This book is a series of essays written mostly by political theorists and philosophers on the relationship between ethics and political economy in light of the recent economic crisis and ensuing Great Recession. Some were presented at the International Society for MacIntyrean Enquiry “Virtue and Economic Crises” in Vilnius, 2010. They try to advance Alasdair MacIntyre’s neo-Aristotelian critique of capitalist modernity, especially as elaborated in his book After Virtue.
Readers of this book will find good, though repetitious, accounts of what may be called left-wing Aristotelian critiques of capitalism. Essentially, for Aristotle, the use of money to acquire more money is chrematistics, is unnatural, and leads to the vice of acquisitiveness. In a capitalist society, our emotions and desires tend to dominate our reason, leading to poor characters and a relatively impoverished life. Deception, fraud, miss-education through advertising, and unfulfilling work abound. Rather than humans’ flourishing and realizing their potentials, with work as a rational activity and consumption subservient to the good, rational life, there is a narrowing of “human life and aspiration towards fulfillment in consumption” (p. 65). Moreover, in today’s postmodern world, people are coming to accept the neoclassical model of humans and our “interest-based market relationships as an adequate depiction of any interpersonal relationship” (p. 158), rather than a theoretical simplification or caricature of the complexity of human existence, human capacities, and incommensurable virtues.
Most of the authors are content to give MacIntyre–Aristotelian-based criticisms. However, John O’Neill, in “Equality, Vulnerability and Independence,” contrasts Jean-Jacques Rousseau and Adam Smith on dependent social relations; Peter McMylor, in “No Place to Hide for the Moral Self: Bureaucratic Individualism and the Fate of Ethics in Modernity,” compares and contrasts MacIntyre and the Polish sociologist Zygmunt Bauman; Mustafa Ongun, in “Reappraising Neoliberalism: Homo Economicus, Practitioners and Practices,” discusses MacIntrye and Michel Foucault; and Niko Noponen, in “The Great Perverting Transformation,” compares MacIntrye and Karl Polanyi. There is no consensus on what should replace contemporary capitalism or how to effect the transformation. Kelvin Knight, in “Formalising Functions: The History of a Passing Challenge to Capitalist Economy,” discusses guild socialism. Russell Keat, in “Towards a Critical Ethical Economy,” favors some form of market socialism. Andrius Bielskis, one of the editors, has the last article in the collection: “Anti-Capitalist Politics and Labour for the 21st Century: History and Future Challenges.” There, he calls for the renewal of the Marxist emphasis on alienated labor and exploitation.
Piotr Machura correctly writes, “One of the tasks for contemporary Aristotelians is to work out some kind of Aristotelian economics ” (p. 166), and Keat writes that “there is some possible alternative set of economic institutions that would be normatively preferable” to contemporary capitalism (p. 193). These are profound, difficult tasks, which are not accomplished by this collection of essays. Although, I suppose, how could they? Readers interested in Aristotelian criticisms of contemporary capitalism by political theorists and philosophers, and their groping attempts to radically reform or replace it, will find this book of interest. Those wishing to read what professional economists have recently written on this same topic may want to consult Ricardo Crespo (Reference Crespo2013) and Spencer Pack (Reference Pack2010; Reference Pack2014).
The mainstream modern economic tradition more or less follows Adam Smith’s theory and emphasis on the unintended consequences of human actions, and their assumed generally benign or positive results. Aristotle and twenty-first-century Aristotelians emphasize, rather, the importance of goal-oriented, teleological, or final causes. For Aristotle and contemporary Aristotelians, things happen, or rather ought to happen, largely because humans use their reason to plan for them to occur and then follow through as an efficient causal force. In this age of dangerous, worsening, and possibly irreversible climate change, largely as a result of the unintended consequences of human actions, finding the correct synthesis or combination of these two quite different approaches to the economy and society may be this generation’s, and humanity’s, most important challenge. Hence, essays such as these, attempting to explain and develop the ancient pre-modern Aristotelian approach and its urgent relevance to the postmodern world, are welcomed.
