Hyland, Lee, and Mills (Reference Hyland, Lee and Mills2015) make a strong case for research and practice on mindfulness within the industrial–organizational community. Their main argument is that mindfulness has the potential to provide physical, psychological, and performance benefits to employees and organizations. However, to realize these benefits, organizations must first provide mindfulness training programs to their employees. Along these lines they note that some organizations have established mindfulness training programs to enhance employee well-being, and some firms specialize in providing workplace mindfulness training.
Although workplace mindfulness training programs have been adapted from the mindfulness-based stress reduction model to be more conducive to the workplace (e.g., shorter classes, online programs) with some success, Hyland et al. note that there are concerns that limit the implementation of mindfulness training programs in the workplace, such as time demands that may make it impractical in organizations. However, there are also other concerns that revolve around the potential costs and benefits of mindfulness training programs. For example, what possible benefits can organizations expect, and what is the potential return on investment of mindfulness training? Why would an organization invest in mindfulness training over other potentially more important and beneficial training programs? What is the training need that might require mindfulness training? It would seem that, at best, mindfulness training might be used for stress management or as part of employee health and wellness programs. But even this begs the question of how mindfulness training compares with other stress management and wellness programs in terms of the costs and benefits.
In the remainder of this commentary, we offer a solution to this problem. In effect, we suggest that rather than trying to implement mindfulness training programs as stand-alone interventions in organizations, it will be more practical and feasible to provide mindfulness training as part of existing training programs.
Mindfulness in Training
Mindfulness has great potential for facilitating learning and training effectiveness because it is an individual, state-level variable that enhances cognitive, psychological, and physiological functioning and because the central outcome of mindfulness is improved self-regulation of thoughts, emotions, behaviors, and physiological reactions (Glomb, Duffy, Bono, & Yang, Reference Glomb, Duffy, Bono and Yang2011). As noted by Glomb et al. (Reference Glomb, Duffy, Bono and Yang2011), “mindfulness is the process of paying attention to what is happening in the moment—both internal (thoughts, bodily sensations) and external stimuli (physical and social environment” (p. 118). Glomb et al. (Reference Glomb, Duffy, Bono and Yang2011) also note that awareness and attention are at the heart of mindfulness, both of which are necessary for learning. Furthermore, they argue that mindfulness practices improve employee performance and well-being through self-regulation.
Self-regulated learning has been shown to be strongly related to learning, and trainees who engage in self-regulatory activity learn more than those who do not self-regulate (Sitzmann & Ely, Reference Sitzmann and Ely2011). Thus, if mindfulness practices lead to improved self-regulation, then including mindfulness practices in training should be beneficial for facilitating and improving learning and retention. Indeed, Kee and Liu (Reference Kee and Liu2011) found that mindfulness is associated with higher performance on a self-controlled motor learning task.
Therefore, we suggest that rather than offer mindfulness training as a distinct and independent type of training program, workplaces should include and embed it in existing training programs. This has a number of benefits for both mindfulness and training research and practice. For starters, the cost and time involved in providing mindfulness training in the workplace will be minimized because it will be provided as part of existing training programs. In addition, it removes concerns over the relevance of and need for mindfulness training as it is being used to enhance the effectiveness of a particular training program. In addition, the purpose of mindfulness practices and skills is clearly evident within the context of a particular training program and the associated skills being learned. As a result, it is no longer necessary to try to explain the “need” for mindfulness training or to justify its costs. In effect, employees will learn mindfulness skills as they learn training content within the guise of facilitating their learning. This not only has the potential to facilitate and improve trainee learning and retention but also can improve the transfer of training.
Mindfulness and the Transfer of Training
A key indicator of training effectiveness is the transfer of training or the extent to which knowledge and skills learned in training are used on the job and result in meaningful changes in job performance (Blume, Ford, Baldwin, & Huang, Reference Blume, Ford, Baldwin and Huang2010). In a meta-analysis of transfer of training research, Blume et al. (Reference Blume, Ford, Baldwin and Huang2010) found that trainee characteristics and work environment factors are related to transfer. Among the trainee characteristics, those with the strongest relationships were cognitive ability and conscientiousness. Neuroticism, self-efficacy, motivation to learn, and a learning goal orientation had small to moderate relationships with transfer. Among the work environment factors, the strongest relationships with transfer were the transfer climate and supervisor and peer support, although supervisor support had a stronger relationship with transfer than peer support. Finally, the effects of posttraining transfer interventions such as goal setting and relapse prevention were small to moderate.
