When asked about the relationship of Americans with photography, photographer and novelist Wright Morris once noted that “considering the fervor of our adoption it is puzzling that some ingenious Yankee was not the inventor of the camera. It profoundly gratifies our love for super gadgets, and our instinct for facts” (“In Our Image” (1978)). With this statement, Morris situates photography at the very heart of American life and practices, a connection which has been well explored over the years. Two new offerings look to make their own imprint on this field. The first, American Modern, a companion volume to the recent exhibition of the same name, reexamines the development of documentary photography in the 1930s through the styles of three leading photographers, Bernice Abbott, Walker Evans, and Margaret Bourke-White, while the second, Photography and the USA by Mick Gidley, offers the latest edition in Reaktion's Exposures series on photography, which goes beyond other ventures in investigating the role and symbolism of nationhood in the development of the art form.
American Modern was brought together by three curators, each contributing a critical essay to the collection: Jessica May (Amon Carter Museum of American Art) on Walker Evans, Sharon Corwin (Colby College Museum of Art) on Margaret Bourke-White, and Terri Weissman (University of Illinois, Urbana–Champaign) on Bernice Abbott. Their overall objective is to move firmly beyond the reaches of the Farm Security Administration (FSA) projects to discuss these three photographers on their own terms, and given how much excellent scholarship has already been devoted to FSA-related debates over the years, this prospectus offers a refreshing design. The book takes a somewhat different approach by positioning these three photographers closely alongside one another to better access a modernist “documentary style” itself; that is, how each demarcated themselves against prior social-documentary practices from the turn of the century (prominently marked by that of Lewis Hine and Jacob Riis) and how their work came to occupy the centre of American public culture and vision during the Great Depression era. Hence the essays situate themselves quite visibly with one another, spotlighting where Evans, Abbott and Bourke-White both intersect and contradict in their vast career arcs. For example, in the introduction, these differences are prefaced: Abbott's notion of photography was intrinsically caught up with creating critical dialogue and communication, while for Evans photography was explored more for its unique and essential relationship with time and for Bourke-White her documentary images attempted to “fuse the logic and pageantry of modern industry with drama and the individual narratives of its subjects” (2). In this sense, the exhibition catalogue succeeds in offering as much critical perspective as visual merits. Furthermore, each essay is followed by twenty-five full-page plates from that artist's collection, and several smaller photographs run alongside the text, all of which are discussed to various degrees within the essays themselves.
The authors likewise amass three key factors that shaped documentary style more broadly in the wake of the photography modernism of the 1920s generation: the influence of commercial and government commissions, new attitudes toward or the acceptance of art within museums and other public institutions, and the growing presence of mass media. Thus they continue to probe “documentary” as a commonly understood term, building on previous scholars’ interventions but also situating their analysis more fundamentally within the image dynamics of these three photographers. The most striking feature of the volume remains, however, its images and each writer's ability to showcase the differences between these photographers, most notably in their respective representations of New York City and approaches to the human subject. They posit how each artist demonstrates “a specific characteristic of 1930s documentary”: Abbott, “the changing nature of social and economic relationships” by examining her various attempts to create the great democratic book; Evans, “documentary's anthropological side” by reassessing those overlooked differences between the original exhibition of American Photographs and the more famous publication that would put Evans and the photo-book itself on the map; and Bourke-White, its emotional appeal and narrative potential as her aesthetic gradually turned to foreground the human subject at the most befitting of times (158). Yet, of course, a few other photographers (Lange, Shahn) could have likewise been included in this respect, and the authors’ reasoning for their final selections could have been elaborated on further, especially since this analytical feature – why these three facets of the genre are more worthwhile than others – would have greatly enhanced the authors’ argument. Moreover, in the afterword, several discerning claims on the relevance of 1930s documentary photography to our own contemporary moment are offered, but perhaps in a too-curtailed fashion to sustain adequate inquiry. Nevertheless, the volume provides an exceptional and original focus on those intersections between Evans, Bourke-White and Abbott and their continuing significance within the American documentary tradition.
Gidley's book likewise takes up the theme of intersections but on a far greater scale, providing an insightful portrait of photography's stake in shaping American history and identity from its inception, and adding further fuel to claims that America is fundamentally a culture of the image. Early on, Gidley himself ponders how causal this link between America and photography can be made, but prefers to leave this debate open by underscoring the “and” in his title: in other words, his project neither traces a national photography nor showcases a photography only representative of nation, but instead investigates where these two entities meet and occupy shared ground. Gidley, emeritus professor of American literature and culture at the University of Leeds, has long played a crucial role in placing photography more firmly within American studies. His previous books on Native Americans and photography, most notably on the work of Edward S. Curtis, and landscape photography of the American West have proved vital to burgeoning interdisciplinary approaches within the field. With this present volume, however, Gidley negotiates more than 170 years of history to spotlight the affinities between America as nation and photography as practice, in particular its personal, commercial and vernacular dimensions, and argues for how both, following Whitman's signature words throughout, can only be apprehended in their entirety and diversity (25). The stated aim of this particular volume is to provide a “concise yet comprehensive overview of photography in the United States” (inside cover) and at just under two hundred pages, including the illustrations, the book purports itself to be a viable asset for undergraduate American and visual-culture courses alike. This issue is well stocked and laid out with 107 illustrations, demonstrating not only an ample range from historical archives and more contemporary material but moreover the ability to combine them into an integrative portrait.
While other histories have traced American photography according to designated periods, trends or specific styles, Gidley skews standard chronological order to fit more topical interests by dividing the book into four chapters – “Technologies,” “Histories,” “Documents” and “Emblems” – each reassessing that shifting role photography has played over the last 170 years. The first focusses on the cultural implications of American contributions to photographic technologies and commercialization over the nineteenth century and into the early twentieth, especially when compared to European counterparts. The second addresses photography's intersections with major themes in American history, primarily immigration, the western frontier, race and racism, urbanization and the growth of consumerism, and stresses the need to include more than the iconic. The last two chapters delve swiftly into the twentieth century to highlight key moments within the American documentary tradition and to discuss the medium's ascension into the art world since the 1960s. While many of the particular arguments raised here could have been taken up in lengthier form, the volume's economic style in forging so many rich links stands as testament to the author's ability to create a fluently woven portrait of emerging nation and visual culture, a strength apparent within each chapter frame as it spotlights the iconic and monolithic while complicating these images at the same time. In the end, both volumes, Photography and the USA and American Modern, revolve around this same element – the complexity of reading photographs in any American cultural context, but nevertheless the need to understand the synergy between the two.
