Invisible China is an important book. It presents a noteworthy area of research seldom discussed by politicians and policy advisers outside of China. Scott Rozelle is an expert on China's rural development and leads the Rural Education Action Program (REAP) at Stanford University. For this book, he teamed up with writer Natalie Hell to make REAP's formidable research available to a wider audience. Since 2006, REAP has established a large international network of scholars, many of them in China, and has collected an impressive amount of high-quality data on China's rural poor. The program also explores policy solutions in the areas of education, health, and nutrition.
The book's thesis is as simple as it is convincing. China's labor force has the lowest level of education among middle-income countries. This, together with the many prevailing problems of rural education, makes it more likely for China to fall into the middle-income trap. The potential consequences of economic stagnation and polarization pose a high risk for China's own socioeconomic development and the world economy at large.
The authors use macroeconomic data on China and selected current or formerly middle-income countries, such as Mexico, South Korea, and Ireland, to mount their argument for the importance of human capital and high school education for escaping the middle-income trap. They paint a picture of China on the brink of an economic crisis brought about by its own rapid success and the low level of education of its rural labor force that enabled this success in the first place. Since the early 2000s, China's economic growth has led to rising wages and upgrades to production technologies but also production shifting offshore and first difficulties for low-skilled workers to find employment. The authors calculate that 70 percent of China's work force—200 million to 300 million people—were unprepared for China's transition to a new growth strategy, because they lacked adequate education or training.
The book goes on to describe some of the most salient policy decisions and structural developments that have contributed to the current situation. China's slow political acknowledgment of general education as an important factor in economic development has contributed to the country's historically uneducated workforce. China's administrative separation of urban and rural spheres, introduced in the 1950s, has also had a tremendous impact on the current inequalities. The household registration (hukou) system and internal migration controls are among the most powerful elements of this separation that has strongly discriminated against rural migrant workers. Here, the book lacks an updated account of these well-studied structures. Research has shown that in the last decade the hukou system, for example, has transformed from an instrument of separating urban and rural populations to one that differentiates mainly according to levels of education and wealth. Readers would also benefit from a discussion of the more recent reforms that have been promoted as part of China's new urbanization policies since 2014. These include the dismantling of the hukou system and accelerated integration of rural migrants in cities. Whether these reforms will be able to generate any significant effects on China's educational inequalities, however, is still up in the air.
In the final three chapters of the book, the authors substantiate their claim about China's human capital crisis by providing a detailed account of some of China's major rural education and health problems. The chapters rely on several large-scale studies by the REAP team and other scholars, as well as on Rozelle's rich personal research experience. This very readable presentation of the outcome of many years of outstanding research clearly is the centerpiece of the book. The studies provide compelling evidence that, despite the different reform programs and actual improvements of the last decades, rural children in China still receive much less and much worse education than children in the bigger cities. Failings of the recently expanded vocational high school system, the prevalence of rural health and nutrition problems, and problems of infant development are among the most important findings.
Overall, the book makes a significant contribution to explaining China's rural education and health problems to a wider audience and emphasizes the significance of these problems outside of humanitarian arguments. In addition to its specific findings, the book could also stimulate further discussions on how governments shape populations for future economic growth, as well as on the development of rural areas. In any case, it provides an excellent starting point for conversations on the future of labor in China and beyond.
