Due to the deadlock of the Doha Development Agenda, the World Trade Organization (WTO) is now facing a rapid preference for regionalism or bilateralism all over the world, including East Asia (e.g., ASEAN). Amid this trend, the Research Institute of Economy, Trade, and Industry, located in Tokyo, published this volume, which aims at conveying “a simple and crystal-clear message to readers: Maintain the robustness of the multilateral trading system, and strike the optimal balance between regionalism and multilateralism” (p. xv). In response to such recent preference for regionalism, the authors of this volume share the viewpoint that “[h]istory has witnessed that a multilateral approach has been more successful in achieving a win-win situation” (p. xvi).
This volume is composed of eighteen chapters and attempts to offer proposals to revitalize the Doha Round and the multilateral trading system from various perspectives. The part dealing with economics conducts an economic analysis of the policy disciplines in the less-developed Asian countries (Chapter 7, Kimura), international co-operation in the WTO dispute-settlement mechanism (Chapter 13, Furusawa), the rules of origin in regional trade agreements (RTAs) (Chapter 14, Ishikawa), the institutional relationship between the RTAs and the WTO (Chapter 16, Kikuchi), creating a multilateral investment regime (Chapter 17, Akaneya), and the trade and environment issue (Chapter 18, Abe). The political perspective contains an analysis of global governance (Chapter 4, Yamamoto) and domestic politics (Chapter 8, Uchiyama; Chapter 9, Destler).
The articles on legal issues are of particular interest. In Chapter 5, Kometani explains that the Appellate Body (AB) established in the Japan-Alcoholic Beverages II case is the “would-be” benchmark, which focuses on the competitive relationship between imported and domestic products that would exist but for an internal measure, in interpreting Article III.2 of the General Agreement on Tariff and Trade (GATT) (p. 58). As an alternative, he proposes that the WTO should adopt the “should-be” benchmark in examining the national-treatment requirement and rules on subsidies; that is, to consider “the competitive relationship between imports and domestic products that should exist in light of the legitimate objective of an internal measure” (p. 59). He concludes that this alternative approach would provide governments with the flexibility to form domestic regulatory policy that is not an exception under Article XX of the GATT.Footnote 7
In Chapter 6, Araki carefully examines the proposals by Barfield, Cottier, Ehlermann, Pauwelyn, and Sutherland for modifying the current WTO decision-making process governed under Article IX:1 of the Marrakesh Agreement Establishing the World Trade Organization, and presents his core idea that “the current consensus-based, decision-making mechanism of the WTO reflects the delicate balance between power politics and the strengthened dispute settlement process at the WTO; any proposal to change it substantially, therefore, will face opposition by Members” (p. 95). In conclusion, Araki focuses on the General Council's decision of 24 November 1995 (WT/L/93), which expanded the consensus rule to the decisions on waivers and accessions, and proposes, on the ground that both issues are specific to a particular situation, that the “majority decision-making” should be introduced as during the GATT era (e.g., Articles XXV:5 and XXXIII of the GATT). He also indicates that this proposal, once accepted on the basis of “consensus”, could open the door for the members to adopt a majority vote in the WTO decision-making (p. 116).
In Chapter 11, Kotera understands in principle that the WTO functions in the context of the international community which “is composed of sovereign states, and, as distinct from domestic societies, lacks compulsion monitored by a central government” (p. 213). Thus, in response to the argument that characterizes the so-called “judicialized” or “legalized” WTO dispute-settlement proceeding as the domestic court system, he emphasizes that the element of consent which prevails in the international community also plays a role in each stage of the dispute-settlement process. Lastly, further improvements especially on amicus curiae and pecuniary compensation are considered.
In Chapter 12, Kawase offers innovative and realistic proposals to promote compliance with recommendations or rulings of the Dispute Settlement Body from the “normative” aspect, which is “to find factors promoting and ensuring compliance in … acceptance of norms” (pp. 236−37). For the sake of this, he proposes that the factors which might render parties’ acceptance of substantive norms uncertain should be improved as follows: the panel's exercise of judicial economy should be restrictive; panels and the AB should make specific suggestions on how to implement the recommendations under Article 19.1 of Understanding on Rules and Procedures Governing the Settlement of Disputes; and, panels and the AB should not interpret relevant WTO provisions in an unreasonable or unconvincing manner, or should not be too reliant on textualism to deviate from the original intent of Uruguay Round negotiators (pp. 246−49).Footnote 8
Some of the chapters contained in this volume are arguably foremost in the WTO research field. This book provides useful insights for both academic researchers and practitioners who are willing to consider the contemporary state of WTO research in East Asia. Nevertheless, this volume subtitled “East Asian Perspectives” could have been better completed if more pages were devoted to the discussion on China and Taiwan.
