Every so often and with increasing frequency, some columnist or social media commentator enjoins scholars to write for the broader public and to make their work “relevant” to contemporary concerns. Two books—Jordana Cox's Staged News: The Federal Theatre Project's Living Newspapers in New York, and James Shapiro's The Playbook: A Story of Theater, Democracy, and the Making of a Culture War—respond to this call while offering a case study in contrasting styles and audiences. Reading these two books in tandem—both excellent in their research and writing but divergent in their sense of purpose—is a crash course in the contours both of a fascinating chapter of US national theatre and of the ongoing debate about our own scholarly aims.
Shapiro's book builds on the appeal of recent popular work, such as his 2021 Shakespeare in a Divided America, but shifts the focus from that most canonical of theatre history subjects to a more obscure one. Yet the maneuver is essentially the same: to illuminate our current cultural and political dynamics by looking to our theatre-historical pasts. In this case, Shapiro frames the political history of the Federal Theatre Project (FTP) and its leaders—especially the idealistic and tenacious director Hallie Flanagan—against its most effective political adversary, Texas Congressman Martin Dies. The Dies Committee, as it was broadly known, is now most famous as the standing committee that emerged from its initial success: the House Committee on Un-American Activities. Through careful and detailed historiography and apt storytelling, Shapiro traces what he characterizes as an origin story for our contemporary culture wars, a playbook used by conservative lawmakers to scapegoat public funding of the arts as a cheap but effective catalyst for turning the tide of public opinion.
The Playbook's structure bookends a history of the FTP with Shapiro's political frame. Two chapters set up the conflict between the ambitious Dies and his target in the form of Flanagan and her Works Progress Administration–funded vision for a national theatre. Chapters 3–7 trace out the FTP's history through five of its most significant performances and scripts. And finally, three chapters on the machinations of Dies and his special committee close out the book, elaborating what Shapiro suggests is a right-wing blueprint for cultural antagonism that has been passed down from Dies to Joseph McCarthy to Roy Cohn to Donald Trump (with assists from Jesse Helms and Patrick Buchanan). The implicit argument is simple: that the arts are crucial to a functioning democracy, but that such persistent attacks on arts funding flirt recklessly with fascistic impulses in service of political expediency and individual aspiration.
For readers of this journal, the most engaging part of Shapiro's book will be the five theatre-historical vignettes at its center. Although the FTP was truly a national project, Shapiro focuses primarily on its New York presence in individual chapters on Orson Welles's production of Macbeth; the stage adaptation of Sinclair Lewis's novel It Can't Happen Here; the Project's forays into modern dance; and two Living Newspaper projects—the successful One-Third of a Nation and the shelved Liberty Deferred. Shapiro follows conventional critical outlines of earlier FTP histories by reading each of these performances through the terms of their perceived politics—often-leftist artistic impulses set against centrist administrative efforts to pull them back toward the more fundable middle ground—in ways that sometimes eschew nuance for the sake of the larger narrative. At the same time, sustained attention to the complicated racial dynamics of the FTP's workings provide some of Shapiro's most compelling insights. The analysis of Welles's “Voodoo Macbeth,” for example, attends to the pervasive racism that shot through the production's history and the reproduction of racism in its archive. Even more complexly, the chapter on modern dance takes up the figure of Tamiris (Helen Becker) and the deep ambivalences of representation, appropriation, and affiliation between Black and Jewish art makers at this vexed moment in performance history. Though brief chapters and awareness of a wider audience limit the depth of analysis that these subjects warrant, Shapiro's treatment of each play showcases his characteristic ability to balance scholarly insight and broad reach.
Jordana Cox's treatment of this territory is not bound by a concern with wide accessibility, with predictably rewarding results for scholarly readers. Although Staged News is itself comparatively brief, its narrower focus on the Living Newspapers (specifically the New York unit) and the disciplinary intersection with histories of journalism give Cox a compelling lens on these (until recently) under-studied plays. Her argument is borne out of this specificity: the Living Newspapers were an intervention into debates about the roles of both theatre making and journalism in an era of contested democracy.
