Hostname: page-component-7b7567c8c-tnkh4 Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2026-11-16T09:11:35.580Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false

Optimal perturbation for two-dimensional vortex systems: route to non-axisymmetric state

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  21 September 2018

Navrose*
Affiliation:
Département Aérodynamique Aéroélasticité Aéroacoustique, ONERA, 92190 Meudon, FranceDepartment of Aerospace Engineering, Indian Institute of Technology Kanpur, Kanpur 208 016, UP, India
H. G. Johnson
Affiliation:
Département Aérodynamique Aéroélasticité Aéroacoustique, ONERA, 92190 Meudon, France
V. Brion
Affiliation:
Département Aérodynamique Aéroélasticité Aéroacoustique, ONERA, 92190 Meudon, France
L. Jacquin
Affiliation:
Département Aérodynamique Aéroélasticité Aéroacoustique, ONERA, 92190 Meudon, France
J. C. Robinet
Affiliation:
DynFluid Laboratory, Arts et Métiers ParisTech, 75013 Paris, France
*
†Email address for correspondence: navrose@iitk.ac.in

Abstract

We investigate perturbations that maximize the gain of disturbance energy in a two-dimensional isolated vortex and a counter-rotating vortex pair. The optimization is carried out using the method of Lagrange multipliers. For low initial energy of the perturbation ($E(0)$), the nonlinear optimal perturbation/gain is found to be the same as the linear optimal perturbation/gain. Beyond a certain threshold $E(0)$, the optimal perturbation/gain obtained from linear and nonlinear computations are different. There exists a range of $E(0)$ for which the nonlinear optimal gain is higher than the linear optimal gain. For an isolated vortex, the higher value of nonlinear optimal gain is attributed to interaction among different azimuthal components, which is otherwise absent in a linearized system. Spiral dislocations are found in the nonlinear optimal perturbation at the radial location where the most dominant wavenumber changes. Long-time nonlinear evolution of linear and nonlinear optimal perturbations is studied. The evolution shows that, after the initial increment of perturbation energy, the vortex attains a quasi-steady state where the mean perturbation energy decreases on a slow time scale. The quasi-steady vortex state is non-axisymmetric and its shape depends on the initial perturbation. It is observed that the lifetime of a quasi-steady vortex state obtained using the nonlinear optimal perturbation is longer than that obtained using the linear optimal perturbation. For a counter-rotating vortex pair, the mechanism that maximizes the energy gain is found to be similar to that of the isolated vortex. Within the linear framework, the optimal perturbation for a vortex pair can be either symmetric or antisymmetric, whereas the structure of the nonlinear optimal perturbation, beyond the threshold $E(0)$, is always asymmetric. No quasi-steady state for a counter-rotating vortex pair is observed.

Information

Type
JFM Papers
Copyright
© 2018 Cambridge University Press 
Figure 0

Figure 1.Results for $Re=5000$ isolated vortex: variation of the largest energy gain with the horizon time for $m=1$, 2 and 3. The linear optimal gain curve is the envelope of the gain curves for different $m$ and is shown by a thick solid line. Inset is a magnified view of the part of the gain curve where the linear optimal perturbation switches from $m>1$ to $m=1$. The variation of the 2D linear optimal gain for $Re=1000$ and $m=1$ reported by Antkowiak & Brancher (2004) is shown by a dashed line.

Figure 1

Figure 2.Results for $Re=5000$ isolated vortex: (a) vorticity field of the linear optimal perturbation for varying horizon time; (b) the corresponding vorticity field at the horizon time $t=T$.

Figure 2

Figure 3.Results for $Re=5000$ isolated vortex: evolution of the energy gain with time for computations initiated with the linear optimal perturbation corresponding to different horizon times. The azimuthal wavenumber of linear optimal perturbation is written inside parentheses in the legend. The evolution of perturbation is governed by the linearized version of equation system (2.4) and (2.5). The variation of the linear optimal gain with $T$ is shown using a dashed line. The long-term perturbation vorticity field for the computations initiated with the $T=2.0$ and 7.0 linear optimal perturbations are shown as insets. The time instants from which the two fields are taken are marked by arrows.

