Chinese Sculpture follows 3000 Years of Chinese Painting, Chinese Architecture, and The Formation of Chinese Civilization as the fourth volume in the high profile series intended to highlight cooperative efforts between the finest art and cultural historians of China and the United States. The names George H.W. Bush, Henry Kissinger, and Nelson Rockefeller on the US Advisory Board bespeak the attention intended for these books. Four of the most outstanding scholars of Chinese sculpture were selected as authors, Angela F. Howard and Wu Hung representing the United States and Li Song and Yang Hong representing China. Their efforts are noteworthy. Chinese Sculpture not only is a serious scholarly achievement written for a serious but not necessarily scholarly audience, in addition, the illustrations and production of the book are of the highest quality.
Following the format of the other books in the series, Chinese Sculpture has two introductions, one by a Chinese author and the second by a US author. Li Song's essay begins with a statement that seems to be contradicted by the discussion of Neolithic sculpture in Chapter One. He writes, “. . . sculpture as the result of cutting or carving into stone or wood was not an art form indigenous to the Han Chinese . . . ” (p. 7) Building on this, he proposes that “sculpture in China can be seen as the interplay between foreign inspiration and elite support” (p. 7). Reading the nearly 500 pages that follow, it is hard to believe that Li himself subscribes to what he wrote. On p. 9, Li tells the reader that Khubilai Khan was the second Yuan emperor. Reckoning from Chinggis he was the fifth; otherwise, and according to many Chinese histories, he founded the Chinese dynasty known as Yuan. Khubilai (posthumously known as Shizu) in fact is listed as the first Yuan emperor in the chart in the introductory section of the book. Li also introduces major, dramatic finds of sculpture and the different kinds of sculpture to be discussed—funerary, Buddhist, and Daoist. Howard's introduction attempts to introduce the vocabulary of sculpture, the subjects of each author's essays, and the major type of sculpture associated with each period of Chinese history. The essays are parallel, but do not work together. They are the weakest sections of an otherwise spectacular book. Still, they set forth the organisation and presentation of the book: sculpture may be divided chronologically or thematically, with the major thematic division secular vs. religious.
The first chapter, by Wu Hung, focuses on Chinese sculpture from the Neolithic period through to the Han dynasty, or through the second century CE. It is a period for which new material emerges from the soil monthly. Wu begins the way Li should have, with terminology. He tells the reader that the Chinese characters for sculpture combine to mean “carving” or “modeling”. He then shows how these artistic forces were at work in China by the fifth or fourth millennium BCE. Through sixty-eight perfectly selected illustrations, Wu Hung narrates the history of China's earliest sculpture. He includes images with which many readers will be familiar, but he has new views of some on them and a few brand new images. The only direction in which Wu might have gone but did not would have been to China's outer edges. Sculpture of northernmost China and the impact of the Ordos region are represented only by the tiger biting the deer from the tomb of King Cuo of Zhongshan (Fig. 1.22) and no bronze from Yunnan is illustrated. Wu peppers his discussion with art history, talking about representation, abstraction, and realism. It is a strong, coherent chapter in which the reader learns about China's earliest art as well as many legends and literary passages behind it.
Chapter Two, by Yang Hong, deals with secular sculpture from Han through to the nineteenth century. Again the choice and quality of images is outstanding. Sometimes, however, Yang either takes liberties or errors have crept into the translation of his text. For instance, in discussion of the Four Directional Animals, a ubiquitous theme in Han and post-Han funerary art, he refers to a turtle riding on clouds. The figure, of course, is the Dark Warrior, a turtle around which entwines a two-headed snake (p. 139). On p. 170, in the discussion of the tomb Yongguling, he calls its occupant, Dowager Empress Feng, the grandmother of Emperor Xiaowen, when in fact, she was the mother. Most unfortunate, however, is the sinocentric posture of Yang's chapter. In his discussion of statues along the spirit paths of Song tombs (181–185), Yang refers to non-Chinese envoys as coming from vassal states. No country of South or West Asia, whose nationals these statues portray, was either subservient to or received protection from China during the period 960–1127. Then there is the reference to the two relief sculptures from Zhaoling, tomb of the second Tang emperor, in the Museum of the University of Pennsylvania. Yang writes that the sculptures were stolen. Not only has the University Museum published the bill of sale on these pieces,Footnote 1 it is noteworthy that of all the sculpture in museums outside of China mentioned or published in this book, these are the only ones whose departure from China is questioned.
