1 Mountbatten to Listowel: 24th April 1947
Dear Listowel,Footnote 620
In my letter of the 17th April I said that your predecessor's letter of the 12th April had just arrived; his letter of the 18th April has just reached me, and so in this letter I am replying to the points mentioned in both these communications.
2. I followed up the publication of the joint statement by Gandhi and Jinnah by writing to PatelFootnote 621 and asking him to take steps to ensure that the press took an objective line in reporting events in the country at the present time, and did not add to our difficulties by tendentious and one sided reports. I have just had a reply from Patel giving me a copy of the instructions which have been sent out to the press, but like all party leaders he found it impossible to complete his letter without a violent attack on the attitude of Jinnah and the Muslim League. I am, however, satisfied that we have made a step forward, and the statement by Gandhi and Jinnah and the favourable press it has received in India, should be a great help to us in the coming weeks.
3. Patel has also figured in another incident I feel I must report this week. He has always been one of the Congress leaders who have stated publicly that he is anxious to keep British officials after the transfer of power in June 1948. He has, however, never shown any practical signs to support these statements, and his attitude has been made particularly clear in the case of the appointment of a relief for Mr. Porter, Secretary of the Home Department, who is going home on seven months leave.
4. The obvious person to succeed Mr. Porter is Mr. Williams,Footnote 622 the Joint Secretary of the Home Department, who is a competent official with Home Department experience and 24 years service in the I.C.S. Patel, however, proposed that Mr. Banerji, who is now Secretary of the Commonwealth Relations Department, should be appointed in Mr. Porter's vacancy, and this can hardly be resisted as Mr. Banerji is senior to Mr. Williams.
5. Mr. Banerji is not, however, a particularly competent official, and Mr. Williams having heard of the recommendation has asked to be allowed to go home on leave. Mr. Williams, as Joint Secretary of the Home Department, is concerned with Service questions, compensation, proportionate pension, terms of repatriation and so on. He is thus a key man at the present time, and with the greatest regret I have had to turn down his application for leave; though in the circumstances it would be too much to expect that we can get the best out of him. I feel very sorry for him.
6. Meanwhile I think you should know that since Patel had not referred the question of Mr. Porter's relief to the Selection Board I asked that this should be done. As a result the Home MemberFootnote 623 wrote on a minute the following remarks:
I am not surprised that the Selection Board felt embarrassed at the indication of my preference, I myself feel equally embarrassed in having to deal with this matter once again in the light of the Selection Board's comments. In the very nature of things, the Selection Board cannot appreciate the requirements of the Department in the same way as I can. I regard a reference to the Selection Board as both pointless and inappropriate.
The appointment of a Joint Secretary to act in a leave vacancy is by no means an invariable rule. There are instances in which a Joint Secretary has not stepped into the place of Secretary in a leave vacancy. Apart from this, I regard the next six months, or even more, as most crucial from the point of view of the work which is entrusted to the Secretary of the Home Department. A more experienced and senior man is clearly necessary, and I am glad that the Selection Board have agreed on Mr. Banerji's complete suitability for the post, and in view of this their further remarks regarding the officiating appointment of the Joint Secretary in the Department seem quite out of place and uncalled for.
I could not overlook this insubordination, and have replied on the same minute sheet: –
I agree to the appointment of Banerji. There are some points about the tone and substance of the Home Member's minute which I think should probably be taken in Cabinet. I should like to discuss the matter with the Home Member at our next interview.
7. I saw him today on this subject and have recorded a condensed version of the interview in paragraph 31 of my Personal Report No. 4.
8. I fully see the point which was made by Pethick Lawrence about the appointment of a European barrister to a permanent vacancy in the Oudh Chief Court. Of course in this case, where the barrister concerned had been acting as Senior Additional Judge for two years, it would have been unfair to disappoint him; but I will certainly bear in mind in the future the undesirability of adding to the number of permanent European judges, if it can be avoided without undue personal hardship.
9. In his letter of the 12th April, Pethick Lawrence referred to the case of the Nagas. I discussed the matter with Clow,Footnote 624 when he was here for the Governors’ Conference, and he said that the Naga National Council is self-constituted, but is as representative a body as can be found of the more educated Nagas, particularly of the Angami and Aos tribes.
10. In the copy of the memorandum which my predecessor sent you on the 4th March, the Naga National Council in their reference to an interim government meant an interim form of British rule. The placing of the hill tribes under a Central Indian Government would mean that they would be subject to politicians at Delhi, who would be even more unaware of their needs than the politicians in Assam, and to whom they would have no access. If they can be brought with suitable safeguards within the framework of the Assam constitution, they can themselves expect some share in the Government there and will have access to and influence over Government.
11. The question is not one which merely affects the Nagas. It affects in the same or only a slightly less degree all the excluded and partially excluded areas of Assam. The real problem is not preservation of the economic equilibrium. The excluded areas are all deficit districts and will have, as at present, to be supported by some other part of India. But the main problem is the protection of these people from exploitation, and the preservation of their way of living.
12. Clow has set out his views on the subject briefly in a pamphlet entitled ‘The Excluded and Partially Excluded Areas of Assam’, of which I attach an uncorrected copy.Footnote 625 It is being reprinted, and copies will be sent to you, but I thought it might be useful for you to have this copy in advance.
13. Your predecessor in his letter of 12th April referred to Bevin's discussion with Stalin on the subject of India, and I was interested to read the account of what they said. I took the opportunity during the Governors’ Conference of discussing with them the Communist Party in India, and the possibility of financial aid being supplied by Soviet Russia. The Governors were all very doubtful whether such financial aid was being given, although Burrows’Footnote 626 Secretary referred to a report that the Russian Representative on the World Youth Delegation, which visited India early in the year, had handed over a sum of half a lakh of rupees, and had promised further payments for the Party's work in future. This was the subject of your Private Secretary's letter of the 17th April, to my Private Secretary, and is under further investigation in the light of the Foreign Office remarks. We were unanimously opposed to any attempt at declaring the Communist party illegal; a step which even in the height of the war was never attempted by H.M.G.
14. I have referred paragraphs 6 and 7 of your predecessor's letter of the 18th April to my Political Adviser, and will let you have comments in due course. I quite agree with the remarks that a special treaty relationship with the U.K., rather than Dominion status, is the only possible future for the Indian States, unless British India elects for Dominion status and they join the Union of India.
15. I am forwarding herewith for your personal information the record of my meetings with the Governors:Footnote 627 additional copies are also being sent separately for circulation as may be required. As I said in my last report, it was a very successful conference, and I am sure we all got very good value out of it.
16. The Governors also unanimously recommended that everything possible should be done to assist British officers of the Indian Police to obtain employment when they retire from India. There are fairly good prospects for I.C.S. officers and for most members of the technical services, but police officers are badly placed because they seldom have University degrees, and their experience does not at first sight qualify them for appointments elsewhere under the Crown, except possibly in the Colonial Police forces, where there seem to be few vacancies.
17. Many of the British police officers are men of considerable ability with adequate secretarial training and experience. The Governors and I feel that they should not be automatically excluded from consideration for the Home Civil Service. After the last war several were taken into the I.C.S., one became Chief Commissioner of Delhi, and another is now an invaluable member of the Central Board of Revenue. I should say that a policeman with a really first class record would be a better choice for some Departments in Whitehall than an I.C.S. officer with a less good record.
18. I think special efforts should also be made to secure vacancies for police officers in business through the organisation that has been set up for the purpose, and I should be grateful if you would draw the attention of those concerned to this request by the Governors and myself.
19. Finally, I should like if possible to help British members of the Provincial Services, some of whom are likely to retire. Could it be arranged that the Re-employment Bureau which you have started should accept enquiries from Provincial Service officers and assist them in finding appointments.
20. I am forwarding herewith two copies of each of my first three Personal ReportsFootnote 628 in response to the telegram from your Private Secretary. I am sorry that we have no more spare copies but I will send 8 copies of the Report in future.
Yours sincerely,
Mountbatten of Burma
2 Listowel to Mountbatten, 25 April 1947
My dear Viceroy,
I would like to tell you with what tremendous interest I have read your first three Personal Reports; I had not seen the first two at the time of their receipt. I hope you will agree with the suggestion which has, I understand, already been made to you that you should in future send sufficient copies of these reports to be circulated to all the Members of the India and Burma Committee, since they will clearly form an essential part of the background to the decisions which the Committee will be called upon to take during the next few months.
2. To turn to your third report, Pethick-Lawrence has already sent you a message of congratulation upon the achievement of the joint appeal by Mr. Jinnah and Mr. Gandhi for the renunciation of the use of force for political ends. I would like to associate myself with those congratulations and with the hope he expressed that the appeal may have some effect in reducing communal strife. I cannot help noting, however, that in paragraph 22 of the same Report you draw attention to the likelihood that, if any attempt is made to impose the Cabinet Mission Plan on the Muslim League, they will report to arms to resist it.
3. It was perhaps hardly surprising that nothing came of Mr. Gandhi's outline for a scheme for an Interim Government pending the transfer of power.
4. Your full and vivid accounts of your prolonged talks with Mr. Jinnah seem to lead remorselessly to the conclusion that there is only the remotest possible chance that the Cabinet Mission's plan can still be implemented. It is clear that this result is not for want of your having impressed upon Mr. Jinnah with ‘ruthless logic’ the probable consequences for the Muslims of insisting on a full-blooded Pakistan, however truncated. It is, of course, only natural that, as a corollary to the Muslim refusal to accept what they represent would be a Hindu Raj on the all-India scale, the non-Muslim elements in those areas which the Muslims regard as naturally destined to become a part of Pakistan are beginning to agitate for partition of provinces. The growing force of this agitation in Bengal, for example, is illustrated by paragraph 3 of Burrows’ letter to you of 11th April (No. F.J.B.22).
5. There certainly appears to be an impressive consensus of opinion in official quarters in India as to the need for a very early declaration of H.M.G.’s intentions and I shall, of course, await with keen expectations a more explicit exposition of what you have in mind. I need hardly say, however, that I appreciate all too well the crucial nature of the recommendations which you will be making and you may rest assured that I have complete confidence that you will choose the right moment for making them.
6. It was very encouraging to learn that the Governors are happy about the decision reached in regard to compensation for the Services. In particular, the attitude that appears to have been adopted by TrivediFootnote 629 and HydariFootnote 630 leads one to hope that the decision not to grant compensation to Indian members of the Services except in special cases will not cause resentment on the part of Indian members of the Services.
7. I am sure that the Governors’ Conference will have been of the greatest value to the Governors themselves, all of whom are carrying an exceptionally heavy and difficult burden at the present time. The Congress attitude to Jenkins,Footnote 631 CaroeFootnote 632 and MudieFootnote 633 will only serve to increase the difficulty of their tasks and is greatly to be deprecated. It is also a sad reflection on the statesmanship of some Indian political leaders that the best proof of a Governor's success should lie in the equality of the violence with which he is accused of partisanship by either side.
8. The problem raised by Mr. Liaquat Ali KhanFootnote 634 in his letters to you of 7th and 13th April about the communal aspect of the reorganization of the Indian Army is a difficult one and it is to be hoped that your suggestion that the matter should be discussed by the Defence Committee will be acceded to and that the discussion in Committee will be a helpful one. The vital need for avoiding any step which may adversely affect the reliability of the army is well illustrated by one passage in the Governor of Bihar's fortnightly letter to you of 5th April D.O.No. 86/G.B. where he says that, in his Province, a position has already been reached in which the government is only kept in power by the presence and loyalty of the army. This is indeed a significant admission.
9. In paragraph 6 of his letter of 21st April, Pethick-Lawrence referred to our policy in respect of the Indian States, and suggested that our only possible course at this stage is to stick to the lines of the Cabinet Mission's Memorandum on State's Treaties and Paramountcy. You may be interested to know that the American Embassy made an informal approach to the India Office the other day on the basis of reports which have been reaching the State Department from their representative in Delhi. The Embassy asked to be assured that H.M.G. are not contemplating departure from the Mission's plan in so far as the States are concerned, and in particular are not contemplating maintaining direct relations with the States after the transfer of power. The suggestion was that, if this were the case, the U.S. Government might have to consider modifying its present attitude of open support for British Policy towards India.
10. The main ground for this démarche seems to have been an interview in Delhi between Merrill and Nawab Mir Nawaz Jung,Footnote 635 the newly appointed Trade Commissioner for Hyderabad in London, whose status I understand the Hyderabad Government have shown a desire to raise to that of a quasi-diplomatic ‘Agent General’. He apparently told Merrill that Hyderabad intended to remain a separate political entity, independent of any Indian Union, and wished to remain in alliance with the United Kingdom; he added that Bhopal would do the same. He claimed that his own appointment was intended as a covert means of sounding H.M.G. in the matter. He admitted, however, that Sir Mirza IsmailFootnote 636 is clever enough to create the basis of cooperative relations with the Congress successor regime, even if this is not intended to lead to any fusion with an Indian Union.
11. It was suggested to the American Embassy that the reference to Sir Mirza Ismail's disposition to work with Congress indicated that there might not be much in Nawaz Jung's claims: Hyderabad was perhaps chiefly concerned to raise its stock for bargaining purposes with the future leaders of India. In any case, nothing was known in the India Office of any abandonment of the Cabinet Mission's plan in respect of the States, and we did not contemplate continuance with them of special relations outside the Indian Union; paragraph 12 of the Statement of February 20th in fact implied no change in the Mission's plan. It was of course not beyond the bounds of possibility that before June 1948 the Viceroy might report that there was no possibility of the Mission's hopes as regards the States being realised, and in that event he might propose to H.M.G. some other means of fulfilling our undertakings. But no such proposition was before H.M.G.
12. This conversation was on the Chancery level and it was not apparently desired that the Ambassador should approach me formally on the subject. I am, therefore, passing on the report to you in the same informal manner. I should add that Merrill apparently reported very adversely on the speech made to the States Peoples Conference at Gwalior by Nehru, whose lack of statesmanship in this matter he deplored. He also reported that the feeling in Delhi was that the Cabinet Mission's plan in general no longer held the field, that there was no sign of leadership towards an All-India solution among British Indian politicians as a result of your talks, and that while some states had decided to join the Constituent Assembly, the majority showed little intention of doing so. You will of course treat these disclosures of what Merrill has been saying to his Government with all due discretion.
13. In paragraph 33 of your Personal Report No. 2 you mentioned the Polish refugees in Kolhapur. I find that the position in respect to the removal of these people, who I understand number about 4,700, not 9,000 is far from easy. The financial responsibility for their maintenance used to be borne by H.M.G. the Government of India acting as their agent. Last August financial responsibility was taken over by UNRRA [United Nations Relief and Rehabilitation Administration]. There have been recent representations that the funds from which the cost was borne were exhausted at the end of March, but is hoped that UNRRA will find ways and means to discharge their responsibility up to the end of June. After then it is expected that their functions will be taken on by the International Refugee Organisation [I.R.O.]. Strictly speaking, therefore, the decision about the future of the Poles in Kolhapur does not lie with H.M.G.
14. On the other hand you may count on the co-operation of H.M.G. in the removal at the earliest possible date of the wives and children of members of the Polish Forces who have joined the Polish Resettlement Corps; and it is probable that at a later date the definition of a ‘dependant’’ will be extended to include other relatives. Many of the Poles in the Resettlement Corps, however, are likely to go to other countries such as Canada or Brazil, and there would be no point in moving their relatives till their destinations are fixed. Indeed, to bring them to this country would be a physical impossibility in existing circumstances.
15. I understand that a token move from India of about 100 wives and children of ex-Polish soldiers, who have joined the Polish Resettlement Corps and who have settled in this country, has already been initiated by the War Office who have been in correspondence with the Commander-in-Chief on the matter. But the soldier relatives of a large number of dependents in Kolhapur are still in the Middle East, and will not be brought here for some time yet. I am told that there can be no question of their dependents being moved till their men have been brought to this country, and have joined the Resettlement Corps, as not only have they no place to go to, but it also is a cardinal element in H.M.G's policy towards members of the Polish Forces that dependents should not be admitted to this country in advance. Otherwise the men might be tempted to refrain from joining the Resettlement Corps and to join the recalcitrants who have been causing H.M.G. considerable worry.
16. You will thus gather that the process of settlement is likely to be rather slow and that even after relatives have been taken out of India, a residue will remain for whom new homes will have to be found by IRO. In the meantime, of course, those Poles who desire repatriation to Poland will be moved by UNRRA or IRO.
17. From the point of view of the provision of shipping, the implications of what I have said in the previous paragraphs are, first, that, as in the past, UNRRA will find berths for the few Poles who may still opt for repatriation in any ships, British or others which may have accommodation to offer, and, secondly, that no arrangements can be undertaken for shipping the remaining Poles, apart from the small number to be moved by the War Office, till their new homes are known.
18. I hope that in these circumstances your Government will not press for the removal of the Poles from India by a given date. You may be assured that I will do everything I can to help, but this is a problem in which the best will in the world must wait on opportunity.
19. May I, in conclusion, say how particularly pleased I am to learn of your decision to appoint three Indian A.D.C.’s and of the unprecedented extent to which Indians are taking part in official functions. I am sure that changes of this kind, which are long overdue, will have a beneficial effect out of all proportion to their apparent importance.
Listowel
3 Mountbatten to Listowel, 1 May 1947
My dear Listowel,
Thank you for your letter of the 25th April. I particularly appreciate the kind and encouraging things you say, which are a great help as one is apt to feel rather cut off from Whitehall out here.
2. This letter is being taken home by Ismay and Abell,Footnote 637 who will be able to give you a first-hand account of the situation, which I am sure will be very helpful. I should like to take this opportunity to tell you how magnificently Abell has played in with our new team and what a grand example he has set to the old staff. He has volunteered to stay on although he has had to give up his magnificent office to Ismay. I could not wish for a more public spirited, competent or delightful P.S.V.
3. While Abell is away my Personal Secretary, Captain R. Brockman, CIE, CBE, R.N.,Footnote 638 will act as P.S.V.
4. I am forwarding herewith my Personal Report No. 5 for the past week, for distribution as usual. I have aimed at giving you the background of Ismay's mission in this Report.
5. Ismay will give you the background of the difficult situation in the N.W.F.P. [North-Western Frontier Province], and will explain how Nehru will only accept a referendum on the issue of whether the N-W Frontier Province is to join Pakistan or Hindustan,Footnote 639 and that if we try to force through an election merely as a result of pressure from the Muslim League civil disobedience movement, Congress will refuse to take part in the election as a strong gesture of their disapproval.
6. I have also charged Ismay with seeing you personally on the subject of Olaf Caroe. I like him immensely and in my opinion he is a very competent loyal and honest official. But I have had to warn him that Congress are so bitterly against him that it may not be in the best interests of all concerned to retain him; though whilst he is there I have guaranteed him my fullest support. I still think that he is showing signs of the great strain under which any man in his position must suffer.
7. Thank you for telling me about Merrell's report on his interview with Nawab Mir Nawaz Jung. The line I am taking up here to the question of individual membership of the Commonwealth for parts of India is clearly shown in my Personal Report. I am working a very delicate manoeuvre to give Congress an opportunity of offering to come back into the Commonwealth in some form, which might possibly bear fruit, but it is too delicate a matter to write about at present. Ismay can give you the latest form.
8. The business of the sterling balances has been very difficult. Nehru took the line that neither he nor any of the Congress Members could possibly be snared to go home on the Sterling Balances Mission. On my advice Liaquat Ali Khan brought this to a head at the Cabinet yesterday, when it was agreed that if it was impossible for the British to send a Mission out here, we would send a Mission home about mid-June, which would include Liaquat Ali Khan, MatthaiFootnote 640 and provisionally Rajagopalachari, though this is not yet firm.
9. I am so glad that the question of compensation for the Secretary of State's Services has now been finally settled. The result of the meeting of the Special Cabinet Committee has already been reported by telegram and two copies of the Minutes were sent to the India Office earlier in the week. The statement has been well received by the Indian Press. The statement will, I know, give the greatest satisfaction to all members of the Services out here and will be a great help in improving morale during the difficult months ahead. I shall be glad if you will express my thanks to your colleagues on the I. and B. [Indian and Burma] Committee who have been so helpful in arriving at this satisfactory conclusion.
