There has been a long-standing interest in the effects of immigrants' legal status on several areas of life, with particular attention to how legal status affects immigrants' access to goods and services and to the labour market. Although this interest has continued, and even expanded, the angle from which legal status is examined has shifted from depicting it as an individual characteristic commonly used as a variable, to a focus on (il)legality, a status that the laws of the receiving country construct. This new perspective treats legal status as a condition that is created and is mutable and in which state power plays a central role in its perpetuation. This analytic shift allows for analysis that locates a multiplicity of activities and behaviours in direct relation to the state, and allows us to consider how far into intimate spaces of immigrant life state power can reach. Boehm's book is a welcome addition to this new tradition.
In this engaging book, Boehm takes us into the intimate spaces of Mexican families whose members conduct their lives between two countries, even when individuals do not physically move. Her study participants are deeply affected in one way or another by US immigration and enforcement policies, which reach deep into origin communities in Mexico. The study shows how state power penetrates intimate spheres and tears families apart, altering gender and generational relations, transforming families, shaping motivations and plans, and guiding and directing (and redirecting) migrations. She shows how the strong presence of the state is felt and reacted to, how people understand it and in turn adjust, transform and create new family forms. However, she also demonstrates that though the potency of the state can transform lives, it does not determine them completely. Boehm's nuanced work calls attention to how individuals respond and act, from specific social positions and within the constraints that state institutions impose. And while Boehm's observations capture the predicament of Mexican immigrants, they are also pertinent to examinations of immigration to other major receiving countries, as well as for a more general understanding of the relationship between individuals and structural forces. As such, this book is relevant beyond the empirical case on which Boehm focuses.
The book is divided into three substantive parts – transborder families, gendered migrations and children on the move – that together represent the different analytical angles from which to explore transnational families. It should be mentioned that Boehm did not conceptualize these topics a priori or end up writing about them by accident; the areas on which she focuses came up in interactions and conversations she had with her students in language classes she taught during fieldwork in New Mexico and during visits to the immigrants' hometowns in Mexico. Thus, in inductive fashion, she arrived at this structure of her work by listening closely to her study participants' stories and making observations of their quotidian activities. The result is a wonderful book that demonstrates that combining interviews with participant observation – and doing it well – can produce multiple benefits.
In the chapters in the first part, Boehm captures what it means to live separated across borders – a situation resulting from state actions and enforcement practices – and how individuals reconfigure families and kin relations under such conditions and even change their very notions of where ‘home’ is. In this section Boehm questions the notion of US ‘family reunification’ laws. She observes that even though family reunification is a core aspect of immigration law, the definition of ‘family’ that the state uses to regulate family reunification categorises family members as individuals and not as members of a family (that is, treating the entire family as a whole). Thus, the state ends up splitting the very families it supposedly seeks to reunite, as well as creating families with great potential for separation, such as those in which members have different legal statuses (the so-called ‘mixed-status families’). In the very perceptive chapters that comprise the second part, Boehm examines how migration trajectories intersect with legal status and gender ideologies, to produce a nuanced picture of how experiences of migration vary deeply for women and men. This picture is not static or black and white, and shows how individuals act within and outside state power, as well as the gendered transgressions in intimate spaces that state control makes possible. Part three exposes how the power of the US state, through its immigration laws, manifests itself in the lives of Mexican transnational children, as they migrate alone or with relatives to reunite with family members or in search of work, or stay in Mexico, contributing to the reconfiguration of these families in flux. Two important points that Boehm mentions are worth noting for future research on immigrant families. She takes issue with the often-used typology of immigrant generations (such as ‘1.5’ and ‘second’); in her view these can convey a static, uniform group, when in fact individuals in these generations are linked in various ways to transnationality and, depending on context (in the origin community, for instance), can be categorised very differently. She draws attention to the different forms of citizenship that current forms of migrant ‘illegality’ can produce, including one that she names ‘contingent citizenship’ – this is a form of citizenship that is partial, contingent and relational, and which, she argues, best captures the experiences of belonging and attachment that transnational children and youth experience today.
Since the state and laws play such a key role throughout the book, I would have liked to see a chapter or a section that summarises exactly what these laws are, how they are enforced and what they require immigrants to do, so as to better comprehend how they organise life for the migrants in the study. We do not see the mechanisms through which the state exerts its power. And although the observations in this study are rich and informative, I would have liked to see a discussion of how this case can (or cannot) inform a broader category of transnational families, so that the lessons learned from this study can resonate theoretically beyond it. The exercise of placing this case within a broader dialogue could have helped to solidify the arguments presented here. These comments, however, should not detract from the significant contributions that Intimate Migrations makes. There is a lot to learn from this timely book, and it should be read widely. I particularly recommend it to anyone interested in immigrant families, immigration law, citizenship and families in general, but its appeal should go beyond academia. This book would be ideal for helping politicians and pundits to understand that political decisions regarding immigration law have broad and deep consequences, often beyond the territory in which laws are enacted.
