A diverse set of contributions speaks to the many complex and contradictory facets of contemporary Brazil in this edited volume. Writing on the heels of massive social uplift and upheaval the authors identify shifts in representations of Brazilian society in television, film and social media. A wide range of subjects, theoretical engagements and methodologies are presented, from media critiques of recent films to ethnographic accounts of social movement dynamics. Editor Naomi Pueo Wood has arranged the book's eight chapters into three themed sections, as well as adding her own introductory and concluding reflections. Wood contextualises the contemporary Brazilian media landscape as a part of a society experiencing increased visibility, and responsibility, as an emerging global economic power while struggling with the legacies of socio-economic and racial inequality. This historical crossroads is marked by burgeoning middle-class fortunes accompanied by heightened insecurity, as well as by international mega-events met with popular discontent. The core argument of this collection, Wood thus suggests, is that the national myth of Brazilian unity through mixture has been replaced by a new narrative of social mobility that emphasises difference and distinct identities.
The first section of the volume addresses these myths and stereotypes of brasilidade, or Brazilianness. Gabriela Antunes reviews the history of US cinema portrayals of Brazil and Brazilians and finds recurrent tropes of leisure, criminality and irrationality. Carolina Rocha uses two popular biopics to argue that the story of upward social mobility has reshaped the Brazilian public imaginary. These two contributions to the volume draw attention not only to the effects of the foreign gaze and neoliberal individualist ideology on Brazilian identity but also to the capacity of film to critique and subvert those forces.
The second section focuses on representations of marginalised spaces and peoples in recent Brazilian film and television. In one of the book's most original and provocative arguments, Aline Frey suggests that the cinematic Brazilian street is portrayed as an enclosed space, and that the focus on marginal figures such as street children obfuscates the role of the ruling classes in perpetuating conditions of violence and precarity. Volume editor Wood's own chapter contribution studies race, gender and body disciplining in two documentaries protagonised by benevolent artist ‘saviours’ who seek to demonstrate to viewers the power of art as a liberatory vehicle for impoverished individuals. Cacilda Rêgo tracks the rising visibility of favela residents in Brazil's quintessential telenovelas (soap operas) as an index for a rising consumer class. Not only are favela dwellers taken to be the face of an expanding middle class but, riding a credit boom in the first decade of the twenty-first century, this same demographic, as viewers of these dramas, become valuable targets for product-placement advertising.
The third section turns thematically towards how new media figure in struggles against social inequalities. Mercedes Vásquez examines three popular films that foreground the liminal role of the police in the contentious maintenance of Brazilian class relations. In the book's only study of social media, Leonardo Custódio employs a symbolic interactionist approach to online reactions of two favela youths to human rights violations in their Rio communities. He connects their Internet activities to offline engagements as activists in civil society. The final chapter, by Anthony Pahnke on the Landless Workers Movement (MST) education programmes, is an odd inclusion for its focus on institutional structures and strategies rather than the role of media.
How this book identifies and captures a distinct historical moment in Brazilian cultural and political movements remains its biggest virtue, but it also represents a limitation. Ironically, as the authors analyse important examples of cultural production from the past decade or so, the reader is left to wonder how relevant or salient the arguments built upon these studied works will be in another decade or two. The nationwide street demonstrations of June 2013, as well as the 2014 World Cup and 2016 Olympic Games, are recalled continually throughout the book as a critical social moment, but without analytical acumen. As a result, the shallowness of these invocations somewhat undermines the book's general argument that the lens of popular media brings the complexity of Brazilian society into sharp focus. Another habit across most chapters is to render the relationship between media representations and social reality through a fast and loose citation of socio-economic indicators as a straightforward picture of a changing Brazil. The emphasis on treating media representations as texts to be interpreted maintains the dichotomy between image and real-world states of affairs. One author mentions, for example, that she attended screenings of the film Elite Squad 2 in Havana and Hong Kong (p. 120), but she avoids discussing how it resonated among different publics. Such reflections could render valuable sociological insights into the social life of media images.
These blindspots aside, Brazil in Twenty-First Century Popular Media is a valuable contribution in its unique scope and variety of perspectives contained within a slim volume. The chapters on documentary film by Wood, on cinematic marginality by Frey, on telenovelas by Rêgo and on favela youth online activism by Custódio stand out in particular as exceptional contributions. Either in its entirety or as selected chapters, this is a timely and accessible collection suitable for introductory Brazilian studies or media studies courses, especially if instructors also pair the readings with screenings of the films analysed in depth.