10. In paragraph 5 of my letter of the 24th April, I referred to the case of Mr. Williams and the way that he had been passed over by Patel for the Secretaryship of the Home Department. I asked him for Williams to come as Secretary of the Governor-General's Secretariat (Public) where a vacancy occurs shortly, and where he would be of the greatest help in dealing with the many Service problems which are going to arise during the next year. Somewhat to my surprise, however, Patel at his interview with me this week, suggested that Williams should be appointed as Secretary of the Information and Broadcasting Department where a vacancy occurs shortly. This Department comes, of course, directly under the Home Member and this change of heart on Patel's part is surprising, as I am sure he has no real desire to keep on any Englishmen. I am, however, hoping he will release Williams to me, as we really need him, and Williams has no desire to continue serving under Patel.
11. Nehru has recently been taking a keen interest in the future of the Indian States, especially from the point of view of the people of the States, and in a recent letter to me he complained that the Political Department worked in secret and no-one knew what it was doing. In particular, he expressed anxiety regarding the relations of Hyderabad with Bastar and Berar. I think much of the trouble has been due to the fact that although Lord Wavell offered to arrange a meeting between CorfieldFootnote 641 and Nehru at which the fullest information was exchanged, Nehru never followed this up and has developed a slight sense of grievance, although I think the fault was undoubtedly his. In the last week, however, he has had a very full talk with Corfield, covering such matters as the representation of the States in the Constituent Assembly, the working of the Political Department, the future of the Indian States and the relations of Hyderabad with Bastar and Berar. Corfield reports that the meeting was held in a very pleasant atmosphere and that Nehru had no critical comments to make.
12. I am taking the opportunity of sending Corfield home with Ismay this week for a brief visit which I hope will be helpful both to you and to him. You will, I expect, by now have seen the Minutes of the recent Residents’ Conference, which were sent home last week.
13. Your Private Secretary's letter of the 17th April, 1947, and its enclosures, discussed a report from the C.I.O. [Central Intelligence Office] Calcutta, about aid from Russia to the Communist Party of India.
14. The D.I.B. [Director of Intelligence Bureau] obtained this report, and passed it on to the Home Department. I understand that it has not been followed up, and that the report is not regarded as completely reliable. I doubt whether this report by itself will have much effect on the Government of India, but the Home Member is almost as jumpy about Communists as American politicians; so that I think you may take it that their activities are being pretty carefully watched.
15. I am afraid I cannot offer any advice on the question your predecessor asked as to what use can be made of the report in Great Britain.
16. In my letter of the 24th April, I referred to the Indian Police and the desirability of special efforts being made to assist British police officers to obtain employment when they retire from India. I have since had a letter from WylieFootnote 642 who suggests that in addition to Government administrative posts similar to those now offered to members of the I.C.S., Indian police officers would be suited for appointments of the following type: –
(i) Police appointments in the U.K. or Colonies.
(ii) Administrative or Police appointments in the German Control Commission.
(iii) Military Intelligence (particularly for officers with C.I.D. [Criminal Investigation Department] or Intelligence experience).
(iv) Security posts in Commercial organisations.
(v) Labour Welfare Officers.
(vi) Government departments such as Home (Police, Fire Service, Salvage Corps), Port of London Authority, Post Office (Investigation & Claims Branch), Prisons, Transport, Customs & Excise, Ministry [of] Labour.
(vii) Local Self-Government appointments in Town, Borough or District Councils such as Public Control officers.
17. Some junior Indian Police officers have also suggested that H.M.G. might offer facilities and assistance for University or Technical training on the same lines as assistance now being offered to ex-Servicemen. I am sure that many junior officers would gladly welcome an opportunity for such specialised training, and I think this is a line of action which is well worth following up.
18. I have no doubt that many Indian Police officers whose services are shortly to be terminated, would willingly forgo any compensation if they could secure permanent employment with reasonable pay and prospects, and I feel there must be some demand in England or the Colonies for men with administrative and executive experience in positions of trust where a high standard of integrity is required.
19. I am asking Ismay to raise with the India Office the question of a greatly increased allotment of honours for the last New Year's Honours List during our time in India. He, Corfield and Abell are well briefed with my views. I do hope you will be able to give them your support.
20. In my letter of the 9th April, I mentioned how both my wife and I thought it most important that the British Council should be adequately financed for its work in India. I am sorry to have heard now through the High Commissioner that the Treasury have found it necessary to reduce the Council's grant, which means that the amount allocated for India will be about £53,000/-, a third of which will be spent on overhead charges in London. I realise how difficult the position must be from the Treasury point of view, but I do think that a larger investment in India at this time will pay great dividends. I do hope you will do whatever you can to see that the Council gets a good start here.
21. I am sure Auchinleck,Footnote 643 Ismay and Abell will be able to give you a picture which will convince you of the supreme need of speed, and I sincerely trust that you will be able to help forward the pace of the discussion, so as to release Ismay within a week or ten days at the most. The price to pay for any appreciable delay may well be a general communal eruption out here.
22. I was very glad to have Burrows up here; although he still looks to me to be pretty ill, his doctors tell me he is on the mend, and he has promised me that he will go up to Darjeeling on Sunday. In the meanwhile, he is going to suggest to SuhrawardyFootnote 644 that he should immediately form a coalition government and offer joint electorates in the future. If he can bring this off, he should be on a good wicket to retain the unity of Bengal as an independent Province.
23. I have been averaging 17 to 18 hours a day for six weeks now, and my doctor wants me to go to Simla to get really rested and fit for the much more important discussions which will start when Ismay gets back. I think I shall go up after the next Cabinet and come down before the following one. I shall be in just as good touch with you at Simla as in Delhi.
Yours very sincerely,
Mountbatten
4 Listowel to Mountbatten, 3 May 1947
My dear Viceroy,
Thank you for your letter of 24th April and for Personal Report No. 4 and the records of your meetings with Provincial Governors which accompanied it. I am very glad that the Personal Reports are to be circulated to all the members of the I. & B. Committee – I obtained the Prime Minister's agreement to this – as I myself find them most informative and enlightening. The Prime Minister has just invited Lord Chorley,Footnote 645 Mr. C.P. Mayhew, M.P. and Mr. A.G. Bottomley, M.P. to join the Committee. Mayhew and Bottomley were members of the U.K. Delegation for last December's Conversations with the Delegation from the Governor of Burma's Executive Council and Bottomley subsequently attended the Panglong Conference. Chorley will, I am sure, be of great assistance to me in the House of Lords on Indian and Burma affairs. He was a member of the Parliamentary Delegation to India.
2. I read the full records of the Conference with Provincial Governors with the greatest interest and look forward to reading the report of the Conference with Residents, which you say is on its way. Records of such excellence prove the value of the additional staff which you have at your disposal. I was very glad to hear that the newcomers and the old hands had settled down so well together and that all are exhilarated rather than oppressed by the magnitude and urgency of the tasks confronting them.
3. Perhaps it is just as well that the episode over Mr. Porter's relief should have revealed Patel in his true colours so far as the employment of European officers is concerned, although episodes of this kind cannot fail to have adverse effects on service morale and efficiency. The truth of the matter is, I suppose, that the temptation to appoint an Indian for the first time as Secretary of the Home Department, even though the appointment was not the best that could be made on the merits of the case, proved too great for the first Indian holder of the Home Department portfolio. I hope that Mr. Williams, whose work as Joint Secretary of the Home Department is well-known and appreciated here, will be able to establish good working relations with Mr. Banerjee.
4. I am grateful to you for sending me an advance copy of Clow's pamphlet ‘The Excluded and Partially Excluded Areas of Assam’, which will be studied with interest here.
5. I find myself in whole-hearted agreement with the conclusion reached at the Conference of Provincial Governors to take no action on the suggestion that the Communist Party should be declared illegal. Such action would appear to be quite unwarranted, at any rate until there is much more conclusive evidence than exists at present that the Party is engaged in subversive activities that constitute a threat to the Government.
6. I shall hope to let you have in my next letter some information as to the prospects of European police officers obtaining other suitable employment when they leave India. I am also investigating the question whether the Re-employment Bureau which has been established here can assist retiring British members of the Provincial Services to find suitable jobs. There has, as a matter of fact, been some interest shown recently in Parliament about the future of British members of subordinate services in India and Burma who are not entitled to proportionate pension on premature retirement, and I have already asked that the whole question of their future should be looked into.
7. In paragraphs 13 to 14 of Personal Report No. 4, you refer to the case put forward by the Sikh representatives when you interviewed them. I shall hope to include in my next letter some comments on the Sikh complaints.
8. A speech of the kind made by Nehru at Gwalior is certainly not encouraging from the point of view of a peaceful settlement of India's future. It is indeed extraordinary that a man of his stature can seriously contend that it is open to him to say publicly, in the capacity of President of the States Peoples’ Conference, things which it is obviously quite improper for him to say as Vice-Chairman of the Executive Council. Not that ill-judged speeches are a monopoly of one side; Liaquat's published riposte to Nehru was in its way just as mischievous.
9. Auchinleck has arrived and I have already had a short talk with him. He is to see the Prime Minister on Monday morning and I hope will have an opportunity of talking to other Ministers. I have also this week had an interesting talk with Weightman.Footnote 646
10. It is a great relief to all of us here, as it must be to you, that the Compensation announcement has been made and I would like to congratulate you upon the extent to which you secured concessions from your Cabinet and their agreement upon the form of the announcement. The terms have, broadly speaking, been accorded a remarkably favourable reception here. The statements in Parliament prompted few Supplementary Questions and press editorial comment gives the impression that the terms are regarded as having struck just about the right balance. It is, of course, possible that, when there has been more time for detailed study of the White Paper and the Tables, the Opposition may press for a Debate. Prima facie, this would seem more likely to happen in the House of Lords than in the House of Commons, but it is a good sign that Hailey, who raised the Question by arrangement in the House of Lords and who received an advance copy of the White Paper did not raise any question upon it. I have heard from the Prime Minister that Simon is satisfied.
11. The case of Mahbub Ali, the Political officer of Malakhand who failed to prevent Nehru being stoned during his visit to the Frontier a few months ago,Footnote 647 to which Caroe referred in his letter to you of 7th April. d.o. No. GH/37, illustrates well the vindictiveness on the part of Ministers against which the Indian Services have to contend, and the genuineness of the need for compensation for Indians in the special categories.
12. We have been a bit mystified here by the line taken by the Indian Representatives at the Wheat Conference, which ended on 23rd April. While it is, of course, generally recognised that the prime cause of the failure of the Conference was the insistence of the United States on an exorbitant price for wheat under the proposed agreement, some surprise is felt in United Kingdom circles at the extent to which the India representatives based their policy on the hypothesis that four or five years hence India will require to import little or no wheat. This hypothesis would appear to depend on
(1) acceptance of standards of nutrition no better than prewar;
(2) the success of a ‘Grow More Food’ campaign which depends on machinery, fertilisers, and above all, the education of the cultivators;
(3) restoration of rice imports, and
(4) the absence of civil strife on any major scale
(1), though probably inevitable, means the abandoning of a cherished and most desirable aim, whilst not one of the last three factors can be regarded as certain. In these circumstances India might have been expected to put her name down for level quantities of wheat of not less than 1 million tons for each year of the post agreement and, if she had done so, her position in the Conference would have been likely to be much stronger and far more acceptable in principle both to exporters and to the regular customers.
13. I am greatly looking forward to seeing Ismay and hearing his impression of the present position in India. Your telegrams 954-S and 955-S have only just arrived and there has not yet even been time to read them carefully, but it will make all the difference having the outline of your plan in advance of Ismay's arrival, and we intend to embark upon intensive discussions next week.
Listowel
5 Mountbatten to Listowel, 8 May 1947
My dear Listowel,
I am afraid this will be a shorter letter than usual as I am at Simla and have no letter of yours to answer.
2. Last week I referred to the passing over of Mr. Williams, the Joint Secretary Home Department, by the Home Member, Patel, in favour of Mr. Banerji, his own nominee, and I added that after my protest Patel proposed to appoint Williams as Secretary of the Information and Broadcasting Department. I am glad to say that Patel has now acceded to my request and agreed to release Williams to become Secretary to the Governor-General (Public) in succession to Mr. Godbole who was leaving in any case. Mr. Williams is particularly well suited for this appointment as there will be a number of questions arising in regard to the Secretary of State's Services during the next few months, with which he has been dealing in the past in the Home Department. I am arranging for him to join at once, as this appointment has been vacant for the past week.
3. Patel has also been creating difficulties in regard to the Chief Commissioner of Delhi, Mr. Christie,Footnote 648 who is an Englishman. It is an open secret that Patel has wished for some months past to replace him by an Indian, but his appointment is on the Viceroy's patronage list and my predecessor refused to give way. Recently Patel has trumped up two charges against the Chief Commissioner, which came to me with recommendations that he should be called upon to resign.
4. I saw Patel and asked him point blank whether he wished that the Chief Commissioner should be replaced by an Indian; I told him that if he wished to get rid of Mr. Christie he should do so by coming to ask me outright for his relief and not to attempt to accomplish it by underhand methods. Patel somewhat surprisingly said that he was content for the Chief Commissioner to stay on provided he changed his ways, but I am sure that there will only be friction if Mr. Christie stays. I have therefore written privately to the latter telling him that I think I shall have to agree to Patel's wishes and have an Indian as Chief Commissioner; but I have made it clear to him that I should have no wish that he should leave his appointment immediately and that nothing will be done until he has told me when he would like to leave. I am sure he should be treated with every consideration because, in my opinion, he has done his job efficiently and fearlessly.
5. In paragraph 7 of your letter of the 18th April, you mentioned a letter from the Resident at Hyderabad about the steps to be taken on the death of the present Nizam,Footnote 649 and said that you thought that I might encounter difficulties with the Central Government if I considered it necessary to despatch troops to Hyderabad to support the State Forces at such a time. Since you wrote, I understand that the Political Department has sent you a copy of a letter to the Resident at Hyderabad, dated 29th April, which shows that the possibility that difficulties may arise with the Interim Government over attempts to discharge our treaty obligations with the States is being borne in mind.
6. I saw Major General LyneFootnote 650 just before I left for Simla and he reported to me the very satisfactory talks that he and the Indian representatives had had with the Maharajah of Nepal at Khatmandu [sic].Footnote 651 It looks as if with care the negotiations will be satisfactory and Gurkha troops will he provided for both the British and Indian armies, but I have impressed on Lyne the desirability of handling this matter with the very greatest care, as the position is not yet completely cut and dried.
7. Clow completed his five year period as Governor of Assam on the 4th May and Sir [M.] Akbar Hydari took over the next day. I shall be sorry to lose Clow as, although I have not been out here long, I saw enough of his work during the South East Asia campaign to appreciate him at his true worth. He leaves for England shortly and I hope you will take the opportunity of having a talk with him about the position in Assam.
8. Ismay has reported to me that the initial reception of my plan by the India and Burma Committee was very favourable and I am so glad that this was so. I am awaiting further news from home with some eagerness.
Yours sincerely,
Mountbatten of Burma
6 Listowel to Mountbatten, 9 May 1947
My dear Mountbatten,
Thank you for your letter of 1st of May covering Personal Report No. 5 which provided a most useful background to the visit of Ismay and his party. They arrived safely last Sunday afternoon and I think I may say that we have been making steady progress ever since with our consideration of your plan. There is certainly no disposition whatever here to question the need for an early decision as to the plan we are going to adopt for transferring power in June 1948 and the announcement of it. Apart from our consideration of the plan, I have had most valuable talks with Ismay and Abell[,] and Ismay has also seen the Prime Minister.
2. I took the opportunity provided by a meeting of the India and Burma Committee yesterday to thank the Committee on your behalf for their help in arriving at a satisfactory conclusion to the discussions on compensation for the Services.
3. Nawab Nir Nawaz Jung, to whom reference was made in paragraph 7 of your letter, has now arrived in London and has lost no time in trying to build up his position as ‘Agent-General’ for Hyderabad in the manner that was expected of him. He has arranged a banquet at the Dorchester in honour of the Nizam's birthday and has sent invitations to other Cabinet Ministers besides myself. I thought it right (and I understand that Corfield, who has been consulted, concurs) to have it indicated to the Nawab that the nature of his post of Trade Commissioner is not such as to justify the public entertainment of Cabinet Ministers. It is clearly most undesirable to give him any undue encouragement.
4. I am hoping to have a good talk with Corfield tomorrow about States matters, on the basis of the minutes of the Residents’ Conference which I have just received and am reading with great interest.
5. In paragraph 6 of my letter of 3rd May I promised to let you have some information on re-employment questions: in the meanwhile paragraph 16 of your letter of 1st May contained some suggestions on the matter made by Wylie.
6. We have realised from the beginning that it would not be easy to find careers for Police Officers. It was partly for this reason that the first officer of the Indian Services to be appointed to the staff of the Re-employment Branch was a retired Police Officer from the Central Provinces, who has since devoted most of his time to preparing the ground and planning for the future. The Re-employment Branch has already covered, on an exploratory basis, all the points mentioned by Wylie and some appointments have already been made from among the younger officers on leave preparatory to retirement both to security posts and to the Ethiopian Police. The question of re-training is also receiving particular attention.
7. With regard to the specific suggestions made in your letter there are very few opportunities in police work in the Colonies and, in view of the official promotion policy, practically none in the U.K. We expect to get some men into the Control Commission and some into various temporary Government appointments, such as that of Food Enforcement Officer. But, though I have given instructions that the point should be taken up again with the Treasury, I very much doubt if there is any possibility of police officers being taken in to the Home Service through the Special Principals’ Competition and vacancies in permanent Government Service in the U.K. are, therefore, only likely to fall to those who are successful in the Reconstruction Competitions for the Administrative Grade or who are prepared to go in at a lower level: I hope there will be a few of the younger men who will apply as private individuals for the Colonial Administrative Service – the police are not eligible as a Service for the special competitions – and we hope that some of them may be successful. We also hope that Local Government will take on a few – we have been having discussions about this recently; but the main body will undoubtedly have to go into business and it is on this that efforts are at present being concentrated.
8. You can assure Governors that the problem is being tackled energetically and that all the ground will be properly covered by the time the main body of police officers begins to leave India. We are also considering the possibility that a limited number of men might, assuming they can be spared, be brought home for interview for business appointments in due course. It goes without saying that employers are unwilling to make appointments unless they have seen the men first.
9. You ask whether members of the Provincial Services can make use of the Re-employment Branch. The position is that the Re-employment Branch in the India Office (which will, when our final plans take shape, be charged with policy and questions involving permanent Government employment only) could not legitimately be expanded beyond the field in which I have direct responsibility and obligations. It is, however, the intention that, when the Indian Services Section in the Ministry of Labour Appointments Office is functioning (probably in the autumn), Provincial Service Officers should be able to make full use of the facilities provided by that Section and by the unofficial committee which Lord Hailey intends to establish very shortly. I hope you will agree that these arrangements will provide what is needed.
10. I might also mention that the Re-employment Branch hopes before long to begin sending to Provincial Governments and other authorities concerned a monthly letter explaining some of the background to what is now being done to find alternative careers for members of the Secretary of State's Services.
11. You referred in paragraph 6 of your letter of 9th April and paragraph 20 of your letter of 1st May, to the British Council's proposals for their work in India. I need hardly say, that I entirely share your views and those of ShoneFootnote 652 regarding the importance of the development of cultural relations with India and for this reason I am most anxious that the Council should make an early start with their representation in India and that whatever they do should be done well. It is most unfortunate that financial stringency should have led to a reduction in the original estimate for India for the present year but I shall not fail to impress upon the Foreign Office and the Treasury our joint conception of the needs of the situation with a view to obtaining a substantial increase in the grant for next year.
12. The amount finally allocated for this year has necessitated some modification of the proposals made in Sir Angus Gillan'sFootnote 653 report. There has been some delay, owing partly to illness in the staff of the council, in submitting its revised proposals. These, though envisaging a more restricted field of immediate operations, are designed to build a solid foundation for the future development of its work in India. They are now being put into final shape as speedily as possible and we hope to get Treasury approval in the very near future to enable a start to be made next cold weather. I will let you know how matters progress.
13. I said in my last letter that I hoped to let you have my comments on your interview with the Sikhs described in paragraphs 13 and 14 of your Personal Report No. 4.
