Politics and the media are uneasy bedfellows at the best of times. In the context of profound political, economic, social and cultural change, their relationship is even more complex and, as three recent additions to the literature show, less predictable. Set against the backdrop of South Africa's political transition from apartheid to the current phase of democratic consolidation, they illustrate how the media function simultaneously as an arena and instrument of change, focusing on roughly successive historical periods: Krabill's monograph on apartheid-era television reaches from the 1970s to the first democratic elections in 1994; Olorunnisola and Tomaselli's edited volume on the transformation of the media sector takes us from the 1980s into the first decade of democracy; and Wasserman studies the relatively recent and fascinating phenomenon of local tabloid journalism in South Africa. It is notable that both Wasserman and Krabill base significant parts of their accounts on ethnographic research or at least a large number of qualitative interviews. This adds a level of analytical depth and originality to their case studies that is still rare in the literature on African media.
Wasserman's point of departure is that South African tabloids are in a rather peculiar position: they are shunned by a media establishment in the habit of projecting its own failings onto a welcome scapegoat, largely ignored by the ‘traditional’ middle-class print readership, and treated with similar reservations in academic circles. Yet they have been extraordinarily successful as a commercial venture (with the Daily Sun now the biggest-selling daily newspaper in the country (Wasserman 2010: 1)) and have managed to unlock a new market for print media in the process. The author makes a convincing attempt to explain this paradox, not least by questioning Western-liberal notions of quality in journalism against the backdrop of a transitional African society (ibid.: 144) and the particular needs and expectations of a new mass readership drawn from the ‘poor and working-class Black majority … that had hitherto been largely ignored by the post-apartheid mainstream press’ (ibid.: 1). Wasserman transcends normative debates on the role of media in democracies by treating tabloids ‘as social phenomena that tell us something about the society in which they exist and the role of media in that society’ (ibid.: xii). He concludes that despite, and partly because of, their failings and shortcomings (sensational journalism, factual errors, peddling of stereotypes around homophobia, xenophobia and racism, uncritical coverage of what critics would call ‘fiction’, such as witchcraft and accounts of ghosts), tabloids ought to be taken seriously as a response to wider political, economic, social and cultural changes (ibid.: 176). Of particular value here is the author's study of the professional identities of tabloid journalists and their interactions with the communities they report on, for and (usually) from (Ch. 7). The often close and reciprocal relationship between reporters and readers stands in contrast to news production processes in the mainstream media, centred around the much debated ideals of ‘neutrality’ and ‘objectivity’. These differences not only shed light on current South African media debates; they also raise questions about the ‘negotiation between African contextual imperatives and a globalized discourse of journalistic professionalization that positions itself as having universal validity’ (ibid.: 173). This is a thoughtful, refreshing and timely contribution to the South African and international media literature. It attempts to grasp tabloid journalism in all its dimensions: in its blatant commercialism, its social justice implications, its unpalatable eccentricity and sensationalism, its challenge to hierarchies of taste and cultural capital, and its role vis-à-vis the national journalistic field on the one hand and broader society on the other.
Krabill's Starring Mandela and Cosby: media and the end(s) of apartheid provides an unusual perspective on a phenomenon that may have been marginal in the bigger context of South Africa's transition towards democracy, but nevertheless adds an interesting view to the study of communication in authoritarian systems: the state media's unintended subversive potential (ibid.: 5). It proposes that the introduction of state-controlled television in the country, and the counter-intuitive success of the US-produced ‘Cosby Show’ among ‘the less overtly political collective of White South Africans’ (ibid.: 156) in the late years of apartheid, served as an unintended catalyst for a gradual shift in Whites’ identities, subjectivities and perceptions of the oppressed Black majority, particularly the latter's ‘structured absence in the nation’ (ibid.: 151). While alternative newspapers questioned the political status quo more directly, exposing segregated communities to the reality of the respective other via national public television, Krabill argues, helped pave the way psychologically for a politically and racially integrated society (ibid.: 5), and had a normalising effect: ‘Nelson Mandela became to politics what Bill Cosby had already become on television – a nonthreatening, reassuring Black presence that allowed White South Africans to rethink their processes of identification’ (ibid.: 152).
