This is an extraordinarily vibrant and innovative work in which Elaine and Gerry (as they playfully call themselves in the book) share with us, girls and boys, the thrills and the pleasures of the popular as potentially political experience. At a time when theatre studies shy away from a more focused discussion of popular theatre and some scholars might feel a certain pleasurable guilt if they decide to go and see (and perhaps enjoy) Disney's Beauty and the Beast, Aston and Harris manage to create a valuable balance between popular culture and the theoretical underpinnings of contemporary feminisms. Rather than concentrating on utopian feminisms, as too many scholarly volumes often do, the authors provide an illuminating analysis of a number of mainstream and experimental shows aimed at women (and not only) through the lens of what they define as popular or lived feminisms.
Although a detailed discussion of shows like Mamma Mia!, Calendar Girls, the Chippendales, Susan Boyle, New Burlesque or the stand-up comedy of Andi Osho and Shappi Khorsandi would hint towards a potential dilution of the theoretical component of this book, contemporary feminist theory works remarkably well when discussed in connection with the performances mentioned above. A Good Night Out for the Girls is usefully structured in nine chapters, starting with an introduction that maps the framework of feminist criticism in the twenty-first century and concluding with some final reflections from both contributors, highlighting the main aims of their project as exploring ‘the politics of location’ (p. 185) and ‘the connections between different locations, audiences and “cultures”’ (p. 186) in order to identify some of the cultural, political and social issues that derive from these connections.
Within this structure, Elaine and Gerry embark on a journey of discovery and exploration of ‘profitable and pleasurable’ (p. 25) women's shows: from Tim Firth's Calendar Girls, with its heightened sentimentality and issues of disrobement and transformation, to a different kind of disrobement in the Chippendales’ Ultimate Girls Night Out; from the reimagining of the older woman in talent shows like Britain's Got Talent to an analysis of the Susan Boyle phenomenon; from more experimental theatre productions like Nic Green's Trilogy, exploring the legacy of second-wave feminism, to the all-conquering chick megamusical Mamma Mia! and the feminist potentialities of stand-up comedy and New Burlesque. The journey is completed with a discussion of Marisa Carnesky's Ghost Train in Blackpool, a performance experiment that brings together the funfair ride, performance art, theatrical illusion and digital technology to explore issues of women, immigration, disappearance and memory.
Although it contains discussion and analyses of a large variety of performances, the multifarious character of A Good Night Out for the Girls provides an extraordinary account of contemporary popular theatre and performance and it should become essential reading for those interested both in popular feminism and in having a great night out (or in) with the girls.
