Saba Mahmood begins this book about the women's mosque movement in Cairo, Egypt, with the question many Western feminists ask of women who support Islamist movements: “why would such a large number of women across the Muslim world actively support a movement that seems inimical to their ‘own interests and agendas’?” (p. 2) Mahmood begins by challenging the very frameworks within which such a question is asked. Her ethnographic study exposes assumptions of both feminist theory and “secular–liberal thought” about the nature of the self, agency, and politics, as well as assumptions about the relationship between interiority and performance. Mahmood's goal in exposing these assumptions is to make room for other ways of conceptualizing the self, authority, and tradition—most particularly, to identify multiple forms of agency beyond that of subversive agency.
The women's mosque movement, which began to emerge in the 1970s as part of the larger Islamist revival and piety (da

wa) movements, developed in response to what participants experience as a marginalization of religious knowledge, ethics, and piety in an increasingly secular society. Participants gather at local mosques to study religious texts and to receive teachings from female preachers about how to cultivate piety. The emphasis of the mosque movement is on what Mahmood calls “outward markers of religiosity”: ritual practices, how one conducts oneself in public and in the family, dress, choice of entertainment, and so forth. Whereas many critics identify these markers as potentially mechanical and a substitute for a more “sincere and personal connection with God” (p. 146), movement participants maintain that these bodily practices actually shape and create piety, ethics, and morality.
Throughout the book, Mahmood tacks back and forth between ethnographic analysis of the mosque movement and discussions of Western feminist and liberal political intellectual history and theory. In the first chapter, she lays out the assumptions that many of her readers will bring to the terms “agency” and “resistance.” She concludes that agency has come to be understood in feminist thought as coterminous with “resistance,” “subversion,” and a particular “politically prescriptive project” [emphasis in original] (p. 10), thus precluding many scholars from seeing other forms of agency, which she defines as “ability to effect change in the world and in oneself” (p. 14).
Mahmood argues that mosque movement participants' primary mode of agency is through the construction of a pious self through cultivation of bodily practice. She builds here on Judith Butler's discussion of the significance and creative potential of performativity as a theory of agency (Butler, 1999, xxiv). Whereas Butler is interested primarily in the subversive potential of performativity, Mahmood analyzes ways in which performance creates when it is not subversive.
This site of agency is further complicated by the religious authority to which mosque movement participants resort, authority located outside of the individual. Mahmood asks, “How do we conceive of individual freedom in a context where the distinction between the subject's own desires and socially prescribed performances cannot be easily presumed, and where submission to certain forms of (external) authority is a condition for achieving the subject's potentiality?” (p. 31). A mosque movement participant arguing with her husband about her participation in the da

wa, possibly even defying him in her insistence to live by rigorous standards of piety, does so not out of an assumption of equal rights for women but out of “certain…moral orientations” based on scriptural authorities that she shares with her husband. Women's participation in the mosque movement and their increased literacy in religious texts and ethics give them the authority to engage in such discussions within frameworks traditionally limited to male religious specialists.
The ethnographic portions of Politics of Piety focus on the mosque movement's “pedagogies of persuasion”—teaching of textual traditions and modes of interpretation (chapter 3)—and the embodied character of Islamic knowledge as practiced by the mosque movement (chapter 4). Mahmood introduces female preachers (dā

iyāt, literally, those who perform da

wa) from several different kinds of mosques, whose preaching/teaching styles vary widely. One dā

iya trains her audience in modes of interpretation within the bounds of the four authoritative legal schools. Mahmood gives a wonderful description and analysis of how this kind of choice “works” when the dā

iya is confronted with the question of whether a woman should lead prayer when a capable male is present. The preacher “does not ground her justification for leading women in prayer rituals in an argument for gender equality, or women's equal capacity to perform such a task. Instead, she locates it within the space of disagreement among Muslim jurists about the conditions under which women may lead the prayer ritual” (p. 88).
The strongest contribution of the book is the analysis of ritual and bodily performance of piety and indigenous interpretations of such performance. Bodily practice such as veiling has often been interpreted by both scholars and secular–liberal Muslims as a “sign” of Muslim or nationalist identity. Mahmood argues that such interpretations are drawn from a post-Enlightenment tradition that assumes the existence of an abstract ethical system that is only enacted through external ritual and practice. In contrast, participants in a da

wa movement understand practice not simply as reflective of interior piety (and hence perhaps not ultimately necessary), but as transformative and creative of the (pious) self. Mahmood gives several examples of the ways in which this “work” of bodily and argumentative practices is understood, including practices of veiling and modesty, ritual prayer and weeping, and mosque lessons. The body is a site of moral training; it “constitutes both the potentiality and the means through which interiority is realized” (p. 159).
Through close ethnographic analysis of rhetorical teaching and bodily practice, Mahmood successfully articulates alternative forms of agency. However, she realizes that many feminist readers may still not be able to fully step into this alternative framework; and so she concludes by encouraging a mode of analysis that, rather than being singularly authoritative, minimally enters a conversation—a conversation that enables respectful coexistence of difference.
Politics of Piety is an excellent ethnographic study of an Islamist movement that takes the movement's own terms of engagement and practice seriously; it is an important (and corrective) contribution to feminist and religious studies for its emphasis on indigenous terminologies and alternative interpretive frameworks and to anthropology for its analysis of religious authority and the performative creation of ethics. The heavy theoretical engagement of the book will make this a difficult text for most undergraduate classes, but makes it particularly useful for graduate seminars.