In the first instance, Cox situates Living Newspapers in the well-established theatrical contexts of Bertolt Brecht, Erwin Piscator, and Soviet Blue Blouse troupes. But her novel inclusion of contemporary debates about journalism of the moment help explain some of the particularities of Living Newspaper performances: the role and comparative importance of objectivity, the staff collaboration (including out-of-work newspapermen) that went into the productions, the labor politics of white-collar work, the construction of the public, and the relationship of propaganda to mass media. Cox takes up these subjects in a form that will be familiar to readers of academic texts; an Introduction establishes the critical frame, and a handful of chapters illustrate key critical ideas through case studies. Her concluding pages treat the influence of Living Newspapers on contemporary echoes of the form, such as Illinois Humanities’ 2014 Shelter/Chicago and the Royal Court Theatre's 2020 Living Newspaper: A Counter Narrative. By this point, the argument laid out in the Introduction is thoroughly established and elaborated in ways that should inflect not just studies of New Deal–era theatre, but also thinking about the many iterations of theatre of the real that have flourished in the decades since.
These two books are valuable contributions, in different ways and for different purposes. A quick look at the two productions covered by both books will illustrate. One-Third of a Nation (a production focusing on poverty and the housing crisis of the Great Depression) and Liberty Deferred (a script on racism and the Black experience that remained unproduced by the FTP) receive a full chapter each in these texts. Shapiro offers well-told stories, presenting the two productions within the book's overarching frame about the effects of political contestedness on the entire history of the FTP. His chapter on Liberty Deferred shares with his earlier chapters a deft understanding of complex racial politics, tracing the history of a script penned by Black collaborators Abram Hill and John Silvera that highlighted liberal white hypocrisy, but was rewritten by a script doctor to foreground African complicity in slavery's origins and highlight intellectual conflict among Black people, as a way of deflecting critique of white interest in the status quo.
Cox puts these debates more directly into scholarly frames that no doubt inform Shapiro's work, but for obvious reasons do not get full treatment there. In her chapter on One-Third of a Nation, that play's contested politics is occasion to consider both journalism and the FTP's ambivalent relationship with propaganda (as Flanagan termed it, “propaganda for democracy”), which Cox situates within current critical conversations about theatrical witnessing. Her chapter on Liberty Deferred covers territory similar to Shapiro's, but frames debates about representation within Richard Iton's notion of the “solidarity blues.” While Iton's analytic may be a layer too dense for a lay audience, I was especially glad to read Hill and Silvera's ill-fated script within a framework that detailed the undermining forces of liberal white supremacy.
Other key distinctions in the books illustrate their different uses for discrete readers. Shapiro makes use of a strategic presentism to show how the right used the FTP as a scapegoat in drawing up the playbook for future culture wars, but Cox stays firmly in the realm of critical historiography. Whereas Shapiro's connections in his Epilogue occasionally seem to stretch to connect disparate historical moments, Cox underplays the echoes that I think extend well beyond her brief contemporary examples, into recent documentary and verbatim theatre. Similarly, while Cox's scholarly apparatus is precisely what a fellow scholar would hope for, Shapiro's publishers have eschewed notes and a bibliography for a “Bibliographical Essay,” which presents his exhaustive research in a readerly fashion more than a “researcherly” one; it would be a frustrating document to use to track down an individual reference.
In a way, both books stage a question about audiences in the form of historiography that their subjects were putting on actual stages across the United States: Who is this work for? How might it be used? Personally, I will not hesitate to recommend The Playbook to politically like-minded theatre-loving friends, and I may assign a chapter or two in my theatre history classes. But as a fellow scholar in this corner of the field, I will turn to Cox's work regularly, and likely for a long time.
