A few years into Latin America's shift toward electing left-leaning presidents, Jorge Castañeda wrote an influential essay arguing that in fact two different types of leftist parties were coming to power; furthermore, the more modern, reformist type (“the right Left”) would benefit the region's political and economic progress and should receive U.S. support and encouragement, while the populist type (“the wrong Left”) would prove disastrous and should be contained (Jorge Castañeda, “Latin America's Left Turn,” Foreign Affairs 85 [May 2006]: 28–43). The edited volumes reviewed here take up the same task of assessing the new left governments now that more time has passed, but their evaluations diverge significantly.
Leftist Governments in Latin America, accepts Castañeda's dichotomization of the Left and his placement of most cases, though not his labels, and argues that, on the whole, the moderate left governments in Brazil, Chile, and Uruguay have advanced democracy and development more than what the editors call the “contestatory” left governments in Bolivia, Venezuela, Ecuador, and Nicaragua. Latin America's Left Turns, rejects the dichotomy, explicitly critiquing it in several chapters, and rather than offering a consistent typology, presents the left turns “as a multiplicity of disparate efforts to reopen or refound the constitutional order or social pact” (p. 4). The editors and contributors of Left Turns do not present a unified, simple take-away message regarding the Latin American Left's performance in office other than its diversity; most chapters reject the notion that one type of Left has performed better than another, a few chapters imply that the jury is still out, and one suggests that the Left produced better economic outcomes than other governments in the region.
Despite their diverging perspectives, both books find several areas of common ground. Both argue that the turn toward the left is unprecedented, has broad relevance for Latin America, and is partly, if not mostly, attributable to the flagging popularity of neoliberalism. Furthermore, both mostly eschew the populist label for the governments of Hugo Chávez, Evo Morales, and Rafael Correa, recognize that the new Left is less radical than the Left of the past, and refrain from providing advice to U.S. policymakers. The two books also coincide in the judgment that none of the left governments has created a coherent, systematic, and sustainable development strategy that could serve as a model for the region. Nonetheless, the editors of Leftist Governments clearly argue that the moderate Left, represented by Luis Inácio Lula da Silva and the Workers' Party of Brazil and by Ricardo Lagos, Michelle Bachelet, and the Socialist Party of Chile, offers a safer and superior option than the contestatory Left.
This central argument in Leftist Governments emerges most forcefully in Kurt Weyland's introduction and in the concluding chapter written by the editors collectively, where the cross-case comparisons are most explicit. The gradualist, prudent, moderate Left is respectful of and willing to negotiate with the opposition within existing political institutions to make relatively small changes to those institutions and to social and economic policy, and is thereby laying the groundwork for long-term success. The more radical, contestatory Left puts “ambition ahead of prudence,” deviates further from neoliberal policies, “and pushes through political reforms that strengthen the participatory, majoritarian features of democracy at the expense of pluralism and liberal safeguards” (p. 7); its successes in increasing political participation of traditionally marginalized groups are offset by its erosion of civil liberties, by its weaker economic and social performance, which moreover is unsustainable given dependence on natural resource exports, and by the risk of an “involution toward authoritarianism” (p. 152). In the end, the editors cite Aesop: The slow and steady tortoise is better than the impatient hare.
Javier Corrales's chapter on Venezuela reinforces the editors' arguments about the contestatory Left, yet unwittingly sparks doubts as well. Corrales provides several compelling, well-founded critiques of Chávez that underscore the editors' concerns, such as the expansion of presidential powers in Venezuela compared to other countries in the region and to the old constitution. However, these critiques resonate less than they should because, unlike the rest of the volume—which offers pros and cons of the different governments and considers competing perspectives—this chapter presents only one side. In so doing, it includes several questionable claims, among them that the “government controlled … 3,000 community radio stations” (p. 34); that the communal councils, with their millions of participants, are “presidentially appointed” (p. 36); that “income inequality has actually expanded” (p. 46); and that Chávez has done more to undermine democracy than any other elected president in the region since the 1980s. Furthermore, the chapter avoids mentioning the opposition-led military coup or its seven-week oil lockout. Those unfamiliar with Venezuela may be confused, wondering what “prestrike levels” (p. 43) of oil production means and why, as the editors state later, “mass satisfaction with democracy” has increased under Chávez (p. 174). Also complicating matters is the inclusion of a Heritage Foundation figure showing Brazil with the same score on the “Index of Economic Liberties” as three of the contestatory left countries (p. 41).
