In his introduction to Desiring Arabs, Joseph Massad positions his book as a corrective to the “Orientalist” studies of culture, sexuality, and human rights in the Arab world. He first critiques Orientalist and Arab nationalist scholarship as lacking an historicized notion of culture. An historicizing approach to Arab intellectual production, Massad argues, will reveal a “civilizational” mode of thinking on the part of Arab intellectuals: that in their defense of Arab culture and civilization against Orientalism, they uncritically accepted European notions of “culture” and “civilization,” with their attendant social Darwinism and Victorian moral values. As a result, Arab intellectuals, like those of Europe, came to evaluate and categorize civilizations and cultures, including their own, according to the concepts of sex, sexuality, the norm, the natural, and the deviant. Desiring Arabs illustrates the civilizational rather than epistemological nature of this ongoing battle between Arab intellectuals and Orientalists over representation of the Arab cultural past. It does so by placing the sexual question at the center of its analysis of Arab writings from the end of the 19th to the beginning of the 21st century.
Chapters 1 and 2 establish that the sexual question and a focus on civilizational progress and worth were central to the self-representation of the Arab cultural past. Chapter 1 presents a fascinating discussion of literature (poet Abu Nuwas's ghazal in the masculine) and heritage (turāth). Chapter 2 examines nationalist, Islamist, secular, and feminist historical studies of Arab sexual life published during the second half of the 20th century. Both chapters aptly demonstrate that civilizational concerns and commitment to the telos of assimilation into the West dominate these writings, leading to pedagogical and liberatory approaches to the past in order to explain and liberate the present.
Chapter 3 focuses on Western interventionist trends outside the Arab world toward the end of the 20th century, specifically “the Gay International.” Criticizing its essentialism, ahistoricism, and Orientalism through discussion of cases such as “The Queen Boat” raid in Egypt, Massad argues that “it is the very discourse of the Gay International, which both produces homosexuals, as well as gays and lesbians, where they do not exist, and represses same-sex desires and practices that refuse to be assimilated into its sexual epistemology” (pp. 162–63). Further developing this point, Chapter 4 focuses on the increasing publication of materia sexualis on sex and sexual deviance from the early 1980s onward. Massad's examination of these writings demonstrates that European concepts that connected “sexual deviance” with civilizational progress and worth were employed by and against secularists and Islamists alike in writing about sex and that the emergence of AIDS and the influence of the Gay International led to calls for state involvement in the regulation of sex and desire in the 1980s. This further restricted the non-Western expression and practice of same-sex contact in the 1990s.
The last two chapters of the book focus on the literary representations of how desire was lived in contemporary Arab societies from the 1940s to the mid-1980s. Massad skillfully demonstrates that Arab novelists, short story writers, and playwrights developed homosexuality from a “sideshow” or an enriching detail into a political allegory and a metaphor. They eventually zeroed in on the figure of the passive homosexual as the new national subject and passive homosexuality as a central element of national decline during colonial and postcolonial modernization.
Desiring Arabs has already received critical acclaim from a number of scholars for making much-needed critical connections between Arab thought, Orientalism, Foucauldian historical studies of sexuality, and Western human rights and gay-rights discourses. Although the book certainly deserves such acclaim, its approach to sexuality, subjectivity, and sexual desire is not without problems. In covering more than a century of colonial and postcolonial developments as well as globalization in the Arab world, the book assumes cultural change is unidirectional (from the West to the East) and that Western identities necessarily replace local forms of same-sex desire and practices without any local agency affecting the process. However, this is hardly the case; current research shows, for example, that the word “gay” is being subsumed under the existing active–passive designations in some parts of the Muslim world, such as Turkey, and increasingly being applied to passive, receptive men in sexual intercourse. In addition, the totalizing, unstoppable Westernization argument in Desiring Arabs sidesteps the fact that not all men who have sex with men in the West identify as gay despite the history of gay-rights movements in North America and Europe. Massad's undifferentiating use of the label “native informants” demonstrates that there is little accounting for contemporary local queer agency in this study. Although the critique of Orientalists’ use of native informants as part of the imperialist ethnography is on target, the broadening of this category to apply to all those who “collude” with the Gay International all but obliterates contemporary Arabs’ agency regarding their sexuality. Finally, Massad's overwhelming focus on male sexual desire and practices (with some limited discussion of “sapphism”) shifts attention away from issues of gender and heterosexism, which should be central to the examination of sexual desire and practices in any cultural context.
Massad concludes Desiring Arabs by expressing a hope that
there emerges in the literature [Arab intellectuals] produced an elaboration and an occasional contestation of the place of sexual desires in wider discourses and practices of modernity. It is at these rarer moments when the imposition and seduction of Western norms fail that the possibility of different conceptions of desires, politics, and subjectivities emerges. My hope is that the critique that Desiring Arabs offers marks an instance of that possibility (p. 418).
The book makes an important contribution to cross-cultural studies of sexuality in posing this question about the possibility of, and the need for, an alternative discursive model for conceptualizing sexual desire and practices; however, Desiring Arabs ends up begging the question about existing or future acceptable non-Western forms of same-sex desire because it does not attempt to develop those “rarer moments” in the numerous Arab works examined into “different conceptions.”
This study focuses its energies on freeing the Arab and Muslim world of Orientalist and Western blame for being repressive by focusing on epistemological affinities they both share: on showing that “desiring Arabs are no different from desiring Europeans” (p. 417). Desiring Arabs certainly deserves commendation for this conclusion, since some of the current attempts to understand the Middle East further “other” and focus exclusively on Islam. For those interested in an archive of Arab intellectual history, including both nonfiction and fictional texts, and a critique of Orientalist, Western conceptions of sexual desire, Desiring Arabs will prove valuable. However, those who hope in reading the book to find an alternative, viable discursive model for thinking about same-sex desire will have to look elsewhere.
