Armed conflicts rage in many parts of the world, claiming high numbers of victims.Footnote 1 These victims are not without protection: it is well established that violations of international law must be remedied by reparation. Thus the Permanent Court of International Justice held in the Chórzow Factory case that ‘reparation must, as far as possible, wipe out all the consequences of the illegal act and re-establish the situation, which would, in all probability, have existed if that act had not been committed’.Footnote 2
The recent discussion on this subject has largely centred on the question of whether an individual right to reparation exists. Although scholars have not yet reached consensus on this point, there is at least a strong tendency to acknowledge the entitlement of the individual to reparation under modern international law.Footnote 3 Among the different forms of individual reparation, restitution and compensation are those most commonly awarded.Footnote 4
In contrast to individual reparation, collective reparation has received little scholarly attention. It is unclear to date whether collectives have a right to reparation, so this question is examined in the present article. In the first part, the concept of collective reparation is defined. It is followed by an analysis of the normative framework for collective reparation, which shows that international law supports the idea of collective reparation but leaves unclear whether such a remedy must be conceived of as a right. The final part stresses that the uncertainties as to the legal status of collective reparation should not divert attention from the need to develop robust programmes of collective reparation.
Definition of collective reparation
For the purposes of the present article, collective reparation will be defined as the benefits conferred on collectives in order to undo the collective harm that has been caused as a consequence of a violation of international law.Footnote 5 Collective reparation thus consists of four elements: benefits, a collective as beneficiary, collective harm, and a violation of international law. These elements will now be considered in greater detail.
Benefits
Collective reparation encompasses a wide range of different benefits. Representative examples can be found in the reports of truth commissions, which have repeatedly underlined the importance of collective reparation. Among the measures that have been recommended are the construction of schools or hospitals,Footnote 6 the establishment of memorials,Footnote 7 or the renaming of streets.Footnote 8
Two aspects of these benefits merit special attention. First, they are indivisible: victims who receive collective reparation are not able to enjoy the benefit on their own, but have to share it with other victims. Second, the benefits are diverse: while the most commonly awarded forms of individual reparation – that is, compensation and restitution – have a clearly defined content, collective reparation can take very different forms. As will be shown below, this has consequences for the question of whether collective reparation can be conceived of as a right.
Collective
Various collectives might be the beneficiaries of reparation.Footnote 9 The collectives that truth commissions have dealt with have included women and children,Footnote 10 village communities,Footnote 11 rural communities,Footnote 12 native communities,Footnote 13 and groups of displaced persons.Footnote 14 Examples of groups enjoying collective rights are found in the jurisprudence of the Inter-American Court of Human Rights (IACtHR).Footnote 15 For purposes of legal categorization, the beneficiaries of collective reparation might be divided into groups with legal personality on the one hand and aggregates of individuals on the other.
Collective harm
One of the most fundamental concepts of collective reparation is that it helps to undo what has been called ‘collective harm’.Footnote 16 This term is intended to express the idea that the targeting of a collective can cause harm that differs from the harm caused by targeting the same number of individuals who are not part of a collective. The existence of collective harm is evident in cases such as the Holocaust or the genocide of the Tutsi in Rwanda. The systematic extermination of the Jews in Europe caused harm that transcended the harm that would have resulted from the killing of an equivalent number of people not belonging to that group. It would likewise have made a difference for a Tutsi whether he or she was attacked as a Tutsi or as a person. Thus the group of Tutsi or Jews might constitute a source of identity and a socialization mechanism whose disruption constitutes collective harm.Footnote 17
The fact that international criminal law penalizes the destruction of groups as genocide confirms that the harm resulting from such a crime is greater than the harm resulting from the killing of an equivalent number of people not belonging to a group. Collective harm is not, however, restricted to cases of genocide. A widespread killing of members of a certain tribe who do not constitute a group in the sense of Article 6 of the Rome Statute of the International Criminal Court (ICC)Footnote 18 might still cause collective harm. Nor does collective harm presuppose a violation of collective rights, as the example of the European Jews or the Tutsi in Rwanda shows. For collective harm to occur it is therefore sufficient that victims share certain bonds, such as common cultural, religious, tribal, or ethnic roots.Footnote 19
Violation of international law
The collective harm must have been caused by a violation of international law. A regime of liability for lawful conduct has not yet developed in international law.Footnote 20 The rules on collective reparation are thus secondary rules that govern the relationship resulting from the breach of primary rules.Footnote 21 In this regard it should be noted that there are several primary norms that require states to act. In particular, there are an increasing number of positive human rights obligations.Footnote 22 Conceptually, collective reparation has to be distinguished from these primary obligations. While positive obligations require states to act irrespective of a prior violation of international law, the obligation to make reparation presupposes such a violation.