The Blume et al. (Reference Blume, Ford, Baldwin and Huang2010) meta-analysis indicates a number of shortcomings when it comes to improving the transfer of training in organizations. First, the individual difference variables that are most strongly related to transfer are traits rather than states (cognitive ability and conscientiousness), and as such they can't be developed. Second, the strongest situational predictors of transfer are outside the control of the trainer and trainees (e.g., the transfer climate and supervisor support). Third, the effects of posttraining transfer interventions are small to modest. To make matters worse, when the same-source and same-measurement context (SS/SMC) is controlled, there are few strong predictor relationships with transfer (Blume et al., Reference Blume, Ford, Baldwin and Huang2010). This led Blume et al. (Reference Blume, Ford, Baldwin and Huang2010) to conclude that “although there are some significant relationships across studies, there are surprisingly few consistently strong individual predictors of transfer” (p. 90).
We suggest that mindfulness has the potential to overcome these shortcomings. First, it is important to understand why mindfulness might influence the transfer of training. Mindfulness involves attending to both external and internal phenomena in the present moment (Dane, Reference Dane2011). This can be especially beneficial for trainees given the importance of external events (e.g., peer and supervisor behavior) as well as internal processes (e.g., self-efficacy) for the transfer of training. Second, mindfulness is associated with a wide attentional breadth of present-moment phenomena (Dane, Reference Dane2011).
A wide attentional breadth of both external and internal phenomena can improve the likelihood for transfer of training in a variety of work situations. This is because with a wide attentional breadth to external factors, trainees will be attuned to a large number of stimuli, materials, and data in the transfer environment. With a wide internal attentional breadth, trainees will be attuned to their own thoughts, beliefs, and emotions in transfer situations. Thus, a wide external and internal attentional breadth is expected to facilitate and improve the likelihood that trainees will apply what they learn in training on the job. In addition, a number of the processes that link mindfulness to self-regulation (see Glomb et al., Reference Glomb, Duffy, Bono and Yang2011), such as a decreased use of automatic mental processes, response flexibility, decreased rumination, affective regulation, and increased self-determination and persistence, seem particularly relevant for the transfer of training.
What is perhaps most appealing about mindfulness as a predictor of the transfer of training is that it is a psychological state that can be developed, unlike other trainee characteristics that are related to transfer (e.g., cognitive ability, conscientiousness). Furthermore, in addition to having a direct effect on transfer, mindfulness might also function as a moderating and/or mediating variable for the effects of training on the transfer of training.
Mindfulness Practices in Training
In effect, what we are suggesting is that all training programs, regardless of their content and objectives, fully integrate mindfulness practices into the training process. Mindfulness practice can be included in training for the purpose of learning (learning mindfulness) and/or transfer (transfer mindfulness). The basic idea is to train trainees to observe internal and external stimuli related to learning the training content and/or the transfer of training.
There are several ways that mindfulness practices can be incorporated into existing training programs. For example, mindfulness interventions can be provided prior to the start of a training program either during an initial meeting or online, at the start of a classroom training program, during a classroom training program, and/or at the end of a classroom training program, much the same way that posttraining transfer of training interventions such as relapse prevention have been used.
What distinguishes mindfulness as a posttraining transfer intervention from relapse prevention is that it enables trainees to focus on external events and internal processes in the present moment. By comparison, relapse prevention, which is the most studied posttraining transfer intervention and has received only limited support (Hutchins & Burke, Reference Hutchins and Burke2006), focuses primarily on external future events that might make transfer difficult. However, with a mindfulness intervention, “individuals are attuned to a relatively large number of external and internal phenomena” (Dane, Reference Dane2011, p. 1001). Thus, a mindfulness posttraining transfer intervention would differ from relapse prevention in terms of its temporal orientation (present moment versus future oriented) and attentional breadth (wide versus narrow).
In the case of online training programs, mindfulness prompts can be used throughout a program in much the same way that self-regulation prompts have been used. Self-regulation prompts encourage trainees to engage in self-regulatory activities during training by asking them whether they have set goals, whether they are using effective strategies, and whether they are making progress toward their goals. Prompting self-regulation has been found to have positive effects on declarative and procedural knowledge as well as performance (Sitzmann, Bell, Kraiger, & Kanar, Reference Sitzmann, Bell, Kraiger and Kanar2009; Sitzmann & Ely, Reference Sitzmann and Ely2010). Mindfulness prompts can be used to stimulate mindfulness by prompting trainees to think about external and internal phenomena, which might also lead to improvements in learning and the transfer of training.
Conclusion
Our contention is that, for a number of reasons, it will be difficult to get organizations to invest in mindfulness training programs. Therefore, we maintain that the most practical and feasible approach for organizations to implement mindfulness training is to include it in existing training programs. This not only has the potential to improve trainee learning, retention, and transfer but also makes it more likely that trainees will be more mindful in other aspects of their work life, which can lead to further improvements in employee health, well-being, and performance.
