Pliny the Elder's well-known characterisation of Palmyra-Tadmor as an independent city between the Roman and Parthian empires serves as the starting-point of this volume with nine contributions, originally presented at the conference ‘Palmyra.Orient.Okzident’ that was organised by Michael Sommer in Oldenburg in 2018. Most historians think Pliny's description of the renowned oasis city in the Syrian desert is anachronistic at best, arguing that Palmyra was firmly within the Roman Empire and its province Syria by the Flavian period. In the first chapter and introduction to the volume, S. stands up for the Roman polymath by arguing that it is incorrect to say that Palmyra was ‘part of’ the Roman Empire. He argues the intensity of governance within ancient empires varied across space and time. When Pliny wrote his Natural History around c.e. 70, Palmyra still was in the twilight between empires, and basically independent. Over time, the city gradually moved into Rome's orbit, but S. concludes that it remained a unique, hybrid civilisation till Zenobia was defeated by Aurelian in c.e. 272. Instead of looking for the moment Palmyra was integrated in the imperial system, S. argues, historians should try to gauge how Rome's influence and control changed over time. He briefly illustrates this by sketching three histories: Palmyra as a trading hub, Palmyra's symbolic world and Palmyra's institutions.
The scope of the articles in this volume is more limited than the ambitious programme S. presents in his introduction (and that he fully developed in his Roms orientalische Steppengrenze. Palmyra – Edessa – Dura Europos – Hatra. Eine Kulturgeschichte von Pompeius bis Diokletian, first published in 2005). Whereas the second chapter by Ted Kaizer may be read as a general overview of the various stages in the relationship of the oasis with Rome, the following five articles focus primarily on aspects of Palmyrene trade. Palmyra's symbolic world and its institutions are occasionally mentioned, but only in passing. Strictly speaking, the two final articles fall outside the scope of this volume. George Müller analyses Palmyra's position between East and West in Zosimus’ historiography. Although the article has interesting things to say about the fifth-century Greek writer's perspective on history, it adds little to our understanding of the history of Palmyra and its relationship with Rome during the first three centuries c.e. The final chapter by Alexander Will deals with the present-day political situation in post-war Syria, notably the relationship of the Assad regime with external political powers, such as Russia, Turkey, Israel and Iran.
In ch. 2, Ted Kaizer discusses the possible development of Tadmor-Palmyra into a Greek city in the Roman world in five subsequent periods. Following S.'s suggestion, Kaizer examines how far Roman influence and control reached in Palmyra. Although he agrees with S. that this influence had grown significantly by the second century c.e., he refers to a recently published military tomb stone dated in c.e. 27 to illustrate Palmyra's incorporation in the empire under the Julio-Claudians. Whether this implies that he rejects S.'s notion of the region of Palmyra as a twilight zone is not entirely clear. In the description of the subsequent periods, the stress is on gradual change and Palmyra's extraordinary position in the Roman Empire. For Kaizer, it is Palmyra's unique character that stands out, not its character as a Greek city.
The following five chapters are all related to Palmyra's main source of income and the reason for its growth: (long-distance) trade. In ch. 3, Michael Sommer focuses on the beginnings of this trade. Recent ceramic finds from Hellenistic trenches to the south of the wadi in Palmyra confirm the long-standing hypothesis that trade with Mesopotamia took off after the Parthians took over in Mesopotamia. In the politically unstable period that followed, the Palmyrenes, helped by the nomadic population living in its environs, managed to become the gateway between East and West. In the following chapter, Jorgen Christian Meyer uses recent Norwegian research into the area surrounding Palmyra to explain how the city could sustain its growing population. He shows that floodwater farming in the al-Tarafa depression west of the oasis enabled Palmyra to import nearly all its cereals from its hinterland. Ch. 5, by Matthew A. Cobb, focuses on Palmyrene merchants and the Red Sea trade and sets out to explain why some Palmyrene merchants preferred this route over the highly profitable Mesopotamian Persian-Gulf trade. Cobb conjectures that the merchants followed the Palmyrene military units stationed in Egypt.
The following chapters by Eivind Heldaas Seland and Ann-Christine Sander focus on the status of members of Palmyra's elite who were involved in long-distance trade. In view of the lacunary character of the evidence, it is not surprising their interpretations diverge. In his short, but lucid and thought-provoking article, Heldaas Seland reviews the three traditional models for interpreting elite involvement in trade; the merchant prince, the tribal leader and the Roman aristocrat. Whereas Heldaas Seland himself and other contemporary historians have recently propounded the importance of tribal leaders of some sort, he now argues that this aristocratic elite was replaced in the late second and third centuries by a new elite of rich ship-owners that is best described in terms of Rostovtzeff's merchant prince. The idea is fascinating, not least because it is plausible that Palmyra's social organisation changed over the course of time. Nonetheless, this reviewer thinks that the arguments that Heldaas Seland advances to substantiate his hypothesis fail to convince. In line with S.'s stress on the tribal aspects of Palmyrene society, his PhD student Ann-Christine Sander underlines the extraordinary position of Palmyra's elite as military leaders. It is laudable that she sets out to supplement the lacunary information provided by the caravan inscriptions with other models and sources. Hence, she refers to representations of camels and horses in Palmyrene elite graves to illustrate the martial identity of the deceased. One should not, however, dismiss the possibility that these animals refer to other elite activities, such as hunting (a hunting scene is part of the painted decoration of a banquet hall owned by Palmyrenes in nearby Dura-Europos).
The contributions in this volume share a fascination with Palmyra's incomparable character. No doubt Palmyra was unique. But so, in a way, were all cities in the Roman empire. The label ‘unique’ is as meaningless as it is true. Our understanding of local idiosyncrasies is largely determined by the evidence at our disposal. Compared to most cities in the Roman empire, the evidence for Palmyra's history is extensive. Consequently, Palmyra provides us with one of the most interesting case studies of economic and cultural interaction in the Roman empire. The volume under review makes an important contribution to this discussion.
