That theatre can change people is a sentiment dearly cherished by many theatre artists, and yet this notion is notoriously difficult to prove. Indeed, in recent decades, steeped as they have been in the radical relativism of postmodern philosophy and its various theoretical offspring (poststructuralism, deconstruction), a statement as straightforward and optimistic as “Theatre can change people” can seem at best naïve, and at worst intellectually lazy; Naomi Rokotnitz, however, is neither. In her excellent book Trusting Performance: A Cognitive Approach to Embodiment in Drama, she makes two interrelated arguments, comingled throughout the text, designed to defend philosophically and scientifically the validity of the idea that theatrical performance can, in fact, change people. In so doing, Rokotnitz directly confronts the legacy of much postmodern theory—a legacy, as she sees it, of doubt and skepticism about truth in general, but especially about embodied truths.
First, Rokotnitz argues for the validity of embodied knowledge. That is to say, she argues for the validity of knowledge that is grounded not in logic or the rational analysis of empirical evidence, but rather in prerational and prediscursive modes of knowing—intuition and gut feeling, for example, but especially, for Rokotnitz, empathetic understanding. Our bodies, she argues, possess a finely tuned knowledge-producing capacity as a consequence of their evolution as bodies within the world. In other words, our bodies are not untrustworthy repositories of irrational feelings but, rather, highly evolved instruments for taking in and processing a myriad of signals from our environment, filtering those signals through our experience and evolved instincts, and, finally, arriving at conclusions. One may not be able to articulate and defend such conclusions in a formal manner, but they are not therefore less valid. Rokotnitz makes the case for embodied knowledge through appeals to a wide swath of contemporary research in both cognitive neuroscience and experimental psychology, and her conclusions are compelling.
Second, Rokotnitz argues that theatrical performance is a particularly potent medium for the elicitation of just the types of experience that can lead to embodied knowledge. Rokotnitz supports this second prong of her argument through close theatrical readings of Shakespeare's The Winter's Tale, Tom Stoppard's Travesties, Timberlake Wertenbaker's Our Country's Good, and Moisés Kaufman's 33 Variations, each considered in a separate chapter. These chapters are mostly close readings of the texts of these plays, paying special attention to theatrical elements such as stage directions rather than to specific historical productions, although Rokotnitz does, at times, make reference to aspects of staging and audience response in particular shows. Frankly, quite apart from her larger argument about embodied knowledge and trust, the book is worth reading just for Rokotnitz's analysis of these four plays. Her dramaturgical insights are keen, and her unpacking of the complex intertextuality of these works has the potential to be enormously helpful, not only to scholars, but also to actors, directors, and designers.
Rokotnitz's purpose, however, is not simply to perform an excellent analysis of these plays, though she certainly has done that. She wants to demonstrate, by means of these four particular plays, the broader potential of theatrical performance to elicit embodied knowledge. So, for example, a person attending a performance of The Winter's Tale may come to realize, just as Leontes does, that when one's trust in others is subjugated to a demand for proof of their veracity, mistrust—and possibly tragedy—will likely follow. Such an audience member may then be moved to extend trust to their own loved ones, where before they were consumed by anxiety and doubt. Or, an audience member attending Wertenbaker's Our Country's Good may leave the theatre convinced of the civilizing value of living in a community and of cooperating with others, as opposed to the isolation engendered by suspicion. It is precisely these types of new understanding that theatre artists regularly strive to engender in their audiences, and that Rokotnitz so robustly defends in her book as being anything but naïve, suspect, or unprovable.
Trusting Performance does have its flaws. The book can sometimes be digressive, and, at times, it is a struggle to see the relation of a particular point Rokotnitz is making, about, say, one of the four plays she discusses, back to her overall thesis. In some ways, the book is less one cohesive whole than it is four related essays. But this is only a minor criticism. I found the book insightful and exciting. Most important, Rokotnitz's book is a significant contribution to the relatively new field of cognitive approaches to literature and theatre. This is a rapidly growing area with great potential for deepening the scientific sophistication of literary and theatrical criticism and production. In a field still much in thrall to the radical relativism of so much twentieth-century theory, even tried and true ideas—such as the capacity of theatre to change hearts and minds—are too often held suspect. In this regard, Naomi Rokotnitz's Trusting Performance is a very welcome contribution.