Hyland, Lee, and Mills (Reference Hyland, Lee and Mills2015) make a strong case for research and practice on mindfulness within the industrial–organizational community. Their main argument is that mindfulness has the potential to provide physical, psychological, and performance benefits to employees and organizations. However, to realize these benefits, organizations must first provide mindfulness training programs to their employees. Along these lines they note that some organizations have established mindfulness training programs to enhance employee well-being, and some firms specialize in providing workplace mindfulness training.
Although workplace mindfulness training programs have been adapted from the mindfulness-based stress reduction model to be more conducive to the workplace (e.g., shorter classes, online programs) with some success, Hyland et al. note that there are concerns that limit the implementation of mindfulness training programs in the workplace, such as time demands that may make it impractical in organizations. However, there are also other concerns that revolve around the potential costs and benefits of mindfulness training programs. For example, what possible benefits can organizations expect, and what is the potential return on investment of mindfulness training? Why would an organization invest in mindfulness training over other potentially more important and beneficial training programs? What is the training need that might require mindfulness training? It would seem that, at best, mindfulness training might be used for stress management or as part of employee health and wellness programs. But even this begs the question of how mindfulness training compares with other stress management and wellness programs in terms of the costs and benefits.
In the remainder of this commentary, we offer a solution to this problem. In effect, we suggest that rather than trying to implement mindfulness training programs as stand-alone interventions in organizations, it will be more practical and feasible to provide mindfulness training as part of existing training programs.
Mindfulness in Training
Mindfulness has great potential for facilitating learning and training effectiveness because it is an individual, state-level variable that enhances cognitive, psychological, and physiological functioning and because the central outcome of mindfulness is improved self-regulation of thoughts, emotions, behaviors, and physiological reactions (Glomb, Duffy, Bono, & Yang, Reference Glomb, Duffy, Bono and Yang2011). As noted by Glomb et al. (Reference Glomb, Duffy, Bono and Yang2011), “mindfulness is the process of paying attention to what is happening in the moment—both internal (thoughts, bodily sensations) and external stimuli (physical and social environment” (p. 118). Glomb et al. (Reference Glomb, Duffy, Bono and Yang2011) also note that awareness and attention are at the heart of mindfulness, both of which are necessary for learning. Furthermore, they argue that mindfulness practices improve employee performance and well-being through self-regulation.
Self-regulated learning has been shown to be strongly related to learning, and trainees who engage in self-regulatory activity learn more than those who do not self-regulate (Sitzmann & Ely, Reference Sitzmann and Ely2011). Thus, if mindfulness practices lead to improved self-regulation, then including mindfulness practices in training should be beneficial for facilitating and improving learning and retention. Indeed, Kee and Liu (Reference Kee and Liu2011) found that mindfulness is associated with higher performance on a self-controlled motor learning task.
Therefore, we suggest that rather than offer mindfulness training as a distinct and independent type of training program, workplaces should include and embed it in existing training programs. This has a number of benefits for both mindfulness and training research and practice. For starters, the cost and time involved in providing mindfulness training in the workplace will be minimized because it will be provided as part of existing training programs. In addition, it removes concerns over the relevance of and need for mindfulness training as it is being used to enhance the effectiveness of a particular training program. In addition, the purpose of mindfulness practices and skills is clearly evident within the context of a particular training program and the associated skills being learned. As a result, it is no longer necessary to try to explain the “need” for mindfulness training or to justify its costs. In effect, employees will learn mindfulness skills as they learn training content within the guise of facilitating their learning. This not only has the potential to facilitate and improve trainee learning and retention but also can improve the transfer of training.
Mindfulness and the Transfer of Training
A key indicator of training effectiveness is the transfer of training or the extent to which knowledge and skills learned in training are used on the job and result in meaningful changes in job performance (Blume, Ford, Baldwin, & Huang, Reference Blume, Ford, Baldwin and Huang2010). In a meta-analysis of transfer of training research, Blume et al. (Reference Blume, Ford, Baldwin and Huang2010) found that trainee characteristics and work environment factors are related to transfer. Among the trainee characteristics, those with the strongest relationships were cognitive ability and conscientiousness. Neuroticism, self-efficacy, motivation to learn, and a learning goal orientation had small to moderate relationships with transfer. Among the work environment factors, the strongest relationships with transfer were the transfer climate and supervisor and peer support, although supervisor support had a stronger relationship with transfer than peer support. Finally, the effects of posttraining transfer interventions such as goal setting and relapse prevention were small to moderate.