Normative framework
The four characteristics of collective reparation as described above are fundamental to understanding the problems inherent in conceiving collective reparation as a right. These will be dealt with in the following part. It will first be explained that there are two ways of conceptualizing a right to collective reparation. It will then be shown that international law de lege lata leaves unclear whether groups have a right to collective reparation. Finally, some considerations de lege ferenda will be set forth.
Conceptualizing a right to collective reparation
There is heated discussion among scholars as to whether and, if so, to what extent public international law endorses the idea of group rights.Footnote 23 Some authors argue that international law already comprises certain group rights, which should therefore be accepted as a distinct category of rights.Footnote 24 Others take a rather critical stance towards group rights.Footnote 25 It would be beyond the scope of the present article to engage in an in-depth analysis of this problem. It does, however, need to be highlighted that there are two ways of conceptualizing a right to collective reparation. On the one hand, one might conceive of a right that pertains to a group with legal personality. For the purposes of the present article, such rights will be designated as ‘group rights strictu sensu’. On the other hand, one might conceive of a right that pertains to an aggregate of individuals. Thus, the right at issue in such a situation is not a group right strictu sensu but a right that pertains to a multiplicity of obligees. Rights of a multiplicity of obligees are known from national legal systems. As an example, one might adduce Section 432 of the German Civil Code, which stipulates:
If more than one person is to demand indivisible performance, then to the extent that they are not joint and several creditors, the obligor may only effect performance to all of them jointly and each obligee may only demand performance for all of them.Footnote 26
In a similar vein, Article 10.201 of the Principles of European Contract Law envisages ‘communal claims’ where the ‘debtor must perform to all the creditors and any creditor may require performance only for the benefit of all’.Footnote 27 Such communal claims can result from the nature of the obligation.
In the following analysis of the legal framework for collective reparation, this distinction between group rights strictu sensu and rights of a multiplicity of obligees will play an important role.
Considerations de lege lata
Soft law
The most recent effort to delineate victims' rights to reparation was finalized with the adoption by the UN General Assembly on 16 December 2005 of Basic Principles on the Right to a Remedy and Reparation (henceforth ‘Basic Principles’).Footnote 28 Though not binding, these principles give important insights into the right to reparation. Under the Basic Principles, victims are defined as
persons who individually or collectively suffered harm, including physical or mental injury, emotional suffering, economic loss or substantial impairment of their fundamental rights, through acts or omissions that constitute gross violations of international human rights law, or serious violations of international humanitarian law.Footnote 29
The remedies cited include adequate, effective, and prompt reparation.Footnote 30 Examples of reparation include measures such as commemorations and tributes to the victims.Footnote 31 These typically constitute collective reparation in the sense of the definition given above.Footnote 32
In spite of this commitment to protect persons who are targeted collectively,Footnote 33 the Basic Principles leave unclear who is entitled to claim reparation. Some guidance can be found in the so-called ‘Van Boven report’. This study, which preceded the adoption of the Basic Principles, explicitly demanded that groups of victims or victimized communities be entitled to present ‘collective claims’ for damages and to receive collective reparation accordingly.Footnote 34 This formulation is broad enough to cover group rights strictu sensu and rights of a multiplicity of obligees.
