Amalia Cabezas' Economies of Desire offers an ethnographically rich and analytically illuminating comparative study of heterosexual sex work in Cuba and the Dominican Republic. Exploring the impact of neoliberal reform on gender and sexuality, Cabezas insightfully probes the sexual politics of two culturally analogous yet historically disparate Hispano-Caribbean nations. Accessible, but without compromising analytical sophistication, Economies of Desire demonstrates how low-income Cuban and Dominican women use affective relationships to navigate neoliberal economic transitions. Bringing political economy to life through poignant ethnographic interviews, the book offers a fresh take on the long-standing scholarly debates about women's agency in the Latin American and Caribbean sex tourist trades.
Economies of Desire begins by examining the historical and socio-economic contexts of contemporary Caribbean sex tourism. With a primary focus on the Cuban economic crisis after the dissolution of the Socialist Bloc, the first two chapters argue that Cuban and Dominican governmental reliance on tourism at the start of the twenty-first century thrust the islands into global capitalist circuits in a way that heightened class, gender, racial and sexual inequalities. Drawing parallels between global tourism and histories of sugar production, Cabezas compares former colonisers to transnational tourists who consume ‘a new kind of brown sugar’ (p. 53).
The book begins with familiar critiques of Caribbean tourism, but then expands on these claims to suggest that the Cubans and Dominicans objectified by the ‘tourist gaze’ also ‘consume’ the tourists. Most notably, Cabezas persuasively argues that scholarly deployments of the category ‘sex worker’ diminish the fluid practices and encounters that characterise transnational affective bonds. Here, Economies of Desire offers its most important and far-reaching intervention into sex tourism research. Cabezas maintains that scholars should be more judicious when applying the category of sex work to erotic cross-cultural encounters, especially in situations that are ‘not clearly marked as commercial endeavors’ but do combine ‘pleasure, intimacy, and monetary support’ (p. 20).
As an alternative way to frame the dynamics of care and commerce inherent in transnational relations, Cabezas proposes the category of ‘tactical sex’. Rather than hold sex work apart from other shadow economies, ‘tactical sex’ places sexual relationships within a range of informal economic networks developed by young men and women struggling to make ends meet. Moreover, as a category of analysis that privileges women's decisions to engage in transnational relationships, ‘tactical sex’ helps to undo the entrenchment of victimhood models within scholarship on Caribbean sex tourism. In a stark departure from representations of Caribbean women as victims, the subjects in Cabezas' study vividly come to life as clever strategists who struggle against police harassment, poverty and discrimination.
In its final chapter, Economies of Desire responds to a question implicitly raised by Cabezas' analysis: does the rejection of the ‘sex worker’ category foreclose the possibility of organising around a common identity to advance collective political agendas? Cabezas suggests that sex workers may adopt identities strategically for political purposes and advocates for sex workers uniting with other sexual minorities to build social movements. To illustrate this point, Cabezas shows how Dominican women's activists in the Movimiento de Mujeres Unidas (MODEMU) successfully used the term ‘sex worker’ to position their cause within an international human rights framework. In support of the work of MODEMU, Cabezas holds state governments responsible for what she argues are human rights abuses resulting from tourist-based economies.
Drawing on a rich ethnographic investigation into the affective relationships between foreign tourists and local women, Economies of Desire reconfigures scholarly assumptions about power, sex and transnational ties. Informed by her decades-long engagement with Cuba and the Dominican Republic, Cabezas' analysis resists reductive political conclusions. Throughout the text, Cabezas' reflection upon her position as a Cuban-American feminist presents an additional layer of critical insight. In part due to this measured reflexivity, Economies of Desire provides a comprehensive account of the accomplishments of the Cuban revolutionary government alongside criticism of state violence against poor women of colour in Cuba and the Dominican Republic.
Although the subject as a whole is beyond its scope, the book's engagement with state violence raises rich questions for future research. In particular, it becomes clear that analysts would benefit from an ethnographic inquiry into the everyday practices that make up state bureaucracies. For instance, the book briefly discusses how women in the Federación de Mujeres Cubanas led the effort to criminalise and eradicate the Cuban sex tourist trade. How do Cuban women's advocates working within state organisations challenge and complicate theories of ‘male state violence’? A more thorough investigation of the decision-making processes of state leaders would illuminate the complexities behind the forms of state violence that Cabezas describes.
Economies of Desire offers an important model that will prove useful for future analysts of gender, Latin America and the Caribbean. Cabezas' critique of universalising Western discourses of ‘sex work’ exemplifies the potential for a more nuanced, post-colonial framing of class, gender, race and sexuality in contexts of neoliberal restructuring. Likewise, Cabezas' work amply captures a critical moment of convergence for Cuba and the Dominican Republic. More recently, the Cuban government has begun to de-emphasise international tourism as a major engine of economic growth, largely due to the proliferation of inequalities that Cabezas outlines. Thus, it remains to be seen whether the parallels between the two countries will endure into the twenty-first century. Economies of Desire will help us to unravel the intersecting nexus of affective ties, economic development and gender politics over the coming decades.