The Blume et al. (Reference Blume, Ford, Baldwin and Huang2010) meta-analysis indicates a number of shortcomings when it comes to improving the transfer of training in organizations. First, the individual difference variables that are most strongly related to transfer are traits rather than states (cognitive ability and conscientiousness), and as such they can't be developed. Second, the strongest situational predictors of transfer are outside the control of the trainer and trainees (e.g., the transfer climate and supervisor support). Third, the effects of posttraining transfer interventions are small to modest. To make matters worse, when the same-source and same-measurement context (SS/SMC) is controlled, there are few strong predictor relationships with transfer (Blume et al., Reference Blume, Ford, Baldwin and Huang2010). This led Blume et al. (Reference Blume, Ford, Baldwin and Huang2010) to conclude that “although there are some significant relationships across studies, there are surprisingly few consistently strong individual predictors of transfer” (p. 90).
We suggest that mindfulness has the potential to overcome these shortcomings. First, it is important to understand why mindfulness might influence the transfer of training. Mindfulness involves attending to both external and internal phenomena in the present moment (Dane, Reference Dane2011). This can be especially beneficial for trainees given the importance of external events (e.g., peer and supervisor behavior) as well as internal processes (e.g., self-efficacy) for the transfer of training. Second, mindfulness is associated with a wide attentional breadth of present-moment phenomena (Dane, Reference Dane2011).
A wide attentional breadth of both external and internal phenomena can improve the likelihood for transfer of training in a variety of work situations. This is because with a wide attentional breadth to external factors, trainees will be attuned to a large number of stimuli, materials, and data in the transfer environment. With a wide internal attentional breadth, trainees will be attuned to their own thoughts, beliefs, and emotions in transfer situations. Thus, a wide external and internal attentional breadth is expected to facilitate and improve the likelihood that trainees will apply what they learn in training on the job. In addition, a number of the processes that link mindfulness to self-regulation (see Glomb et al., Reference Glomb, Duffy, Bono and Yang2011), such as a decreased use of automatic mental processes, response flexibility, decreased rumination, affective regulation, and increased self-determination and persistence, seem particularly relevant for the transfer of training.
What is perhaps most appealing about mindfulness as a predictor of the transfer of training is that it is a psychological state that can be developed, unlike other trainee characteristics that are related to transfer (e.g., cognitive ability, conscientiousness). Furthermore, in addition to having a direct effect on transfer, mindfulness might also function as a moderating and/or mediating variable for the effects of training on the transfer of training.
Mindfulness Practices in Training
In effect, what we are suggesting is that all training programs, regardless of their content and objectives, fully integrate mindfulness practices into the training process. Mindfulness practice can be included in training for the purpose of learning (learning mindfulness) and/or transfer (transfer mindfulness). The basic idea is to train trainees to observe internal and external stimuli related to learning the training content and/or the transfer of training.
There are several ways that mindfulness practices can be incorporated into existing training programs. For example, mindfulness interventions can be provided prior to the start of a training program either during an initial meeting or online, at the start of a classroom training program, during a classroom training program, and/or at the end of a classroom training program, much the same way that posttraining transfer of training interventions such as relapse prevention have been used.
What distinguishes mindfulness as a posttraining transfer intervention from relapse prevention is that it enables trainees to focus on external events and internal processes in the present moment. By comparison, relapse prevention, which is the most studied posttraining transfer intervention and has received only limited support (Hutchins & Burke, Reference Hutchins and Burke2006), focuses primarily on external future events that might make transfer difficult. However, with a mindfulness intervention, “individuals are attuned to a relatively large number of external and internal phenomena” (Dane, Reference Dane2011, p. 1001). Thus, a mindfulness posttraining transfer intervention would differ from relapse prevention in terms of its temporal orientation (present moment versus future oriented) and attentional breadth (wide versus narrow).
In the case of online training programs, mindfulness prompts can be used throughout a program in much the same way that self-regulation prompts have been used. Self-regulation prompts encourage trainees to engage in self-regulatory activities during training by asking them whether they have set goals, whether they are using effective strategies, and whether they are making progress toward their goals. Prompting self-regulation has been found to have positive effects on declarative and procedural knowledge as well as performance (Sitzmann, Bell, Kraiger, & Kanar, Reference Sitzmann, Bell, Kraiger and Kanar2009; Sitzmann & Ely, Reference Sitzmann and Ely2010). Mindfulness prompts can be used to stimulate mindfulness by prompting trainees to think about external and internal phenomena, which might also lead to improvements in learning and the transfer of training.
Conclusion
Our contention is that, for a number of reasons, it will be difficult to get organizations to invest in mindfulness training programs. Therefore, we maintain that the most practical and feasible approach for organizations to implement mindfulness training is to include it in existing training programs. This not only has the potential to improve trainee learning, retention, and transfer but also makes it more likely that trainees will be more mindful in other aspects of their work life, which can lead to further improvements in employee health, well-being, and performance.