14. I suppose the basic fact of the situation is that the Sikhs have an exaggerated idea of their proper status in the future set-up. No doubt this is due to their historical position as the rulers of the Punjab, partly to the rather flattering treatment they have received from us as one of the great martial races of India, and partly to the fact that they consider that they have contributed out of proportion to their numbers to the economic wealth of the Punjab. On the other hand, they are a community numbering only some 6 millions out of nearly 400 millions and in the Punjab itself they number only 4 millions among 28 millions. On any democratic basis, therefore, they must definitely be regarded as a minority (and not even as a ‘major’ minority). Owing to the fact that in no single district of the Punjab do they constitute a majority of the population, it is out of the question to meet their claims by setting up a separate Sikh State.
15. I understand that during the Cabinet Mission these considerations were put to the Sikhs in answer to their case but evidently if has all been like water off a duck's back. It was pointed out to the Sikhs, I am told, that even minimum Pakistan would include 1 million Sikhs and that therefore the alternatives for them were to be all together in Pakistan or divided between Pakistan and Hindustan. They were asked to say which they preferred. Their reply was that if there were Pakistan there must be Sikhistan. In short, they refused to face the facts. The Mission's plan had the great advantage from the Sikh point of view that the Sikhs would all remain within the Punjab (except those in the States). One would have thought that the right thing for the Sikhs to have done would have been to throw their weight into getting the Cabinet Mission's plan adopted and to that end to make terms with the Muslim League as to their position in Section B. There was, in fact, some skirmishing between the Sikhs and the League but it never came to anything. It may be that Jinnah adopted an unduly frigid attitude, but no doubt the Sikhs also asked for far too much. The Sikhs then clamoured to be given the same right as the Muslim and General communities in the Union Constituent Assembly, i.e. a majority of Sikh votes should be required for any decision on a major communal issue. The Mission naturally felt unable to accede to this demand. It would have given four Sikh voters a veto on any question of this kind. The Sikhs also asked for the same right within Section B. This could not be conceded without conceding it also to the major communities in all three Sections and it would have raised a demand for a similar right from the Depressed Classes.
16. I had not heard before of the Sikh contention that they were ruled out of voting on a major communal issue in the Union Constituent Assembly by the wording of paragraph 19 (vii) of the Statement of May 16th. I do not think this is a correct reading of that paragraph. The position, of course, is that decisions of the Union Constituent Assembly are by majority vote except where paragraph 19 (vii) applies, in which case the majority must contain a majority of each of the major communities. But since on a population basis the Sikhs are entitled to four votes only, it has to be recognised that it is almost inconceivable that the Sikh votes could actually sway a decision of the Assembly.
17. There is no doubt that the Sikhs are a very dangerous element in the situation. Under your proposals they will be divided and I do not think that any subsequent adjustment of boundaries can possibly begin to satisfy the claims they put forward. I understand from Ismay that they are asking that the Lahore Division be kept out of the partition you propose pending a Boundary Commission at which Sikh claims would be considered. But Sikh claims are based not on population but on such factors as the economic position of the Sikhs in certain parts of the Punjab and religious sentiment applying to certain areas where there are Sikh shrines. Unless the Boundary Commission were told to give weight to these factors it could not do more than make marginal adjustments in the boundaries where the division by districts has included in the Muslim or Hindu areas small parts of districts in which Hindus or Sikhs or Muslims were in the majority. But if you are satisfied that a Boundary Commission, with terms of reference such as will help to keep the Sikhs quiet until the transfer of power, can be set up without provoking the hostility of the two major communities, I shall be very ready to support your view to my colleagues.
18. What the situation really calls for is a settlement between the Muslims and the Sikhs. Their interests are not necessarily irreconcilable and indeed have a good deal in common, as appears from the fact that they have worked together for many years under the Unionist party system in the Punjab. In this way the Sikhs would avoid being split up (which is their major interest) and the Muslims would get a larger and more viable Pakistan. But I fear the recent bloodletting has done much to destroy any chance of this, anyway for the present.
19. I understand from Leo Amery that he has already sent you a copy of his proposals for a ‘United Commonwealth of India’. These proposals, which of course, have much in common with Jinnah's ideas as to the relationship of Pakistan with Hindustan, are interesting and not without some value but their practicability clearly depends to a very great extent on whether the major parties are capable of that degree of mutual trust and respect that underlies the relations between the United Kingdom and the present Dominions. No doubt, if there were full and real acceptance of partition by Congress, such relations could be established and made to work well, but if Congress only accept Pakistan in order to convince the Muslims that it is impracticable, and to force them ultimately into Federation, they could hardly do so.
20. One further point is perhaps worth mentioning. Amery's preference to ‘the definite solution which they (i.e. H.M.G.) ‘as arbiters, are compelled to impose’ seems to imply an over-estimation of the part which H.M.G. can, or indeed should, play in framing the shape of the future India. It would be impossible to impose the partition of India against the wishes of both major communities.
21. I was very glad to hear that you had decided to go to Simla for a short break. The intensive negotiations you have been conducting ever since your arrival in India, in addition to the innumerable interviews you must have had to grant on assuming the office of Viceroy, must have put a tremendous strain upon you and some degree of relaxation before the next and perhaps even more intense phase of negotiations is obviously most desirable for you.
Listowel
7 Mountbatten to Listowel, 15 May 1947
Dear Listowel,
Thank you for your letter of the 3rd May. I am glad that my Personal Reports are of interest and that they are to be circulated to all members of the I. & B. Committee. I am sending extra copies to cover the three latest additions to the Committee.
2. With all that has been going on I have not been following closely the proceedings of the International Wheat Conference, but will certainty look into the question of the line taken by the Indian representatives, and try and find out their reasons for not asking for imports of wheat. At first sight I am surprised that they had such an optimistic outlook.
3. In connection with the International Wheat Conference, am sorry to say that Hutchings, who was one of the Indian representatives, and who has just returned to Delhi, has just been informed by his doctor that he has a tumour on one lung and will have to return to England for an operation. I am afraid that he will be away for at least four months, which is a big loss as he is an outstanding man.
4. I expect you are aware that the External Affairs and Commonwealth Relations Departments of the Government of India are about to be amalgamated and Sir G.S. BajpaiFootnote 654 has been selected to be Principal Secretary of the combined Departments. I think he is a very good choice as he has had plenty of experience of the type of work he will be handling.
5. The High Commissioner for India in London has in the past come under the Commerce Department of the Government of India, but it was decided by my predecessor that control should be transferred to the External Affairs Department. This was obviously a desirable step, and the more so in the changed circumstances which will result from the transfer of power in June 1948, when the High Commissioner will become the first Indian Ambassador. The transfer of control is now about to take place, and I have also approved plans for reorganising and strengthening the High Commissioner's staff. The appointment of a new High Commissioner is naturally being delayed until the political decision about the transfer of power to Indian hands has been taken.
6. I need not say how distressed I was to have to telegraph on Sunday explaining the entirely unexpected situation which had arisen in regard to the PlanFootnote 655 which Ismay brought home. I have just received the Prime Minister's telegram inviting me home for consultations and I am very hopeful that by the time I leave I shall have achieved some sort of agreement to the revised plan among the leaders.
Yours sincerely,
Mountbatten of Burma
8 Mountbatten to Listowel, 5 June 1947
My dear Listowel,
I see from his letter of the 26th May that Sir John ColvilleFootnote 656 kept you in the picture during my time in England of what was happening out here. My letter this week will be brief as I naturally have none from you to answer, and the last few days have been fully occupied with the meetings with the Indian leaders, to which I have referred in the attached Personal Report.
2. I think you will like to know that the Honourable Mr. Jagjivan Ram,Footnote 657 the Labour Member, is leading the Indian Delegation to the next Session of the International Labour Conference at Geneva on the 19th June, 1947. This will be his first visit abroad and Sir John Colville, who saw him recently, told me that he was quite excited about it. He is particularly looking forward to his visit to London and I should be very grateful if he could be given the opportunity to meet people and to see something of London, where I gather he intends to be from 27th June to 2nd July. He is a charming little man and quite remarkable for an ‘untouchable’.
3. The question of dealing with outstanding appeals from the Privy Council after demission of power has been exercising attention out here. This is a matter for which provision must be made in the future constitutions drawn up by successor authorities and also I suggest might appropriately be included in any Treaty drawn up by H.M.G. with such authorities.
4. If the whole or any part of India remains within the Commonwealth then I understand that it is possible by agreement for the Privy Council to be used by Commonwealth members as the final appellate authority. This matter cannot be the subject of a definite recommendation at present, but I thought it might be useful if I mentioned it to you, in order that you could have a preliminary examination made at your end.
5. Sir John Colville returned to Bombay on Sunday; this is the fourth time he has officiated in the absence of the Viceroy in England and I have heard from all sides since my return that he has officiated once again with his customary ability and charm. I think Ramamurty [sic]Footnote 658 had a very good fortnight's experience at Bombay and I have just received a useful fortnightly report from him, of which I think you have a copy. I understand that he brought 16 members of his family to live in Government House during his fortnight and had all three Government houses in the Bombay Presidency opened, and entertained lavishly.
Yours sincerely,
Mountbatten of Burma
9 Listowel to Mountbatten, 5 June 1947
I would like first of all to add to the message from the Cabinet already telegraphed to you by the Prime Minister an expression of my personal congratulations on what you have achieved. Although no well-informed person would be so foolish as to minimize the risks attendant upon the policy that has been announced or the scope for mischief still left to fanatics and those elements in Indian politics which do not sincerely desire a settlement broadly acceptable to all the main parties, there can be no denying that at the present moment the prospects of such a settlement appear to be more real than they have ever been before and we are all deeply conscious of the degree to which this is due to you personally. I greatly hope that during the coming critical months you may be enabled to complete the work which you have so successfully begun.
2. It was of the utmost value that the Prime Minister and I were able to preface our reading of the announcement in Parliament by saying that the planFootnote 659 had been received favourably by the leaders of all parties. It was, of course, only after the announcement had been made that we received your telegram reporting in detail the course of your meeting with the leaders of the three parties on the morning of 3rd June and learned of the awkward corners you had had to turn with each of them and of the help you received from V.P. MenonFootnote 660 in dealing with Nehru and Patel. It looks very much from here as if Gandhi, having failed in his efforts to sabotage agreement on this occasion, has now thought it wise to try and get in on the ground floor before it is too late; but, even if this is the correct interpretation of his actions, his support will be no less valuable for that. There would seem to be good ground for hoping that acceptance of the plan will now be ratified by the All-India Committees of Congress and the Muslim League since a failure to ratify on the part of either would involve the throwing over of its Working Committee and an immediate prospect of large scale civil strife. If the plan is ratified, the broadcast appeals of all three leaders should contribute substantially to the preservation of order during the transition period.
3. Thanks to the promptitude with which you informed me of the changes in the text of the announcement, all the arrangements went very smoothly at this end and we actually succeeded in getting the White Paper released immediately after the actual making of the announcement. You will doubtless have seen full press reports of the reception of the announcement in both Houses and will, I know, share my pleasure at the compliment paid by Winston Churchill to the Prime Minister, which created a very favourable impression in the House. I hope you noticed the pleasant tributes paid you in the Lords by Bobbety Salisbury and Perth.Footnote 661 Thanks very largely to Joyce's efforts, the publicity arrangements at this end proved most satisfactory and the maximum possible coverage was obtained both from the B.B.C. and the Press. Perhaps you were able to listen to the B.B.C.’s 9 p.m. broadcast which contained an excellent summary of the plan besides the Prime Minister's broadcast and relays of your broadcast and of extracts from the broadcasts by the Indian leaders. The press reactions have been uniformly favourable, save only for the ‘Daily Worker’!
4. As you have pointed out in one of your telegrams, it will be of vital importance to ensure that there is no ‘resting on oars’ now that the announcement has been made but that all necessary consequential action is pressed ahead as fast as possible. You may rest assured that we shall do all we can at this end to help you retain the initiative and make full use of the advantage gained.
5. I was very grateful to you for keeping Rance in touch with developments in Delhi in the final stages. We have just received a telegram from him reporting the first reactions of his Council to the Indian announcement which are not unpromising. If, as we really believe, it would be as advantageous to India and Burma themselves as to this country that they should remain within the Commonwealth, everything will depend on our ability to bring home to the leaders of both countries during the next few months the validity of this belief.
6. To turn to other matters, you will be glad to hear that, on a joint memorandum from the Colonial Secretary and myself, the Cabinet his week agreed to raise the ban on the admission of persons of non-European descent to permanent engagements in the Royal Navy and the British Army and an announcement to this effect was made in Parliament yesterday. This change of policy is, of course, of much greater significance to the Colonies than to India but, so far as India is concerned, it will be a real gain both in principle and because it will enable Indians resident in this country to join all three Services.
7. While you were with us in London, Colville wrote to me on the 22nd May asking that all possible help should be given to Hamilton, your Chief Conservator of Forests, when he arrived in the United Kingdom on the 9th June to investigate the chances of finding other employment for I.F.S. [Indian Forestry Service] officers when their present careers are terminated.
8. As you will see from the attached memorandumFootnote 662 (which has already been circulated to all I.F.S. officers on leave in this country and is in course of circulation in India and Burma), specially liberal concessions have already been obtained by the India and Burma Services Re-employment Branch for I.F.S. applicants for appointment under the Forestry Commission. We have also, after discussion with the Colonial Office, now agreed a memorandum offering appointments in the Colonial Forest Service and this will be distributed within the next week. I am told that your people have also been given details of a small number of appointments in Southern Rhodesia.
9. I think it will be clear from the above that most of the ground mentioned in your letter has already been covered, but we shall, of course, be very glad to see Hamilton and to put him in touch with the people concerned. No doubt his long experience of Indian conditions will provide them with valuable background.
10. I recently held a meeting here for the purpose of enabling the Minister of Education and myself to hear from the President of the Royal Academy and the Chairman of the Executive Committee of the Indian Art Exhibition 1947/48 the present state of the preparations for the exhibition. You may care to have the enclosed copy of the note of the discussionFootnote 663 from which you will see that at the date of the holding of the meeting the prospects for the exhibition were encouraging. Subsequently I received a letter from Sir Walter LambFootnote 664 about the failure of Udaipur and Gwalior to co-operate on which I have sent you a telegram (No. 67); I hope that it will be possible to get round this difficulty. You may also like to have the enclosed copy of a letter which George TomlinsonFootnote 665 has written to Maulana AzadFootnote 666 about the Exhibition. Anything you are able to do by way of keeping an eye on the preparations for the Exhibition in India and assisting the Indian Committee to surmount any obstacles that arise would be most valuable. I know you share my desire to make the exhibition a resounding success.
11. I understand that it was at your suggestion that ChundrigarFootnote 667 originally decided to visit London on his way to Geneva. You will be glad to hear that we secured agreement to his being treated as a guest of H.M.G. during his stay and that, before leaving for India, he wrote me a letter which showed that he had enjoyed his visit. A number of social functions were arranged in his honour.
12. At your request Ismay brought to my attention while he was in London your desire to obtain a generous allotment of honours for the next two lists and I assured him that, although proposals of this kind have to be submitted for the approval of the Committee on the Grant of Honours, Decorations and Medals, I would consider your proposals when they are received with the utmost sympathy and give them all the support I could. You will no doubt have already realised that the likelihood that the successor authorities in India will have obtained Dominion status before the end of the present year has a bearing on this question and that it may be that your wishes in regard to honours will have to be met by a special ‘Transfer of Power List’ in advance of the next New Year List. Doubtless I shall be receiving your recommendations on this matter before long.
13. There is one other point in connection with honours which has been outstanding for some time. In his letter to Pethick-Lawrence of 12th March, Wavell asked whether any objection was seen to his asking Shone to comment on recommendations for honours in favour of members of the British Mercantile community in India received from recommending authorities and also, if he (Shone) wished, to send in names himself to the Viceroy. This suggestion has been examined here from the point of view of the procedure at present followed in the Dominions and no objection is seen to its adoption.
Listowel
10 Mountbatten to Listowel, 12 June 1947
Dear Listowel,
Thank you so much for your letter of the 5th June and for the good wishes and congratulations which you were kind enough to send me. I must say that everything has gone very well so far and, although we are not out of the wood yet, I have every hope that the good start we have made will be continued.
2. The All India Muslim League Council held their meeting on Monday the 9th June and I have referred to this in more detail in my weekly report attached. The All India Congress Committee meeting takes place next Tuesday the 17th June and, although both Nehru and Patel have written to me about the Muslim League resolution, I feel I will be able to solve this difficulty by further personal negotiation.
3. We might have had a little trouble with Gandhi but, as I have described in my report, I think we can now count at least on some form of co-operation from him. Nehru and Patel of course also worked on him hard.
4. Gandhi also told me that there was a lot of loose talk going about that His Majesty's Government might have different agreements with Hindustan and Pakistan which would possibly tend to favour one over the other. He felt, therefore, it was important that an announcement should be made to the effect that it was His Majesty's Government's wish either to enter into tri-partite arrangements with both the Dominions, or to have similar bi-lateral agreements with each of them: and that, in any event, there would be no question of differentiation. One solution might be for this to be referred to by the Prime Minister in the House.
5. I have read Hansard for both Houses of Parliament; I am so glad that the plan had such a favourable reception, and am most appreciative of all the kind things that were said. I was particularly pleased at Winston's very nice reference to the Prime Minister. The publicity arrangements at this end were also most satisfactory and I have written specially to Vallabhbhai Patel to thank him for the assistance which was given by All India Radio and the Information and Broadcasting Department, particularly in regard to my press conference.
6. There has been no relaxation of the pace here and we have pressed on hard all the week in ensuring that the leaders and the Cabinet face up squarely to the administrative consequences of partition. The pace is so hot that we are still three or four lengths ahead, but certainly June in Delhi is not a month in which anyone – British or Indian – can be expected to give of his best.
7. Thank you so much for the information you have given me about the employment for the Indian Forest Service officers after the transfer of power. I was very glad to see the arrangements which have been made for applications for employment in the Forestry Commission and to hear that further appointments are in prospect with the Colonial Forest Service. There is no doubt that the ground has been very thoroughly covered and I think that Hamilton should be well satisfied with what has been done. But no doubt, as you say, he will be able to provide some additional background and perhaps help with some of the details.
8. I am sorry I am not in a position yet to reply to your telegram No. 67 about the failure of Udaipur and Gwalior to co-operate in the Indian Art Exhibition 1947/1948. I have shown what you have written to my wife and we are going to keep in touch with Maulana Azad, and his opposite number when Pakistan is formed, in order to be able to give any help we can in this matter. At the present time I agree with you that it is most desirable to make this Exhibition a great success.
9. I notice in your letter of the 5th June you refer to the possibility of a special honours list in advance of the New Year list 1948. I am very keen to have a special allowance of honours particularly for those who helped to put the agreement through and should have liked to have had the names included in the New Year's Honours List 1948. But before I reach any decision on this point I should be glad if I could be informed whether it is the intention that the Star of India and the Indian Empire Orders should lapse on the 15th August this year. Naturally it would be preferable for all concerned to receive honours in these two Orders rather than in other British Orders which are available, but this may prove difficult if the Indian Orders have lapsed on the 15th August, unless arrangements can be made for a special allocation for the New Year List 1948. I should be very grateful if I could receive an early decision on this point. [Handwritten – Personally I feel strongly they should certainly not be allowed to lapse for the present].
10. In letters to your predecessor I have referred more than once to the position of Caroe in the Frontier Province. As you know, I have been pressed continuously and most strongly by the Congress party for his removal. These representations have recently been renewed to the effect that there is no hope of peace, nor of a fair and orderly referendum in the Frontier Province so long as Caroe is Governor, and I therefore decided that the time had come when I must, for the moment at any rate, replace him.
11. I attach a copy of my letterFootnote 668 to Caroe and I have just heard from him to say that he accepts my suggestion and that he would like to go on leave to England to settle affairs consequent on the recent death of his mother. This seems the best solution for a difficult problem.
12. In one of my past letters to your predecessor I referred to the American Ambassador Elect to India and to the impression he had created at his first press conference. I do not know whether it has been reported in England, but Mr. GradyFootnote 669 has managed to say the wrong thing again, this time on his arrival at Singapore, where he told reporters that ‘We hope to be of assistance to India in her fight for independence’. If this statement had been made before the 3rd June it would, to say the least of it, have been tactless, but at the present time it is, of course, merely pointless. One of the high ranking members of the Congress hierarchy, referring to this statement, said to me ‘Some people take time to grow up’.