Collective reparation also plays a role in the Updated Set of Principles to Combat Impunity.Footnote 35 According to Principle 31, ‘Any human rights violation gives rise to a right to reparation on the part of the victim or his or her beneficiaries’.Footnote 36 Principle 34 specifies that reparation shall include ‘measures of restitution, compensation, rehabilitation, and satisfaction as provided by international law’.Footnote 37 It is noteworthy that a previous draft of Principle 34 contained the word ‘individual’ before the phrase ‘measures concerning the right to restitution, compensation …’. This restriction was deleted in order to make clear that reparation does not pertain solely to individual measures but also includes collective measures.Footnote 38 As regards the procedure of providing reparation, Principle 32 now stipulates that reparations may be ‘provided through programmes … addressed to individuals and to communities’.Footnote 39 The legal position of these communities is not specified in more detail.
Treaty law
Compared to the soft law principles discussed above, treaty law is even more vague as regards the existence of a right to collective reparation. Provisions such as Article 3 of the 1907 Hague Convention (IV) or Article 91 of 1977 Additional Protocol I to the 1949 Geneva Conventions, which are often referred to as a basis for a right to reparation,Footnote 40 do not explicitly deal with collective reparation. Neither do human rights instruments.Footnote 41
Some human rights conventions, however, implicitly recognize the existence of collective victims. Thus Article 2 of the Optional Protocol to the Convention on the Elimination of All Forms of Discrimination against Women provides a communications procedure, which allows either individuals or groups of individuals to submit individual complaints to the Committee established under Article 17 of the Convention. Communications may also be submitted on behalf of individuals or groups of individuals.Footnote 42 Likewise, the European Convention on Human Rights stipulates that the
Court may receive applications from any person, non-governmental organization or group of individuals claiming to be the victim of a violation by one of the High Contracting Parties of the rights set forth in the Convention or the Protocols thereto.Footnote 43
A similar provision can also be found in the American Convention on Human Rights. Its Article 44 stipulates that groups of persons or non-governmental entities ‘may lodge petitions with the Commission containing denunciations or complaints of violations of the Convention by a State Party’.Footnote 44 What is striking about these examples is that there is a procedural norm giving groups a possibility to present a claim before the respective judicial authority. It is left unclear, however, whether groups can only assert a violation of primary norms or whether they can also claim collective reparation.
Finally, mention must be made of Article 75 of the Rome Statute of the ICC, which states that ‘The Court shall establish principles relating to reparations to, or in respect of, victims, including restitution, compensation and rehabilitation’.Footnote 45 The ICC's Rules of Procedure and Evidence contain additional information on reparation.Footnote 46 Rule 97 stipulates that ‘the Court may award reparations on an individualized basis or, where it deems it appropriate, on a collective basis or both’.Footnote 47 The formulation ‘on a collective basis’ is ambiguous. On the one hand, it could signify that the Court makes multiple awards without taking into account the particular circumstances of every single claim. In this case, Rule 97 would be interpreted as a norm paving the way for a mass claims procedure. On the other hand, it could be interpreted as a norm envisaging the award of reparation to collectives.Footnote 48 In light of Rule 98, this seems more convincing. According to the latter rule, ‘The Court may order that an award for reparations against a convicted person be made through the Trust Fund where the number of victims and the scope, forms and modalities of reparations makes a collective award more appropriate’.Footnote 49 Thus Rule 98 does not speak of several awards being made in a mass claims procedure, but of a single collective award. This might be interpreted as an implicit acknowledgement of a right to collective reparation – be it a group right strictu sensu or the right of a multiplicity of obligees. However, the wording of Rules 97 and 98 does not explicitly spell out such a right.
State practice
In state practice, collective reparation has seldom played an important role. The most relevant examples of such remedies can be found in the jurisprudence of the Inter-American Court of Human Rights and in recommendations by truth commissions.
