Il lavoro in Italia. Un profilo storico dall’Unità a oggi is Manfredi Alberti’s latest monograph. This book focuses on the evolution of labor in Italy from the Unity (1861) to the present day, prioritizing the cultural, political, and socio-economic changes that have shaped this country in the shift from a rural economy to a service-oriented society. The focus on these multifaceted changes makes this book highly interdisciplinary. For exploring in depth these changes that had a crucial impact on variables like employment and wages, Alberti adopted a twofold longitudinal perspective that embraces, on the one hand, the role of the State and its policies to improve (or not, in some cases) workers’ lives and their well-being, and, on the other, the status of the most vulnerable categories in the Italian labor market during those years, namely those of employees and salaried workers.
In this broad historical context that ranges from Unity to the present day, Alberti critically pointed out the joint impact of economic theories and political movements on labor dynamics, including tools such as statistical data and legislative sources for this analysis. Among the topics that Alberti addressed alongside these issues directly related to labor dynamics, there are the impact of migrations, gender stratification and inequality, the role of institutions, rights, and unions in the labor market.
These elements make this tale even broader than the title of the book suggests, creating also the possibility for the author to choose one of these topics for another successful work like this. I argue that these different levels of inquiry make this book interesting mainly for economic historians and historians of economic thought but also labor economists, scholars in gender studies, and so on. In this regard, the distribution this book is having in Italy is noteworthy, both within and outside a scholarly audience, as witnessed by the various invited book presentations that Alberti has recently had in different intellectual contexts that range from universities to museums. I firmly believe that Alberti’s book is effective mainly for his choice to practice a scientific (very rigorous) analysis of the historical evolution of labor in Italy—making this book a must-have on the shelves of the historians of economic thought and other specialists of labor economics—but adopting a very clear and pleasant narrative that makes the book accessible also to a more generalist intellectual audience. This is one of the main strengths of Alberti’s book.
Once the success of this book is acknowledged within and outside the community of the historians of economic thought and economic historians, you might still wonder why I decided to review a book written in Italian on the Italian modern history of labor in an international and specialized journal as is the Journal of the History of Economic Thought. The main reason is the relevance of this work for those scholars who might be quite familiar with the Italian language and are interested in the historical evolution of Italian labor economics. Although this focuses on a local context, these topics might be a subject of interest for international scholars who work on the Italian socio-economic historical context. At the same time, I hope that Alberti will consider translating this monograph also into English in order to make his research more accessible to international scholars.
Indeed, this book is located within a consistent existing literature and significantly contributes to its extension. Among the most recent works on the Italian history of labor, along with others, Stefano Gallo and Fabrizio Loreto (Reference Gallo and Loreto2023) offered a chronological analysis of the main economic, political, and social shifts that affected work in modern Italy, focusing on industrial relations, labor law, and the evolution of collective bargaining for shaping workers’ rights. Stefano Musso (Reference Musso2019), instead, privileged workers’ struggle, unions’ efforts, and the key legislative reforms from Unity to the 1970s, and the historical perspective of wartime labor and postwar boom through an extensive use of archives and personal stories, sometimes neglecting other theoretical frameworks in their narrative. Furthermore, Guido Cavalca, Enzo Mingione, and Enrico Pugliese (Reference Cavalca, Mingione and Pugliese2023) combined comparative history with statistical analysis, from the Industrial Revolution to the contemporary age, addressing classic themes (for instance, Fordism and Taylorism, and industry conditions) alongside the main digital-era changes to show their impact on employment.
The originality of Alberti’s book reviewed here—compared to these recent works on similar topics—is represented, under a methodological profile, by a strong interdisciplinarity that integrates the history of economic thought with resources brought from statistics, legislative texts, and so on to offer a long-term profile of Italian labor. Under a thematic profile, based on this interdisciplinarity, the book also offers insights about migrations, gender inequalities, and union struggles in front of the persisting phenomenon of precarious employment in Italy.
In addition, Alberti probably provided the deepest and broadest theoretical overview among these books for historians of economic thought (and beyond), considering the above mentioned multifaceted analysis of the changes that affected the historical evolution of Italian labor. In this regard, Gallo and Loreto (Reference Gallo and Loreto2023) appear to be more oriented to sociologists and political historians in their perspective. Musso (Reference Musso2019) might be an ideal book for students and general reading, through his introductory history of labor. Cavalca, Mingioni, and Pugliese (Reference Cavalca, Mingione and Pugliese2023) wrote a concise but highly specialized book about digital-era transformations but mainly oriented to these specific topics.
More in-depth, what emerges from Alberti’s book is the coexistence of elements of continuity and discontinuity in the Italian history of labor. Regarding continuity, issues such as low wages and high unemployment persist. For instance, between the 1960s and 1970s, wages grew more than labor productivity. Another aspect of continuity that arises in his analysis is the persistent gender gap. This phenomenon is confirmed in the recent Rome Business School’s (Reference School2025) report. The document highlights that only 51% of women of working age are employed, compared to 69% of men, with employment rates falling below 40% in the South. Furthermore, Italian women still earn on average 10.7% less than men, with the gap reaching 27.3% in managerial roles.
The evolution of political parties and labor market reforms, instead, has caused alternating phases of labor market expansion and contraction, representing key elements of discontinuity in this Italian history of labor told by Alberti. More specifically, these reforms introduced greater flexibility through deregulation and decentralization, which led to an expansion in job opportunities, particularly in fixed-term and part-time contracts, during periods of economic growth. However, we also experienced regressive effects due to these reforms, in particular, through an increased job precarity, growing income inequality, and reduced protections for workers, especially during economic downturns. In the last thirty years, the most important reforms that interested the Italian labor market are represented by the Treu Reform of 1997, the Biagi Law of 2003, the Fornero Reform of 2012, and the Jobs Act of 2014, all of which played a central role in reshaping the labor market structure in Italy.
Another important topic mentioned by Alberti is the “Southern Question,” where we might observe one of the most significant inequalities in the Italian labor market. This topic is still very timely. By the end of 1997, the unemployment rate in northern Italy had declined to about 6%, while in the South it was about 23% and rising. These disparities highlight that convergence is more of an exception than a rule in the Italian labor market.
I conclude this book review by trying to summarize this essay with a formula based on Alberti’s analysis. I think that probably the best one is that “labor has done more for Italy than Italy has done for labor." In this sense, labor played a pivotal role in shaping the face of modern Italy, but Italy has probably done less than expected to safeguard labor, also considering the impact of labor on making the Italian state great.
