Until the 1970s, few books on Japanese law written in Western languages could be found. The situation has been changing over recent decades. Thanks to this book, and other recent publications, researchers interested in Japanese law are given the opportunity to learn about it, despite the fact they are not fluent in the Japanese language.
This is a wide-scoped, merit-worthy work coordinated by Daniel H. Foote (hereinafter referred to as the editor) that comprises areas such as administrative, criminal and constitutional law. It addresses the current challenges to the Japanese legal order, and the right and wrong turns of the reform thereof by means of projects that encompass the legal educational system, choice of a participative system for hypothetical trials of serial crimes, and other important adaptations indicated by editor.
Carl Steenstrup pursues, through extensive research, the fall of legal paradigms and concepts concerning the Japanese system by establishing new historical standards and non-acceptance of traditional ideas about the concept of ‘sin’, women rights, [and] samurai families of the Tokugawa period.
We are also given the opportunity to take a closer look at Nobuhiko Kasumi's paper, thanks to the editor's translation. It focuses on the peculiarities of the Shinritsu Koryo as well as the structure of trials made by prefectures, known as the ‘ukagai/shirei’ order, and unmistakably unravels the jurisdiction and authority of powers then held by local prefectures.
Eric A. Feldman's review of the undeniable influence of the model set by Takeyoshi Kawashima for the resolution of conflicts in Japan comes as a surprise. Emphasis should also be given to the study carried out by Yasuhei Taniguchi on the ideals spread by Kohji Tanabe about the ‘adversary system’ related to Japan's civil procedure code. Their production is a paradigm for any law specialist, irrespective of one's age or citizenship.
John O. Harley studies the Japanese judiciary system, starting with Supreme Court and the resources and the possible alternatives to maintain unchanged its integrity, autonomy, organizational structure, and the Judge career plan, in order to ensure its political independence. It is a structuralist approach intended to identify, in simple though not superficial terms, the reasons for their recognized success from the viewpoint of effectiveness of its institutions. A supplement to such a study is expected in the near future on account of the introduction of the new lay participation system to trials in 2009.
On the other hand, in addition to the Japanese judiciary system, Yasuharu Nagashima and E. Anthony Zaloon offer readers an approach to law and law practice by analyzing the operation of firms consolidated as of the 1990s, starting from examples offered by Anderson Mori, Mori Sogo, Nagashima Ohmo & Tsunematsu, and Nishimura & Partners. They highlight those facts that resulted from the changing approach from 1985 to 2002, such as globalization and the increasing internationalization of businesses that allowed mergers of a number of law firms in order to compete with British and US firms and for the future of legal practice in the country.
Yoshiro Miwa and J. Mark Ramseyer tackle the deregulation of Japanese services. Through the 1980s, the Japanese financial system was under the strict control of the Ministry of Finance. For example, there were unsurpassable restrictions between banking activities and stock trading. The article reviews the legislative enactment, the constitutional structure, and the political and electoral rules as well as the relationship between bureaucrats and politicians, business and public interest. Furthermore, it describes the dispute over commercial papers and the emergence of so-called non-bank intermediaries, which were unknown through the 1990s when Japan's financial system was exposed to the first major restructurings.
The book would not be complete without Kahei Rokumoto's review of legal education in Japan in terms of courses offered, the current program to be developed, the merits and errors of the ‘lecture-based law’ system of the [Japanese] Legal Training and Research Institute (LTRI), the examination assessment method, and the legal internship programs. Aided by quantitative tables, it is inclusive of the successful achievement of law students in the legal exams in major academic centers such as the universities of Tokyo, Waseda, Keio, Kyoto, and Chuo.
Additionally, Kahei Rokumoto reviews the new reforms implemented by the so-called ‘Japanese-style Law School System’. Two years following publication of this book, it can be seen that the planned results are different from the form anticipated in the beginning.
From such a micro review of the judiciary system, legal education, and practice of law in Japan, which were thoroughly detailed in Section I of the book, in Section II one will find articles on the individual, the State, and public law, which address Japanese constitutionalism and changes in infrastructure, its pacific and patronizing nature towards the freedom of the press described by Kazuyuki Takahashi and Lawrence W. Beer, and focus on its imperfections and effectiveness with respect to fundamental rights.
In a further step into public law, one will also learn how the concepts of transparency and accountability have been consolidated in administrative law over the last 40 years, especially with regard to freedom of information as the main topic of the Administrative Procedure Act, by strengthening Japanese governance and modifying the relationship among politicians, free enterprise, and bureaucrats so as to create new fronts demanding reforms in such fields, as reported by Tom Ginsburg and Katsuya Uga.
