In this welcome synthesis, Penelope Francks integrates the work of a broad array of English language studies with work by Japanese scholars to analyze the high degree of path dependency evident in the transformation of agriculture as Japan moved from an overwhelmingly agricultural economy to one dominated by heavy industry. Given the demographic and economic significance of agriculture during this period, and its political role well into the postwar era, the subject cries out for systematic treatment. Francks's ability to place the modern development of Japanese agriculture in the context of comparative developmental agriculture rather than treating Japan as sui generis, breaks a common pattern of works on Japan.
Professor Francks is particularly well qualified to bring a broad perspective to this subject. She has previously published Japanese Economic Development: Theory and Practice (London: Routledge, 1992; originally published in 1980) and Technology and Agricultural Development in Pre-War Japan (New Haven, CT: Yale University Press, 1984), and was a co-author of Agriculture and Economic Development in East Asia: From Growth to Protectionism in Japan, Korea and Taiwan (with Johanna Boestel, Kim Choo Hyop, et al., London: Routledge, 1999). This past work permits a careful placement of her subject in the context of both Japanese economic history and the comparative development of agriculture.
Francks argues that the nature of farming and agricultural technology at the end of the Tokugawa era (ca. 1600–1868) created a farm enterprise pattern based on multiple economic activities (the pluriactive household), and that this pattern, although transformed over time, survived through World War II and shaped the development of modern Japanese farming. Challenged by the growing impact of commerce on agriculture in the eighteenth and early nineteenth centuries, many farm households responded by producing some crops for market, and more importantly, engaging in nonagricultural labors in ways that did not interfere with agriculture. Such labors disproportionately relied on maximizing the economic contributions of women, although men also took advantage of off-the-farm opportunities. Francks sees this multitasking as the key to the survival of small, labor-intensive farms during the Agricultural Transition within Japan's increasingly industrialized society.
In addition, the author argues that the nature of Japan's agricultural transformation did much to shape key elements of the industrial component of Japan's economy. Rather than compete directly with agricultural labor, industrial firms, through practices such as contract employment of teenage women and seasonal employment of labor, managed to draw on rural labor without removing it from its main agricultural activities. This early practice underwent a variety of transformations until, in the postwar era, rice paddy agriculture became fully mechanized and could be undertaken as a part-time endeavor.
Francks shows that the transformation required support from the state. State efforts appeared grudgingly in response to both increased demand for rice (as opposed to other grains) as the staple in the Japanese diet and a perceived challenge to Japan's food self-sufficiency at the end of World War I. Support took such forms as extension of credit and encouragement of agricultural cooperatives. These efforts supported the mid-sized farm households that owned most of the land they farmed and shifted support away from large landlords by the 1930s. Simultaneously, the middling rural groups were aligned to Japan's increasingly expansionist efforts in Taiwan, Korea and Manchuria. These economic links between the state and domestic agriculture reinforced other links between the state and rural society that aligned the latter firmly behind Japan's war efforts.
Francks's argument is far more multifaceted and nuanced than conveyed by the foregoing summary, which should, however, at least suggest to readers the scope of the work.
This study is distinctive in two further respects: First, it successfully integrates rural and industrial economic growth, subjects usually treated quite separately. Second, it provides us with a truly long-term focus on rural economic development, enabling us to appreciate connections that might otherwise remain hidden.
Scholars looking for extended statistical analyses will be disappointed, but this lack is not surprising because systematic and comprehensive data collection for population, labor, and many other facets of Japanese society was not well developed until approximately 1920. Thus, for much of the period covered by this work, statistical data are scattered and not nationwide. Francks does capitalize on numerical data where available, however.
To compensate for data limitations, Francks relies on secondary studies by major Western and Japanese scholars. These are often case studies of limited areas of Japan, sometimes a province, sometimes just a village or small district. The synthesis that the author derives is adroit, but one is sometimes very conscious of the limitations of evidence. These notwithstanding, the author is, especially in the early parts of the book, rather more cautious than I think warranted. A number of Francks's tentatively phrased characterizations of late Tokugawa rural life are generally accepted by early modern historians.
Although Francks has given us a helpful perspective on the transformation of Japanese agriculture and illuminated developments that affected the largest segment of Japanese society in the late nineteenth and early twentieth centuries, the manuscript is badly in need of editing. It is repetitious, and some phrasings are awkward enough to almost hide the import of some (minor) arguments, especially in the early chapters. Even as someone very interested in the subjects Francks plumbs, I found it a challenge to stick with this work.
In sum, Francks has given us a very valuable study, but reading it requires some effort on the part of readers.