Figure 3

Figure 4.LSA results for $Re=5000$ of an isolated Lamb–Oseen vortex: variation of the non-dimensional (a) growth rate and (b) frequency of the displacement mode with the size of the computational domain. The results have been rendered non-dimensional with respect to the rotation time of the vortex $\unicode[STIX]{x1D70F}$. The growth rate of the perturbation calculated using the energy decay rate at large time for $T=7.0$ in figure 3 is shown by a bull’s eye symbol. (c) Part of the continuous spectrum for $m=1$. (d) Vorticity distributions for eigenmodes from the continuous spectrum corresponding to two eigenvalues. Here $r$ denotes the radial distance from the origin of the cylindrical coordinate system.

Figure 4

Table 1.Effect of the size of the computational domain on the value of optimal gain for $T=4.8$ and 7.0 ($R$ is the radius of the computational domain). The nonlinear gains are for $E(0)=0.01$.

Figure 5

Figure 5.Results for $Re=5000$ isolated vortex: (a) variation of the nonlinear optimal gain for $T=4.8$ with initial energy of the perturbation. The azimuthal velocity field associated with nonlinear optimal perturbation (at $t=0$) for $E(0)=10^{-4}$ and $E(0)=3\times 10^{-3}$ is shown in (b) and (c), respectively. A magnified view of the two spiral dislocations in the nonlinear optimal perturbation is provided. A synthetic two-colour scheme has been used in the magnified view to display the dislocations clearly. In (a) the value of the linear optimal gain is indicated by a dashed line.

Figure 6

Figure 6.Results for $Re=5000$ isolated vortex: Fourier decomposition of the azimuthal component of the $T=4.8$, $E(0)=3\times 10^{-3}$ nonlinear optimal perturbation ($t=0$) velocity field at various radial locations. Here $m$ is the azimuthal wavenumber. The shaded part corresponds to the radial segment between the two spiral dislocations in the nonlinear optimal perturbation shown in figure 5(c).

Figure 7

Figure 7.Results for $Re=5000$ isolated vortex: variation of (a) the nonlinear optimal gain and (b) the increment in gain with iteration number during the optimization process for $T=4.8$ and $E(0)=0.01$. The suboptimal and optimal states are labelled $A$ and $B$, respectively. The optimal gain reported by Bisanti (2013) is indicated by a dashed line in (a). (c) Vorticity field for the $m=2$ optimal perturbation and its evolved state at $t=T$ as reported by Bisanti (2013). (d) Vorticity field for suboptimal perturbation and its evolved state at $t=T$ as obtained in the present work.

Figure 8

Figure 8.Results for $Re=5000$ isolated vortex: variation of (a) the ratio between the nonlinear optimal gain and the LO-G with initial energy of the perturbation for $T=4.8$ and 5.5, and (b) linear and $E(0)=0.01$ nonlinear optimal gain with horizon time.

Figure 9

Figure 9.Results for $Re=5000$ isolated vortex: evolution of energy gain with time for computations initiated with (a) linear optimal perturbation and (b) $E(0)=0.01$ nonlinear optimal perturbation, for different horizon times. The evolution of perturbation is governed by equation system (2.4) and (2.5).

Figure 10

Figure 10.Results for $Re=5000$ isolated vortex: (a) variation of the energy gain during one rotation period of the quasi-steady non-axisymmetric state for computations initiated with the $T=4.8$ LO-P; (b) the perturbation vorticity field at various time instants marked by solid circles in the gain curve.

Figure 11

Figure 11.Results for $Re=5000$ isolated vortex: (a) variation of the energy gain during one rotation period of the quasi-steady non-axisymmetric state for computations initiated with the $T=5.5$ LO-P; (b) the perturbation vorticity field at various time instants marked by solid circles in the gain curve.

Figure 12

Figure 12.Results for $Re=5000$ isolated vortex: Fourier decomposition of the azimuthal component of perturbation velocity in the azimuthal direction at a time instant in the quasi-steady non-axisymmetric state for computations initiated with (a) the $T=4.8$ LO-P, (b) the $T=5.5$ LO-P, and (c) the $T=4.8$, $E(0)=0.01$ NLO-P. The time instants are $t=25.5$, 31.8 and 59.9, respectively.