Chapter Three, by Angela Howard, is strong from its first to last page. Howard begins with a discussion of proto-Buddhist sculpture, material that in recent years has come to be fairly well known in the Chinese art field, but still has not been incorporated into all the introductory books (200–207). There follows a discussion of Buddhist sculpture of the fourth and fifth centuries, much of it in situ, and more than half from the Hexi corridor of Gansu province. The Gansu material is even less well known than the proto-Buddhist images: sculpture from Jintasi, Binglingsi Cave 169, and Qingyang North Caves, all discussed in this chapter, is almost unpublished except in Chinese monographs. Further, the rock-carved images are discussed alongside portable statues in museum, as a coherent group. The chapter then proceeds to cave sculpture, freestanding images, and stele across China from the sixth century, from the capital city Luoyang to Qingzhou in Shandong to Chengdu in Sichuan. Similarly for the Northern Qi and Northern Zhou, sites through which Chinese sculpture of the period has long defined itself, such as Xiangtangshan and Maijishan, are part of this study, but here are examined alongside less well known cave-temples in Anyang county such as Xiao Nanhai and Northern Zhou sites in Ningxia and Gansu such as Xumishan and Lashaosi, respectively. Similarly, as one moves into the Tang and Song periods, Dunhuang caves and famous statues in museums of China, Japan, and the West are studied together with the cave-temples of Sichuan and Yunnan, not just those in the Dazu region, but Anyue, Leshan, Zizhong, and others in Sichuan, and sculpture of the Nanzhao and Dali kingdoms, and Bai, of Yunnan. It is hard to find a more evenly distributed, clearly written coverage of Buddhist and some Daoist sculpture of China's third through thirteenth centuries in approximately 150 pages, and certainly no comparable book or book section has such spectacular images. The Howard chapter is highly recommended for anyone who would like to see and learn about religious sculpture across all of China.
The last chapter, by Li Song, covers later religious sculpture. Li begins where he left off in the introduction, with a summary discussion of China's three faiths (Buddhism, Daoism, and Confucianism). He does this in order to make the point that religious syncretism occurred in the Song and later dynasties. Li then moves to several of China's monasteries where images remain or have been uncovered at the ruins—Yongningsi in Luoyang, Foguangsi on Mount Wutai, Zhengguosi in Pingyao, Huayansi and Shanhuasi in Datong, Longxingsi in Zhengding, and a few others. Some of the images could have been incorporated into Howard's chapter. Beginning on page 382, Li discusses types of images such as bodhisattvas, arhats, and historical figures of Buddhism; Daoist worthies and local deities; Esoteric Buddhist images; and Daoist images associated with the zodiac and cosmos. The chapter concludes with Buddhist, Daoist, and Sino-Tibetan Esoteric sculpture of the Ming and Qing dynasties. As in the earlier chapters, the illustrations are exquisite. Again the reader learns about sites little-published in western languages, such as Feilaifeng, near Hangzhou, in Zhejiang, Jade Emperor Temple in Jincheng, Shanxi, and Xiaoxitian, in Xixian, Shanxi. The iconography behind the statues is complex, such that interested readers will probably want to do additional reading.
Chinese Sculpture is a major and important contribution to the study of Chinese art and sculpture. Anyone interested in the subject will want to make sure he is familiar with every statue and site discussed, for they are likely to form the core images for the field for years to come.