13. I wonder if you can tell me whether there is any more information about the prospects of further employment in the Colonial Service in the case of Irrigation Engineers. Mr. C.F.V. Williams, my Public Secretary, attended a meeting at the Colonial Office on the 2nd August, 1946, at which it was stated that the prospects of employment in the Colonial Service were good in the case of medical officers and technical officers, such as engineers, but there was some doubt in the case of irrigation engineers. I have been asked whether there is any further information on this subject, and the Chief Engineer, United Provinces, has recorded the following note, which he sent to the Governor, Wylie: –
I shall be grateful if you will inform the authorities who are dealing with the selection of Civil Engineers for re-employment that Irrigation Engineers in India have to design and construct their own buildings, including water supplies and sanitation, roads and river training works. In addition, they have to design and construct dams, weirs, barrages and canals. On the latter they have to design and construct bridges, falls, aqueducts, draining syphons or level crossings. In recent years in the United Provinces, Civil Engineers, have, in addition had to design and construct power houses, both hydro and steam, transmission lines, tubewells complete with water distribution systems consisting of lined and unlined channels or unreinforced concrete pipes. Irrigation Engineers from India should, therefore, be capable of dealing with almost any Civil Engineering problem.
14. There certainly seems to be something in what he says and perhaps this might be passed to the Colonial Office.
15. I may not be sending you a Personal Report next week as I am going to Simla from Friday evening the 13th to Monday morning the 16th inclusive, and to Kashmir from Wednesday the 18th to Monday the 23rd inclusive, returning to Delhi in time for the visit of the Chief of the Imperial General Staff. I have promised Nehru to try and smooth over some of his recent difficulties with the Maharajah, as the latter is a very old friend of mine.
Yours sincerely,
Mountbatten of Burma
P.S. [Handwritten] Ismay has had a better brain wave than para.11 re Caroe & I attach a copy of the letterFootnote 670 I've just written to him. M of B.
11 Listowel to Mountbatten, 13 June 1947
Dear Mountbatten,
Thank you for your letter of 5th June enclosing Personal Report No. 8, which I, and I am sure all my colleagues, have read with the keenest interest. I have also been most interested to read the full records of your crucial meetings with the Party leaders and with the members of the States Negotiating Committee. It is clear that you achieved a tactical success by at once bringing the leaders up against the administrative consequences of partition.
2. On receiving your telegram No. 1348-S of 7th June about the proposed Arbitral Tribunal, I at once approached the Lord Chancellor about a possible Chairman. It seems that, apart from any other consideration, the members of the Judicial Committee of the Privy Council are all ruled out on account of age since 69 ought, I think, to be regarded as an absolute maximum and 55 would probably be the optimum age. As you doubtless realise, the pressure upon High Court Judges at the moment is very heavy and the Lord Chancellor can hold out no hope of one being made available for your purpose. An approach is, however, being made to Sir Cyril RadcliffeFootnote 671 who would, I think, fill the bill admirably. Apart from his great legal abilities, he has just the right personality and acquired during the war administrative experience which would be likely to be of great assistance to him. Of course, he may well feel unable to leave the Bar, even temporarily, so soon after returning to it, however worth while your job can be made to appear, but there is just a possibility that he might be attracted by it.
3. I am also having the question of the manning of the Boundary Commissions, raised in your telegram No. 1364-S, looked into and the suggestion about U.N.O. taken up with the Foreign Office. Clearly, the handling of this Boundary Commission business is going to be of crucial importance. It seems as if the Sikhs may try to get back at the Boundary Commission stage some of the ground which they surrendered over the announcement of policy. It is to be hoped that the staking out of claims, as, for example, for the River Chenab line, in advance of the findings of the Boundary Commissions will not get out of hand since, once claims of this kind have been staked out, withdrawal is apt to prove difficult without loss of face.
4. I was interested in what you say in paragraph 30 of Personal Report No. 8 about Suhrawardy's plans for the economic development of Eastern Bengal. It looks as if Eastern Bengal will be a pretty poor show economically and will require a good deal of development economically if it is to live. I am not surprised that American businessmen should already be making offers to Suhrawardy, because it is their tendency in fluid conditions, such as obtain at present in India, to make such offers, in order to get their foot in on the ground floor, but without necessarily having any intention of carrying the matter through. Doubtless interest which American businessmen are now taking in India generally will be reflected in a certain number of orders, availability of dollars permitting. But British exporters have great advantages, flowing from their long connection with India, the organisations which they maintain there, and the fact that the Indians are accustomed to their products. They are tending to mark time at present but I think that we shall find that when they talk business they will do so seriously. We shall have to consider in due course what encouragement we should give them to help build up Pakistan economically to enable it to stand on its feet. I agree that the matter is one for Shone to handle.
5. I was a little surprised to see Ismay's telegram to MonteathFootnote 672 No. 1354-S about Caroe. When I mentioned the matter to you at Northolt, I understood that the Prime Minister did not wish any action taken in the matter for the time being. I can quite understand, however, that, if the public agitation for Caroe's removal had subsided, you consider it politic in all the circumstances to meet Congress criticisms on this score and, in particular, to forestall any allegation that a referendum conducted under the local direction of Caroe would not be carried out with complete impartiality. I have already obtained the Prime Minister's consent to my approaching the Palace with a view to obtaining the King's informal approval and I shall hope to be in a position to telegraph to you within a day or so. At the same time I feel very strongly, and the Prime Minister agrees with me in this, that it would be most unwise that Caroe should be allowed to resume the Governorship of the North West Frontier Providence if he once relinquishes it. Surely such action would be taken as implying that we ourselves believe that Caroe is prejudiced in favour of the Moslem League and therefore ought not to be in office during the holding of the referendum.
6. The Prime Minister recently held a meeting of the Ministers concerned to discuss the future of the India and Burma Offices. As a result of the meeting Sir Edward BridgesFootnote 673 was instructed to arrange for the preparation of a detailed scheme for the establishment of a Commonwealth Relations Office to which would be assigned, not only the duties at present entrusted to the Dominions Office, but also the affairs of India, Burma and Ceylon, if those countries, on attaining their independence, desire to retain a link with the Commonwealth. It was recognised that it would be possible, and probably necessary, to provide, within the new Department, for what would in effect be separate sub-departments to carry out our special responsibilities to India and possibly Burma, which for some considerable time would be likely to differ in tiny ways from any which we have to exercise in respect of other countries, whether within or without the Commonwealth.
7. All concerned here have been pressing ahead as fast as possible with the preparation of the draft Indian Dominions Bill. According to present plans, the draft Bill will be considered by the India and Burma Committee on Tuesday morning next, a copy being sent to you before the week-end so that you may have it available by the time that the views of the Committee reach you by telegram. The time-table in regard to the Bill is of course going to be very tight indeed and great care will be required at every stage to ensure that nothing is allowed to upset it.
8. You will remember that at the meeting of the I. & B. Committee on 22nd May, at which you were present, it was agreed that, on the grant of Dominion status to one or more successor States in India, the offer of facilities for Indian Officers to attend the Imperial Defence College [IDC] and the Joint Services Staff College should be renewed. This matter has been taken up with the Ministry of Defence who have been consulted at the same time about the possible renewal of the invitation to India to attend the Commonwealth Advisory Committee on Defence Science and on the subject of the disclosure of classified information to India. I have asked that these matters should be approached with the desire to do everything possible to convince Indians of the advantages to be derived from membership of the Commonwealth.
9. You may care to know that of late we have rather gone out of our way to keep in close touch with the ‘Joint Committee on India’’ which is a co-ordinating body for British commercial and industrial organisations with interests in India. It seemed very desirable to let the Committee feel that they were being given the opportunity to express their views while the draft Bill was still in a fairly fluid state and I am glad to say that Stafford Cripps has agreed to be with me tomorrow when a deputation from the Committee is calling on me.
10. I am very glad that it has been possible to obtain the agreement of the Foreign Office and the Prime Minister to the Government of India's scheme for a temporary Indian diplomatic establishment in London to handle India's relations with a number of smaller countries in Europe. Krishna MenonFootnote 674 was able to see both McNeilFootnote 675 and Bevin on this question when he was over here and I have just sent a telegram to Nehru conveying H.M.G.’s agreement.
11. In paragraphs 9 to 12 of your letter of April 24th you referred to the Nagas and to Clow's pamphlet on ‘The excluded and partially excluded areas of Assam’. The problem of these areas is very similar to that of the frontier areas of Burma; and there is some resemblance between the suggestions in Clow's pamphlet and the observations in Part 3 of Chapter 3 of the report of the Burma Frontier Areas Committee of Enquiry. I enclose three copies of this report,Footnote 676 and suggest that you may like to send one to Hydari. The report would probably also be very useful to the Sub-Committee of the Advisory Committee of the Constituent Assembly which is dealing with the future administration of the tribal and excluded areas.
12. Talking of Burma, it now looks very much as if the Burmese are going to shun the Indian example and decide for complete independence outside the Commonwealth. Whilst this decision is of course greatly to be regretted, it has to be recognised that it is probably due to the fact that the Burmese rank and file are completely ignorant of the meaning of Dominion Status which they regard as an inferior brand of independence and that the leaders of A.F.P.F.L who probably themselves would prefer that Burma should remain inside the Commonwealth, do not feel certain enough of their position to give a firm lead in that direction. Certainly, if the result of their endeavouring to do so was their own overthrow and the coming into power of the Communists, we should have still greater cause for regret.
13. I was very glad to hear that Mr. Jagjivan Ram would be visiting this country on his way to Geneva and you can rest assured that we will do all we can to make his visit a success. I shall greatly look forward to meeting him myself. This week I have seen General Savory,Footnote 677 the Nawab of BahawalpurFootnote 678 and Mr. B.C. Roy.Footnote 679
Listowel
12 Listowel to Mountbatten, 20 June 1947
Dear Mountbatten,
Thank you for your letter of 12th June and your Personal Report No. 9.
2. Since I last wrote the All-India Congress Committee [AICC] has ratified the Congress leaders’ acceptance of the announcement of 3rd June so that another potential obstacle to progress has been surmounted. It is clear from your Personal Report that it was by no means plain sailing and that once again the successful outcome was in large measure due to your own initiative. It was perhaps hardly surprising that, with the example before them of what had happened in regard to the Cabinet Mission's plan, the Muslim League were chary about committing themselves to a definite acceptance of the announcement until they knew where the A.I.C.C. stood.
3. It is also clear from your letter and report that Gandhi will continue to require very careful watching and handling, though it is to be hoped that the stage has now passed when it was within his power to sabotage the whole plan. It has to be recognised, however, that injured vanity might still impel him to try to do so.
4. I have given some preliminary consideration to his point about agreements between H.M.G. and the two Indian dominions which you mentioned in paragraph 4 of your letter but am not yet entirely clear as to how we should proceed in regard to it. It may very well prove the right course that the Prime Minister should say something on the point in the House but the terms of any statement will require to be very carefully thought out and I am not at all sure that it won't have to be on lines rather different from what Gandhi would like.
5. I am also having the proposals you made about honours in paragraphs 9 of your letter and in your telegram No. 1429-6 examined as a matter of urgency and shall hope to be able to let you have an answer at an early date.
6. I am sorry that it took a little time to fix up at this end the change in Governorship in the N.W.F.P. but in the result a premature leakage seems to have been avoided. I had myself thought, as you know, that it would have been better that Caroe should resign outright from the start but I can see the advantages of handling the matter on the lines finally adopted and I am glad to know that you yourself do not contemplate Caroe resuming office as Governor unless a recommendation in his favour were made by the Pakistan government.
7. In paragraph 13 of your letter you asked for further information about vacancies for Irrigation Engineers in the Colonial Service. I attach a copy of a memorandumFootnote 680 which has recently been issued on this question, from which you will see that Irrigation Engineers are eligible for consideration equally with other officers of the I.S.E [Indian Service of Engineers]. With regard to the desirability of impressing their general qualifications on the Colonial Office, Dawson, who was Chief Engineer in the United Provinces and presumably recorded the note sent on to you by Wylie, called on the Re-employment Branch on the 16th June and repeated his points. He was given a copy of the memorandum and the point was subsequently discussed with the Colonial Office on the telephone.
8. I feel sure that the interests or irrigation specialists will not be overlooked in making appointments, but I have asked that Dawson's note should be passed on to the Colonial Office to make sure that his case is given due weight.
9. In addition to your letter and Personal Report I have received during the past week the reports of your various meetings with the Indian leaders about the administrative implications of partition, for which I am most grateful. It seems that you have been able to achieve considerable progress in spite of unseemly wrangles. I note that it was agreed at your meeting on 13th June that Patel and Liaquat Ali Khan should consider together the composition of the Arbitral Tribunal; possibly, however, the services of a distinguished outsider as Chairman may still be required. You will have received my telegram No. 71 about Radcliffe who, as I said in my previous letter, ought to fill the bill admirably if he is acceptable. I am glad that the idea of consulting U.N.O. about the composition of the Boundary Commissions has been abandoned and it will probably be best if a reference even to the President of the International Court of Justice is also avoided as it would inevitably involve delay.
10. We feel every sympathy with you and your staff having to work at such intensity at the height of the hot weather. All concerned here, particularly those engaged on the Bill, have also been set a very fast pace, and it may interest you to know that the Cabinet Secretariat staff worked until 5 a.m. on Wednesday morning producing the minutes of a meeting of the Cabinet Committee as a basis for communicating to you the Committee's comments on the draft Bill.
11. It is clear from the A.I.C.C. Resolution on the subject and from various other pointers that the Congress are working up opposition to policy towards the States and, in particular, to our declared intention not to hand over any degree of paramountcy to the successor authorities in India. Some comment on this issue is beginning to appear in the Press here and diverse opinions are expressed. You ought to know that Stafford Cripps recently received a letter on the subject from Rajagopalachariar [sic] in which he challenged alike the legal, historical, political and moral bases for the doctrine of the lapse of paramountcy. The only possible line to take in reply to such representations is, of course, that, from an historical and constitutional point of view, the Cabinet Mission's statement of 12th May, 1946, was and remains right. Thus, there can be no doubt that the relations of the States have always been with the Crown; the point is argued at some length in the Joint Opinion of 24th July, 1928, by Leslie ScottFootnote 681 and other eminent Counsel given to the States (cf. in particular paragraph 7(1) of Appendix 3 to the Report of the Butler CommitteeFootnote 682). Before 1935 the Government of India was, of course, used as the agent of the Crown for conducting these relations; but this function was not to be confused with that government's executive functions as the Government of British India. At the same time it is imperative that our policy should take full account, as it has, in fact, done, of the practical consequences of the principle by which it has had to be determined. Thus, we have scrupulously avoided, and must continue to avoid, doing anything which might be taken by individual States as an encouragement to them to stand out of the new Indian set-up – this, I am sure you will agree, applies particularly to Hyderabad, Travancore and any other States which are reported to have declared their intention to assert independence – and we must clearly give any assistance in our power towards the working out of satisfactory new agreements between the States and the successor authorities. The letters to Residents which it was agreed should be despatched at your meeting with the Indian leaders on 13th June may be expected to help in bringing about the desired result.
12. I thought it would be helpful to you to receive in advance the text of the announcement on Wednesday in Parliament about the future of Ceylon. It may interest you to know that the agreements which it is contemplated should be negotiated when the new Government is in office will relate to defence, external affairs and safeguarding of minorities.
13. I was not at all surprised to receive your telegram No. 141-S about the food situation. Both Pethick-Lawrence and I have lost no opportunity in recent months of impressing upon the Minister of Food the desirability of doing all we possibly can to help India over food and about a month ago I circulated a memorandum to the Cabinet Committee warning them of the facts. I was, therefore, able, on receipt of your telegram, to follow up on my previous representations with a further memorandum inviting my colleagues to ask the Minister of Food, as a matter of political urgency, to arrange for the diversion to India of some quantity of wheat or flour, even at the risk of slowing down the rebuilding of our own stocks, and to ask the Secretary of State for the Dominions to instruct the U.K. High Commissioners in Australia and Canada to urge those Governments as a matter of Commonwealth interest to do everything they can to assist India at this moment. I shall hope to let you know the outcome of my efforts very shortly.
14. On the subject of food I was interested to see what Ramamurty said in his fortnightly letter to you of 30th May (No. 83). Although you have hinted to me that Ramamurty acted rather lavishly during his short spell as Governor of Bombay, it appears from the letter referred to that he approached his responsibilities in an energetic and constructive manner.
15. At the beginning of the week I attended the opening of the Fifth Commonwealth Forestry Conference. This Conference is being attended by a large Indian Delegation under the Inspector-General of Forests and I am arranging that the Delegation should be suitably entertained by the India Office.
16. You spoke to me when you were in London and have since telegraphed to me (No. 1366-S dated 9th June) about the case of the civilian ex-service clerks serving in G.H.Q. (India). Their case was also raised with Monteath by Auchinleck during his recent visit. The case of these civilian clerks is admittedly, on the face of it, a hard one and I entirely appreciate the considerations which impel you and the Commander-in-Chief to do all you can to secure for them the best terms obtainable. I can assure you that all of us here have approached their case with the utmost sympathy and desire to assist them but I am afraid that we have found it impossible to avoid a final conclusion that, so far as compensation at any rate is concerned, their case cannot be distinguished from that of other Europeans – some also after discharge from the Forces – who are serving as civilians under engagements with one or other government in India, for example in the Provincial Police Force. You will doubtless have noticed that it is recognised in the extract from a letter from Mr. W.J. Wood to Mr. A.E. Phillips which Ismay sent to ScoonesFootnote 683 that one reason for the refusal in 1933 to allow these men to revert to military service was the desire to preserve their better prospects as civilians. It may be that the good intentions of the government in this matter have been frustrated by events but it would not seem right to undo the past for one small category of a large class, whatever special merits they may possess. The only wise course seems to be to make no exception to the general principle that compensation is admissible only to the Secretary of State's Services or to officers appointed to posts by the Secretary of State.
17. There remains the question of the future employment of these men and their pensions. So far as their employment is concerned it seems probable that the services of most of them will be badly needed in the G.H.C. of one or other of the Indian Dominions and that there is therefore a good prospect of their being able to serve out their time. Those, however, who do not continue so to serve will be able to look to the Military Department of this Office and the Appointments Department of the Ministry of Labour (the staff of which includes an officer of the Indian Army) – who work in close co-operation – for assistance in finding alternative employment.
18. As regards pensions, it is, of course, the intention to make provision in the Treaty for the payment of pensions of this kind. I do feel, however, that there is a good case for endeavouring to persuade the Government of India to concede to these men the right to retire on proportionate pension once the transfer of power has been made, since it cannot be denied that conditions will be very different for them and they may be exposed to the risk of a reduction in their emoluments. I should therefore have no objection to your taking this point up with Patel if you wish to do so.
19. I am glad to know that you have been able to get up to Kashmir for a few days which will, I hope prove most refreshing to you and Lady Mountbatten.
Listowel
13 Mountbatten to Listowel, 27 June 1947
Dear Listowel,
Thank you for your letters of the 13th and 20th June, 1947; I did not write to you last week as I was away for brief visits to Simla and Kashmir.
2. I was very glad to hear of the possible appointment of Sir Cyril Radcliffe. I saw a certain amount of him when he was Director-General at the Ministry of Information during the war and formed a high opinion of him. I have put the matter in confidence to the leaders and I hope to let you have a reply shortly to your telegram.
3. There is, as might be expected, some difficulty in finding a Chairman for the Boundary Commissions, for the setting up of which the Leaders have just agreed, and, as the Arbitral Tribunal will probably not have much to do in the early stages, Jinnah has suggested that Radcliffe, if he proves acceptable, might perhaps serve in the first instance as Chairman of both Boundary Commissions to sit only to settle disputes within the Commissions. This is so far a purely tentative proposal. If anything comes of it I will let you know by telegram.
4. I was interested to read of the proposal for the establishment of a Commonwealth Relations Office to take over the duties at present entrusted to the Dominions Office and the India & Burma Office. I feel that this change of name will be a popular move as the title ‘Dominion’ seems to be going out of fashion these days and becoming almost unpopular.
5. I am glad to note, from Press accounts, that there is now a possibility that Burma may follow India's lead and ask for Dominion status in the first instance.