Furthermore, criminal law is reviewed since 1961 by Koya Matsuo, Joseph L. Hoffmann, and David T. Johnson from the viewpoints of the problems represented by the language used, international cooperation, the threat of terrorism, disclosure of information technology, and globalization. Nevertheless, it remains effective, efficient; today it is called ‘minute justice’ and it should be taken into account that the swift process thereof grants a considerable role for investigative prerogatives to prosecutors and police officers, and also approaches the penalties issue, including the death penalty.
The importance of environmental protection is recalled in the retrospective review by Koichiro Fujikura on the Minamata mercury disaster 50 years ago by means of a coherent report of the case, victims, and administrative compensation programs; such a case is a paradigm for the perception of liability and the damages awarded to the adversely affected population, and the presumed damages inflicted on the victims.
Within the individual-related field, Robert B. Leflar offers an interesting review of the medical malpractice doctrine based on statistical comparative studies conducted in Japan and in the United States. Such studies disclose the concern of both countries to acquire accurate information in order to diagnose the frequency and reasons for such errors, and in Japan to subsequently achieve an actual reduction in the occurrence thereof with the aid of the Japanese criminal justice system.
As expected, Section III of this book offers a comprehensive study of two of the major human science fields, namely law and economics. The articles presented clearly elucidate the nuances of tax, labor, and competition law and must necessarily be read by those law operators who wish to closely learn about Japan's business and corporate law.
Hideki Kanda and Curtis J. Milhaupt reviewed the transplantation of the US corporate model applicable to corporate duties (the director's fiduciary duty in Japanese Corporate law) of directors to the Japanese model.
Takashi Uchida and Verônica L. Taylor review the change of concepts used in contract law, such as the change in personal liability, the Product Liability Act, and consumer contracts foreseen by Takeyoshi Kawashima in the book organized by Arthur Taylor Von Mehren, which indicated material changes introduced since then, especially after the 1990s. In order to maximize effectiveness, the Labor law, Residential Tenancy Act, and the return to contract freedom are also addressed by such scholars. They also establish the role of Justice to optimize the effectiveness of contract relations.
Ryuichi Yamakawa reviews the changes in Japan's labor law with respect to the dismissal of workers and the hypotheses thereof, as well as the actual changes in the ‘life time employment’ system.
Furthermore, Harry First and Tadashi Shiraishi provide an important study about the advancement of competition law in Japan vis-à-vis the US system, and describe the [Japanese] Fair Trade Commission (JFTC) system. Starting from a review by legal Yoshio Kanazawa in 1963, the feature covers both JFTC studies and administrative guidelines established by distinct domestic agencies, especially by the Ministry of International Trade and Industry (MITI), and makes an attempt to sketch the ideal model for the anti-trust doctrine in Japan.
Naoki Koizumi and Toshiko Takenaka make conjectures about the influences of the Fujitsu/TI case on the Japanese Intellectual Property law as compared to the US system.
Hiroshi Kaneko reports on the reform of the Japanese tax system from the second half of the twentieth century and early twenty-first century. During the occupation of Japan, the US sent the Shoup Mission, which was intended to study Japan's tax system and make proposals for a reform. The Shoup's Reform played a significant role in the post-war Japanese tax system which underwent changes through the first oil crisis in 1973. Subsequently, there were the reforms of 1986–1988 inclusive of the choice of the value-added-tax and the income tax reform. This highlights important issues to be solved in the twenty-first century, such as the ‘System of tax mix’ issue, formed by ‘income, consumption, and property’; refers to reforms in individual and corporate income taxes, inheritance tax, value-added tax, and local taxes, in addition to improvement of tax management and the growth of tax law as a law school course. Christopher H. Hanna refers to Kaneko's paper, and presents proposals to the taxation system.
At last, Kent Anderson and Makoto Ito review the Japanese bankruptcy system and theorize on a new structure for the new century. They address special procedures, insolvency trends, and debtors' protection during bankruptcy proceedings available to corporate debtors.
In conclusion, I could notice the writers were not satisfied with easy answers for the misfortunes suffered by the legal order and did not limit themselves to reporting the modern doctrine. They pursue answers in papers and reports written by Japanese scholars in the past, and grant due attention and respect to the reasoning and thoughts consolidated through the generations in order to carry on the strict and trustworthy legal and doctrinal training. In addition, in this sense, the book has thoroughly accomplished its purpose.