Figure 13

Figure 13.Results for $Re=5000$ isolated vortex: variation of the contribution of different azimuthal components of perturbation velocity in the azimuthal direction with time, for nonlinear simulation initiated with $T=4.8$ LO-P and $E(0)=0.01$. The key is the same as in figure 12.

Figure 14

Figure 14.Results for $Re=5000$ isolated vortex: (a,c,e) displacement of the vortex centre with time for computations initiated with the LO-P for (a,b) $T=2.0$, (c,d) $T=4.8$ and (e,f) $T=5.5$; (b,d,f) corresponding trajectory of the vortex centre in the $X{-}Y$ plane.

Figure 15

Figure 15.Results for $Re=5000$ isolated vortex: (a) displacement of the vortex centre with time for computations initiated with the $T=4.8$, $E(0)=0.01$ nonlinear optimal perturbation; (b) trajectory of the vortex centre in the vortex plane.

Figure 16

Figure 16.Results for $Re=5000$ isolated vortex: (a) variation of the energy gain during one rotation period of the quasi-steady non-axisymmetric state for computations initiated with the $T=4.8$, $E(0)=0.01$ nonlinear optimal perturbation; (b) the perturbation vorticity fields at the time instants marked by solid circles in the gain curve.

Figure 17

Figure 17.Results for $Re=1000$ vortex pair: (a) streamlines and (b) vorticity field for the base flow. The Kelvin oval is indicated using dotted lines in the two panels. The vortex separation is denoted by $b$. The approximate boundary of the two vortex core regions is indicated by a dashed circle in (b). The radius of the circle is equal to the vortex dispersion radius calculated using (3.3).

Figure 18

Figure 18.Results for $Re=1000$ vortex pair: (a) variation of the linear optimal gain with horizon time. The gain obtained using the most unstable mode as the initial perturbation is indicated by a dotted line. The bottom row shows the velocity component parallel to the centreline for the LO-P corresponding to (b) $T=0.5$, (c) $T=1.0$ and (d) $T=5.0$. The solid circles (respectively hollow squares) in (a) correspond to data points for which the LO-P is symmetric (respectively antisymmetric).

Figure 19

Figure 19.Results for $Re=1000$ vortex pair: variation of the LO-G with horizon time rendered non-dimensional by the rotation period of the vortex. Also shown is the LO-G curve for an isolated vortex for $Re=5000$.

Figure 20

Figure 20.Perturbation vorticity field for (a) $Re=5000$ isolated vortex and (b) $Re=1000$ vortex pair. The left column shows the field corresponding to $T^{\ast }\sim 2.5$ LO-P and the right column shows its evolved state at $t=T^{\ast }$.

Figure 21

Figure 21.Results for $Re=1000$ vortex pair: variation of (a) the nonlinear optimal gain with the initial energy of the perturbation for different horizon times, $T=0.3$ (○), $T=0.5$ (●), $T=0.6$ (▵), $T=0.8$ (▫), $T=1.0$ (▿), $T=1.2$ (▪) and $T=2.0$ (▴); and (b) the horizon time for $E(0)=0.05$.

Figure 22

Figure 22.Results for $Re=1000$ vortex pair: perturbation vorticity field of the $T=0.6$ nonlinear optimal perturbation for (a) $E(0)=10^{-4}$ and (b) $E(0)=0.02$.

Figure 23

Figure 23.Results for $Re=1000$ vortex pair: (a) time evolution of the energy gain for computations initiated with the LO-P and the $E(0)=0.02$ nonlinear optimal perturbation. (b) Perturbation vorticity field at $t=0.6$ and $t=6.0$ for the computation initiated with the LO-P. (c) Perturbation vorticity field at $t=0.6$ and $t=6.0$ for the computation initiated with the $E(0)=0.02$ nonlinear optimal perturbation.

Figure 24

Table 2.Linear and nonlinear $E_{0}=10^{-2}$ optimal gains $G(T)$ obtained for a Lamb–Oseen vortex at $Re=5000$, with $T=4.8$ using a frozen base flow and a diffusing base flow.

Figure 25

Table 3.Value of $C_{mum}$ (defined by (B 1)) calculated for LO-P corresponding to various horizon times.