Gilles Dostaler's book will be of use to some, but will disappoint others. It is a lively introduction to the life and writings of John Maynard Keynes, easily recommendable to undergraduates, but as a contribution to the scholarly literature, it has weaknesses.
Dostaler examines Keynes’ beliefs and contributions to philosophy, politics, economics, and art. The book is explicitly directed at “Keynes and not to Keynesianism” (p. 2). Emphasis is placed on Keynes’ contemporaries and their roles in influencing—and being influenced by—his work. Thus Dostaler creates an intellectual biography by focussing on the relationships between Keynes and his peers. The author also devotes two interludes of complementary dialogue about Keynes’ private and public lives in a more typically biographical manner.
Chapter 2 focuses on the conflicts between “Victorian morality” and the Bloomsbury group (of which Keynes was a member). Keynes’ evolution into a critic of the prevailing moral ideology is discussed alongside the influence and impact of G. E. Moore's Principia Ethica.
The first interlude provides an insight into Keynes’ personal life by tracing the composition, relationships, and history of the Bloomsbury group and their interests in art, morality, philosophy, and psychoanalysis.
Chapter 3 explores Keynes’ approach to knowledge. John Neville Keynes is described as a source of Keynes’ passion for methodological and epistemological discussions. The chapter also delves into Keynes’ writings on logic and his early works on probability, along with his criticisms of methods associated with Frank Ramsey and Karl Pearson.
Chapter 4 examines the various interpretations of Keynes’ political beliefs (dating back to his interest in history at Eton College), his treatment of Adam Smith, free trade, socialism, and Marxism.
The second interlude discusses the competing British ideologies of the period, emphasising how Keynes’ political links created tensions with the Bloomsbury group.
Chapter 5 further explores the evolution of Keynes’ political life (suggesting the Boer War as a significant moment with respect to his relationship with orthodoxy). This chapter also describes Keynes at the Treasury during the First World War, his anti-militarism, his work on German reparation, and his involvement in the 1919 Paris Peace Conference (which culminated in The Economic Consequences of the Peace).
Chapter 6 focuses on Keynes’ conception of money, its psychological dimension, and his approach to his own personal investments. This chapter also discusses the development of Keynes’ approach towards the role of money in the economy.
Chapter 7 discusses theories of labor prior to Keynes’ General Theory, and how Keynes battled to escape these shackles. We are told that Keynes’ focus on the psychological factors associated with labor and unemployment allied him with the British Liberal Party, but left him at odds with the British Treasury. This battle continued at the Economic Advisory Group and in the LSE-Cambridge disputes (including his debates with Friedrich Hayek). The chapter also examines Keynes’ attempts to influence President Franklin Roosevelt and his administration.
Chapter 8 examines Keynes’ crusade against a return to the Gold Standard at pre-war parity, and his efforts at the Bretton Woods conference (in opposition to Harry Dexter White and the American delegation).
Chapter 9 discusses Keynes’ other great passion, art, discussing his writings on aesthetics, his private collections, and his patronage of the arts through his founding of the Arts Council of Great Britain.
Dostaler concludes with some remarks on the links between Keynes, the Keynesian Revolution, and Keynesianism. The book also contains two appendices: one a chronology of Keynes’ life, the other a collection of short comments about Keynes from friends and contemporaries.
The book is a translation from the French—and at times the quality of the prose creates distractions. For example: “Anglicanism, the established Church of England, which had taken its definitive form with the promulgation in 1563 by Elisabeth 1 of the 39 articles to which members of English universities, as all those holding civil office, were obliged to declare allegiance, was in crisis” (p. 12). Some rhetorical flourishes also grate, for example “The ‘Keynesian economics’ taught in universities today would have Keynes turning in his grave had his ashes not been scattered” (p. 260).
There are a few errors. For example, Roosevelt defeated Herbert Hoover in 1932 not 1933 (p. 156, n. 36) and in Chapter 6 “money” is used in what could be described as a sloppy fashion (sometimes, apparently, referring to income and wealth). Also, Milton Friedman did not “develop” the natural rate of unemployment model in 1968—but much earlier (p. 178). Moreover, the assertion (p. 185) that “the solution to unemployment is to lower wages … is proposed by [A. C.] Pigou in Unemployment, published in 1913” will irritate those who have actually read that book (which is not cited in the bibliography). Those who have read A. W. H. Phillips’ 1954 Economic Journal theoretical article might also object to the assertion that the Phillips Curve was “born in 1958 … illustrating the trade-off between inflation and unemployment” (p. 256). Also (pedantically, perhaps) the famous libertarian group is usually referred to as the “Mont Pelerin Society” (p. 257). But overall, this is a reasonable introduction to Keynes and the attempt to paint a detailed picture of the personalities involved (the second interlude in particular) will help newcomers get a feel for the subject. But this book also reminds us of the enduring market niche still held by the Keynes industry almost two thirds of a century after his death.
Keynes became a savior-icon during the Great Depression; but the revolution that bears his name may have contributed to the process by which politicians were set free to pursue self-interest behind the facade of macroeconomic management. The consequent Great Inflation tooled-up other iconoclasts just as the Keynes industry was taking off (in the decade or so before the centenary of his birth). In terms of influence, the primary beneficiaries were members of the Chicago School. As we approach the centenary of Friedman's birth, the Chicago Counter-Revolution is now perceived to have contributed to the process by which players in the financial sector were set free to pursue self-interest behind the facade of market-based regulation.
The Great Recession may (temporarily) do to Friedman's reputation what the Great Inflation (temporarily) did to Keynes’. Both constructed their influence by picking up the iconoclastic sword, becaming worshiped as icons and then demonised by other sword wielders. This augurs well for the Friedman industry.