6. In this connection, I was interested to read the suggestion put forward by Rance in his telegram No. 161 of the 11th June, suggesting that the time was now ripe for investigation of a form of association within the British Commonwealth. I feel that the British Empire must move with the times and that it might well prove possible to find a somewhat looser form of association on the lines that Rance suggests. There are other parts of the Empire which might be placed in a similar position to India, Burma and Ceylon in the next few years, particularly the West Indies, where some form of federation seems to be quite possible in the future.
7. At this point may I say how much I appreciate your giving me advance information of the Colonial Secretary's announcement about Ceylon. One of the first things I had to do after reaching Kandy in April 1944, was to advise H.M.G. that an inquiry into the political future of the island was an urgent necessity if trouble was to be avoided in one of our principal bases in the Far East. The result was the Soulbury CommissionFootnote 684 and I have retained an interest in Ceylon's affairs from that time.
8. I am so glad to hear that the Ministry of Defence are being consulted about the possible renewal of the invitation to India to attend the Commonwealth Advisory Committee on Defence Science and on the subject of the disclosure of classified information to India. These points, together with the offer of facilities for Indian Officers to attend the I.D.C. and the Joint Staff College, Chesham, will make a very good impression out here and will be a great help in convincing India of the advantages to be derived from membership of the Commonwealth.
9. Thank you also for your reply about Honours and Awards. I feel that the best solution is to include the final Indian List with the New Year's Honours List 1948 and to back date it to the 14th August, 1947. It will thus, I think, attract less notice and will not appear as if we are celebrating our departure by a triumphant Honours List.
10. I am glad to hear that the interests of Irrigation Engineers have not been overlooked. I felt sure that the Colonial Office had the matter in hand; I am grateful to you for the memorandum which you have forwarded to me and which I will see is made available to all concerned.
11. Wylie has written me a long letter about certain U.P. [United Provinces] Officers who had retired on proportionate pension between the 1st January 1947 (when proportionate pension was re-introduced) and the 30th April 1947 – the date of the announcement on compensation. I have replied to him regretting that it will not be possible for me to give a certificate to nine officers who had retired between these dates, as, by the terms of paragraph 10 of the announcement, these officers are expressly debarred from receiving compensation. Four of these officers are, however, candidates for alternative employment under the Crown and I promised Wylie that I would write to you and ask that everything possible should be done to help these officers as they all have first-class records. Their names are : –
Mr. A.P. Hume (1927). He was Collector at Benares –a most disheartening place for any official under present conditions – before he retired on proportionate pension in February of this year. He is a candidate for alternative employment under the Crown.
Mr. H.T. Lane (1937). He was Collector at Ballia, one of the worst districts in the U.P., when he retired on proportionate pension on 15th April, only a fortnight before the Secretary of State's ‘terms’ were announced. He is a candidate for alternative employment under the Crown.
Mr. A.C. Cowan (1932). He was Collector of Azamgarh, if possible a worse district than Ballia, when he applied for proportionate pension. There tragically enough from his point of view he actually still is. He is a candidate for alternative employment under the Crown.
Mr. A.I. Bowman (1937). He retired on proportionate pension in January of this year and is a candidate for alternative employment under the Crown.
12. Paragraph 10 of your letter about the late hours worked by the Cabinet Secretariat staff reminded me of the war years in Whitehall, and, although we have not yet managed to achieve as late an hour as 0500, it is only with the greatest difficulty that I manage to avoid after-dinner work and ‘midnight follies’ are all too frequent. But in spite of it all the whole party out here are as keen and cheerful as ever.
Yours sincerely,
Mountbatten of Burma
14 Listowel to Mountbatten, 27 June 1947
I have no letter from you to answer this week – not that I was expecting one after what you said in the last paragraph of your last letter.
2. In paragraph 4 of your Private and Top Secret letter of the 12th June you said that Gandhi was pressing for an announcement to be made to the effect that H.M.G's wish was either to enter into tripartite arrangements with both the new Dominions or to have similar bilateral agreements which each of them and that in any event there would be no question of differentiation. You suggested that this might be referred to by the Prime Minister in the House of Commons in his speech on the Second Reading of the Bill.
3. This proposal of Gandhi's seems to me to be of such importance that I have put the matter before the India Committee. We all felt strongly that we should be extremely guarded in dealing with it.
Clearly one of the main objections to partition from the Congress point of view has been the danger that Pakistan would fortify itself with outside assistance from ourselves, the Americans or others. It seems to have been the fear of this happening through Pakistan remaining in the Commonwealth which in the end brought Congress to agree to temporary Dominion status and several utterances have been made to the effect that anyone who indulges in giving support to Pakistan will incur the hostility of Congress. The Congress would hardly pay so much attention to this point if they did not regard it as a serious danger.
4. Our position is that we want good defence arrangements with India as a whole and from our point of view it would be much best if they were on the same basis with both the Dominions and if the Commonwealth relationship provided the nexus between the two. But we feel that we should be very careful not to say that we shall not in any circumstances have closer relations with Pakistan than with India. Once we have said that, it will be open to the Congress to refuse any definite arrangements with us in regard to defence and other matters and then to say that we are precluded from having any better relationship with Pakistan. The best hope of getting an effective relationship with the Congress derives from their fear that if they do not play up we shall have differential and better relationships with Pakistan and possibly with non-acceding Indian States. The probability is that this is the strongest bargaining point we have with the Congress and it is one that may continue to operate for a substantial period. We feel that we should be very ill-advised to throw it away.
5. Further we do not think that we should say at this stage that it is our wish to enter into tripartite arrangements. Of course, if all parties were co-operating fully a tripartite arrangement would be the best but there can be a great deal of difference in the way in which an identical agreement is operated by two different parties. If we had a tripartite agreement all the arrangements under it would require the assent of the three parties. If, on the other hand, we had separate agreements with Pakistan and India we should be free, even though the agreement were in identical terms, to develop our relations with Pakistan under the agreement without India having the right to object. In practice, formal agreements about defence matters cannot contain more than general principles and what really matters is the kind of arrangements which are reached between the Chiefs of Staff or between the Governments in implementing the general agreement. Clearly Ghandi's idea is that we should commit ourselves before we even begin to negotiate not to have any arrangements with Pakistan different from those which we have dealt with Hindustan. Once we have said that, Hindustan can decide what arrangements, if any, we shall be committed to have with either of the new Indian Dominions.
6. At the same time we recognise that it is of immense importance to have, if possible, good and close relations with the new India and we agree that the Prime Minister in the Debate on the India Bill should refer to our desire to have close and effective arrangements with both the new Dominions in all fields and particularly in the defence and economic field on a basis of free negotiation. It might be added that what we hope for is to have equally good and close arrangements with both the new States in India.
7. I regret that I have not yet been able to let you know the outcome of my efforts reported in para.13 of my last letter to obtain from H.M.G. a gesture in the matter of food, but I am not letting the matter rest and shall hope to reply to your telegram soon.
8. We are indeed grateful to you for your prompt reply to our latest telegrams to you about the draft Indian Independence Bill. The receipt of your telegrams No. 1598-S this morning has made it possible for the Prime Minister to send copies of the draft Bill to Opposition Leaders before the weekend with a view to discussing it with them on Monday afternoon. It is to be hoped that after that discussion the way will be clear to authorise you to discuss the Bill with Indian leaders.
9. Thank you for your letter of 20th June (1446/18) enclosing one you had receivedFootnote 685 from BhopalFootnote 686 forwarding a statement of views upon H.M.G's policy towards the States. It is certainly to be regretted that any of the Princes should feel as he does about our policy but much of what they criticise is an inevitable consequence of the termination of British rule in India rather than a result of the particular way in which we have thought it best to handle matters.
10. You will like to know that the discussions with the Burmese Goodwill Mission which is here at present have been on a very friendly basis although it has now become quite clear that, in spite of what appear to be their own personal inclinations, the AFPFL leaders feel bound by the ignorances and prejudices of their rank and file to persist in their determination to take Burma out of the Commonwealth. It has been made clear to them that there can be no question of legislation to transfer power during the present Session except on the basis of dominion status for a reasonable period of time and that, if it is a question of transferring power to a sovereign republic, H.M.G. cannot do more than promise to introduce legislation next Session and secure its enactment as soon as possible.
Listowel
15 Mountbatten to Listowel, 4 July 1947
Dear Listowel,
Thank you for your letter of the 27th June. I quite see the point of view expressed in the first few paragraphs of your letter. I, of course, entered into no commitment with Gandhi beyond promising to refer the matter to you. The line the Prime Minister intends to take, as described in paragraph 6 of your letter, may not satisfy Gandhi, but I feel it will have a reasonably good effect out here.
2. I am sorry to hear that it appears likely that Burma will leave the Commonwealth. I am sure, from their point of view, it will be a retrograde step; there is much we could have done to help them and their departure can only result in the end in their being a more backward country than they would have been with our assistance.
3. Can you not go ahead on the basis of an interim Dominion period as in India and Pakistan until Burma have completed their new constitution and completed the legal drafting? If you were to rush legislation through now this session and made it last until such time as the new constitution were accepted, I feel sure Rance could convince them of the advantages in the meanwhile.
4. You will remember in my letter of the 5th June I referred to the question of outstanding appeals with the Privy Council. I am glad to see that Clause 9(c) of the draft Bill allows for the continued use of the Privy Council. The question of outstanding appeals to the Privy Council and also whether the Privy Council is to be used in future for appeals is at present being considered by the expert Sub-Committee of the Partition Council dealing with legislative matters.
5. Nehru has shown to me a copy of his letter to you dated 20th June, in which he asked that arrangements might be made for the acting High Commissioner for India to meet the Colonial secretary in regard to proposals concerning Indians resident in East Africa, West Indies, Fiji and Mauritius. I do not, of course, know the background of the case, but anything that you can do at the present time to meet Nehru's request will be a great help to me in view of his peculiar frame of mind and the difficult negotiations I have on hand.
6. This letter and attached Report are rather shorter than usual, but I have had a very full week and a particularly difficult one dealing with the Indian Leaders in regard to the draft Bill and the Reconstitution of the Interim Government. The latter, as you will have realised from the exchange of telegrams, has been, I think, the most difficult matter I have had to handle since I came out here.
Yours sincerely,
Mountbatten of Burma
16 Listowel to Mountbatten, 4 July 1947
I am writing this letter whilst we are still in the throes of launching the Bill. Copies of the Congress and Muslim League comments on the Bill and of your views on those comments only became available shortly before a meeting of the Cabinet Committee was due to be held at 9.30 p.m. last night. The Committee sat until midnight by which time the final terms of the Bill had been decided upon and it was just possible to get a copy to the Clerk at the Table by 1 a.m. this morning, which was the latest possible time if the programme was to be adhered to. The Bill was printed off during the course of the night and was formally presented by the Prime Minister at 11 a.m. this morning. Copies were made available in the Vote Office at 2 p.m. and the Prime Minister and I immediately held a Conference with the Lobby Correspondents. I have also this afternoon had Press Conferences with the Indian correspondents and the Empire and Foreign Correspondents.
2. The Congress insistence on a change in the Interim Government, which has made it necessary for us to telescope still further an already foreshortened programme, appears at this end as most unreasonable but the risks of not making any attempt to meet them were undoubtedly too great to be run. We must now do our utmost to achieve our target date of 20th July although it is not going to be easy.
3. You will remember that at your request the clause that appeared in the original draft of the Bill stating that any sums falling [failing] to be paid as a result of the passing of the Act out of the Revenues of India should be paid out of those Revenues, was omitted. You may be interested to see a memorandum, of which I enclose a copy,Footnote 687 setting out the problem which the clause in question was designed to solve. The difficulty has been got over, as proposed in the memorandum, by means of a Motion to the effect that Standing Order 67 and the practice thereunder should not apply to proceedings on the Indian Independence Bill. This Motion was moved by the Lord PresidentFootnote 688 this morning at the time of the presentation of the Bill. It may be helpful to you to have this background information in case questions are raised on the point in India.
4. I was glad to get your letter of 27th June covering Personal Report No. 10. It is certainly excellent that you have succeeded in getting Radcliffe as Chairman of the Boundary Commissions. He is approaching the whole matter in a most public-spirited manner and will, I have little doubt, fill the role admirably. As you have already been informed by telegram, he is hoping to leave for Delhi on Sunday and Lady Radcliffe hopes to join him about 10 days later.
5. I thought you would like to have advance telegraphic warning of the change in the title of the Dominions Office. The change has, of course, been prompted by developments in India but it was considered desirable from the point of view of the existing Dominions to make the change as far in advance of August 15th as possible in order to make it less obvious that the change had been dictated by events in India.
6. I am glad to be able to tell you that definite progress has already been made with the cases of two of the four officers referred to in paragraph 11 of your letter dated 27th June. Hume as accepted an offer of permanent employment in the Home Civil Service and is shortly going to the Department of Health of Scotland. Lane has also just been declared successful for the Home Civil Service and we hope that he will accept.
7. As regards the other two, Cowan, who is a candidate for the Reconstruction Competition, is likely to be interviewed for the Home Civil Service shortly and Bowman who is apparently doing a temporary job with a Youth Organisation in Scotland has not applied for any Government employment except the vacancies under the British Military Administrations in North Africa. The War Office have not yet decided whether to make him an offer. You can rest assured that they will both be given any assistance possible in obtaining further employment.
8. Congress seem out to cause trouble over the States though it is good news that the new States Department has been entrusted to Patel with V.P. Menon as Secretary. As you say, it would have made things very difficult indeed if Nehru had insisted upon taking this on himself. As you are doubtless aware, Zafrullah KhanFootnote 689 is now in London and is busy putting Bhopal's case before individual Ministers. Incidentally, I believe that Amery sent you a copy of his address to the Royal Empire Society on 18th June. In a letter to me covering a copy of it he laid emphasis on the distinction between paramountcy – based on treaties and other arrangements between the East India Company and the Princes, developed since by usage and sufferance of the Government of India – and the bond of allegiance between the Princes and the Crown, which was a new relationship introduced when Queen Victoria assumed direct government over India. Still further strengthened by her proclamation as Empress and by subsequent Royal Durbars. On Amery's suggestion I asked PatrickFootnote 690 to let me have a note on this question and I enclose a copyFootnote 691 as I think it will be of interest to you. I am sure that it will be politic to avoid at this juncture any recognition of a continuing formal relationship between the Princess and the Sovereign, although in practice the exchange of courtesies between them will doubtless continue.
9. It is clear from your latest report that nerves are getting on edge in Delhi – an inevitable consequence, I suppose, of a combination of over-work and excessive heat. I have no doubt that, if any opportunity presents itself of inviting the key people to the cooler atmosphere of Simla for a few days, you will take advantage of it.
10. It was good news to hear of the invitations to Colville and NyeFootnote 692 to stay on and I hope that they will be willing to do so.
11. I have just heard that Ismay is arriving next week. We shall, of course, be delighted to see him again.
Listowel
Since writing this letter I heard, with much relief, that you have succeeded in getting the change in the Government postponed until July 20th.
L.
17 Mountbatten to Listowel, 11 July 1947
My dear Listowel,
Thank you for your letter of the 4th July. I was interested to read the details of how the Congress and League comments on the Bill were dealt with in London. As I said in paragraph 5 of my Personal Report No. 11, all of us here were most grateful and appreciative of the way these comments were dealt with so expeditiously. I can only repeat once more my admiration and gratitude.
2. Thank you so much for details of the future of the four officers I referred to in my letter of the 27th June. I am glad to hear that they all have employment in sight or good prospects and I am informing Wylie accordingly.
3. As you surmise, Amery did send me a copy of his address to the Royal Empire Society on the 18th June. He has subsequently sent me his latest book on the Commonwealth, but as I am too busy at present to look into it in any detail, I have asked Morris JonesFootnote 693 (Constitutional Adviser) to let me have his comments. I hope soon to read Amery's address, the relevant chapter in his book and Patrick's note which you have been kind enough to send me.
4. I shall be interested to hear who exactly will look after the interests of India in the Commonwealth Relations Office, and through whom it will be possible to have my private letters sent in the future.
Yours sincerely,
Mountbatten of Burma
18 Listowel to Mountbatten, 18 July 1947
Dear Mountbatten,
It is, I fear, a fortnight since I wrote to you and in the meanwhile I have received two of your letters and personal reports. At the end of last week, when a letter was due from me, we were all preoccupied with piloting the Bill through Parliament and I felt it would be better to defer writing until that process was completed.
2. In your letter of 4th July you asked whether it would not be possible to follow in the case of Burma a procedure similar to that adopted in regard to India, namely, to rush through Parliament during the present Session legislation on the basis of dominion status for Burma in the hope that it might still be possible to convince the Burmese of the advantages of remaining in the Commonwealth. I can assure you that the possibility of following this course was fully weighed and that it was with the utmost reluctance that we finally decided that it could not be for the reason that, whether out of honesty or on other grounds, the Burmese leaders made it perfectly clear that there was no possibility of their changing their minds about leaving the Commonwealth and that if power were transferred forthwith on the basis of dominion status, Burma would ask for complete independence at the earliest possible moment thereafter and without making any show at giving dominion status a fair trial. Apart from any question of the prostitution of dominion status, it was at least doubtful whether the Opposition would co-operate to the extent of treating any such legislation as non-controversial and legislation this Session was out of the question on any other basis.
3. In the same letter you referred to Nehru's interest in the appointment of Indian agents in East Africa, the West Indies, Fiji and Mauritius. As a matter of fact, I received a personal letter from Nehru on this matter and am glad to say that the Colonial Office have now agreed in principle to the appointment of such agents, the question of their exact function being left open for negotiation between our High Commissioner in India and the Government of India. I have replied to Nehru's letter on these lines.
4. In paragraph 2 of your Personal Report No. 11 you gave us the background to the announcement of 1st July about the partition of the Armed Forces. This announcement naturally took us rather by surprise as we had had no preliminary warning of it but examination of its details revealed no apparent defects. The part played by Trivedi in achieving this important success illustrated well the vital importance of the personal factor in the handling of Indian affairs at the present time.
5. I would like to say here how full of admiration I am for the public-spirited and generous way in which you have faced the question of the Governor-Generalships of the new Dominions.Footnote 694 The whole affair must have been most baffling and exacting to your personally, but, as you know, everyone here without exception believes that the right course is the one you have so unselfishly decided to follow.
6. I am very sorry that it was not possible, as you suggested, to announce appointments to Governorships during the passage of the Bill through Parliament but I hope that an announcement of at any rate some names will be possible very soon. While it is excellent that CunninghamFootnote 695 is willing to return to Peshawar, it is perhaps rather surprising that KillearnFootnote 696 feels at all attracted by East Bengal but it would certainly help to raise the status of Eastern Pakistan in the eyes both of Indians and of outside world if he were finally to accept.
7. I hope you will not have been too disappointed about Slim's refusal to accept the invitation to be Commander-in-Chief of the Army of the new Dominion of India. Personally, I formed the new impression that Slim's conviction that he was not in fact the right person for the job was sound and from all that I can hear I think that Lockhart,Footnote 697 of the appointment is offered to him, would be a more suitable choice.
8. The future of the Interim Government must have been a perpetual anxiety to you in recent weeks but it is to be hoped that your latest device for bridging the time that remains before 15th August will meet the case.
9. Krishna Menon came to see me on Tuesday. It has to be admitted that in the past the impression he has created in home circles has been by no means favourable but, in view of his selection as High Commissioner in the United Kingdom for the new Dominion of India, it is encouraging to know that his services have been of such assistance to you in the difficult negotiations in Delhi in recent weeks. I am arranging for him to meet some of the Opposition leaders to whom at the moment he is by no means persona grata. The great need at India House at the moment is, of course, for someone at the top with real organising and administrative capacity. I rather doubt whether Krishna Menon will supply this need but perhaps he will be wise enough to realise that, if he wishes to concentrate on higher policy, he must find someone as his deputy who will carry out the re-organising of the office that will be required.
10. In view of what you reported in paragraph 13 of your Personal Report No. 11, it is indeed fortunate that the period to 15th August is so comparatively short. The strain upon you and your staff during this critical period must, I am afraid, be almost unbearable but I trust that after 15th August there will be a relaxation of the tension.
11. I entirely agree with you as to the great political importance of our providing the cruiser which the Congress members of your Cabinet have agreed that they should have. At the moment we are rather held up by the fact that the official telegram from the Defence department, promised in paragraph 18 of your Personal Report No. 11, has not yet been received and the Admiralty (whose ways will be familiar to you!) stoutly refuse to make any move except on the basis of an official request. The matter was raised in the House of Commons during the Debates on the Bill and the Prime Minister undertook to inform Commander Noble (M.P. for Chelsea)Footnote 698 of the decision finally reached in the matter.
