The past few years have seen several books expressing concern for the state of contemporary music. British writers Julian Johnson (Reference Johnson2002) and Ivan Hewett (Reference Hewett2003) have made eloquent contributions to the debate and now two American publications add to their number. One is an anguished plea for re-thinking the production and reception of contemporary ‘classical’ music; while the other is an attack on the complacency with which the musical industry has accepted equal tempered tuning as a basis for performing practice.
In Classical Music, Why Bother? composer and Harvard professor Joshua Fineberg laments the continuing alienation between composers and their audiences. The initial impulse for writing the book came from Fineberg's experience of teaching students who were ‘not music majors’. ‘Through my discussions with this highly educated, but non-musically oriented group of students, I have come to feel that ideas concerning the nature and purpose of art were no longer givens . . . I became increasingly convinced of the need to address to a non-specialist public some thoughts on the role of art in society, especially difficult art (and its relationship to a lack of audience for contemporary music).’ Fineberg has thoughtful and interesting observations to make, acknowledging that much blame for the sorry present situation attaches to the European avant-garde who emerged in the years following the Second World War. This pioneering (and, by today's standards, generously subsidised) group of composers may have produced stunning sonorities in their quest for ‘making it new’, but they had scant regard for the perceptual abilities of ordinary listeners. While the reception of early 20th century works such as The Rite of Spring has responded well to the passage of time and the natural learning processes that occur through repeated hearings, much of the music composed by Boulez and Stockhausen in the 1950s remains as remote from today's audiences as it was then. Fineberg sees hope in recent developments among European ‘serious’ composers such as Tristan Murail and Gerard Grisey in their patenting of ‘spectral’ music that pays greater attention to what the ear and brain can assimilate. However, I am less optimistic than Fineberg that these somewhat marginal developments are pointers to a brighter future.
One of Fineberg's chapters deals with technology and challenges the widely held belief that the advent of equal temperament allowed composers the freedom to write in any key. However, this development was at the expense of allowing keys to retain their distinctive characters. Before equal temperament became the industrial standard: ‘modulations [were] not just movements from one key to another; they [were] huge transformations of the colour of the instrument: pure to gritty, stable to wobbling, and so on. An important reason for writing in all keys . . . was to show how different they were, not to exploit their homogeneity.’
Ross Duffin, in How Equal Temperament Ruined Harmony (and Why You Should Care), takes up this theme in an entertaining and stimulating way. In an informative book crammed with illustrations, both pictorial and notated, Duffin takes us on a scholarly tour of developments in tuning since the 18th century and makes the case for restoring much of what we have lost, especially in the way we experience the sound of chords and of modulations to different keys. Early in the book, he gives an example of how the shift from D minor to B flat major near the start of Beethoven's 9th Symphony must have sounded more dramatic in the days before equal temperament: the 3rds in the B flat chord would have rung out with awe-inspiring clarity. Where the tuning of keyboard instruments is concerned, there is not much we can do about the current situation. However, string quartets, a capella choirs and other ensembles less dependent on standardised tuning should take note of Duffin's arguments: there is the potential to make music come alive and be a richer and more vivid experience for listeners and performers. Duffin's book is well informed about the science and the history of developments in musical tuning from the ancient Greeks to the present era.
It is a shame that neither writer feels obliged to consider styles outside their immediate professional concerns. There are two brief references to non-classical styles in Fineberg's book and none at all in Duffin's. Neither book considers how practices that relate to the creation, performance and reception of classical music fit into a context that embraces all genres currently available. Are not issues of tuning as alive for musicians working in non-classical styles: the bent notes of the blues, and the awkward relationship between the nuances of pitch made by jazz singers and instrumentalists and standardised tuning of the keyboards that accompany them? How do Indian musicians cope when they blend the delicate intonation of ragas with the equal-tempered harmonium (a 19th century import from the Colonial West) that features in so many ensembles on the subcontinent?
Similarly, I would have liked Fineberg to pursue in greater depth his acknowledgement that non-classical styles such as jazz and progressive rock can explore feelings and challenge listeners’ ears without being as perceptually opaque as Stockhausen. Both writers feel passionately that music could be a richer and deeper experience for performers and audiences and their books make for a thought-provoking read. Duffin sees value in turning back the technological clock to embrace ways of hearing that we are in danger of losing for ever. Fineberg feels that audiences need to connect with an art form that still has important things to say. However, both could have ranged more widely, especially in acknowledging the huge contribution made by their fellow Americans to the development of such a wide diversity of musics appealing to people of all social and ethnic groups.
