Granada, collapsed.” On the preceding pages, the capital of Umayyad Spain is correctly identified as Cordova. On page 49, it is stated that in 1066 “Samuel ibn Nagrela was assassinated along with his son, Joseph,” whereas Samuel had died of natural causes ten years earlier. Mention is made on page 68 of the Almohads being defeated in Spain in 1212 by “rival Muslim warriors.” However, the defeat of Muhammad al-Naʾir at the Battle of Las Navas de Tolosa (or al-ʿiqāb in Islamic historiography) was at the hands of a coalition of the Christian rulers of the Reconquista kingdoms. On page 75, mention is made of Rabbi Isaac Tzarfati's letter to his brethren in Ashkenazi Europe, inviting them to come to the more tolerant Ottoman Empire in the 14th century. Although historians disagree on the precise dating of the letter, all place it solidly in the 15th century. On page 114 under note 13, the opening of the Alliance Israélite Universelle school in Tangier is dated 1869, whereas 1864 is the correct date. These are but of few of the inaccuracies and/or typographical errors that run through this first section.
The first nine chapters also suffer from a number of interpretive or explanatory problems. Gilbert's discussion of the notion of jizya is unfortunately oversimplified and somewhat misleading on pages 21 and 22, where after citing the example of the tax on the Jews of Khaybar in the 7th century, he jumps directly to a case involving the 12th-century Fatimid Caliph al-Amir and gives no inkling of how the tax itself and the understanding of the Qurʾanic injunction (Sura 9:29) that it should be paid “out of hand and in a state of humility” evolved over time. The discussion of the Tanzimat era on pages 110 and 111 mentions a number of reforms but never mentions the Hatt-i Şerif or the Hatt-i Humayun specifically nor does it provide any real contextualization.
The second half of the book (Chap. 10–22, pp. 144–354) is considerably more satisfying and more in line with Sir Martin's usual standards. These chapters deal primarily with the 20th century, and the writer is clearly on more solid ground and in more familiar territory. He deftly portrays the cultural and economic successes of Jews during the interwar period against the background of events. The rise of Arab and Jewish nationalism on what was to be a collision course is given due attention—so too is the rise of fascism in Europe and its role as a contributing factor in rising anti-Jewish sentiments within the Arab and wider Muslim world. The chapters dealing with the post-World War II period, the creation of the State of Israel, and the mass exodus of Jews from the Muslim world are vintage Gilbert—detailed, vivid, and absorbing reading. He is much more an anecdotal rather than an analytical historian. He has a keen eye for revealing vignettes and makes very good use of personal memoirs, interviews, documentary testimonies, and private correspondence that put a dramatic, human face on events in which hundreds of thousands of people were swept up.
The final two chapters are very short sketches. Chapter 21, “The Search for Recognition” (pp. 325–34), deals with attempts of various diaspora groups such as World Organization of Jews from Arab Countries and Justice for Jews from Arab Countries to obtain recognition of the displacement and financial loss endured by Jews who were expelled or fled from Arab countries after the establishment of the State of Israel. Gilbert is fully cognizant that any such recognition and possible compensation will most likely only occur through a resolution of the Palestinian refugee question. Chapter 22, “Jews Who Remain in Muslim Lands” (pp. 335–54), very briefly touches upon some of the existing remnants of Jewish communities in predominantly Muslim countries. The lengthiest section (pp. 348–53) deals with one of the two largest of these communities, located in the Islamic Republic of Iran. Oddly enough, the equally large Turkish Jewish community receives no mention whatsoever. The survey of other communities is by no means even either. For example, Yemen, Tunisia, Afghanistan, and Egypt get more detailed coverage than Morocco, which has the largest and still best-off community in the Arab world today.
It is no easy task to write a survey of Jewish history in the Islamic world, much less in a single volume, due to the enormous expanse of historical time, geographical space, and cultural diversity. It is also difficult to find a balance between the polarities of the Golden Age approach of both the Wissenschaft des Judentums scholars of the 19th century and polemicists of anti-Zionist or anti-Israel persuasion in more recent times, on the one hand, and the persecution and pogrom approach of some strongly Zionist or pro-Israel partisans, on the other. While trying to portray both the positive and the negative sides of the Jewish historical experience in the Muslim world, Gilbert does tend to emphasize the latter at the expense of the former. Still, the book has much that is valuable, especially in its coverage of the turbulent events of the past eight decades. It ends with the “hope that this book will encourage a better understanding of the past and help to make possible a future that emulates only the best aspects of the past” (p. 354). This is indeed a noble hope. It is this reviewer's wish that Sir Martin would have elucidated these “best aspects” somewhat more.