12. In paragraph 4 of your letter of 11th July you ask about the new set-up in the Commonwealth Relations Office and to whom you should address your private letters after 15th August. Ismay is fully informed on these matters and will explain the position to you on his return.
13. An intense effort will certainly be required of Radcliffe if the work of the Boundary Commissions is to be completed by 15th August. I have always had a feeling that the reactions of the Sikhs to the decisions of the Punjab Boundary Commission would be one of the most critical danger spots in the process of transferring power and I hope that the services of Major Short, over whose appointment the Treasury have been most helpful, will be of some assistance in this connection.
14. In my telegram No. 9035 of 14th July I sent you a message for transmission to Sir C.P. Ramaswami AiyerFootnote 699 in reply to identical telegrams which the Prime Minister and I had received from him. It is clear that Travancore is going to require very careful handling indeed and that we must avoid any statement which would give the State leverage in asserting its independence or economic autonomy. The Report No. 12 in paragraphs 27–32 of your Personal Report No. 12 on the discussions with the representatives of Hyderabad is very encouraging. I do indeed hope that you are right in believing that, if you can get Hyderabad to abandon the idea of complete independence, this would set an example which no other State, not even Travancore, could resist.
15. To-day the Indian Independence Bill has received the Royal Assent and we have fulfilled our intention with two days to spare. I was able to be present for part of the Second Reading Debate in the House of Commons and was, of course, present throughout the talking of all stages of the Bill in the House of Lords on Wednesday but could not find the time to attend the Committee Stage or Third Reading in the Commons. On the whole the Opposition in both Houses have been most co-operative and constructive in their criticism. It looked at the last moment as if the programme might be delayed in the House of Lords by the tabling of some amendment by Lord RankeillourFootnote 700 but in view of the course of the debate he did not even move them.
16. Ismay left this morning. His presence has as usual, been most valuable and he will be able to bring back to you first-hand impressions of the atmosphere in both Houses of Parliament.
17. To turn to other matters, it is unfortunate that Nehru has not responded to Smuts'sFootnote 701 efforts to secure a détente between the Government of India and the Union [of South Africa] about the Indians in South Africa. He appears to be unwilling to co-operate unless Smuts accepts the implications of the U.N.O. Resolution, i.e. admits that U.N.O. has the right to intervene in matters of this kind, that the arrangements entered into between the Union and India in the past have the status of international obligations, and that consequently the Asiatic Land Tenure ActFootnote 702 will have to be suspended or withdrawn. This, however, might mean political suicide for Smuts. He has already lost an important by-election mainly because of his alleged liberal attitude towards Indians, and if he goes further his fall at the 1948 election in the Union seems certain.Footnote 703 The result would be the return to power of MalanFootnote 704 and the Nationalists, whose extreme views towards Indians are well known. This is surely not in Nehru's interests.
18. It would be very desirable to avoid at the next meeting of the U.N.O. Assembly a repetition of last year's controversy. The State Department, who like ourselves are uneasy about the position, have suggested to the Canadians that they might try to find out what the position is and we have privately advised the Canadians to make discreet enquiries both from the Union and from the Government of India as to the line each proposes to take. Bottomley, the Parliamentary Under Secretary of State in the new Commonwealth Relations Office, will take any opportunity he has in the course of the visit he is now paying to South Africa to talk the matter over with Smuts, I gather that Smuts has had considerable success with the moderate Indian leaders in South Africa, who are alarmed at the reaction in South Africa to the U.N.O. Resolution and have formed a new organization with the object of co-operating with the Union Government.
19. All this is, of course, very confidential to yourself. You will doubtless use any opportunity you get to guide Nehru on the path of moderation.
20. You mentioned in your letter of 5th June that the Hon. Mr. Jagjivan Ram, the Labour Member, would be visiting London after the end of the meeting of the International Labour Conference in Geneva. He actually arrived in London the 8th July and we were able to arrange that his time in London was used to the maximum advantage. In addition to interviews with the Prime Minister, Bevin, Cripps and Alexander as well as with Henderson and myself, Ram was taken to see various Ministry of Labour training centres etc., and also attended a Garden Party at the Palace as well as being present in the Commons for the Second Reading debate on the Indian Independence Bill. We also gave him a small official lunch which was attended by Nanda, the other Indian Delegate in Geneva, as well as Lall, the Secretary of the Labour Department and the principal members of the Indian Sterling Balances Delegation. Ram seemed to have enjoyed himself and I think that he will consider that his trip to London has been well worthwhile. We were, of course, grieved to hear of the air crash at Basra but are thankful for his miraculous escape.
21. Yesterday we gave a Luncheon Party to the Indian and Burma delegates to the Empire Forestry Conference. It was a very successful occasion and from all accounts the delegates have played a most valuable part in the Conference's deliberations and have been very impressed by the arrangements made. They have also, I am glad to say, greatly enjoyed their stay in this country.
22. I was consulted by Lord Robinson,Footnote 705 Chairman of the Conference, as to whether, from a political point of view, it would be a wise gesture to give India the opportunity of inviting the next Conference (in 1952) to be held in India. The Indian Delegation had indicated that they would like the matter left over for two years so that India, if so disposed, might then issue a firm invitation. I informed Robinson that, from a political point of view, it would certainly be most advantageous if it proved possible for the next Conference to be held in India and that I, therefore, hoped that it would be possible to arrange for the question to be left open for a year or two by which time it was to be hoped that the situation in India would be clearer.
23. I am most grateful to you for what you have been able to achieve in the matter of Gwalior and Udaipur and the Indian Art Exhibition. You will, I think, like to see the enclosed copy of a letterFootnote 706 from the President of the Royal Academy which appeared in ‘The Times’ on Tuesday last and the Question and Answer in the House of Commons on 15th July of which I also enclose a copy.Footnote 707 The arrangements for the Exhibition are, I think, for the moment at least proceeding smoothly.
24. When I saw Amery the other day he threw out the suggestion that you might find it helpful to have on your staff during the next few months someone who was versed in Dominions procedure. The idea struck me as a good one and Ismay, to whom I mentioned it this morning, thought that it might meet your need if you were to have the advice of such a person even for a month or six weeks; it would probably be very difficult, if not impossible, to spare anyone for longer. I am making some quite tentative enquiries but if you feel that the idea is worth pursuing, it would be helpful if you would let me know.
Listowel
P.S.
Since writing paragraph 9 above I have met Krishna Menon at lunch and he would be very grateful if you would take an opportunity of mentioning to Nehru that I am, at my own suggestion, arranging for him (Krishna Menon) to meet Opposition leaders in view of the fact that, as High Commissioner, he will be brought into official contact with them.
19 Listowel to Mountbatten, 25 July 1947
Thank you for your personal report No. 13 which, as usual, I have read with the greatest possible interest.
2. We were delighted last night to get your telegrams 2195-S and 2196-S and you are indeed to be congratulated on securing the agreement of the Partition Council to this important statement. It is to be hoped that it will have a calming effect throughout all the areas affected by partition and will help to discourage any large-scale migration of Muslims to Pakistan and Hindus to the territories of the future dominion of India; it has been disturbing to learn from Indians I have met in this country recently that such migration will be the natural tendency. It is also encouraging to learn from your latest personal report that Radcliffe has formed a favourable impression of the members of the Bengal and Punjab Boundary Commissions.
3. I sincerely hope that the absence of any information to the contrary can be taken as meaning that your solution of the problem of the Interim Government during the period that remains to August 15th is working out satisfactorily in practice.
4. I was delighted to learn of the arrangement you have been able to make with Admiral PalliserFootnote 708 about the shipping of the exhibits for the Indian Art Exhibition. It is particularly satisfactory that the Admiralty have arranged specially to divert an oiler for the purpose. There now appears to be good reason to hope that the Exhibition will be a real success.
5. I was also very glad to hear that all the leaders have so warmly welcomed the suggestion that Ismay and some of your staff officers should remain on with you during the transition period. As you say, Ismay may prove of the greatest help as a link between you and Jinnah.
6. I think we can regard the arrangements you have come to with the leaders about flags as satisfactory. It is clearly desirable to avoid pushing them so far in the direction of accepting the ‘externals’ of dominion status that they will forfeit the confidence and support of their followers.
7. Since I last wrote there have been the tragic events in Rangoon. Aung San is, of course, a tremendous loss both to Burma and to us, since we had put our confidence entirely in the will and ability of A.F.P.F.L. to take over power from us and exercise it worthily. At the same time it is indeed fortunate that Thakin Nu who, though not perhaps of quite the same calibre as Aung San, is undoubtedly a man of fine character and a potential leader, should have been spared and should so recently have visited this country and made the acquaintance of Ministers. It is, of course, disquieting that any degree of suspicion should attach to British officers over the theft of arms and ammunition from the Base Ordnance Depots and regrettable, though not altogether surprising, that this suspicion should have helped to engender some degree of anti-British feeling. I have considerable confidence, however, that Rance and Thakin Nu between them will succeed in keeping the ship level and on its course.
8. A member of my staff has been shown confidentially by a member of the American Embassy the instructions issued by the State Department to the U.S. Ambassador at Delhi about the attitude that he and American officials should observe towards the Indian States. The State Department have indicated that they do not wish any formal dealings to occur between American representatives and the governments of Indian States while the negotiations for the inclusions of the States in one or other of the two Dominions are continuing. They recognise that at some later time it may be necessary for the U.S. Government to determine its attitude towards any States which remain outside the two Dominions but they attach importance to their remaining uncommitted so long as there is any prospect of the States who have asserted claims to independence entering into political arrangements with one or other Dominion. This is very satisfactory. There are indications, however, that the attitude of the French Government, particularly in regard to Hyderabad, may not be quite so sound but the Foreign Office are taking such steps as they can to prevent the French going off the rails.
9. After getting your private telegram 1960-S of 15th July, I saw Sir William Haley of the B.B.C. about the Corporation's plans for their programme dealing with the transfer of power in India. Haley appreciated the possible difficulties but I rather got the impression that he did not feel that they were sufficiently great to deflect the Corporation from their path. It is, I think, a good thing that the programme (as distinct, from mere reporting of events) is not to be begun until some time next spring and that no public announcement will be made about it before the New Year and I think that Haley would be quite prepared to review it, if events in the meanwhile pointed to the desirability of doing so. I also took the opportunity putting to Haley that it would be desirable that he should obtain the consent of the governments of India and Pakistan to the activities of the Corporation's representatives in India in connection with their projected programme.
10. I telegraphed to the Finance Department of the Government of India on the 19th July, No. 9306, asking that the Central and Provincial Governments should be invited to reconsider their attitude on the question of applying the Pensions (Increase) Act, 1947 to Indian pensioners in the U.K. I hope you will take any opportunity that offers itself for influencing the Indian leaders to change their minds on this matter. The question has already aroused considerable interest in this country, both inside and outside the Parliament, and I fear that the refusal of the Indian leaders to extend the benefits of the 1947 Act to their pensioners in this country may afford an opportunity to throw doubts on the sincerity of the undertaking of the new Governments to maintain existing conditions of service.
11. In my last letter (paragraph 22) I mentioned the possibility that matters might be so arranged that it would be left open to India to issue an invitation for the next Empire Forestry Conference to be held in India. I am glad to say that the Resolution eventually passed by the Conference on this point was so framed as to give the future government of India the opportunity of doing so.
12. In my last letter I also mentioned (paragraph 13) that the promised official telegram from the Defence Department about the cruiser for India (Hindustan) had not yet been received. I am afraid I owe you an apology for this as the telegram had, in fact, been received on the 15th July but I had not seen a copy. This matter will, of course, now be pressed forward.
13. In conclusion, I might mention that on Friday last, after acting as a Royal Commissioner for the purpose of the King's Assent to the Indian Independence Bill, I attended a very successful inaugural luncheon of the newly formed association of Indian Journalists in London. It was altogether a very successful affair and the Association, which should be of the greatest assistance to us in the future, could not have had a more auspicious inauguration. This was largely due to your message, which I read to the gathering.
14. I have now arranged a luncheon for Krishna Menon on 5th August, to which prominent figures in all three Parties in the Lords and Commons have been invited. Menon would be reassured to know that you have mentioned this to Nehru, and that it has his approval.
Listowel
20 Mountbatten to Listowel, 25 July 1947
My dear Listowel,
Thank you so much for your long letter of the 18th July, which I read with much interest.
2. I am sorry to hear that the Burmese leaders during their recent visit to the U.K. made it perfectly clear that there was no possibility of their changing their minds about leaving the Commonwealth. In the circumstances I fully appreciate that there is no possibility of rushing legislation through in the same way as has been done in the Indian Independence Bill, as it is obvious that there would be no chance of the Opposition co-operating on such terms.
3. But I am still worried whether at some future date we shall not find the Union of India wishing also to leave the Commonwealth – after all their vowed intent is still a sovereign independent republic – and I hope this matter is receiving consideration at home. In an earlier letter I suggested the possibility, to which Rance had also referred, of some looser form of association within the British Commonwealth, and I am putting the staff out here on to thinking about this and trying to find out the way in which more prominent Indians are thinking. I have been wondering whether some form of common citizenship, as was proposed for France and England in the summer of 1940, might be a possible solution and I shall be grateful for any thought on this matter from you at home.
4. In speaking of Burma I need hardly say how distressed and shocked I was to hear of Aung-San's death.Footnote 709 In my opinion, he was far and away the outstanding man of that group and I had hoped that he would occupy an outstanding position in Burma for many years to come. I do not think any of the others are up to his standard, and, although no one is irreplaceable, I fear that affairs in Burma will be much more unsettled now that he is dead. I suppose there is no chance of persuading the new Government to give Dominion status a trial.
5. I am sorry the announcement about the partition of the Armed Forces took you by surprise. Had there been time I would certainly have kept you informed, but it was a delicate matter securing agreement on so complicated a subject. Not only the political parties but also the Commander-in-Chief had to be carefully handled. With the valuable help of Ismay and Trivedi I managed to secure an agreement, and it was essential that once the negotiations were completed the formal decision of the Partition Council should be recorded and the announcement made. This was one of the biggest hurdles we have jumped since I came out here, and had I known I should have to jump it so soon I would have let you know, though clearly it was for the Partition Council to make the decision.
6. Jinnah has offered East Bengal to Killearn, who with Lady Killearn has been staying with us. They are now on a visit to Dacca to see if they can find adequate accommodation, and I think the final answer will probably depend on that, for they have a family of small children and there are practically no modern sized houses in that one-horse town.
7. I was very sorry that Slim decided not to accept the appointment of Commander-in-Chief, India; I have had a very nice letter from him and I fully see his point of view. I understand that he felt he had been away from India too long, that he did not know the new Government or the new set-up and that he felt he would not fit in. I know him so well that I am sure there is nothing anti-Indian about him but that this is a perfectly straightforward honest opinion. Fortunately in Lockhart we have a most capable substitute.
8. I fully appreciate all that you say about Krishna Menon. I was aware that he is ‘persona non grata’ in many circles at home, and I would not say that he was popular or entirely trusted here. But he has been the very greatest help to me in the past difficult four months. Fortunately I made his acquaintance some years ago in England when he was very much an outcast because of his left-wing views and activities. He has never forgotten this and I have found him a valuable contact between Nehru (whose complete confidence he has) and myself, and through him I have been able to be particularly well informed about the trend of Congress thought and opinion. I need not stress how useful this has been to me since I came out. In fact with V.P. Menon and his close contact with Vallabhbhai Patel I have been able to know all that has been going on in both ‘camps’ in the Congress Party.
9. With reference to the postscript in your letter I am passing on to Nehru Krishna Menon's message about his meeting with the Opposition.
10. The official telegram about the cruiser must have crossed your letter, as it was despatched by Defence Department on the 14th July, telegram No. 2457. I am afraid as regards personnel it will not give the Admiralty all details they require. But at least it will let them know officially that India once again wishes to acquire the Achilles.
11. Thank you so much for the confidential information you gave me about Smuts and the Indian position in South Africa. This is not a matter which I have so far discussed personally with Nehru, though it has often come up in Cabinet. I will try and draw him out at some convenient opportunity, as I do not think this unsatisfactory state of affairs should be allowed to continue within the Commonwealth.
12. I am so glad to hear of Jagjivan Ram's programme at home and I am most grateful for all that was done to him on his initial visit to England. I am so glad that he survived the crash in the desert as he is a cheerful little man and I should have been sorry if he had been killed. I have not yet had full details of the crash, but I gather that through dust storms they were unable to land either at Basra or Shaiba and had to do a belly landing in the desert. I think they were exceedingly lucky that were not all killed.
13. I am certainly attracted to the idea of having someone on my staff, even for a short period, who is conversed in Dominion procedure and I shall be most grateful if you will go ahead with this. I think the earlier he can come out here the better and I think he will be a help not only to me but to the members of the Government.
14. You will recall the telegraphic correspondence we have had about a request for help in the matter of food, culminating in your telegram No. 8923 of the 11th July. I gave a copy of that telegram to Rajendra PrasadFootnote 710 and I enclose with this letter a copy of his replyFootnote 711 which covers the points raised. I do not know how far the insinuation that H.M.G. themselves gave barter inducements to Argentina is true.
15. The latest reports of the monsoon are slightly more favourable, and although the ration in Madras has had to be reduced further to 8 ounces a day, the situation in Bombay is slightly improved. As usual, much depends on the rainfall in the next two months, and I sincerely trust that we shall get through with the imports which are now in sight.
16. Representations have recently been made to me that the terms offered to I.M.S. [Indian Medical Service] officers for appointment to [the] Colonial Medical Service are unduly low and do not take sufficient account of their experience of tropical diseases. I am told that the D.G.I.M.S. [Director-General of the Indian Medical Service] has already addressed your Medical Adviser on the subject and I shall be grateful for anything you can do to secure more attractive terms for these officers, whose experience should be very valuable in the Colonies.
17. I have been reading Hansard both for the Commons and the Lords during the past week and I am filled with admiration at the way the Bill went through both Houses. If it is not out of place I should like to congratulate you and the members of the Government concerned heartily on this achievement. It is obvious that a very great deal of work must have been put in behind the scenes to smooth the passage of the Bill and to prevent the Opposition from raising controversial points, and I can assure you that I am most grateful to you for all that has been done. I need not say how high the British Government's stock stands out here at present for their honesty and good faith and the smooth and swift passage of the Bill has been the greatest help to me personally in my relations with the Indian leaders. If you see fit I should be very glad if you would pass my warmest thanks to all concerned.
Yours sincerely,
Mountbatten of Burma
21 Mountbatten to Listowel, 1 August 1947
My dear Listowel,
Thank you so much for your letter of the 25th July, and for all the information you sent me, which I read with great interest.
2. My Press Attache, Campbell-Johnson,Footnote 712 visited London recently with Ismay and was able to have an interview with Sir William Haley. He was able to put my point of view across, although he tells me that he did not think that anything he said would make any great change in the Corporation's plans. But Campbell-Johnson is in very close touch with the B.B.C.’s head man out here, Stimson,Footnote 713 and I am sure that in the end we shall be able to get the right slant on things.
3. I will certainly tell Nehru about the luncheon party you are arranging for Krishna Menon on the 5th August. I see, however, that Krishna Menon has been instructed to handle India's case on behalf of Indonesia before the Security Council of U.N.O. and I am wondering whether this will now make some alteration to your arrangements, and may indeed result in Krishna Menon being away from London on the 15th August, when he should be taking over as High Commissioner.
4. In paragraphs 16 to 18 of your letter of the 20th June you dealt with the case of civilian ex-service clerks serving in G.H.Q.(I). Ismay tells me that he conveyed to you while he was in London my strong conviction that these clerks are entitled to special consideration in the matter of entitlement to compensation. I have since had a further talk with Auchinleck, who feels as strongly as I do that it would be most unjust to these men to deny them compensation. For reasons which Ismay gave you their case can be distinguished from that of others employed by the Government of India or Provincial Governments. I trust, even at this late stage, that you have found it possible to reopen the case.
5. Your predecessor in paragraphs 5 to 10 of his letter of the 9th May, 1947 referred to possible future employment for police officers. With reference to paragraph 8 of that letter, I wonder if you can give me any further information regarding their future prospects, particularly in the business world.
