Lisa Freeman's book represents a fresh approach to antitheatricality that can serve as a model for future scholarship. Surveying a broad range of examples, she shows that antitheatrical controversies are never simply about the theatre; rather, they serve as the occasion to give voice to wider social and political concerns. Freeman convincingly argues that episodes of antitheatrical fury demonstrate the enduring power of theatre, not its vulnerability. The examples in Antitheatricality and the Body Public range from William Prynne's 1634 trial over Histrio-Mastix to the US Supreme Court's 1998 ruling on the NEA Four. The examples may be highly selective, but that is a virtue, not a fault, in a book that uses antitheatrical controversies to “trace major struggles over historical shifts in the nature and balance of discursive power and political authority” (2). Only by looking at a wide range of historical episodes can Freeman prove the ongoing centrality of theatre to political culture and model a new approach to antitheatricality that can be applied to other historical and contemporary examples.
Chapter 1 examines the controversy around the publication of Histrio-Mastix and then closely studies three accounts of Prynne's Star Chamber trial. Rather than looking at Histrio-Mastix solely in the context of the antitheatrical tradition, Freeman shows how Puritans, lawyers, and the royal court each vied to assert their political rights and authority. Prynne argued for a godly “body politic … whose tenets could be set against and even surpass the sovereign authority of a secular or civil state” (52). In response, the Inns of Court staged a grand public procession to Whitehall Palace, where they then performed the masque The Triumph of Peace, to demonstrate both their loyalty to the Crown and their own political potency. Turning to archival records, Freeman then reveals how the Crown sought to manage public perceptions of its prosecution of Prynne. The recent discovery of a lengthy new manuscript account of the trial shows that the prosecution, conscious of the broader contest over political authority, pointedly fashioned its arguments for the court of public opinion. The result is a chapter that goes well beyond the voluminous text of Histrio-Mastix in order to see Prynne's story not as an antitheatrical sideshow but as a central event in the political contests of the 1630s.
The second chapter concerns Jeremy Collier's Short View of the Profaneness and Immorality of the Stage (1698). The Collier controversy lasted more than a decade and inspired scores of publications. Scholars have focused largely on the aesthetic and moral elements of the debate, too often treating Collier as a late-century descendant of Prynne. Yet Collier, a nonjuring Jacobite, was a political extremist of an entirely different sort. Freeman contends that the Collier controversy exemplifies the problems of “framing truth and assigning value in post-Revolutionary Britain” (108) since the works he critiques all “display a fascination with what I term the posture of ‘supposition,’ that is, with the potentialities of the ludic conditions that animate and indeed are foundational to theater itself” (108). The concept of “supposition,” however, is fairly vague, and the examples are subtle and based upon a limited selection of responses to the Short View. Readers will notice that Collier and his text quickly fade from view.
If the chapter on Collier takes a big debate and narrows it, the third chapter, which focuses on the controversy over John Home's tragedy Douglas (1756), takes a seemingly minor episode and shows it to be of tremendous significance. With detailed reference to contemporary texts, Freeman shows that the Douglas controversy was not just about the play or about the theatre. Rather, the performance of the play served as a flashpoint in a brewing dispute over the cultural authority of the Scottish church. Home, a Church of Scotland minister, championed Enlightenment ideals of skepticism, reason, and empiricism, which reactionary elements of the church regarded as a challenge from within that echoed external threats to its theological and moral authority. In this context, the hue and cry over Home's play takes on new significance.
Chapter 4 focuses on an antitheatrical event of a much different sort: the Richmond, Virginia theatre fire of 1811. Freeman connects the fire to the Second Great Awakening, pointing out how religious leaders used the event “to call upon Americans to form themselves into a body public that would be dedicated to a reinvigoration of Christian religion in the nation” (191). The details of the tragedy in Richmond and the many responses to it are fascinating, but at times the pathos inherent in the story draws one's attention away from the argument. In the end, Freeman's claim that the fire was the occasion of renewed evangelical discourse and many individual conversions seem to be well-founded; whether this example is in its essence antitheatrical, rather than just a horrifying memento mori, is debatable.
The final chapter is a fitting bookend to the first. As with Prynne's trial, Freeman discusses the debate over the NEA Four by situating it in its broader social and legal contexts. And just as the first chapter analyzed The Triumph of Peace, this chapter carefully examines Karen Finley's We Keep Our Victims Ready and Tim Miller's My Queer Body. Freeman shows why these artists’ works were especially challenging in the context of the 1990s and closely examines the legal record, focusing on First and Fifth Amendment concerns in the case of NEA v. Finley. This analysis brings in the different groups that contributed amicus briefs and, as with Prynne's trial, the ways in which the court's process itself was a performative as well as legal exercise. The result is a fairly damning picture of the Supreme Court yielding to contemporary passions in upholding an arbitrary and vague statute.
The book ends abruptly with this chapter. Given the variety of examples and the broad historical range, the addition of a conclusion would have been welcome, both to highlight common threads and to suggest opportunities for reconsidering other moments of antitheatrical controversy. But even absent a conclusion, the book serves to exemplify the virtues of Freeman's approach and to shed important new light on each of the five cases she considers.