Other chapters in Leftist Governments—one each on Bolivia and Chile and two on Brazil—do not convey the same degree of conviction as that of the editors regarding the successes and shortcomings of the two Lefts, and, in places, they undermine the editors' interpretation of stark differences. The chapters on Chile and Brazil note improved economic growth rates and some limited advances in social policy, but also highlight important problems: In Chile, they are a failure to enhance participation or empowerment for the lower classes, high levels of inequality, and continued reliance on commodity exports. In Brazil, the problems are greater benefits for the business sector than for the poor despite the famous cash transfer program Bolsa Família; failure to restructure the economy to improve dynamism and end the “boom-bust economic cycles” (p. 123) or to overcome its “peculiar type of underdevelopment” (p. 124); a massive government payoff scheme (the mensalão); and an ongoing pattern of closed-door decision making that “has done nothing to begin to reverse the country's history of corruption and exclusion—and indeed may have made matters worse” (p. 123). These chapters do not read as ringing endorsements for the moderate Left. And George Molina's chapter on Bolivia offers a similarly nuanced take, one that, while aware of significant flaws in the Morales government and while advocating dialogue and compromise, seems more open to the possibility that “contestatory politics” could contribute to “progressive social and economic change” (p. 76).
Overall, while this volume is organized to provide support for a central argument through a clear introduction, country-based chapters for the main cases, and a comparative conclusion that examines additional cases as well, Left Turns would have benefited from greater cohesion. Instead of an overarching claim or set of arguments, the introduction offers several themes, and rather than a summary of findings or arguments, the conclusion provides an examination of the international context. The intervening 10 chapters are divided into three parts, with the first two addressing the main themes in the introduction—multitudes, liberalism and post(neo)liberalism, and constituent versus constituted power—and the third examining political economy issues such as social programs, fiscal policy, and relations with foreign investors. Each chapter is organized differently and considers a different case or, more often, set of cases. Thus, the book is rich in ideas and arguments, but difficult to summarize in a brief review.
Most interesting are the many ways in which Left Turns challenges the ideas in Leftist Governments, beginning with the rejection of the two Lefts thesis. Several authors argue that, on the one hand, lumping together cases in this way ignores important organizational and policy differences between pairs like Bolivia and Venezuela or Chile and Uruguay, and on the other hand, it misses or erases commonalities across the broad spectrum of the Left.
For example, Juan Luna argues that because the Uruguayan Left faced greater internal constraints than the Chilean Left, including a stronger party organization with tighter linkages to autonomously organized civil society groups, it was pushed to implement progressive income-tax reform, expand collective bargaining, and empower unions, while the Chilean Left did not. And the political economy section suggests that the left governments across the region are responding to a similar “incorporation crisis” with a diverse mix of policy tools that borrow from liberal, social-democratic, and radical-populist strategies (p. 171), that their economic strategies “combine orthodox and heterodox elements” (p. 193), and that they all have increased pressure on foreign investors because of increased bargaining power of states over firms in recent years. Furthermore, in Left Turns, the new participatory, majoritarian political reforms introduced by part of the Left—especially the constitutional changes allowing for referenda, recall, and citizen initiatives—are viewed with less alarm than one finds in Leftist Governments, mostly because the authors in Left Turns tend to regard liberalism as insufficient in Latin America or even as “complicit with the status quo” (p. 76).
As Maxwell Cameron and Kenneth Sharpe write, the main dilemma for the Left “has been to overcome the entrenched power of minorities in extremely unequal societies…. This is the context in which the use of constituent power to transform constitutions has been sought” (p. 77). For one contributor, Jon Beasley-Murray, the new left governments have not done enough to invoke constituent power and have become instead constituted power, upholding the state against the multitude. Generally, however, Left Turns is more favorable toward the new hybridity and experimentation under the Left than Leftist Governments, and sees the democratic institutions, both liberal and postliberal, as serving real functions of constraining political leaders and holding them accountable, even in Bolivia and Venezuela.
In the end, both books offer readers insightful and plausible interpretations of contemporary politics in the region and contribute to the debate over the two Lefts thesis. Although this reader remains unpersuaded by the two Lefts interpretation, others will surely find it vindicated, and adherents and critics alike would do well to challenge their own positions by reading each book.
