Margaret Kartomi’s edited volume, Performing the Arts of Indonesia: Malay Identity and Politics in the Music, Dance and Theatre of the Riau Islands, uncovers past and present artistic practices from one of Indonesia’s most important maritime silk road regions. In this volume, both local and internationally acclaimed scholars have reworked and expanded conference papers from Tanjungpinang, Indonesia (2012), and Melbourne, Australia (2015), resulting in an essential reader that fills the literary gap on this under-researched collection of islands in Indonesia’s vast archipelago.
The four sections of the volume map out the performing arts upon the geographic distribution of islands that make up “Kepulauan Riau” or Kepri province. The first section features five chapters that highlight the historical and contemporary artistic practices of Malay cultures in the South China Sea and the Straits of Melaka. In the first chapter, Margaret Kartomi provides a comprehensive overview of how Kepri’s music, poetry, dance, martial arts, and theatre reflect concepts of place, cosmology, and performance space. The Southern Malay World is designated in Chapter 2 as part of Leonard Andaya’s historical framing of distinct southern cultural and political spheres with differing genealogical traditions (Hikayat Marong Mahawangsa vs Sejarah Melayu) and divergent early histories (Bujang Valley vs Srivijaya). Andaya takes the reader back in time to appreciate the once nomadic Orang Suku Laut, or “people of the sea,” as indispensable navigators who mediated between political power centres to manage the strategic waterways, rivers, and maritime routes for local, regional, and international trade. These two chapters underscore the mixed and hybrid nature of Malay society called kacukan that gave Southern Malays the ability to combine features of their culture, which have been adapted into, and endured centuries of hybridisation with other cultures. Cynthia Chou in Chapter 3 provides new ways to conceptualise “water spaces” by retracing the maritime cosmologies of the nomadic Malay seafaring communities who have historically operated across the entire sea space of the Riau Archipelago. In Chapter 4, Margaret Kartomi assesses the significance of reviving a royal historical ensemble called nobat. Nineteenth century Island Riau and its soundworld is explored in Chapter 5, through Jenny McCallum’s detailed reading of historical Malay and European texts. She concludes that ritual and performative sounds served as a bonding agent between spatially separated groups.
In the second part of the book, collaborations between six local and international scholars address changing musical traditions in the Western Riau archipelagos. Chapters 6 and 7 take on a comparative approach, examining rural and urban Lingga-based genres in which the mixed Malay-European character of bangsawan theatre serves as the Lingga Regency’s icon of identity. A comparison of traditional and contemporary biola (Malay violin) styles sees a range from cosmological ritual (buka tanah) to “progress rock.” The two chapters not only offer detailed case studies, but also illustrate the fluid and adaptable ontological nature of kacukan hybridity. Chapter 8 examines Penyengat Island’s genealogical kinship networks and the strong bonds formed through jiwa seni, a kind of “tacit-knowing” shared between senior and inheriting generations of musicians. Chapter 9 interrogates traditional Malay geometric and cardinal directional concepts of space in Penyengat’s Arab-influenced zapin dances and the short-necked gambus lute accompaniment.
With a focus on the Northern and Northeastern archipelagos, the third part of this book looks at the performances of two icons of identity from the Anambas and Natuna Regencies. A description of the history and practice of gobang mask dance theatre by Sjafaruddin reveals that masked dancers in European dress featured in the theatre today are actually based on real events from 1890, when Dutch colonials arrested local criminals. In Chapter 11, Karen Kartomi Thomas goes beyond a simple continuity and change study of the thirty years that separate two performances of mendu folk theatre to report that the theatre today “no longer functions as an artistic, spiritually-charged, living centerpiece of the traditional village life” (269).
While the first three sections focus on music of the Kepri periphery, the fourth and final section of this volume brings the reader into the musical practices of its metropoles. Chapters 13 to 15 take on Tanjungpinang and Batam, cities with a combined population of over two million, where musicians are accustomed to global cosmopolitan expressions of mainstream Western popular music. Here genres such as hip hop, jazz, metal, punk, and progressive rock fluidly combine with Indonesian pop, Bollywood-inspired dangdut music, and folk tunes called pantun to form the distinctive Malay kacukan music culture so indicative of this region of Indonesia.
As the first edited volume on Kepri performing arts, this book is an important addition to the ethnomusicology of Indonesia. Granted, more unexplored pockets in this vast archipelago remain underrepresented in the literature. However, Performing the Arts of Indonesia goes a long way toward filling this void. The strength of the volume is that it goes beyond descriptions of Kepri Malay worldviews on music, dance, and theatre to engage the reader in important and increasingly urgent conversations about the significance of local notions of space, place, identity, and memory in Indonesia.
