No CrossRef data available.
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 01 February 2005
Geneviève Gobillot, professor of Arabic and Islamic studies at Lyon-III University and specialist of the mysticism of the first four centuries of Islam, is the author of Les Chiites (1998) and a translation of al-Tirmidhi's Kitab Ghawr al-Umur, “Le Livre de la Profondeur des choses” (1996). In her latest work, La conception originelle, ses interpretations et functions chez les penseurs musulmans, she contextualizes the notion of fiṭra within the complex intellectual milieus it evolved with a historical analysis of the genesis and the development of its varied interpretations. These interpretations emerged out of debates (up to the 10th century) over the significance of fiṭra into seemingly contradictory interpretations that referred both to (1) God's universal religion (Abraham's) or to the spiritual element that everyone possesses; and (2) its exegetical understanding as the individual religion that Jews or Christians transmit to their children. Gobillot presents a historical, synthetic, and analytical study of the use of fiṭra in the reports (hadith) and the exegetical interpretations of the first centuries of Islam and focuses on the legal, theological, and mystical uses of its sole Qur

anic occurrence (Q:30.30). Gobillot provides a preliminary exploration of the various interpretations found in the nine Sunni canonical collections of reports where 110 citations, with many repetitions, amount to thirty-one different texts, with twelve different series of reports with similar meanings.
The work is divided into thematic sections that provide the semantic, historical, legal, and theological framework in which the notion was discussed. The first section, which serves as an introduction, explores and unearths the complex “network” of meanings and interpretations of fiṭra at the heart of the early developments of theological and legal discourses. The second section dwells on the semantic origin of the root “f-ṭ-r,” its derivatives, and their Qur

anic occurrences (Meccan/Medinan), and provides a number of examples that illustrate the coexistence of a number of semantic layers until the 15th century. The next section analyzes the earliest discussions about fiṭra that were related to the report “kull mawlūd yūlad

alā al-fiṭra” via the texts of Abu Hanifa, Ja

far al-Sadiq, and the proto-Isma

ili Umm al-kitab. The fourth section identifies legal problems associated with the report “kull mawlūd” about the status of the People of the Book, discussed by Ibn Hanbal, Shafi

i, Abu Dawud al-Sijistani, Ibn al-Jawziyya, Ibn Qutayba, and Ibn Taymiyya, and the polemics against the Qadaris and the Mu

tazilis over the killing of non-Muslim children. The section that follows presents theological problems raised by the same report, Mu

tazili discussions on the possibilities of God damning innocents—for example, Mankdim Sheshdiv, disciple of

Abd al-Jabbar and al-Maturidi's polemics against the Mu

tazili positions. Gobillot suggests that early legal and theological debates and polemics (end of the 1st century) revolved around the nature of predestination. The sixth section highlights the role of fiṭra in relation to the original pact of the prophets, found in some reports used by Tabari, and its use for the elaboration of a stronger notion of predestination, an interpretation that was opposed by Mu

tazilis and Shi

i theologians such as al-Sharif al-Murtada. An understanding of fiṭra as universally shared—for example, al-Tirmidhi—made it possible to associate fiṭra with the notion of intellect or light. Gobillot finds in the works of

Abd al-Jabbar, al-Tirmidhi, Ruzbahan Baqli, Isfarayini, Ibn

Arabi, Qashani, Ibn Taymiyya, Ibn Batta, and the Shi

i and Nizari traditions traces of this fiṭra-light. The next section explores the affinity between fiṭra and ṣibgha found in the reports about the fiṭra of Abraham. The eighth section discusses fiṭra and the soteriological role of Muhammad found in the mi

rāj traditions, the Shi

i notion of a primordial light associated with Fatima-Fatir, Tustari's Muhammadan light, Qummi, Kulayni, and Sunni Ruzbahan Baqli's appeal to fiṭra-light, which authors such as al-Tirmidhi, Ibn

Arabi, and Jili associated with the notion of universality and omnipotence of the divine. The next section explores the use of fiṭra within more secular and philosophical discourses that naturalize the notion with its embodiment in the four temperaments or natures—for example, Jahiz and Ibn Qutayba—but also the Ikhwan al-Safa

or al-Farabi, who understands it in terms of quiddity, and Avicenna, who identifies it with an individual substance.
Gobillot concludes with a historical perspective on the interpretative contexts of her hypothesis of a development of the use of fiṭra. She identifies two different “exegetical tendencies” (p. 130) within the theological and legal systems: the “universal” interpretation posits fiṭra as the commonly shared divine nature of all human beings, at least, within the monotheistic traditions, linking it with Abraham; while the “exclusive” interpretation posits fiṭra as a “primeval conception” that applies exclusively to Muslims and their children, affirming either freedom of choice or divine predestination. Gobillot concludes by noting that the Qur

anic verse about fiṭra originates in the context of an affirmation of a Meccan monotheism whose interpretative horizon is an absolute “Abrahamic ḥanīfiyya,” without opposition to Christians and Jews (p. 136). Her analysis illustrates the “porosity” of the boundaries that existed between these different interpretations, operating under theological, legal, and mystical considerations.
Gobillot's work is grounded in the analysis of primary sources. Each section begins with and dwells on the relevant Qur

anic verses and reports, making this work a rich source of important material. The limits of her project are set forth by her own stated goals to propose a preliminary investigation rather than a comprehensive, comparative, and exhaustive analysis of fiṭra (p. 130). Gobillot concludes by noting that various interpretations of fiṭra remained both within and went beyond traditional exegeses of the Scriptures. The merits of her work lie in its ability to highlight subtle interpretations and the (thematic) historical framework that maps out their development. Although footnotes are provided, a bibliography is lacking, which makes it difficult to locate sources.