This insightful, well-researched and unorthodox book offers a set of interesting narratives about both the character of Samora Machel and the early years of the ‘Mozambican Dream’ – the radical attempt to build an African socialist revolutionary state in the wake of Portugal's brittle and violent colonial rule. It is not unusual for being a generally sympathetic account of the period written by a former cooperante (solidarity worker) – see also works by, for example, Barry Munslow and Judith Marshall – and it draws on a fair amount of information already in the public domain. However, the author's detailed descriptions of people, events and places carry a rare power to evoke the period vividly in the mind of the reader, capturing elements often effaced in other scholarly work.
The ‘lexical biography’ form – sections of varying length elaborating on an important word and alphabetically ordered – is well-suited to the project of remembering various scattered fragments of this history. This allows the overall portrait of Samora Machel and the broader period for Frelimo to emerge for the reader in the course of moving between them, although there may be some readers who find this frustrating rather than charming. LeFanu's choices cover aspects of Frelimo's programme already fairly well understood by students of Mozambique's political history, such as the ideology of the ‘New Man’ and the practice of ‘re-education’. However these are interspersed with fragments of her own cooperante life in Niassa, memories of Samora from various contemporaries and interesting encounters with figures such as artist Malangatana and Graça Machel. Entries such as ‘Mutimati’, on the place of a fictive poet in the revolution, are especially fascinating, but many of the most interesting entries were frustratingly short.
Some elements of the book's unique conceptualisation, design and execution might, however, be seen as both strengths and weaknesses. This is very much a critical elite sympathiser's account of the revolution, which tends to draw heavily on the experiences of a small group connected with Frelimo and Samora in a particular way. Sometimes this leads to unsatisfying imbalances in emphasis for this reader. For example, under ‘G’, prolonged attention is given to the Girassol Hotel in Maputo, where many cooperantes stayed, but much less to the ‘Grupos Dinamisadores’ who were everywhere amongst the population to mobilise for Frelimo's programme. Greater emphasis on the latter would have been far more revealing about the experience of the revolution amongst the broader population. Furthermore, whilst there is some questioning of various decisions taken by Samora, overall the portrait is deeply reverent and affectionate. Whilst this is no doubt a true reflection of what selected interviewees might have offered, it feels at times as if other perspectives beyond Frelimo could have been sought out, particularly with regard to the later period of rule.
Samora's unique legacy, which this book beautifully captures, is however an important battleground in contemporary Mozambique, both inside and outside Frelimo. There are some saudadista (loosely translatable as nostalgic) tendencies within this book when read in the light of today's politics, but given the author's entry point this is entirely understandable, and the author is transparent about her own commitments. Moreover, it is precisely the author's connection with Mozambique's past that gives this book its distinctive insights and sensitivities. It is highly recommended for anyone at all interested in Mozambique, as well as those curious about the histories of leadership and decision-making in African politics.
