Publications happen for many reasons. For this volume, the spur was one of the Science Museum's possible centenaries, commemorating 1909, when the museum completed a long process of self-extraction from its neighbour, the Victoria and Albert Museum. There are interesting resonances in this, for it was also the year in which Filippo Tommaso Marinetti published his Futurist manifesto, which hailed the aesthetic of the machine. And Marinetti's joy at ‘the sleek flight of planes whose propellers chatter in the wind like banners and seem to cheer like an enthusiastic crowd’ is highly appropriate for the Science Museum, since aviation has had such an important and iconic role in its development and displays, as several chapters show.
The Science Museum has often appeared to struggle with the implications of encompassing, at least in principle, the whole of science. Many of the pieces here show that this has always been a challenge, with the tensions evident today cropping up again and again as the museum tried to forge its identity with respect to science and industry, as a state institution (with all that implies), in the public eye, and in relation to other national museums. A crucial issue has been the attempt to balance the historical and the contemporary; in other words, to decide whether it is a museum ‘of’ science or ‘about’ science. It is a conundrum that has required constant negotiation, notably between being an institution offering science education and one exploring science's history, which in turn raises the question whether scientists or historians are its most appropriate collaborators.
One of the strengths of this collection is to bring together approaches from different authors – including staff, ex-staff and academics from elsewhere – while also providing a sound historical overview. This has been achieved by first telling a chronological story in five chapters that cover the museum's history from the foundation of the South Kensington Museum to about the year 2000. These provide a good basic narrative, yet allow each author to explore their own agenda, finishing with a seemingly even-handed assessment of the most recent, challenging, decades. Moreover, while it takes 1909 as its raison d'être, the volume does address the museum's formation out of the sprawling legacy of the Great Exhibition. Indeed, Robert Bud neatly shows how the issues with which the Museum has long wrestled arose in the half-century after the opening of the South Kensington Museum in 1857.
The chronological section is followed by a series of thematic chapters that look at the changing nature of the museum's exhibitions (and their audiences), including the move from taxonomic to more narrative and social-historical approaches and the museum's changing attitudes towards children, then at the development and management of the collections, and finally at the Science Museum's international context. The best place the museum within broader narratives to show the relevance of the story beyond South Kensington, although a few might have benefited from following this line more ardently. Nevertheless, what comes through is not only the authors' varied approaches and interests but also the connections that can be made between them. While this can occasionally lead to repetition (such as the regular appearance of the Wright flyer), by and large it creates a series of internal conversations that enrich the volume and do justice to the history of a great institution.
Of particular interest to readers of this journal will be some of the discussions that link the Science Museum to the development of science, technology and industry from the late nineteenth century onwards and examine its role in the creation of the history of science and technology as a scholarly activity. Nicholas Wyatt's chapter on the Science Museum Library also reminds us that while the aspiration to become a national library in its own right was never fulfilled, it remains as important a resource for historians of science and technology as do the museum's object collections.
This volume, then, is largely successful in commemorating the Science Museum as an internationally important institution that holds valuable material evidence for historians of science and technology, and which has had a role in shaping those fields. It is a fitting and varied testament to the museum's first century and a half.