In the jurisprudence of the Inter-American Court of Human Rights there are a few decisions indicating that the Court embraces the concept of collective reparation. A prominent example is the decision rendered in the Mayagna (Sumo) Awas Tingi Community v. Nicaragua case, in which the Court found that Nicaragua had violated the right to property protected by Article 21 of the American Convention on Human Rights to the detriment of the members of the said indigenous community.Footnote 50 According to the Court, the violation of this primary right had to be remedied by a measure that benefited the group as such. It therefore decided that Nicaragua had to adopt in its domestic law, pursuant to Article 2 of the American Convention on Human Rights, ‘the legislative, administrative and any other measures required to create an effective mechanism for delimitation, demarcation, and titling of the property of indigenous communities, in accordance with their customary law, values, customs and mores’.Footnote 51 It must be emphasized that the Court considered the Mayagna (Sumo) Awas Tingi Community as holder of a collective right to property. Since this arguably presupposes – though only to a limited extent – legal personality, the reparative measure could be conceived of as a ‘group right’ strictu sensu. The Court did not, however, explicitly spell out such a right. Instead of using the language of rights, it used the language of obligations.
A further decision that addressed collective remedies was rendered in Moiwana v. Suriname. In this case, survivors of a massacre that took place in Moiwana village during the Surinamese civil war asserted a violation of their rights.Footnote 52 Since the massacre had occurred before Suriname became party to the American Convention on Human Rights, the Court could only rule upon those violations that had still continued after the Convention's entry into force for Suriname.Footnote 53 Having found that Suriname had violated Articles 5, 8, 21, 22, and 25 of the American Convention on Human Rights,Footnote 54 the Court made the following remark on reparations:
Given that the victims of the present case are members of the N'djuka culture, this Tribunal considers that the individual reparations to be awarded must be supplemented by communal measures; said reparations will be granted to the community as a whole ….Footnote 55
The collective reparation envisaged by the Court included measures such as an effective investigation,Footnote 56 the establishment of a development fund for health, housing, and educational programmes,Footnote 57 a public apology,Footnote 58 and the construction of a commemorative building.Footnote 59 This judgment is striking in that the decision to grant collective reparation was not based on the violation of any collective rights. Rather, it was the cultural bonds of the victims that, in the Court's view, justified the award of collective reparation. Since the group concerned had no legal personality, a potential right to collective reparation was conceivable only as the right of a multiplicity of obligees. Again, the language used does not clearly support such an interpretation.
Yet another rationale for reparation with a collective dimension can be found in the decision rendered in ‘Street Children’ (Villagrán-Morales et al.) v. Guatemala.Footnote 60 In this case, the Court had to deal with crimes committed against street children by members of the security force, and the failure of state mechanisms to adequately respond to these violations. Ruling upon the question of reparation, the Court stressed the need to address not only the pecuniary damage but also those harmful effects that cannot be assessed in monetary terms.Footnote 61 As one remedy responding to this kind of harm, the Court ordered Guatemala to designate an educational centre with a name allusive to the victims. It further ordered Guatemala to place in that centre a plaque with the victims' names. As a justification for this measure, the Court adduced two reasons. On the one hand, it should raise awareness to avoid the repetition of similar harmful acts. On the other hand, it should keep the memory of the victims alive.Footnote 62
There are good reasons for arguing that this judgment did not concern collective reparation in the sense of the definition given above. First, it is highly questionable whether the benefit at issue was intended to undo collective harm. Doubts arise because the Court ordered a very similar benefit in a case that concerned only one victim: in Trujillo Oroza v. Bolivia, the Court had to deal with the illegal detention, torture, forced disappearance, and death of a single person, José Carlos Trujillo Oroza.Footnote 63 It nevertheless ordered non-pecuniary reparation, including the assignment of the name of the victim to an educational establishment in Santa Cruz. As a justification, the Court argued that this measure would contribute to raising public awareness about the need to avoid the repetition of similar harmful acts and to keeping the victim's memory alive.Footnote 64 The fact that there was only one direct victim did not bar the Court from awarding almost the same kind of reparation as in the Street Children case mentioned above.Footnote 65
Second, it must be noted that, insofar as the reparative measures were designed to prevent the recurrence of similar violations in the future, the Court ordered measures that were typically owed under primary obligations. This blurring of primary and secondary obligations becomes even more evident in Caracazo v. Venezuela.Footnote 66 In this case, the Court had to deal with violations of human rights committed by Venezuelan armed forces and security agencies during public order disturbances.Footnote 67 Ruling upon the question of reparation, the Court ordered Venezuela to provide for training of all members of its armed forces and security agencies on the principles and provisions of human rights protection and regarding the limits to which the use of weapons by law enforcement officials is subject.Footnote 68 These measures are not typical reparative measures, since they are owed irrespective of a prior violation of rights.
