From what might be termed the more theoretical end of the humanities and social sciences, social policy can often get a rather poor press. By treating work in social policy as if it were in permanent and credulous acceptance of the latest think-tanked Whitehall dictat, we can make the silly mistake of conflating the subject with its objects of study. Social policy, as John Clarke observes, is often subordinated, infantilised and feminised as a ‘junior’ subject, existing ‘below the high table of “real” disciplines’ where ‘the big boys play’ (Clarke, Reference Clarke2004: 3).
This refusal to give credence to the critical and conceptual potentialities of the subject is proven doubly wrong by this new multiple-author textbook, which is largely successful in its attempts to set out an overview of the issues of race and ethnicity in recent British social policy. While social constructionism and anti-essentialism are today quite orthodox positions in race theory, the authors of Understanding ‘Race’ and Ethnicity demonstrate considerable skill in applying them to complicate, unsettle and question themes and categories of race and culture, while at the same time holding onto those themes and categories as potential levers to challenge discrimination, prejudice and inequality. This process of continuous conceptual negotiation − where working knowledges are unpicked while a pragmatic eye is kept on the necessarily ‘empirical’ basis of argument and proof within the policy field − makes for a book that nicely refuses a reductively theory/practice division of intellectual labour.
Running throughout Understanding ‘Race’ and Ethnicity is a reading of the weaknesses of ‘community cohesion’, the still-dominant framework of local government race politics. A number of the book's authors highlight community cohesion's tendency to deny or downplay racism, far-right agitation and Islamophobic domestic and foreign policy. A chapter contributed by Ronny Flynn and Gary Craig is rightly scornful of the way that short-termist and reductive readings of ‘integration’ and ‘cohesion’ stand in the way of an adequate understanding of the complex processes they purport to describe. The book does perhaps miss a trick or two in its concluding estimation of community cohesion as ‘a return to the language of assimilation’ (p. 250), for however divisive its race politics, community cohesion is undeniably a product of twenty-first century Britain, and is shot through with its novelties, moralities and contradictions. While, for example, Understanding ‘Race’ and Ethnicity remarks on a need to conceptualise forms of white ethnicity, it does not get to grips with the way that community cohesion, in its reckoning of monadic and uncommunicative tribes of urban trouble, finds a new narrative role for a racialised lumpen ‘white working class’.
Similarly, while this book registers how the incorporation of race into the single Equalities Act (2010) has led to its marginalisation in the housing sector, disability and youth services, it is not quite so good at reflecting on some of the accompanying cultural changes, both within and outside Britain's BME communities, that have been contributory factors in the sidelining of a distinctively black voice and position in policy debate. There is a complex story that is not told here about the attenuation and fragmentation of black organisation and leadership that is in part to do with the social and economic successes of certain fractions and strata of minoritised groups within contemporary British society. While this is a book that is successful in describing and critically engaging with problems and deficiencies in a wide range of social policy areas, it is less successful in thinking through the ways in which the characteristics of race, as they are thought and lived today, make some of the old solutions and strategies of a progressive race politics rather less viable or meaningful than they once were. This is not to suggest that it should be the project of the authors of this book to produce some kind of a manifesto for a new black politics, but rather that critical attention to race in welfare and social policy might develop some useful resources by thinking more carefully about the validity of models and modes of minority representation and engagement that arguably belong to an earlier historical moment.
This is a task easier said than done, and the fact that Understanding ‘Race’ and Ethnicity is lacking in this regard points less to a failing of the book and more to a wider problem with understanding the character of race today. Our culture has shaped the concept of race in ways that are more fragmented and complex than ever before, and the challenge to social policy, as elsewhere, is going to be as much to do with reconsidering some of the orthodoxies of the thinking that sets out to challenge prejudice, inequality and discrimination, as it will be to undertake those tasks themselves.
