The volume examines the changes in the position of religious and ethnic minorities in Muslim nation-states and the factors that have shaped their identities and relations with the majority populations. The chapters written by noted scholars deal with four religious minorities: Copts in Egypt, Maronites in Lebanon, Christians in Pakistan, Bahai in Iran, as well as four ethnic minorities: Berbers in Morocco and Algeria and Kurds in Turkey and Iraq.
Based on these case studies, the aim of the editor is to “develop a set of factors for a common and larger comparative framework.” Bearing in mind the politicization and radicalization of minority identities in “recent years,” the editor aspires to develop “criteria and models by which to measure, understand and respond to the phenomenon of nationalist reactions to minority expression” (pp. vii–viii). These are certainly ambitious goals that perhaps may be achieved if more case studies are analyzed.
In the category of religious minorities, two good studies by Pieternella Van Doorn-Harder and Charles D. Smith discuss the changes in the relations between the Copts and Egypt's Muslim regimes and population in recent decades, whereas Paul S. Rowe draws an intriguing comparison between the Coptic “neomillet” and the more assertive Maronites in Lebanon. This study highlights the differences between the marginal role of the religiously oriented Copts in powerful-centralist Egypt and the central role of the secular Maronite parties in a weak, divided Lebanon. However, unfortunately it does not elaborate on its interesting concept of “neomillet partnership” (p. 101) between the Maronite community and other sects; this new approach has been initiated by the Maronite church since the Taʿif Agreement (1989). Indeed, against the background of the emerging powerful Shiʿi plurality (estimated 40% of the population) with its Islamic agenda (by Hizbullah), it would be important to further examine the newly developed relationship between Christians and Muslims in Lebanon.
The issue of Muslim attitudes toward Christians and other non-Muslim communities is discussed in two more illuminating case studies: the Christians of Sunni Pakistan by Linda S. Walbridge and the Bahai in Shiʿi Iran by Juan R. I. Cole. These cases are unique and perhaps uncommon in certain respects in Muslim states. Most Christians in Pakistan, unlike other Christians in Muslim countries, were “untouchables” who were converted to Christianity by missionaries in the 19th century and are still considered “chuhra,” or an inferior sweeper caste, by most Muslims. They have been discriminated against and persecuted since the 1990s by both the government and Muslim masses.
In Iran, by comparison, the small Bahai minority have been extremely oppressed since the 1979 Islamic revolution, including harsh measures of arrests, executions, and even pogroms (p. 158). They are not considered a religious sect, not even dhimmī, but as heretics or outcasts. To be sure, the status of Bahai in Iran and Christians in Pakistan is worse than that of Copts in Egypt who, in reaction to the rise of political Islam, have been radicalized and have redeveloped their identity as Egyptian Christians, under the leadership of their church.
However, these different case studies are not sufficient to provide a credible model for understanding the identities of non-Muslim religious minorities or communities in Islamic societies. Other important cases must also be considered: cases of Christian communities that have been largely and peacefully integrated into their Muslim majority nation-states or national communities, namely, in Syria, Jordan, and the Palestinian community; and cases of heterodox Muslim communities—Shiʿa and ʿAlawis, in particular—that have played a significant role in Iraq, Bahrain, Kuwait, Pakistan, Saudi Arabia, and Syria (where the ʿAlawi minority has been in power since 1966).
Whereas the volume's comparative analysis of religious minorities or communities in (Sunni) Muslim societies is somewhat problematic, its examination of Muslim ethnic minorities—Berbers in Morocco and Algeria, Kurds in Turkey and Iraq—is more satisfactory. These four cases are well presented by David L. Crawford, Azzedine Layachi, M. Hakan Yavus, and Michael M. Gunter, respectively. In all these cases the main issues that have contributed to the radicalization of the minorities' ethnic–national identities, and to hindering their integration into their states, are cultural–linguistic, socioeconomic, political, and territorial (not in Morocco). Morocco can provide a promising example for its attempts to reduce the political–cultural tensions between majorities and minorities. It did this by recognizing in 2001 the Amazigh (Berber) culture as part of the national community (p. 164) and using Islam, not radical Islam, and its messages of equality and justice, as a common denominator.
This brings us back to the major point of this volume, namely, that Islam has played and will continue to play a central role in determining the position and identity of religious and ethnic minorities. This important point is outlined in an outstanding article by Richard C. Martin, “From Dhimmis to Minorities: Shifting Constructions of the non-Muslim Other from Early to Modern Islam.”
