The title of Charles Gross's most recent collection of essays on the history of neuroscience – a hole in the head – refers to the ancient surgical procedure known as trephination (or trepanation), where a small piece of bone is removed from the skull. It is still practised today, both within established medicine and outside it, the latter largely on account of a belief that it enhances consciousness. In his opening chapter, Gross traces the trajectory of trephination from Neolithic times until today, highlighting how the great nineteenth-century French pathologist and anthropologist Paul Broca (1824–1880) convincingly showed that Neolithic peoples had performed trephination with remarkable success – even though the mortality rate of the procedure in Broca's time was so high that a requirement for the operation was said to be ‘that the wound surgeon himself must have fallen on his head’ (p. 13).
This is just one of the fascinating stories that Gross recounts in his most recent collection of historical essays. Other notable ones include a discussion of Galen's public demonstration that the brain, rather than the heart, was the seat of thought and action (he demonstrated this by cutting the recurrent laryngeal nerves of a squealing pig, immediately rendering it mute); Gustav Fritz (1838–1927) and Edmund Hitzig's (1838–1907) discovery of the importance of the cerebral cortex (specifically with respect to controlling motor movement), and David Ferrier's (1843–1928) replication and elaboration of this central insight; and an investigation into how much anatomy and medical knowledge Dutch painters like Hieronymus Bosch and Rembrandt van Rijn possessed.
Gross is particularly good when it comes to explaining recent developments in his field. He writes an elegant tribute to his mentor, Donald Griffin, who pioneered the study of echolocation in bats and largely founded a new field of research, ‘cognitive ethology’, that gave due weight to animal consciousness and awareness. Two additional chapters discuss recent discoveries that garnered widespread media publicity: first, the fairly surprising realization among neuroscientists that there is such a thing as adult neurogenesis (i.e. that the adult mammalian brain can produce new neurons), and second, that there may be a ‘grandmother cell’ – a ‘neuron that responds only to a highly complex, specific, and meaningful stimulus, such as the image of one's grandmother’ (p. 263).
Gross is a working neuroscientist with a long-standing interest in the history of his field. He published a collection of historical essays in 1998 under the title Brain, Vision, Memory: Tales in the History of Neuroscience, and this makes for a nice companion to that previous work. Although all the chapters have been previously published as articles or given as talks (if in altered form), Gross helpfully adds postscripts to each of the chapters to bring the stories he tells up to the present. Special praise should be accorded to MIT Press on account of the high production value of the book, and to those responsible for helping Dr Gross collect the dozens of illustrations he includes, which do quite a bit to make the reading experience more pleasurable and stimulating.
While there is no theme that explicitly unifies the chapters of this collection together, Gross's passion for understanding the brain, and his belief that the history of neuroscience can enlighten contemporary approaches to studying this most complex of organs, do permeate the book.
As a work in the history of science, Gross's collection fits nicely into an older style of historical investigation, where eminent scientists recount fascinating stories from the history of their field, focusing on particular figures or scientific discoveries that, from the perspective of the present, appear prescient. There is a long tradition of this kind of historical work – and Gross often draws upon exemplars of it (e.g. George Sarton) in his references and endnotes. As the last generation or two of historians of science have shown, however, this approach to the past has some fundamental drawbacks: it has a tendency toward Whiggishness; it focuses almost exclusively on ‘internal’, cognitive developments in the respective field, without duly acknowledging social, institutional and cultural factors; and it strives to understand the past not necessarily on its own terms and in its own context, but very much through the prism of today. While some of this is unavoidable, historians of science may well find the implicit historical framework that Gross relies on to be outdated.
Nonetheless, it seems churlish to level this kind of criticism against Gross and his work, for he is not a professional historian but a working scientist, fascinated with the history of his field. And his essays convey his passion for history and will likely spark the general reader's interest in the history of neuroscience, which can sometimes appear dry in more historiographically sophisticated work.
Thus, while professional historians of science may not be satisfied with Gross's historical approach, he does have an eye for the revealing tale and writes clearly enough to capture a wide audience, including other scientists and those who want to learn more about how we have slowly, but eagerly, become acquainted with our most distinctive organ.
