No CrossRef data available.
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 25 April 2006
Professor Schlozman feels that unless one also assesses three longmemos that accompanied the report by the APSA's Task Force onInequality and American Democracy, one should refrain fromcommenting. She accuses me in my response to the Task Force reports(Bennett 2006) of “not bother[ing] toread the full materials on which … [I comment]” (Schlozman 2006, 55). Schlozman indicates she'd be“interested in … [my] reactions to the whole report instead of anabbreviated version” (55). Since she asks, here goes.
Professor Schlozman feels that unless one also assesses three long memos that accompanied the report by the APSA's Task Force on Inequality and American Democracy, one should refrain from commenting. She accuses me in my response to the Task Force reports (Bennett 2006) of “not bother[ing] to read the full materials on which … [I comment]” (Schlozman 2006, 55). Schlozman indicates she'd be “interested in … [my] reactions to the whole report instead of an abbreviated version” (55). Since she asks, here goes.
There is a much longer version of my reactions to the report and “Inequalities of Political Voice” on my computer's hard-drive. It characterizes the report and the 88-page memo “Inequalities of Political Voice” (Schlozman, Page, Verba, and Fiorina 2004; also available in a shorter version [Schlozman, Page, Verba, and Fiorina 2005]) as illustrative of many political scientists' left-wing tilt (Klein and Stern 2004–2005; Klein and Western 2004–2005; Rothman, Lichter, and Nevitte 2005).
The ideological gap between a left-leaning academe and the American public may have become an unbridgeable gulf. Although different terminology vexes comparisons, UCLA's Higher Education Research Institute found that American faculty in 2004–2005 seemed to be well to the left of the public (cf. Lindholm, Szelényi, Hurtado, and Korn 2005 with the Pew Research Center 2005).
In and of themselves, left- or right-wing tendencies are not worrisome. When narrow ideologies drive analyses of complex trends to the exclusion of alternative points of view, however, one is entitled to ask whether scholarship reflects objective observation, or has become something else entirely. Even if the motivation for creation of the Task Force (and related materials) was “to enhance the public relevance of political science” (APSA Task Force 2004, 1), ideologically driven research risks being irrelevant.