In contrast to the accounts of Krabill and Wasserman that are largely based on ethnographic work, the essays in Olorunnisola and Tomaselli's edited volume follow a more conventional but no less valuable path. This provides a multi-perspectival but largely structural account of media transformation in the new South Africa. Contributions range from analysis of local and continental policy frameworks and classical political economy discourse to racial stereotyping in advertising (Holt, Ch. 3) and critical discussions of the merits and shortfalls of Black Economic Empowerment (BEE) policies as government's attempt to reverse historically skewed racial ownership patterns in the economy, including the media sector (Tomaselli, Ch. 7; Boloka, Ch. 8; Evans et al., Ch. 9). The volume provides rich evidence of the intricate, conflicting and sometimes contradictory relationship between democratisation, economic transformation, and the positioning of the media sector in relation to both. However, the essays focus overwhelmingly on policy and structure when discussing media transformation, despite the editors’ and authors’ declared intention to take the study of the political economy of media transformation beyond questions of ownership, control and commercialisation (2010: 5). The book as a whole might have benefited from a more far-reaching and thorough engagement with the implications of structural transformation for processes of news production, media content and public discourse. Holt's discussion of the advertising industry (Ch. 3) demonstrates the merits of this approach, as does Wasserman's careful analysis of post-apartheid media discourses (Ch. 5), in which he shows how debates about the role of the media also serve to negotiate much broader identities, such as ‘Africanness’ (ibid.: 127). There is much to be gained from straying from the familiar path of structural determinism into the realm of agency, subjectivity and the creation of meaning.
All three books point to an extraordinary level of complexity and paradox in the media's role in relation to the South African political field. Whether we are dealing with tightly controlled apartheid-era television, profit-driven seemingly apolitical tabloids, or media policy frameworks, there is space for counter-discourse and even subversion. Regardless of the intentions of political and business elites, unintended, sometimes contradictory, consequences are a frequent occurrence. Following Krabill's argument, apartheid television, intended as a political tool to advance and entrench a racist ideology, came to create a ‘new communicative space’ (2010: 149) which, in some aspects, subverted the very idea of segregation it was meant to preserve. Various chapters in Political Economy of Media Transformation in South Africa illustrate that the normative ideal of media diversity is by no means an automatic outcome of democratisation, particularly against the backdrop of persistent economic inequality. In the South African case, structural reforms aimed at addressing the latter, such as BEE, may have resulted in tangible change, but not always the kind of change originally envisioned: ‘programs of reform terminate certain problems but create new ones’ (Olorunnisola & Tomaselli 2011: 262). Wasserman (2010: 87), finally, ventures the hypothesis that the South African tabloids, largely owned and driven by ‘White capital’, contribute to an emerging ‘alternative public sphere’. This alternative public sphere may be highly commercialised, but it allows a large part of the population that has been ignored and silenced by mainstream media to enter national public discourse. Curiously, it thereby helps fill the void left by the demise of the alternative anti-apartheid press, even though it quite deliberately defies the widespread professional assumption that the media are charged with holding government to account (ibid.: 175). The political relevance of the tabloids, Wasserman suggests, lies in their addressing the ‘politics of the everyday’ (ibid.: 178). Do they have a political role to play as such? This question he leaves ultimately unanswered. What is clear, however, is that their presence and continued growth is pushing South Africa's mainstream media towards a process of critical self-reflection.
It is to the credit of the authors and editors that none of the books confine their analysis of distinctly South African media phenomena to the national realm, but locate them instead in the context of the African continent and global dynamics. Krabill (2010: 14) illustrates how, even at the height of apartheid, ‘transnational media flows … [allowed] White South Africans … to appropriate the language and attitude of “racial tolerance” in the United States, while simultaneously conceptualising a profound difference between Black Americans and Black South Africans'. Compared with post-apartheid times, such effects of globalisation were still subtle. As the country democratised and its economy and media market emerged from international isolation, the consequences became much more pronounced (Olorunnisola & Tomaselli 2011: Chs. 2, 6, 7, 11). One consequence was the success of British- and Irish-inspired tabloids, built on the ‘glocalization’ (Wasserman 2010: 43) of this particular form of popular media which indeed ‘present a terrain where the meaning of culture, development, and democracy is contested between local and global forces’ (ibid.: 47).
While all three books reviewed here are worthwhile contributions to the literature on South African media, those by Wasserman and Olorunnisola & Tomaselli will also be of interest to the regional and global community of media scholars. Wasserman's and Krabill's studies may also appeal to a broader, non-academic readership.
