In the hundred and eleven years since Nietzsche’s death, academia has pored over his texts, slowly delimiting accepted truths and known heresies. The more that is known, the more hubristic it seems to attempt any large-scale reevaluation of his work, and recent studies tend to confine themselves to individual titles or limited topics (On the Genealogy of Morals, eternal recurrence). In Nietzsche and the Drama of Historiography, Roberto Alejandro challenges this tradition and attempts to redefine the meaning of Nietzsche’s entire corpus, offering an interpretation that integrates man and work, and highlights parallel tensions in both. His book offers a fresh and thoughtful reconsideration of Nietzsche’s lifelong project.
Alejandro is not the most perspicuous of authors, and it is sometimes difficult to define his positions with certainty. Fundamentally, however, he sees Nietzsche as painfully engaged with the intrinsic meaninglessness of life. Indentured to a “metaphysics of meaning” which he cannot shake off, he longs to impose significance on a world void of its very possibility. The anguish of this impasse leads him to write books remarkably dependent on storytelling, a form which Alejandro considers inherently generative of meaning. Nietzsche may present his observations as exercises in history or anthropology, but they are frequently narrative in form, and even when not, they often comment upon historical topics which, for Nietzsche, are intrinsically events in a grand set of stories. One need only look at his account of the rise and fall of the Apollonian and Dionysian, the genealogy of the term “guilt,” or the opening aphorisms of Dawn. Ostensibly, he is describing the past. Formally, he is elaborating the details of a master narrative always under construction.
As Nietzsche elaborates these historical developments and brings the account down to his own era, he comes to see himself as both an inheritor of the past and as one who can redirect his awareness of human history into a vision of the future. By inserting his own existence into the tales he has constructed, he endows his life with a significance it might otherwise lack. It is here that the word “historiography,” which figures in the book’s title, comes into play. As Alejandro explains, “Nietzsche’s stories, ultimately, are the script in which he writes his own biography as a man of destiny.” (279)
The pursuit of meaning and the construction of such stories set Nietzsche at odds with his own insights. While he aspires to devise narratives and affirm the values they represent, he also sees life as a formless, purposeless interplay of drives, which cannot be grasped or interpreted except by the lights of another drive. If life means becoming, then any attempt to foist being (in the guise of meaning) upon it must seem problematic. Alejandro sees this collision of honesty and need as coming to a head in the books of 1888. On the one hand, these works espouse truth as a way to confound the enemy (Christians, idealists). At the same time, the new stress on “saying ‘yes’ to life,” particularly in Ecce Homo, undercuts not only any claim to truth but the very agon with reality on which Nietzsche thrived. The acceptance of life in its totality as “the innocence of becoming” (an attitude which Alejandro terms “reconciliation”) traps Nietzsche in a world in which his narratives are intellectually indefensible. For Nietzsche, Alejandro notes, “The stories are over”. (295)
Some of the themes just presented are challenging, particularly since Alejandro tends to stress the artistic (as opposed to the historically correct) bases of Nietzsche’s tales. As he puts it at one point, “Is Nietzsche merely fighting his own boredom and passing it off as a grandiose epic?” (297) That would be one viable interpretation, given his book. Further, Alejandro inextricably links Nietzsche’s philosophy with the needs and situation of Nietzsche the man. This has the effect of enriching his philosophy, making it more dynamic and clarifying its stress points. It also weakens it, however, and in exactly the way Nietzsche sought to undermine the philosophies of others, by presenting them as symptoms of personal character rather than as intellectual structures that illuminate reality. Finally, one notes that Alejandro’s book itself tells a story, beginning with Nietzsche’s plight and leading to his crisis of conscience in the final years of his active life. To what extent is the apparent significance of his book a consequence, not of its analyses, but of its implicitly powerful form?
There are presentational problems as well. While Alejandro can write a graceful sentence and he is often eloquent, he shows little gift for the sort of conceptual precision one expects in a work of philosophy. If any term is pivotal in this book, for example, it is “meaning,” as in “the metaphysics of meaning,” the wellspring for Alejandro of so much of Nietzsche’s behavior. Yet in the opening chapters he simply points to but never defines or even characterizes this slippery term. Further, although Alejandro’s first chapter is entitled “Storytelling and Meaning,” he does not convincingly demonstrate how the one leads to the other. The connection between these two is vital to his argument, yet only in the fifth and final chapters, where he stresses the interpretative nature of storytelling, does he provide reasons of the kind that this reader found convincing. It would have been useful to have these at the beginning.
Despite such flaws, repeated readings reveal that Alejandro has thought his position through and that his ideas and insights dovetail neatly and resonantly within a surprisingly revelatory and coherent vision. His suggestion that the reader direct attention to the ubiquity of historical construction in Nietzsche is alone a significant contribution. His recognition that to accept life in its totality can be, in effect, a concession to one kind of nihilism opens new horizons when considering Nietzsche and eternal return. And of course, the above summary does not begin to do justice to other themes discussed in the book, such as a new interpretation of On the Genealogy of Morals and the ways Nietzsche found in eternal recurrence a meaning for life that he ultimately could not discover in art.
Ultimately, this book records a unified vision of Nietzsche’s work that is stimulating, fresh, and valuable. Whether one finally accepts it will depend on one’s sympathy with a notebook entry Nietzsche wrote in 1873: “It is an artistic drive, not a drive for truth, that causes the human being to spin his web over and subdue the past. The perfected form of such historiography is simply the work of art, without even a spark of common truth.” (Quoted on p.299) Those who reject this statement will probably find this book misguided. Those open to its view may treat Alejandro’s book with skepticism, but they will be inspired to read Nietzsche with new eyes.
