When a refugee crosses a national border to seek asylum, it is a dramatic act. Not only are the stakes heightened, but there are scripted roles, a dramatic arc, conflict, multiple audiences, and often spectacle. For this reason, the field of refugee performance is replete with case studies, theoretical analysis, and creative production revolving around refugees’ point of entry—their departure from home, arduous journey, the bureaucratic hurdles and the often xenophobic reactions they face upon arrival. In perhaps its most significant contribution, Applied Theatre: Resettlement—Drama, Refugees and Resilience expands this purview to consider the potential for performance to assist refugees in the long-term process of resettlement after their first entry—a process that usually entails relocating to a third country that will host the refugee long term, possibly permanently. Coauthors Michael Balfour, Penny Bundy, Bruce Burton, Julie Dunn, and Nina Woodrow chronicle how the resettlement, not just the exodus, of a refugee is also a dramatic story, a duration piece of sorts, during which the task of establishing one's life in a foreign country produces ongoing challenges of self-definition, community building, and other logistical necessities.
A majority of the book details three case studies that the authors executed in Logan City, Australia, between 2007 and 2012, with projects continuing to develop postpublication. This extensive case-study approach is one of the text's outstanding characteristics. Although a practitioner-oriented perspective in which authors reflect on their own experience of producing performance with and about refugees is common among refugee performance texts, most take the form of a single article or chapter. Resettlement’s extended terms of engagement with a consistent group of researchers and authors results in a highly sophisticated conversation about research methods and the lived experiences of the refugees at the center of the work. Of particular interest to readers might be the depth of reflexivity the authors demonstrate, offering fellow practitioners a series of best practices developed through trial and error as well as significant questions to consider. Similarly emerging from this exemplary case-study framework is a much more holistic view of refugees themselves. The book argues early on for a departure from the typical focus on traumatic personal narratives, which comprise a large majority of representations of refugees in performance and beyond, and instead champions refugee stories that prioritize community building, skills acquisition, and everyday moments of perseverance.
The three case studies at the heart of the book emerged from a collaboration with MultiLink Community Services, a government and privately funded organization that oversees a number of programs in Logan City focusing on migrant communities. With support from Australia's Department of Immigration and Citizenship, MultiLink was interested in using arts to help newly arrived refugees assimilate to Australian culture. From these initial collaborations, three distinct projects developed: (1) using process drama to increase English-language skills among 8–12-year-olds, (2) using enhanced forum theatre to address issues of bullying with participants in an English Language Unit and the Acting Against Bullying program already in place at a large high school, and (3) using a multiarts approach to work with a MultiLink youth group (ages 14–18) and a TAFE (Technical and Further Education) language program. The book is separated into two parts, with Part 1 providing background and context for the evolution of the above partnerships, the specific artistic practices employed, and scholarly conversations about defining refugee status, social acculturation, settlement, and resilience. Part 2 details the case studies and briefly connects their outcomes to the overarching themes. Together, the two parts work to provide a grounding for existing debates about notions of resilience as they relate to the discursive and material definitions of refugees and to expand these debates with the highly situated, exploratory, and ever-unfixed knowledge produced through performance.
Ultimately, each case study arrives at a claim for theatre's ability to situate the particular struggles of refugee resettlement, such as language acquisition, within a broader skills-based pedagogy, such as confidence building or cooperative problem solving, that diminishes the weight of trauma and otherness in processes of acculturation and focuses on a more integrated model of resettlement. Additionally, theatre reveals the qualities of resilience already possessed by refugees rather than endowing them with a resilience that was presumed they must acquire on their own or through social services in order to acclimate into a new cultural milieu successfully. This is part of the book's central argument concerning contemporary views of refugees: that an individualist model of outreach and resettlement proffered by neoliberal economic and political systems must be reconstructed toward what the authors call an ecological view of settlement and resilience. An ecological view considers multiple registers of social, cultural, and historical influence on how one becomes and expresses resilience, rather than framing resilience and the resettlement process as an individual's responsibility or an indicator of dependency. For the authors, an ecological view resists dominant narratives that use notions of resilience to normalize the construction of “the Other.”
Herein lies a consequential paradox of Resettlement. In demonstrating how applied theatre reveals a more ecological perspective, the case studies at times lose track of the specificity of what their methods offer for refugee studies. The refugee experience is situated in such broad contexts as English-language education that the breakthroughs proposed by applied theatre methods occasionally read more like contributions to education theory, not as renarrativizations of resettlement or resilience for refugees specifically. Moreover, although the book expertly and emphatically asserts the need to move beyond personal trauma narratives that trap refugees in singular narratives, the authors’ focus on providing acculturation services determined by their partnerships continues to position the refugees in a reactive relationship to dominant social expectations, recycling some of the one-dimensional representations of refugees the authors attempt to avoid. The ecological practice of refugee performance that this book so excellently establishes in its introduction could be used to create performances that question and critique the social, cultural, and historical dynamics that produce refugees and construct such singular considerations of resettlement in the first place.
