‘Tradition is only democracy extended through time. . .Tradition means giving votes to the most obscure of all classes, our ancestors. It is the democracy of the dead’, said G. K. Chesterton. Jaroslav Pelikan in his lectures has approved of this way of looking at tradition. In his new magisterial study, Credo: Historical and Theological Guide to Creeds and Confessions of Faith in the Christian Tradition and its three partner volumes, Creeds and Confessions of Faith in the Christian Tradition, ed. Jaroslav Pelikan and Valerie Hotchkiss, this understanding is evident, to both the strength and the weakness of the book.
Credo appears on the 125th anniversary of the publication of Philip Schaff's Creeds of Christendom, and is intended as a replacement for that work. It is intended to be, according to the author, a general historical introduction to the companion volumes which contain the primary material of the creeds and confessions. In addition, it is to serve as a freestanding reference work, or even as a textbook for those who do not have the companion volumes. The partner volumes come with a CD which contains the texts of the creeds in their original languages. Pelikan admits that he could not include all the existing texts in the three volumes or on the CD, and tries to expand on this by referring to texts not included with references in the footnotes of Credo.
The author considers this work a continuation of his lifelong scholarly research into the history of confessions, which began with his doctoral dissertation (1946, University of Chicago) in the examination of the First Bohemian Confession of 1935. Likewise, Credo and Creeds have followed from his magnum opus, The Christian Tradition: A History of the Development of Doctrine (1971–89). Whereas Credo investigates, obviously, creeds and confessions, The Christian Tradition investigates doctrines, yet even so Credo, too, is concerned with doctrines.
Credo calls itself a Historical and Theological Guide to Creeds and Confessions of Faith in the Christian Tradition. While it is clearly historical in so far as it deals with historical texts, and theological in so far as the texts it deals with are theological, how is Credo itself theological? It ends on a somewhat hopeful note, implying that creeds have a future as well as a past.
Yet it is their very ‘inertness’ and static quality [like a CD], their continuity, that enables them, at a moment's notice, to become suddenly dynamic in the sound of a Beethoven quartet or Mozart's Magic Flute – or, for that matter, the Symbolum Nicaenum of Johann Sebastian Bach's Mass in B Minor. Historically, that is precisely what creeds and confessions of faith have repeatedly done through the centuries. And they can go on doing it.
Yet thus ends Credo. There is no conclusion to speak of at all. The question is, if tradition is the democracy of the dead, where exactly does tradition's authority lie? The CD illustration makes a good analogy for the creeds, which likewise go from static to dynamic when spoken in liturgy. However, there is no element here for the authority of creed and confession except for the democracy of the dead. Is this authority merely a genre of democracy that determines creed and confession? Or is there some overriding sway, some theological edge to creed and confession? Is it merely that creeds ‘can go on doing it’, going from static to dynamic, or is it that they must, or should? And which ones should, and why? Our generation will soon enough be the dead for whom democracy of the dead will one day be determined. Yet our generation is notorious for being puny custodians of the theological authority of the historic creeds and confessions. Shall we then in our day make up our own creeds, our own traditions? If not, why not, if tradition is just the democracy of the dead? We ourselves will soon enough be among those dead. The next generation will then have to honour us in like manner. Are there not some generations who should not have a ‘vote’ in our ‘democracy’?
Even so, this is a book which you must have. Read it all the way through, from front to back, or take the detours, which Pelikan provides throughout, to previous subjects and subjects to come. The interlacing of themes and self-references gives the impression of a game of ‘Chutes and Ladders’. In other words, you can read it in a back-and-forth movement as well as front to back. The price of the whole set is prohibitive, but at least buy Credo to have on your shelves as a superb reference work.
