At its heart this book, which began as a doctoral dissertation at the University of Texas at Austin, is about the massacre of 4 June 1923 at Uncía, a mining town in northern Potosí. That massacre was the first of a depressingly regular series of such incidents over the last century that have either marked direct watersheds in Bolivian political life or, as in the case of Uncía, triggered political processes that have subsequently shifted the balance of power: the massacre at nearby Catavi in December 1942, which consolidated the rise of the Movimiento Nacionalista Revolucionario (National Revolutionary Movement, MNR) and the Federación Sindical de Trabajadores Mineros de Bolivia (Union Federation of Bolivian Mine Workers, FSTMB) that together led the 1952 revolution; that at Tolata, Cochabamba, in January 1974, which broke the Pacto Militar-Campesino and led to the rise of the Katarista movement; and that at El Alto, La Paz, in October 2003, which sealed the demise of neoliberal hegemony and the rise of Evo Morales. With the appearance of Robert Smale's carefully detailed and closely textured monograph, the only one of these massacres that still lacks a study of properly forensic detail is that at Catavi.
This volume, however, is about much more than an event. It depicts, on the basis of assiduous research in local archives, the emergence of a mining proletariat with such a closeness of touch that one can properly appreciate the existential fluidity coursing between familiar social science categories, with miners and other workers displaying strong artisanal as well as peasant features in language, presumption and expectation, managers proving surprisingly flexible as well as fiercely self-serving, and local military commanders not averse to taking the side of workers in disputes with a plethora of local companies, several of them foreign-owned. In 1923 the ‘Big Three’ companies of La Rosca had yet to cohere as an oligarchy, socialism was a fresh ideational current still to be tested, and the most efficacious forms of self-organisation were far from evident, with forms of syndicalism, old-fashioned gremialismo and more exotic ideologies all newly in the air.
The physical and psychological exigencies of daily labour in the Andean mines, though, were extraordinarily harsh, and Smale's careful account of the negotiations between workforce and management over the first decades of the twentieth century brings nothing more vividly to light than the substance of that struggle. In this effective study about the ‘making of the Bolivian working class’, we can follow, almost on a weekly basis, the transmutation of a nineteenth-century rhetoric of caste and status to one of class and organisation. Shortly before the Uncía massacre Francisco Blieck, manager of the La Salvadora Mining Company owned by Simón Patiño, wrote to the secretary of the new workers' federation, ‘I must inform you that this Company excuses itself from entering into relations with the organization that you represent, in view of the fact that it cannot tolerate the interference of private persons foreign to it in its internal affairs’. To this Guillermo Gamarra replied, ‘I believe, Sr. Manager, in my name and in that of the proletarian class, that instead of an encouraging word, you have issued a challenge, a depressing slight of which the Federation will take note’ (p. 115). If this were not challenge enough, a ‘yellow union’ set up to head off the new challenge launched into a series of insults that sought to co-opt the newly threatening vernacular: ‘We protest with all the energy of our convictions as honourable and free men against your iniquitous attitude … [You are] a tiny group of heterogeneous individuals – a conglomeration of bourgeois persons of diverse type – who have no more in common than their invented self-interest, their incapacity to support themselves, and their desire to prosper by snatching the workers' honourable salary’ (p. 117).
Robert Smale has, in fact, taken these precise quotes from the important and overlooked study by Gumercindo Rivera, La masacre de Uncía (Oruro, 1967), but much of the detail in this volume is derived from the university, departmental and subprefectural archives in Oruro. These have generally been underused in recent decades because the city has experienced general decline, and interest in the history of mining has been overtaken by interest in rural affairs and societies. Oruro is, in many ways, not an easy place for a historian to work, and its climate is distinctly less hospitable than that of La Paz, so one hopes that Smale's industrious work in what was once Bolivia's most industrial city will encourage more of the same. The historical contextualisation here is a little rushed, so the book will be most valuable when read in tandem with others, such as Guillermo Lora's History of the Bolivian Labour Movement, 1848–1971 (Cambridge University Press, 1977), that take a wider and more strategic view. The (still useful) national map is not fully to scale, and a second, more detailed depiction of the Uncía–Catavi–Llallagua–Huanuni–Oruro region would have helped to elucidate the logistical challenges to both state and workers that would prevail not only up to the Chaco War but also for the following half-century. Nevertheless, Robert Smale's diligent study provides a vivid portrait of a social process as complex as it was conflictive and, at times, tragic.