6. I have told both Nehru and Jinnah of Lord and Lady Addison's plans for passing through India on the way to the Conference in Canberra.Footnote 714 Jinnah has asked me to say that he would welcome seeing Lord and Lady Addison at Karachi both on the 18th August and on the 27th October. Nehru also expressed great pleasure at the prospect of this visit and in response to his suggestion I am getting in touch with Rajagopalachari, to see whether on the outward journey the latter will be able to put up Lord and Lady Addison in Calcutta.
7. I asked Nehru whether he himself could attend the Conference in Canberra, or send a high level representative. He told me he intended sending Mr. Rama Rau,Footnote 715 who had gone as Indian Ambassador to Tokyo, and that he would probably give him a subordinate official from Delhi to put him in the picture. I urged that he should send one of his Cabinet Ministers from Delhi to such an important Conference, and be agreed he would have liked to do so, but for the fact that it would mean leaving within a day or two of the formation of the new Government, when nobody would have got a grip of their new portfolios, or of the situation.
Yours sincerely,
Mountbatten of Burma
22 Listowel to Mountbatten, 2 August 1947
Thank you for your letter of 25th July enclosing Personal Report No. 14.
2. I very much hope that within the next two or three days it will be possible to issue the announcement about the formal appointments of yourself and Jinnah as Governors-General and about the appointments of Governors. To-day's reference in ‘The Times’ to the intention of the Constituent Assembly to meet at midnight on 14th/15th August and, as their first act, invite you to be Governor-General of the Dominion of India, about which I have telegraphed to you, is rather disconcerting but I hope it can be got round. On the whole, I think that the two new dominions will get a good start so far as Governors are concerned. I must confess that the new Indian names for Governorships in India do not, with one notable exception, mean very much to me but the experience of Nye, Colville, Trivedi and Hydari should prove of inestimable value. The exception among the new Indian Governors to which I refer above is, of course, Rajagopalachari whose qualities should have ample scope in Calcutta. As for Pakistan, Cunningham will, of course, be a tower of strength. It was hardly surprising that Killearn eventually was obliged to decline Eastern Bengal and I fear that Jinnah may find it very hard to get anyone of the necessary calibre to take the job on. As regards Baluchistan, about which I telegraphed, Weightman was quite ready to travel from the North to discuss the matter with me although he was fully convinced that he ought not to take the job on.
3. I am hav[ing] some enquiries made about providing you with a ‘Dominions’ expert, but I would be misleading you if I were to hold out any concrete hopes at this stage of being able to meet your need.
4. In paragraph 16 of your letter you refer to the terms being offered to I.M.S. Officers on appointment to the Colonial Medical Service. I understand the position to be that the Colonial Office are prepared to recognise in full, for purposes of seniority,‘war’ service performed by I.M.S. Officers but to give only three months seniority for every year of peacetime service. The I.M.S. officer going into the medical services of the Armed Forces, on the other hand, is able to count his full I.M.S. Service for purposes of seniority. I am considering taking this matter up with the Colonial Secretary personally.
5. I much appreciated what you said in paragraph 17 of your letter about the passing of the Indian Independence Act and I feel sure that all the officials and ministers concerned, to whom I have passed on your message, will appreciate it equally.
6. I must confess to having some doubts about the line which you took at your meeting with the delegation from Kalat on 19th July. The treaties of 1854 and 1876 do not lead to the inference that Kalat is an independent and sovereign state and it has, in fact, always been regarded as an Indian state. It figures as such in Part 2 of the First Schedule of the Government in India Act, 1935, and I have no doubt that, as a matter of law, Section 7 (1) (b) of the Indian Independence Act applies to our treaties with it. Consequently the leased areas lapse to Kalat and the future is a matter for negotiation between the State and Pakistan. We have been at pains in Parliament to discourage claims by States to be regarded as separate international entities and to accept such a claim by Kalat will surely encourage other States to press similar claims. There is, moreover, particular danger in admitting such claims by frontier States since it is easier for them to make their independence effective. Apart from the risk to the integrity of India and Pakistan, the emergency of new weak international entities is undesirable. It seems to me, therefore, that any possible simplification of the problem of the areas leased by Kalat is outweighed by the general considerations set out above.
7. I was greatly interested in your account of your talk with the Dewan of Travancore and of your further talk with the Hyderabad Delegation on its return from seeing the Nizam. C.P. Ramaswami Aiyyar is, by all accounts, a past master in verbal diplomacy, and I congratulate you on having brought him to admit openly the danger to Travancore of pursuing a policy of independence. The Nizam is, no doubt, a very different proposition, since he is an incalculable creature and may not be wholly susceptible to reasoned arguments in this matter. If however, what appears in a press message from Hyderabad in today's Times is well-founded, your efforts with both these States have been crowned with success and they have agreed to treat for accession to the Union of India.
8. I have telegraphed to you some comments on the speech you made on 25th July to the representatives of the States. It is still not altogether clear to me how the States can, in fact, be expected to complete by the 15th August the process of adherence to the constitution of India, even if this is limited to three subjects. The draft Instrument of Accession of which you sent a copy, would seem to open up various questions, such as the method of administration of the federal subjects in the States, which would require their careful examination. No doubt also there may be hesitation among the British-Indian negotiators about accepting a reservation, such as you discussed with the Dewan of Travancore, of the right to secede in the event of the Union of India leaving the Commonwealth. I had myself rather expected that the most that could be achieved before the 15th August would be an agreement on the part of the Union of India authorities to extend external protection to the States which were in process of negotiating terms of accession. The conclusion of the Instrument of Accession must surely be dependent on the constitution having been so amended as formally to provide for the admission of Indian States, and a completed constitution might contain other elements which would affect the States, notwithstanding their accession being limited in terms of external affairs, defence and communications. If, therefore, in the long run it is found impossible to secure the final accession of the key States you mention before 15th August. I think we shall feel well satisfied if these and the rest agree to be represented internationally for the time being by the appropriate Dominions while the negotiations are in process of completion, and I should hope that Patel would prove reasonable on such an accommodation, which would not be at variance with paragraph 5 of the Cabinet Mission's Statement of 12th May 1946. Such an arrangement, together with the standstill arrangement in economic and financial matters provided for in Section 7 of the Indian Independence Act, would relieve us of responsibility for the States while acquitting us of any charge of having exercised undue pressure on them to enter the new Dominions on terms against their better interests.
9. Pakistan clearly has a much simpler problem in dealing with the small number of States adjacent to its territory, and individual negotiations with each of these is clearly possible. No doubt Kashmir will claim as a price of accession acceptance by Pakistan of the existing customs arrangement whereby it imports goods from abroad free of duty. I shall be most interested to hear how the negotiations with the States progress, and we shall be asking Shone and Grafftey-SmithFootnote 716 to keep us informed after the 15th August, more especially since Parliamentary interest in this matter is still keen.
10. I am sorry I troubled you unnecessarily with a reminder (telegram No. 9711) about the Resolution on the Services. The wording of the Resolution finally agreed upon is as follows:
… That this House, on the occasion of the transfer to Indian hands of the responsibility for the affairs of India, wishes to place upon record its profound appreciation of the ability and devotion with which, during the long period of British rule, the Civil and Military Services of the Crown in India have served India and its peoples.
I understand that the Prime Minister is now exploring the possibility of associating the Opposition parties with the Resolution, which will be moved and voted in both Houses before Parliament rises at the end of next week.
11. I was, of course, interested in the report of the Union Constitution Committee of the Constituent Assembly presented by Nehru on 21st July. At this end the emphasis in the report on the objective of a sovereign independent republic strikes a somewhat incongruous note at this moment and it seemed possible that it might give rise to some awkward questions in Parliament seeing that the Indian Independence Act had been passed at unprecedented speed on the basis of dominion status. However, the report has had no awkward repercussions here so far.
12. I was interested in the reference in Dow'sFootnote 717 fortnightly letter (D-O.No. 156-GB) to the possibility of a reunion of Bihar with Western Bengal. No doubt this is the right long-term solution. The coalfields and other material assets in Bihar, for example, the very important Ansansol Railway junction, would greatly help stimulate the prosperity of Calcutta and Patna would be able to revert to its former and natural obscurity but the amalgamation would put a lot of local politicians in Bihar out of business and is hardly likely to appeal to the Congress High Command as an immediate measure.
13. It is clear that between now and August 15th Ministers here will be deluged with requests of one kind or another for ‘messages’ for publication on 15th August. I think the best solution will be for a single message to be sent from His Majesty's Government to the Governments of the two new Dominions and that all other requests for messages should be declined. In this connection I have seen a telegram from Canada saying that the Canadian High Commissioner at Delhi has arranged with the Government of India that, since the posts of Prime Minister ‘are still in the air’, messages for the two new dominions should be sent, not from Prime Minister to Prime Minister, but from Minister of External Affairs to the two Ministers of External Affairs and Commonwealth Relations at Delhi and Karachi. I should be very grateful if you would confirm by telegram that this is, in fact, the position and that H.M.G.’s message should, therefore, go from the Secretary of State for Commonwealth Relations to his opposite numbers in the two new dominions.
14. Linlithgow called to see CarterFootnote 718 this morning and mentioned, among other things, that there are some pictures, including Zoffany portraits, which Queen Mary lent to Viceroy's House. Linlithgow (who is, I believe, one of Queen Mary's trustees) suggested that something ought perhaps to be done about these pictures before 15th August but that, so far as he was aware, the matter had not yet been mentioned to Queen Mary. You will no doubt wish to consider whether anything should be done about this.
15. I am very glad you have been able to pay a visit to Bengal as I feel sure that your presence in Calcutta at this time will have had a heartening effect in political and administrative circles and a reassuring effect on the population.
Listowel
23 Mountbatten to Listowel, 8 August 1947
Dear Listowel,
Thank you for your letter of the 2nd August. Amongst the points that you mention is the question whether or not Kalat is legally an Indian State. On this point I have always been very careful not to commit myself personally. It has been made quite clear that it is only Kalat itself and the Pakistan Government which consider, for the purposes of negotiation, that Kalat is not an Indian State. In this week's Personal Report I give an account of my latest meeting with the Khan of Kalat.Footnote 719
2. I enclose the draft communiquéFootnote 720 which was agreed in principle between Jinnah, the Khan and myself, but with the words underlined (which Jinnah wishes included and the Khan does not wish included) still a matter of negotiation between the three of us – unfortunately by letter as Jinnah and His Highness have now left Delhi.
3. I was invited by the Khan of Kalat to add to the communiqué that I also recognised he was an independent sovereign ruler. I replied that so far as H.M.G. were concerned they considered Kalat to be an Indian State, but since the two interested parties both agree I did not propose to interfere with this agreement.
4. I have been sent by the Maharaja of SikkimFootnote 721 a memorandum regarding the cession of Darjeeling. I have not yet received the advice of the External Affairs Department on this memorandum, but I enclose a copy of it for your information.Footnote 722
5. On the issues raised in my speech to the Chamber of Princes, we have already exchanged telegrams. But I feel that, especially with regard to your mention of this in your letter of 2nd August, I should somewhat elaborate my view-point, and am addressing a separate letter on this subject to you.
6. In my last week's Report, I referred to the continued rumours that the Sikhs were likely to make trouble after the Boundary Commission's award has been announced. On 5th August, Jenkins sent down a Police Officer with a verbal report. I took advantage of the fact that there was a Partition Council Meeting the morning he arrived to keep back Mr. Jinnah, Mr. Liaquat Ali Khan and Sardar Patel so that they could hear what he had to say. This Police Officer is a member of the Punjab C.I.D. Control Staff, which coordinates investigation of disturbances cases, special interrogation and intelligence from all sources. He gave an account of the statements which had been made by various instigators of disturbances who had been arrested after incidents. The man who had given away most information was an ex-member of the I.N.A. [Indian National Army],Footnote 723 and had during the war been at the Japanese spy school at Penang and sent to India by submarine. This man's statement involved Master Tara SinghFootnote 724 in the production of bombs and a Sikh plan to attack a certain headworks. Statements of other men who had been arrested involved Tara Singh in plans to wreck the trains carrying the Pakistan Governmental staff from Delhi to Karachi and in plans to assassinate Mr. Jinnah during the celebrations in Karachi on 15th August. The evidence produced was so incriminating that Jenkins may have to arrest Tara Singh and the more hot-headed of his confederates shortly before 15th August.
7. I have recently been in communication with Wylie concerning the future of the [1857 Indian] Mutiny Memorials in the U.P. It is a matter on which the Metropolitan of India,Footnote 725 who was staying with me last week, is much concerned. Wylie has suggested –
(a) The Residency at Lucknow. This should continue under the present arrangements whereby the proprietory rights vest in the Defence Department (who bear the cost of maintenance) and the management is entrusted to a small Committee of which the Area Commander is Chairman;
(b) The Memorial Well and Gardens at Cawnpore. These are the property of a regular Trust composed of European business men. They have agreed to offer 30 acres of the site to the Municipality free of cost on condition that it should be kept for ever as a space and not be built upon. They are considering Wylie's suggestion that the remaining 10 acres, including the Well and the Graveyard, should be enclosed and handed over to the Allahabad Diocese Trust; but may prefer to go on managing the Well and Graveyard area themselves.
(c) The Massacre Ghat at Cawnpore. The Cross on this is not a conspicuous object and Wylie is inclined to leave it alone.
These suggestions seem to me to be sound and I propose to tell Wylie when he comes to pay me his farewell visit tomorrow that I agree with him.
8. The Maharaja of BundiFootnote 726 (a gallant young soldier who won the M.C. under me in the 14th Army) is an Honorary A.D.C. to the King, and most anxious to be invited to attend Princess Elizabeth's wedding.Footnote 727 The other three Honorary A.D.Cs. I believe are the Maharajas of PatialaFootnote 728 and KolhapurFootnote 729 and the Nawab of Bhopal. Not more than one or two of these would be likely to attend if they received invitations, so the total number would be unlikely to exceed three. It would, I feel, be an excellent thing if His Majesty could see his way to issuing invitations to them.
9. I also hope that Dominion Prime Ministers will be invited, for it would be a great thing if we could get Nehru to come to London at such a time of national rejoicing. As I have been invited I could bring him with me in our York [aeroplane]. He is an inveterate sentimentalist, and I feel it would greatly help to strengthen Anglo-Indian bonds if he went. It would also give him an opportunity of meeting the other Dominion Prime Ministers.
Yours sincerely,
Mountbatten of Burma
24 Listowel to Mountbatten, 9 August 1947
Thank you for your letter of 1st August enclosing Personal Report No. 15. As this is the last weekly letter I shall be sending you I should like to say (and I know that all my colleagues (both Ministers and officials) would agree with me) how immensely valuable and enthrallingly interesting your weekly Personal Reports have been. They have gone a long way towards eliminating the effects of distance and have enabled us here to appreciate the atmosphere in Delhi to a degree which has enormously assisted us in carrying out our part in the events of the past months. I would like also, if I may be allowed to, to commend the drafting of the reports which has combined lucidity with graphic description in a high degree. Such touches as paragraph 56 of Report No. 15 have, moreover, served to reassure us that pressure of work has not impaired the detachment and sense of humour of yourself and your staff.
2. As this will be my last letter to you, I must also endeavour to tidy up any loose ends from our previous correspondence. Thus in paragraphs 3 and 4 of your letter of 10th July you referred to the question of appeals to the Privy Council after the transfer of power. No steps seem necessary here at this juncture for, until some contrary provision is enacted by one or both Dominions, appeals all continue to come to the Judicial Committee. We had already sounded the Lord ChancellorFootnote 730 about this question some time ago and he then held strongly that any move for cessation of appeals should come from India. It seems unnecessary to pursue the matter with him further until it is clear that one of the Dominions wishes to stop appeals to the Judicial Committee. In that event, of course, we may have to meet a desire that proceedings pending before the Judicial Committee should be continued to judgement and, to secure this, it might well be expedient to have a clause in a Treaty providing for the continuance of the Judicial Committee's jurisdiction in respect of those proceedings which could be implemented by legislation if necessary at both ends.
3. I was interested in what you said in paragraph 3 of your letter of 25th July about some looser form of association within the British Commonwealth to meet the case of Burma and perhaps later on of India. I can assure you that the wider implications and possibilities are not being overlooked and that some hard thinking is being done at this end on the question. But the problem of devising a form of association which is even looser than that at present binding the Dominions and which is yet not entirely meaningless or indeed, in the absence of a real measure of common purpose and interest, even dishonest, is no easy one. And the reactions of, and on, existing Dominions, and more particularly Dominions such as S.[outh] Africa or Canada, of any weakening of existing links are material factors. However, I agree as to the importance and urgency of the issue.
4. So far as concerns the particular and, indeed, somewhat technical aspect of citizenship to which you refer, as you probably know, following the Commonwealth Conference of experts earlier this year, a scheme is now being worked out by the various Commonwealth Governments which would give the U.K. and each Dominion its own citizenship.Footnote 731 The possession of one of these citizenships would be the only gateway to the status of British subject, which would remain a common status with, it is to be hoped, common privileges in each of the Commonwealth countries. From some points of view the creation of separate citizenships ought to help towards that form of association within the Commonwealth which you have in mind. In another sense, however, to hanker after any form of common citizenship is swimming against the stream. In any case the status of [a] British subject will remain a common status, though in the last analysis it will now, more than ever, mean simply a common allegiance to the Crown. And there, I take it, we are back at our starting-point.
5. In paragraph 4 of your letter of 25th July you said that you supposed that there was no chance of persuading the new Government of Burma to give dominion status a trial. I am afraid that the effect of the assassinations will have been rather to accentuate the feeling of the leaders who have survived that, whatever their own predilections, their position vis-à-vis the rank and file of their supporters is not strong enough to make it possible for them to give a lead in the direction of remaining within the Commonwealth. It has to be recognised, too, that the suspicion (which, I regret to have to say, is not entirely unfounded) that the assassinations were due in some measure to acts of commission or omission on the part of members of the British Services, is another factor inevitably tending to reinforce the urge to ‘cut the painter’.
6. It has taken much longer than we hoped to settle up the question of compensation for the Burma Services. We now expect, however, to be able to make an announcement in Parliament before the Adjournment (which, for domestic reasons, has had to be postponed until the middle of next week) and to lay a White Paper.
7. I am sorry that I have not yet got any news for you on the subject of a ‘Dominions’ expert but if, rather contrary to my expectation, it proves possible to help you, Carter will communicate with Ismay on the matter.
8. I am afraid I am still not in a position to comment on Rajendra Prasad's letter which was referred to in paragraph 14 of your letter of 25th July but which was inadvertently omitted from that letter and has only recently reached me. The questions raised in it affect at least three Government Departments here and the matter will take a little time to investigate. It is hoped to communicate on the subject with the U.K. High Commissioner in the Dominion of India in due course.
9. I am not surprised at what you say in paragraph 2[?] of your Personal Report No. 14 about the desire of the Princes not to be cut off from future intimate and honorific relations with His Majesty. The Princes’ own feeling is natural enough but the reactions of Patel and his forecast of the attitude of the future Government of India are unexpected and, as you say, welcome.
10. As regards the future treatment of the Princes, we feel here that they cannot expect their existing personal relations with the Crown to continue on the same basis otherwise than within the Commonwealth and through the new Dominion Governments. Time alone will show how these will work out. It is, of course, agreed that the fact that Indian Orders are to remain in suspended animation does not preclude the grant of honours by The King to Indian Princes in the future should the Dominion Governments recommend such a course. Therefore the way remains open for the bestowal of decorations.
11. As regards other honours such as appointments as Honorary Aides-de-Camp to The King and Honorary Ranks in the British Army, the present position as we see it can remain undisturbed. There is no idea cancelling existing appointments
12. The appointments of Honorary Aides-de-Camp to The King, since they are so limited in number are very highly prized. Unless any individual Prince took it upon himself to relinquish his appointment, it is not proposed to suggest to His Majesty that He should take any initiative in the matter. On the other hand it seems doubtful whether any new appointments need be made, should a vacancy occur by the death of an Honorary A.D.C. to The King.
13. The same applies to Honorary Ranks in the British Army which will be retained, though no new appointments or promotions would of course be made save on the recommendation of the Dominion Governments. I am not sure, however, that these may not wish future grants of honorary rank to be in their own Forces.