The foregoing analysis shows that collective reparation plays a role in the jurisprudence of the Inter-American Court of Human Rights. In all the decisions examined, the Court awarded remedies that benefited not only a single person but also collectives. These collectives included a group enjoying primary rights, as well as aggregates of individuals without legal personality. It remains unclear whether the Court considered these collectives as a holder of a right to reparation. The language used by the Court is not supportive of a group right. Thus the Court did not speak of a ‘right of the respective communities’ but of an obligation of the responsible state to take reparative measures.
Truth commissions have likewise dealt with collective reparation and, as mentioned above, have repeatedly recommended it.Footnote 69 Despite the various commitments to protect communities, truth commissions did not specifically address their legal status either. In that regard, all that can be found in their recommendations are definitions of the term ‘victim’. Truth commissions have pointed out that victims include persons who are harmed ‘collectively’,Footnote 70 ‘together with one or more persons’Footnote 71 or ‘as part of a collective’.Footnote 72 These formulations closely resemble the definition used in the Basic Principles. They do little to elucidate whether and, if so, to what extent there is a right to collective reparation.
Considerations de lege ferenda
This rather opaque picture of the normative framework de lega lata leads to the question of whether collective reparation is conceivable as a right de lege ferenda. I shall not provide a definite answer to this question but confine my analysis to setting out four dilemmas that the acknowledgement of a right to collective reparation might entail.
Determining the holder of the right
The first dilemma concerns the difficulty of determining the holder of a right to collective reparation. Our society consists of a huge variety of sub-groups. In many cases these groups lack clear delimitations, so that it is difficult – if not impossible – to ascertain who is a member of the group and who is not. It would not make sense for a legal order to grant all these groups collective rights. This is so because, for a norm to be effective, there must be clarity as to who can claim a right. Conversely, it must be clear to whom a duty is owed.
This objection might be countered by arguing that the group of victims who may claim collective reparation consists of those persons who have suffered collective harm. But this does not solve the problem, because it is difficult to determine who has suffered collective harm. In the wake of armed conflicts, different groups might claim to have done so. At one end of the spectrum, there could conceivably be a situation where an armed attack is directed against an already existing group of people with legal personality, which enjoys protection under a primary collective right. In this case it might be quite easy to determine the group of victims who have suffered collective harm. At the other end of the spectrum, there is the situation where no group existed at the time the armed conflict took place. In that case it is only the jointly suffered harm that unites the ‘group’ of victims. It is questionable whether this is sufficient to constitute collective harm.Footnote 73
Determining the benefit
The second dilemma arises from the fact that there are a wide variety of benefits that might be awarded as a form of collective reparation; as stated above, the benefits that have been recommended as collective reparation range from the construction of a memorial through the renaming of streets to the construction of hospitals. There are two ways to deal with this problem. On the one hand, the benefit could be determined in consultation with the victims, as has been recommended by several truth commissions.Footnote 74 This procedure might be a very useful policy option. From a legal perspective, however, it seems rather problematic to let the beneficiaries determine their own benefits. On the other hand, one might conceive of an abstract right that obligates the responsible party to confer upon victims a benefit that is not defined in more detail. This solution, too, seems problematic because the benefit would be highly unspecific. The creation of an ineffective right might weaken the concept of rights as such.Footnote 75
Enforceability
The third dilemma concerns the implementation of a right to collective reparation. The large majority of collectives that have been affected by armed conflicts have no legal personality. They tend to consist of groups that share certain bonds such as common cultural or tribal roots. Even if it is possible to conceive of a right of a multiplicity of obligees who do not enjoy legal personality, the problem of how to enforce such a right would still remain. Groups that want to exercise their rights need to be internally organized.Footnote 76 There must, for example, be an agent who is entitled to represent their interests. Typically, the groups that suffer collective harm do not meet these requirements.
