This impressive work of scholarship well deserves the accolades contained on its back cover, for two reasons. First, the background research is outstanding in a very accessible style. Second, the book carries that research lightly. It is written in a very easy style, suitable for undergraduates, or for those who are beginners so far as the issues with which it deals are concerned. Appropriately for such a work, the reader is not intimidated by excessive use of supporting references to relevant works of secondary literature.
Not surprisingly, given the book's title in the United States, there are eight substantive chapters, plus an introduction and a conclusion. Each chapter deals with a particular idea which, the author rightly maintains, originated in ancient Greece and/or Rome, and remains significant today. The substantive chapters are: 1. Justice; 2. Constitution; 3. Democracy; 4. Virtue; 5. Citizenship; 6. Cosmopolitanism; 7. Republic; 8. Sovereignty. The book also includes helpful tables and maps, a glossary, and brief biographies of key persons, events, and places, as well as a list of references and abbreviations and an index.
The author says that the book “will explore both the similarities and differences between ancient and modern politics” (8). The “guiding principle” for selection was “to choose ideas that can be used to illuminate key aspects of ancient thought while also informing contemporary reflections” (9). So the thread running through the work is one of continuity rather than of discontinuity. No stark contrast is drawn between the ancient and the modern ways of thinking about politics. There is no discussion of what some would regard as the significant absences in ancient political thought: for example, the ideas of individualism, liberty, and rights, all of which (rightly or wrongly) some commentators consider to be peculiarly modern. Consequently, it is not explained what the most significant differences, or lines of discontinuity, are between the ancient and the modem ways of thinking about politics.
Of course some people think that the concept of liberty is a modern one, and therefore not one which might appropriately be included in a work of this kind. Against this, however, two observations might be made. The first is that there was an ancient conception of liberty. This view is defended, for example, both by Eric Havelock, in The Liberal Temper in Greek Politics, and also by Leo Strauss, in Liberalism Ancient and Modern. On this view, there is no historical anachronism involved in talking about the concept of liberty in connection with the political thought and experience of the ancient world. For those who think in this way, the concept of liberty, just like the eight other concepts discussed in this work, also has a history. It emerged in the ancient world and has evolved over time, taking on a somewhat different meaning in the modern period from that which it had in former times.
The second observation is that this also appears to be the author's view. For she refers to the concept of liberty herself, on more than one occasion (34, 68, 85, 91, 120–22, 136, 154, 247, 256, 276, 294, 307). Indeed, in a chapter section significantly entitled “Liberalism” (120–22), she draws attention to the significance of Benjamin Constant's The Liberty of the Ancients Contrasted with That of the Moderns. It is a little surprising, therefore, to find that the book does not contain a separate chapter devoted to the concept of liberty.
One of the most significant developments in political theory and the history of political thought in the last three decades has been the revival of interest in classical republicanism, especially in the writings of J. G. A. Pocock, Quentin Skinner, and Philip Pettit. In this literature, Pettit's idea of freedom or liberty as “nondomination,” in his Republicanism: A Theory of Freedom and Government (Oxford University Press, 1997), has been especially influential. This idea has, of course, classical origins. Again, therefore, it is a little surprising to find no mention of these recent developments in Lane's book, especially given that it contains chapters devoted to the ancient notions of constitution, virtue, citizenship, and republic, and given also that it is supposed to be establishing why these ancient ideas and ideals still matter today.
There has also been a revival of interest in the last twenty years or so in the idea and the ideal of cosmopolitanism. This has occurred largely as a consequence of the impact of what is usually referred to as globalization. Lane's book does contain a nod in the direction of this recent body of literature, with a reference to the work of Anthony Appiah (227). However, there is quite a lot of literature on this and one would have thought that a work containing a chapter on cosmopolitanism in the ancient world, and which purports to explain why this classical idea is of contemporary relevance, would explore these recent developments in more depth.
The phenomenon of globalization has also influenced the way in which political theorists have talked about sovereignty, an idea which (rightly or wrongly) is also sometimes regarded as peculiarly modern. On this view, the concept came into existence with the emergence of the modern state in the sixteenth and seventeenth centuries. For example, it lies at the heart of the political thought of Jean Bodin and Thomas Hobbes. The suggestion that there is or was an ancient conception of sovereignty is therefore, for some people, a controversial one. It would have been good to see some discussion of this issue: an explicit defense of the claim that there is or was an ancient conception of sovereignty, as well as a modern one, and hence also a line of historical continuity that might be traced between the two.
The title of the book when it was published in the United Kingdom in 2014 was Greek and Roman Political Ideas: A Pelican Introduction. This wording does not suggest that the author will discuss the relevance of these ideas today. The title in the United States, The Birth of Politics: Eight Greek and Roman Political Ideas and Why They Matter, suggests otherwise. It seems to me that the former title is more accurate as a description of the book's contents than the latter. The prospective purchaser of the book in the United States is led to believe that the book will spend some time discussing not only the influence that these ideas have had in the later history of political thought, but also their contemporary significance. Reflections of this kind are not entirely absent from the book. The author does make such remarks from time to time, for example when discussing ancient and modern understandings of the concept of democracy in chapter 3 (117–27). Given the altered wording of the American title, more could have been done in this regard. However, the balance between that which is purely historical and that which deals with contemporary relevance could and perhaps should have been drawn in a different place, with more attention being given to contemporary relevance.
As an introduction to the political thought of the ancient world, this book is excellent. The scholarship is impressive and the writing style accessible. As an account of why these ideas still matter, the work is not quite so strong. It is, nevertheless, certainly well worth reading. The qualities it possesses, especially its combination of deep scholarship and accessibility, are rare indeed.