14. Possibly you will think it desirable to say something about this to Jinnah, though the Muslim League attitude towards Honours for Princes may not correspond with that of Patel.
15. Fortunately, Krishna Menon did not have to go to New York and was able to be present at the Luncheon which I arranged for 5th August and which proved a very successful occasion. Apart from Henderson and Pethick-Lawrence I invited R.A. Butler, Godfrey Nicholson,Footnote 732 Samuel and Hopkin-Morris.Footnote 733 I am sorry to say that a certain amount of opposition to Menon's appointment is showing itself here, more particularly in Indian circles in London. Menon certainly has a past to live down, but we will do all we possibly can to help him establish his position.
16. You revert again, in paragraph 4 of your letter of 1st August to the case of the civilian ex-service clerks serving in [unclear] I hope you appreciate that I entirely recognise that theirs is a very hard case, but the old adage about hard cases and bad law remains true. And I concur in the unanimous opinion of my Department, that a concession in this case, however much one may be tempted to make it on compassionate grounds, would make a dangerous breach in the general principles upon which these matters have been settled.
17. In paragraph 5 of your letter of 1st August you asked for further information about the prospects of obtaining employment for officers of the Indian Police, particularly in business. I am afraid that, as we all expected, this problem continues to be the most difficult of those falling to the Re-employment Branch here and it would be wrong to minimise the very great obstacles which lie in the way of an entirely satisfactory solution.
18. You may have heard that, when Linlithgow was the guest of honour at a recent Police dinner in London, he suggested that it was probably in the best interest of many of those present to continue in service in India or Pakistan, so doubtful were the prospects of finding a satisfactory alternative career in business in the U.K. I understand that his remarks created a deep impression and the decision of certain Provinces not to retain the services of any Police officers must, therefore, be all the more disappointing to those who are prepared to stay on.
19. As I have said before, we cannot know how things will work out for the Police until the men concerned are actually in the U.K. All we can do is to make sure that the ground is properly prepared and I am satisfied that this has now been done. The India and Burma Services Section mentioned in paragraph 9 of my letter of 9th May is now on the point of being set up in the London Appointments Office of the Ministry of Labour and will, from approximately August 15th, be in charge of the officer mentioned in paragraph 6 of the same letter. He will be joined later by an I.C.S. officer. The Section will receive first-hand information about the vacancies notified by employers to the Ministry and will be able to submit direct for consideration the names of suitable Indian Service candidates.
20. I am also glad to be able to tell you that Hailey has now formed his unofficial CommitteeFootnote 734 and the Committee has had its first meeting. As you may know, Hailey himself is about to undertake a tour on behalf of the Colonial Office and Anderson has agreed to act as Chairman in his place; the other members of the Committee are Linlithgow, Catto,Footnote 735 Scarbrough, Hailey himself, R.A. Butler, Woodrow WyattFootnote 736 and Alexander Murray. It has been decided to address a circular letter (which will be signed by Anderson personally) to a large number of firms and business concerns, public corporations and academic bodies, explaining our case in detail and asking for their help.
21. I know that the Services are assured of very great good-will and sympathy on the part of the members of this Committee and that they are determined to do everything possible to make sure that the claims of officers appointed by the Secretary of State receive the maximum consideration from business firms. Nevertheless, I do not think that, the present economic position being what it is, they would care to commit themselves as to the extent to which it will be possible to secure appointments. I understand that, at the first meeting, general agreement was expressed with Linlithgow's view, that officers who had the ability, the opportunity and the desire to continue in service in India should be encouraged to do so.
22. It was also suggested, that some kind of central agency might be established in India to investigate further the opportunities of employment there. We shall be glad to know whether anything has been considered on these lines and, if not, whether it is considered that such an organisation should now be established.
23. I hope that I have not painted too bleak a picture in the preceding paragraphs. So far as the I.C.S. and (to a lesser extent) the Technical Services are concerned, we are encouraged by the ease with which men of average or greater ability in the critical age groups have already been able to find themselves satisfactory alternative careers. It is in relation to the less able officers of the I.C.S. and to the main body of the Police in the critical age groups that we are still not content. I have already suggested to you that it may be wise to encourage many of these younger Police officers officers to train themselves entirely for a fresh career (using, if necessary, some of their compensation for this purpose); no doubt we shall be able to arrange for those of them who wish to do so to enter a university,
24. To complete the picture I should add that the Re-employment Branch in this Office will remain in being until the cases of all officers who are applicants for any form of permanent Government employment have been completed. It will also continue to act as a co-ordinating agency.
25. It is very good of you to have done so much to try and arrange a pleasant and interesting passage through India for Addison and Cripps. I am sorry that Addison's schedule will not make it possible for him to meet anyone in India but he hopes to stay with Rance in Rangoon. I am very glad that Cripps will be spending a day with you in Delhi after you have had about ten days experience of your new office; he will no doubt be able to tell us much of interest on his return.
26. It is a pity that none of Jinnah's high level choices for the governorship of East Bengal have materialised but the temporary appointment of BourneFootnote 737 should give more time for the right selection to be made. It is encouraging to read in paragraph 11 of Personal Report No. 15 of the progress being made with the establishment of the new capital at Dacca. The provision of suitable accommodation for the Governor seems a necessary condition of obtaining a man of the necessary calibre for the post.
27. Your account in Personal Report N.15 of your dealings with Nehru, Patel and Gandhi over Nehru's emotional urge to visit Kashmir is illuminating, if somewhat disturbing. Clearly, Gandhi will have a safe passage in Kashmir, even though the MaharajaFootnote 738 finds himself bound to join Pakistan. The realistic attitude of Patel is a great asset to the Congress Party but one cannot suppose that it will be possible for all time to prevent an open clash between such differing temperaments.
28. What you say in paragraph 34 of the same report about the readiness of both Nehru and Jinnah to receive the Chiefs of Staff or high powered representatives of them for discussions with the Joint Defence Council is most encouraging. I will see that the Chiefs of Staff are informed.
29. Your first and last contact with the Chamber of Princes seems to have been a fairly exhausting experience. No doubt the Rulers and Dewans of the bigger states are most of them capable of appreciating the great risks they run in attempting to hold aloof from the Dominion of India. They will have had time to appreciate that they cannot count on active support from the outside world in staking out a claim to independence. We are full of admiration at your success in having overcome the hesitations of so many States about acceptance of the terms of accession offered by Patel. To do them justice, the States have had little reason up to now to assume that the Congress and their friends have any intention of offering them a square deal. Their experiences while Congress was in power in the Provinces before the war and Nehru's repeated abuse of their Governments since he came into power have at least given cause for their adopting an attitude of caution about throwing in their lot for good and all with the Dominion of India. However, having come to realise their weakness if they attempt to stand alone and the growing sympathies of their subjects with the more progressive elements in British India, the more enlightened Rulers and their Ministers seem to have at last accepted the inevitable. I am sorry to hear that C.P. Ramaswami Aiyyer should have been so severely mauled on his return to Travancore, but no doubt his going out of business at any rate temporarily has had the valuable effect of deciding the Maharaja to call off his bid for independence.
30. The personal equation seems for the time being to have dictated the choice of Bhopal, IndoreFootnote 739 and Dholpur.Footnote 740 If your own diplomacy succeeds in persuading them to throw in their lot with their brother Rulers, you will have achieved something which we at this end would not have thought possible a few weeks ago. Even so, there still remains the problem of Hyderabad and its most unaccountable Ruler. It still seems to me that in the case of this State Patel could afford to accept an interim political arrangement of the kind I referred to in paragraph 8 of my letter of 2nd August. So many considerations are necessarily involved in acceding to a constitution which has yet to be finalised, even for the limited range of subjects in question, that I cannot withhold some sympathy from the Nizam in being told that he has to make up his mind to sign on the dotted line by 15th August. However, by the time this letter reaches you it may well be that your efforts and those of MoncktonFootnote 741 will have prevailed against the pressure brought to bear on the Nizam by his Muslim subjects, without it being necessary for the Dominion Government to grant him a locus poenitentiae.Footnote 742
31. With reference to paragraph 54 of Personal Report No. 15, one cannot but regret on grounds of principle that the remaining I.N.A. prisoners will appear to have had their brutality condoned but, taking all in all, the arrangement now proposed for dealing with them is probably the most satisfactory one possible. At the same time it does seem important that the scheme should be put into effect as inconspicuously as possible, and that great care should be exercised to prevent publicity, which might have a serious effect on the morale of the army.
32. You will no doubt like to know how things are shaping administratively here. On 15th August the appointment of Arthur Henderson as Minister of State for Commonwealth Relations will be announced. It will be announced at the same time that the staff of the India Office will be amalgamated with that of the Commonwealth Relations Office and that Carter will serve as a Joint Permanent Under-Secretary of State for Commonwealth Relations. It has been arranged that as soon as possible after the 15th August Henderson, the Under Secretaries and nuclei of certain of the key departments of the India Office should move from their present accommodation into rooms in the Colonial Office building (immediately adjoining the Commonwealth Relations Office) which are being evacuated by the Colonial Office and were to have been taken over by the Foreign Office. It is very difficult to see how things will work out in practice but this move should help accelerate the process of integrating the two departments. You may also like to know that, with the same object in view, we plan to hold a social party for the staff of both Offices towards the end of September when the leave season is over.
33. I have agreed to receive next week a deputation from the Indian Police Association and the newly formed Indian Government Officers (Retired) Association. In order not to raise false expectations it has been made clear to both bodies at meetings with officials that there is really nothing more that can be done for the Services than has already been done, but I felt that it would be unfortunate to resist pressure that I should receive a deputation. The point on which the Indian Police Association are particularly keen to speak is the question of the increase of police pensions which, leaving aside any question of merits, is politically, of course, quite out of the question at the present juncture.
34. The Resolution on the Services quoted in paragraph 10 of my letter of 2nd August was moved in both Houses yesterday. In the Lords there were eloquent speeches by Bobbety Salisbury on behalf of the Conservatives, and by ReadingFootnote 743 on behalf of the Liberals. The Bishop of Salisbury,Footnote 744 Chetwode,Footnote 745 and Hailey also spoke. In the Commons, where the Prime Minister, Eden and Clement Davies spoke, the names of Churchill and Eden were associated with those of Ministers in sponsoring the resolution. I hope these resolutions will give satisfaction to the members of the Services, who will no longer entertain the slightest doubt about the whole-hearted appreciation of Parliament.
35. I have seen the copy of Spens'sFootnote 746 letter to you of July 21st which Abell sent to Harris. It was only natural that the Judges should feel impatient over the delay which occurred in informing them how they stand in the new constitutional situation: and I am glad to note from your telegram No. 2957 of July 26th that a communication has now been made to them. This telegram also formed the basis of Henderson's reply to a Question in the Commons by Niall MacphersonFootnote 747 on August 4th.
36. I was grateful for your telegram No. 3200-S about the proposed messages to India and Pakistan on the 15th August. The messages will be sent to the U.K. High Commissioners with the request that they may be passed to the Prime Ministers of India and Pakistan respectively. The draft of the messages at present runs as follows:
My colleagues in the United Kingdom Government join with me in sending on this historic day greetings and good wishes to the Government and people of India/Pakistan from the people of the United Kingdom. It is our earnest wish that India/Pakistan may work out its destiny as a free country in tranquillity and prosperity and, in so doing, make its full contribution to world peace and progress.
37. It seems at the moment as if the Government of India will have reason to be pleased with the terms of the agreement on sterling balances, which were far more satisfactory than I had dared to hope. Not unnaturally, it seemed at one moment as if the terms of the projected agreement might have to be modified to India's disadvantage in view of the coincidence of the negotiations with the economic ‘crisis’ in this country, but it now seems certain that this will not happen.
38. I telegraphed to you recently about difficulties which had arisen over the embarkation of the exhibits for the Exhibition of Indian Art and I am very glad to hear through the Royal Academy that you have managed to smooth over these difficulties and that shipment is now taking place as arranged.
39. I am enclosing copy of a letterFootnote 748 from the Royal Academy in which they convey what I am sure will be good news to you, namely that the Prime Minister has agreed to be President of the Exhibition. The Royal Academy and the Committee of the Exhibition also ask me to convey to you as Governor-General of India, and to the Governor-General of Pakistan, the High Commissioner for India and the High Commissioner for Pakistan, their invitation to be Honorary Presidents of the Exhibition. I would be most grateful if you would accept the invitation to you as Governor-General of India, and would have transmitted to Jinnah, Krishna Menon and RahimtoolaFootnote 749 the invitations to them. It seems better that these should be communicated through you than from this Office.
40. The Academy have, I think, rightly raised the question whether the title of the Exhibition requires alteration with the coming into existence of Pakistan as a separate Dominion. I do not know whether you would feel justified in asking Jinnah whether, for reasons of convenience, he would be prepared to support retention of the existing title. If not, I would propose advising the Academy that the title might be amended to ‘‘Exhibition of Art of India and Pakistan’’. It would be a great help if you could let me know by telegram before the date of the transfer of power what you think about this.
41. I cannot end this, my last weekly letter, without paying a tribute to all that you and your staff have achieved in the few months since you left for Delhi. When one considers the intractability of the problems, great and small, requiring to be solved, the intensity and bitterness of feeling between the major communities affected and the sheer weight of the work to be got through, one realises the magnitude of what has been achieved by you and your staff. The Indian leaders and officials, civil and military, whose share in the process of transferring power has been indispensable, have made a remarkable contribution to the settlement. It must be with a sense of great relief that you see 15th August approaching and yet relief not untinged with regret at the ending of a great chapter and of concern at the thought of the unchartered seas that lie ahead.
Listowel
25 Mountbatten to Listowel, 16 August 1947
My dear Listowel,Footnote 750
Thank you for your last weekly letter, dated 9th August. Although I understand you will have relinquished office as Secretary of State officially on the 15th August, I am addressing this letter to you in order that you may decide how the various outstanding points may be dealt with.
2. You asked in paragraph 10 of your letter of 25th July that I should use my influence to persuade the Central and Provincial Governments to reconsider their attitude on the question of applying the Pensions (Increase) Act 1947 to pensioners of Indian Services in the U.K.
3. I spoke to Rajagopalachari, while he was still Finance Member, and to Liaquat Ali Khan, but I am afraid it is doubtful whether they will agree as there is a good deal of feeling against increasing liabilities by way of pensions, etc. in any form. The matter will, however, be carefully examined.
4. I am sorry that Nehru made his rather embarrassing request to allow Sir N.R. Pillai,Footnote 751 Mr. K.P.S. MenonFootnote 752 and Mr. K.K. ChetturFootnote 753 to receive certain Peruvian Orders without letting me know. After I received your telegram of 26th July, however, I made enquiries and found that Nehru himself was by no means happy about the telegram which had gone to you. A letter from my Secretary to the Department, pointing out that the grant of restricted permission to receive these Orders would be at variance with the practice followed by His Majesty's Government, and that it might be difficult to explain to His Majesty why Indian officials should be permitted to accept Orders from a foreign Head of State while declining to accept them from him, gave Nehru the opportunity he needed to withdraw the request. I understand that considerable pressure had been put upon Nehru to make the original request and he was glad of an excuse to withdraw it.
5. In my last weekly report (paragraph 43) I stated that I was sending to Mr. Jinnah a bowdlerized version of a paper, prepared by General Messervey [sic],Footnote 754 on the problems facing the Pakistan Army. In fact, I later discovered that General Messervey himself had sent Mr. Jinnah a copy of his own paper; and so my version was never despatched.
6. Thank you for the memorandum on the North-West Tribal Area and Afghanistan which you sent with your letter of August 1st. I discussed it with Cunningham on his way to Peshawar. We agreed that the present is not an appropriate time for me to open this matter with the Political Leaders.
7. There is nothing in the Frontier situation which made it necessary for me to speak of it before the 15th August, particularly since Mr. Jinnah made it clear in a statement to the Press on the 31st July that tribal allowances, etc., will be continued after the 15th August until the Pakistan Government can negotiate new agreements with the Tribes, and that control in the Political Agencies would be continued as at present.
8. I am sure it is necessary that the new Governments in Pakistan and India should start to function, and begin to feel the impact of events before they can shape their foreign policy.
9. Opportunity will undoubtedly occur in the next few months for consultation between the Pakistan Government and Afghanistan, and also H.M.G's representatives, about the Frontier policy. At the moment the Government of India are disinclined to own to any interest in the Frontier, and disclaim any responsibility for its affairs or defence. This attitude will, I hope, mellow as time goes on, and I trust that India, and more particularly, Pakistan, will come to appreciate the need for a common policy in this region, and will welcome the interest and support of H.M.G. in carrying it out. I would suggest that background should be given to both the U.K. High Commissioners and they be instructed to pursue the matter as opportunity offers in the next few months.
10. The communiqué on the negotiations between Kalat and Pakistan, a draft of which I attached to my last letter, was published on 11th August, with the following amendments. Paragraph 1 should read : –
The Government of Pakistan recognises Kalat as an independent sovereign State in treaty relations with the British Government, with a status different from that of Indian States.
In paragraph 2, the words ‘treaties and’ should be omitted.
11. I have referred, in paragraphs 1 and 2 of the attached Report, to the awards of the Boundary Commissions. I do not, however, think that these would be of sufficient interest to all the recipients of the ‘V.P.R.’ I am, therefore, sending you copies of these awards as Appendices I, II and III to this letter.
12. In paragraph 41 of my last Personal Report I mentioned that Ismay had made a statement to the Joint Defence Council about his conversations with the Chiefs of Staff in England, and it occurs to me that the Chiefs of Staff might wish to know what he said. I therefore enclose (as Appendix IV) a copy of the notes from which he spoke. You will see that, in agreement with me, he dealt with the subject on very general lines and made no mention of Naval or Air bases, etc. It would have been a mistake to do so at this stage, since it would have merely frightened them off. Even as it was, the Indian Leaders did not look too happy about the future prospects, and would not commit themselves further than to say that they would examine Ismay's statement carefully and then let us have their reactions.
13. I am all in favour of the Chiefs of Staff's Mission coming as soon as possible, but I do not want them to come before the two new Governments have got over their teething troubles, have got their Defence Departments more or less organised, and have begun to know and trust their British Commanders-in-Chief. As a rough guess, I should say that a suitable target for the delegation to arrive would be about the middle of October: but I will, of course, send a firm recommendation in due course.
14. I have asked Pandit Nehru's concurrence to proceed home for about a fortnight (from about 10th–24th November) to attend the wedding of Princess Elizabeth to my nephew.Footnote 755
15. I was very touched by your kind farewell telegram and deeply appreciated the very generous remarks that you made. Abell, my late P.S.V., left to-day by air and I asked him to go and see you and give you an account of the perfectly amazing scenes which occurred on the 15th August, and which I feel demonstrate the real good feelings that now exist between the British and the Indians.
16. I realise that during these last few weeks we have had to take the bit between our teeth. It is almost impossible to describe the atmosphere in which we have been living or the strain to which everyone has been subjected. Of the six British members of the ‘operational staff’ I brought out with me, four have been in bed recently for longer or shorter periods under the doctor's care. MievilleFootnote 756 has been quite seriously ill with thrombosis; Ismay is still in bed with a very bad go of dysentery; my two ‘personal’ (naval) secretaries, who now become my ‘private’ secretaries have both been in bed, the senior one, Brockman, having had a relapse through trying to get back to work too quickly.
17. It is impossible to over-estimate the value which George Abell and his gallant ‘P.S.V.’ team (John Christie,Footnote 757 Ian ScottFootnote 758 and Peter ScottFootnote 759) have been to the ‘U.K.’ team. They had every reason for their noses to be put out of joint by the new set up, but they played up 100 per cent, and without them we could never have achieved the success which has come our way.
18. Before coming out I asked for a generous allowance of honours and I had at the back of my mind that if we made a success of this job I would like every member of my small team to receive recognition. Now that I myself (to my very great surprise) have received an Earldom, I feel it is all the more important that this recognition should be given to my staff. I will be sending in their names in the ordinary way for the Honours List, but I hope that you will be able to leave a note to the appropriate authorities that no one on my special list shall be turned down.
19. Old members of the I.C.S. out here say that never at any time has the India Office been quite so helpful, quite so quick and quite so valuable as during the last few weeks. I certainly could not have wished for any better support.
Again all my most sincere and heartfelt thanks.
Yours very sincerely,
Mountbatten of Burma
