This book is a welcome contribution to the literature in international relations (IR), demonstrating why feminist IR scholarship matters for understanding IR topics of war, peace, and security, and the ways in which gender differences/orders/hierarchies are evident in IR. There is now extensive feminist scholarship of case studies on women, gender, militaries, and war around the world; yet, as Megan MacKenzie notes, there is little work on Western militaries—and this is what makes this book especially noteworthy. She examines the U.S. military’s combat exclusion policy in which, until 2013, women were prohibited from combat roles. Rather than focusing on the question of whether women “can” or “should” fight, however, MacKenzie considers “how the combat exclusion has been used throughout military history to shape ideals of ‘good,’ ‘honorable,’ and ‘real’ soldiers” (p. 18).
The book convincingly shows that the “band of brothers” myth is a powerful one that has affected military policy and “public perceptions of and emotional responses to war” (p. 194). To show the connection of the band of brothers myth to the combat exclusion and U.S. military identity, she uses a discourse analysis of three kinds of sources: U.S. government military reports, statements, press briefings, and policies related to the combat exclusion; news articles and opinion pieces in major U.S. news outlets (i.e., New York Times, Wall Street Journal, and Washington Post); and public comments to three online articles on The Daily Beast website on the combat exclusion (one of which was published in January 2013 when the combat exclusion policy was lifted, and one published two months later). Debates about women’s physical capabilities by supporters and opponents of the combat exclusion were the most dominant comments for all three articles.
The book presents several key points about the U.S. military, security, and warfighting. First, rather than based on evidence about women’s physical capabilities to perform combat roles, the combat exclusion is a trope: Combat units must be all-male, which fosters the myth of the band of brothers and reinforces who is considered a “real” soldier. MacKenzie notes that “the all-male combat unit lies at the heart of gendered depictions of war, and the band of brothers myth serves as a linchpin to social and cultural justifications for war” (p. 4). She argues that the band of brothers myth is a symbolic myth (stories/narratives used to “explain, justify, or legitimize certain cultural beliefs and practices”) as it is directly related to ideas of both national security and women’s roles in war (p. 8). In providing an overview of women’s historical participation and combat exclusion from World War II through the early 21st century, as well as legal cases, she illustrates that the definition of combat and combat exclusion are constructed. Gender stereotypes as well as historical events and political pressures contribute to the idea of combat exclusion (p. 19). Thus, the combat exclusion is actually not about women’s participation in wars and the military, per se, but rather reinforcing “the all-male combat unit as elite, essential, and exceptional” (p. 3).
Second, emotions (“feelings”) drive much of the perception that combat is the preserve of male soldiers and that there is a natural order in which women are caregivers, peaceful, and weak. While evidence from research shows that definitions about combat are fluid, that there has never been a singular combat exclusion policy, and there are no combat-specific physical standards, it is the emotions of fear, shame, and embarrassment about women in combat, including fears that this will lead to the feminization of the military and the decline in recruitment as well as “threaten the essential masculine atmosphere of training academies and operational units” (p. 90). She argues that the debate about women’s physical weakness relative to men—the dominant theme of why women should be excluded from combat—is a subjective one because while physical standards may seem unbiased, the debates and discussion surrounding them are linked to “emotions, ideals, and the band of brothers myth” (p. 99). For example, MacKenzie discusses how the dual physical standards for women and men created by the military became perceived as double standards—that women were getting preferential treatment. Conflating these standards, she argues, has had a particular outcome: “This position treats the separate physical standards as a symbol of women’s weakness, ignoring calls to measure effort or to recognize difference” (p. 110).
Emotion also factors into the idea of the band of brothers myth and the notion of all-male combat units for cohesion. All-male combat units are necessary for male bonding, and hence troop cohesion and effectiveness. MacKenzie demonstrates that the “cohesion hypothesis” is also “an emotional position, which reifies the ideal that the U.S. military is a band of brothers who are loyal, masculine, and honorable men protecting both their country and their female comrades” (p. 136). And yet, the definition of cohesion has changed historically, originally referring to leadership and institutional strategy, and now defined as small group bonding, identity, and culture. With regards to women, studies have shown that when women are accepted there was a positive correlation with cohesion and combat readiness (pp. 141–42).
Third, women’s participation in the U.S. military challenges the notion of militarized masculinity and the ideal soldier as male. The wars in Afghanistan and Iraq have revealed the increasingly blurred division between combat/front line and non-combat theaters of war given the nature of the insurgency warfare in both wars. The reality on the ground is that women have participated in combat operations in these wars (and, for example, have received combat pay; in the Army, they have received combat training since 2003), even with the combat exclusion in place. There is, in fact, fluidity in what is considered the front line, and thus defining what is considered combat. As evidence of the changing definition of combat, following the DOD’s review of the insurgency warfare in Iraq and Afghanistan, in 2012 DOD announced that 14,000 “new” combat-related positions would be open to women in the Army (p. 51). Yet political efforts continued to reiterate the perception that women were not engaged in combat. MacKenzie shows the tension between maintaining and reinforcing the combat exclusion and the reality of women in the military participating in combat operations in light of these blurred lines between combat and non-combat theaters of war.
While the United States has now lifted the combat exclusion, MacKenzie cautions whether this will lead to a change in gender relations within the military or transform military culture and “the historical valorization of male bodies, male bonding, and male honor” (p. 196). Consequently, she argues for the need to move beyond the band of brothers myth regarding men and war, and calls for a “critical reflection about how this myth has mystified, romanticized, and justified warfare and political violence” (p. 197). Readers will find this book valuable for such a critical reflection and for its understanding of how gender norms and gender relations are both challenged and reinforced when considering the connection between military identity and culture, militarism, and warfare.