Interplay with individual reparation
Finally, there is a general problem about granting rights to groups, namely the risk of thereby undermining individual rights. Group rights and individual rights may in fact conflict in various ways.Footnote 77 Moreover, the rights of the group may not only encroach upon rights of its members but may also come into conflict with rights of outsiders.
Nonetheless, in the context of collective reparation, the significance of this problem seems rather limited. Above all, it must be borne in mind that collective reparation addresses collective harm alone, and not individual harm. In most cases it will therefore only have a supplementary function. Individual harm will still have to be remedied by individual reparation. An exception might only occur if there is exclusive violation of a group right strictu sensu. In such a situation there would probably be no need for individual reparation, because of the absence of individual harm. This would hardly pose any problems, as the secondary right to reparation would only ‘follow’ the primary group right. In other words, in order to challenge collective reparation in this case, the primary group right would need to be challenged as well. Apart from this, it is highly questionable whether the possibility of conflicts between group rights and individual rights is a valid objection to group rights. Conflicting claims to autonomy can be found in every legal system.Footnote 78 From a legal perspective, it makes hardly any difference whether a collective or an individual entity voices such a claim to autonomy: in both cases the conflict between the two claims has to be resolved.Footnote 79 Striking a balance between them seems the most suitable means of meeting this challenge.Footnote 80
Conclusion
The acknowledgement of a right to collective reparation poses several problems. The present article has no intention of suggesting that these problems warrant the rejection of a right to collective reparation. As shown above, there are situations in which one can conceive of such a right. In others, however, this seems hardly possible. Future discussion on a right to collective reparation should therefore be kept under particularly careful observation.
The need for collective reparation
The existing uncertainties as to the legal status of collective remedies should not detract from their high reparative capacity. Above all, collective reparation has a remedial function.Footnote 81 By awarding a benefit to the collective that has suffered harm, collective reparation constitutes a form of acknowledgement of that collective. This helps to undo the harm that has been caused. Unsurprisingly, there is empirical data indicating that victims of armed conflict sometimes demand collective remedies.Footnote 82
Collective reparation is not limited to undoing the immediate effects of the harm suffered. Rather, it also contributes to the long-term goal of building up peaceful post-conflict societies.Footnote 83 Efforts to promote reconciliation in war-torn societies ultimately aim to create conditions for the coexistence of victims and perpetrators. Collective reparation can play an important role in this process, as has repeatedly been emphasized by truth commissions. Thus the Truth Commission for Timor Leste stated: ‘Helping individuals and communities who had suffered to recover, and restoring their sense of dignity, was inseparable from the task of repairing relationships damaged by conflict and of building lasting reconciliation’.Footnote 84
Progress towards the objective of forging a new society might be hampered by an entirely individualized claims process.Footnote 85 This is not meant to suggest that collective reparation should replace individual reparation. However, certain disruptive effects that may go along with individual reparation can be avoided by having recourse to collective reparation. A distinguishing characteristic of collective remedies is notably that they reach every victim who has suffered harm during an armed conflict.Footnote 86 This avoids the negative side-effect of individual reparation that single victims might not receive any reparation at all.Footnote 87 Such an exclusion of individual victims from an individualized claims process can have several reasons: they may not have the necessary funds or information to lodge a claim;Footnote 88 they may be unable to invoke the jurisdiction of a certain court;Footnote 89 and the number of compensatory awards may be restricted due to limited resources.Footnote 90
Collective reparations are thus a necessary response to collective harm. Irrespective of whether one can conceive of a right to these remedies, responsible parties should make every effort to develop robust programmes of collective reparation. The choice of the appropriate remedy should be made in consultation with the victims.
