To say that formal democracy in Venezuela faces challenges in 2017 is an understatement. President Nicolás Maduro does not hide his autocratic tendencies. The judiciary and the electoral commission are packed with government loyalists, and the opposition National Assembly, though officially extant, is so marginalised politically that it is, in fact, impotent. Critical shortages of food and medicine throughout the country have led to unnecessary deaths. The average Venezuelan, according to many reports, has lost approximately 19 lb (9 kg) in weight in the last year. In spring and summer 2017 Venezuelans took to the streets throughout the nation to protest against realities equally deplorable and undemocratic. Violence that became part of the protests claimed the lives of dozens, protestors and police. Many scholars and political observers argue that the current state of affairs, the obvious failure of formal democratic structures, represents the erosion of democracy in Venezuela. Some Venezuelan scholars, however, argue that during the Chávez years informal systems of democracy flourished. The growing and more assertive opposition to President Maduro could be interpreted through that lens. Now middle- and upper-class Venezuelans have to embrace popular and creative forms long deployed by lower classes.
Alejandro Velasco, in Barrio Rising: Urban Popular Politics and the Making of Modern Venezuela, argues that since 1959 working-class Venezuelans have been using informal political processes, independent of formal democratic electoral processes, to hold the state accountable in the social contract. In so doing, Venezuelans created a system in which informal processes, including protest, were not antagonistic to democracy but instead essential to democracy's survival. In one example, when the state did not provide waste removal service to the 23 de Enero neighbourhood and waste accumulated to dangerous levels, residents hijacked waste collection vehicles to force the state to act (pp. 173–9). Democracy as lived every day in Venezuela (and in other Latin American nations), Velasco suggests, does not look like democracy elsewhere but it is still democracy. Velasco acknowledges that analysis of participatory democracy in Venezuela is not new. Indeed, there is a rich historiography on the topic during the Chávez years including studies with a national, political focus or a culture, race and/or class focus. Velasco decided to analyse specifically the 23 de Enero barrio over a 60-year period as a symbol, a microcosm, and a petri dish consistent with extant historiography because ‘El 23’ ‘is marked … by the interplay of formal and informal structures, of dramatically differing visions of the nation's future. It reflects the history of modernizing dictatorships and democratic governments and revolutionary projects. It is a history of barrios and high-rises. It is the history of a neighborhood, and of a nation’ (pp. 7–8).
Velasco relies on the theoretical framework provided by James Holston (Insurgent Citizenship, Princeton University Press, 2009), Brodwyn Fischer (A Poverty of Rights, Stanford University Press, 2008) and Enrique Peruzzotti and Catalina Smulovitz (Enforcing the Rule of Law, University of Pittsburgh Press, 2006) to analyse the dynamic nature of urbanisation and citizenship in Latin America as applied to El 23. Insurgent citizenship conceives of urban spaces as terrains of political opportunity, opportunities used, in Holston's words, to ‘close the gap between democracy as aspiration and democracy as lived’ (p. 12). The fragmented nature of urbanisation, planned and unplanned, requires insurgent citizens to use traditional and non-traditional methods to shape the relationship between state and society. In the end, Fischer suggests, Latin American cities broadly (and Caracas specifically) ‘are defined rather than deformed by the dynamic intersection of formal and informal urbanity’ (p. 12).
Using the above theoretical framework, Velasco's contribution to Venezuelan historiography is two-fold. First, he is one of few historians to tackle the interplay of race, class, politics and the state in the last 60 years, primarily before the Caracazo in 1989. Though the rise of Hugo Chávez is largely outside the scope of Velasco's work, Velasco implies continuity existed between the events of 1989 and those that followed. Indeed, the Caracazo and emergence of Chávez should not be interpreted as surprises in Venezuelan history, as fractures in democratic processes established after the death of Marcos Pérez Jiménez, but instead, Velasco asserts, as consistent with a Venezuelan tradition of participatory democracy, and not only formal political party-driven democracy (often called partidocracia). Second, most analyses of Venezuelan history in the latter half of the twentieth century divide the study of Venezuelan democracy into two periods, before the Caracazo and after. There is scant analysis that deals with the events of late February and early March 1989 head on. In brief, the Caracazo was the wave of violent protest and more violent repression that engulfed Caracas (with violence also in other cities) after President Carlos Andrés Pérez reneged on a campaign promise and signed a financing agreement with the International Monetary Fund. The total death toll is unknown, but estimates range up to 3,000. Velasco analyses the Caracazo, or as he suggests the many Caracazos (p. 225), through the lens of events as experienced in El 23. As he observes, the burning of vehicles, clashes between students and police and military occupation had all occurred in El 23 since the early 1960s. Even so, the scope of the violence and repression in 1989 was beyond the comprehension of the barrio's residents. Whether or not the Caracazo was a true break with past patterns of relationships became immaterial. Lower-class Venezuelans perceived that a social contract had existed between them and the state, one in part defined through electoral processes and party politics and in part through informal means of participation and protest (hijacking waste collection vehicles). Massive violent repression of legitimate protest broke that social contract. Velasco suggests that the rupture created the space necessary for the development of a new political movement (Chavismo), but one that would be defined by lower-class Venezuelans in participatory and electoral terms similar to ones used to define the social contract prior to the Caracazo. In sum, Velasco argues, the history of late twentieth-century Venezuela is better understood through revised continuities rather than irreconcilable fractures. Velasco's use of traditional historical source material is enriched by numerous interviews conducted with residents of El 23. The result is a monograph that will become essential reading in Venezuelan historiography but also one that adds depth to Latin American historiographies on urbanisation and participatory democracy.
The strength of the work is in the thorough application of theoretical ideas to the analysis of bottom-up participatory politics in the decades prior to 1989. Indeed, it is refreshing to read a work that moves away from twentieth-century Venezuelan history read through state-driven partidocracia or oil. Velasco's work grants the residents of El 23 the historical agency that any visitor to Caracas knows they have. The episode at the heart of the conclusion – debates within El 23 over primaries during elections in 2005 – demonstrates the continuity between pre-1989 politics and the twenty-first century. Far from marching lock-step behind the banner of Chavismo, as critics in and out of Venezuela suggest, the working-class poor of El 23 challenged the Chávez state and the CNE (National Electoral Commission) just as much as they challenged the pre-Chávez state. Velasco implies that the Chávez state, perhaps in part because of the agency expressed by Venezuelans, shifted frequently between embrace of participatory politics and rejection of them, between the traditional petro-state form and socialism, between nationalisation of business and industry and flirtation with foreign capital, between referendums and more autocratic forms. Velasco's conclusions seem logical within the context of the rest of the work. The frustrating gap that Velasco leaves others to fill is the 1990s, what could become the lost decade in Venezuelan historiography. It is improbable to suppose that 1989 immediately gave birth to 1998 (or 2005). It behoves other scholars to fill the hole. Velasco's work provides its own useful theoretical framework for others to follow.
