Sufism has always been perceived in the West as distinct from exoteric or orthodox Islamic practice. During the colonial era it was viewed as something primitive, an aimless spirituality in comparison to Christian mysticism. The perception that Sufism “served the function of closing the gap between Islamic law, theology and individual piety” (p. 1) is a very recent shift in Western scholarship. It is interesting that Sufism is not only a contested phenomenon in the West but also a contested tradition in most Muslim-majority countries. With this background in mind, it is a rewarding experience to review Sufis in Western Society. Together, the book's eleven chapters offer a general survey of Sufi networks and their methods of communication in Western societies, with a focus on North America and Western Europe.
In Chapter 1, editors Markus Dressler, Ron Geaves, and Gritt Klinkhammer provide the reader with a brief survey of Western perceptions and scholarship related to Sufism, including some common prejudices. They also illustrate how Sufism blurs the boundary between East and West. For example, the authors observe that there is a subtle tension among Western Sufi masters about the authenticity of their preaching, which is mitigated by maintaining a close cultural relationship between the places of origin of the Sufi orders and cultural contexts of the West.
Chapters 2 and 3 focus on aspects of globalization in relation to contemporary Sufism. Peter Beyer argues that globalization has shifted the paradigms of center and periphery to the point that no core region is any longer perceived to be the center of a religion. After a brief comparative discussion of Judaism, Christianity, Hinduism, and Sikhism, he concludes that all universal religions are global and local simultaneously, and therefore the globalization of a religion is in fact a form of glocalization as well. Although the chapter is informative in terms of the pluralistic aspects of Islamic tradition, it neither focuses on nor reflects upon Sufism in the diaspora. However, it does provide readers with a theoretical framework of the multicenteredness of authority and authenticity in religious traditions. Marcia Hermansen contends in Chapter 3 that forms of communication, especially the Internet, play a pivotal role in popularizing Sufi movements in the United States and Western Europe. Based on the network theory, Hermansen argues that deliberate networkings among the adherents of different orders deterritorialize Sufi movements. She analyzes how the mode of globalization promotes conversion, transgresses locations, and helps Sufi movements negotiate with local cultures.
The next two chapters turn to Sufism in North American cities. In Chapter 4, Michael Frishkopf demonstrates the tension between exoteric and esoteric Islamic traditions among the Muslims of Alberta, Canada. By elaborating on Pierre Bourdieu's concept of “habitus” and Arjun Appadurai's metaphor of “landscape,” he argues that the second generation and nonimmigrant Muslims of Edmonton are not aware that the historical background of the Islamic “soundworld” consists of both oral recitations and musical traditions and that they are prone to delocalize and deculturize Islam. Markus Dressler shows in Chapter 5 how the identity of Sufis is negotiated in New York City. He argues that, in the post-9/11 context, the city's diverse Sufi Muslims have appeared to move closer together while continuing to expand the traditional modes of Sufi activities.
Chapters 6 and 7 both explore Sufi communities in Britain. Ron Geaves notes that until very recently adherents of Sufi traditions in Britain replicated the traditions of their countries of origin. He describes this process of reproduction as “cultural binary fission” (p. 97). Geaves explains that the new generation of British-born Muslims, including those who have converted to Islam, is more interested in the universal version of Islam as opposed to the Sufi version that often mirrors local customs and practices of their countries of origins. He observes that the use of the Internet transgresses regional and ethnic loyalties, which may lead to the emergence of “transglobal” Sufism (p. 110). In Chapter 7, Pnina Werbner draws the reader's attention to the fact that Sufism creates a shared space among the adherents of other religious traditions. She asserts that, on the whole, Sufism is a tolerant tradition that crosses sectarian, religious, and national boundaries.
In the first of three chapters on central Europe, Gritt Klinkhammer argues that in the past few decades Sufism in Germany came to be understood as a way of experiencing one's self, but very recently conversion to Islam has become more visible than the mere search for spirituality. Klinkhammer also explores how competitive Sufi groups are addressing the question of authenticity by inviting Muslim adherents from the country of origin of the ṭarīqa into their groups. Similarly, Søren Christian Lassen observes in Chapter 9 that first-generation Sufi adherents in Germany were seekers of spiritual experience who gradually converted to Islam. He explores how collective rituals, regular meetings, and theatrical performances promote solidarity in the new generation of Sufis. In Chapter 10, Catharina Raudvere and Ašk Gaši chart the important roles Sufism plays in the national self-understanding of “Bosnian Islam” and within a migrant Muslim community in Malmö, Sweden. They also explore how Wahhabism is creating tension among immigrant Bosnians due to its criticism of Sufi rituals. Yet, to many Bosnians, Sufism is not a theological stance but a part of their national heritage.
In Chapter 11, Mark Sedgwick charts the popularity of Sufi literature in the West. He argues that the appeal of Sufi genres should not be interpreted as a revolt against rationality or the crisis of liberalism but rather in the context of “contemporary Western spirituality, as well as of contemporary Western tastes in poetry” (p. 191). He also asserts that Sufism has become a global product, “localized” for Western consumption by neo-Sufis.
Perhaps the greatest strength of the book is that it successfully outlines the ways Western Sufi organizations blur the boundary between “global” and “local.” It also adequately addresses the tensions between Sufism and Islamic modernism and revivalism. The question of authenticity among Sufis in the West is highlighted in almost every chapter. Another interesting emphasis is generational change among adherents of Sufism. First-generation Sufis in the West were Muslim immigrants, but the second and subsequent generations comprise not only the children of migrant Muslims but also native Westerners. In search of a spiritual experience, the latter first become interested in Sufism and then may subsequently convert to Islam. A close reading of the chapters suggests that compared to normative Islam, Sufism has created more of a shared space for negotiation among religious traditions in the secular West. The book also demonstrates how modern communication and technology, especially the Internet, help to popularize Sufism in the West. It shows how the notions of religious center and religious margins are blurred by modern communication and technology.
Unfortunately, the book does not establish a consistent concept of globalization, and some of the contributors often use the term interchangeably with terms such as colonialism, transglobalism, transethnicism, or transmigration. The text also does not address non-Muslim Sufi organizations and networks in the West or questions related to their authenticity. In addition, the editors might have introduced the contributors to the readers. Finally, there are a few disappointing typological errors scattered throughout the book. Nevertheless, I believe this book will contribute to the understanding of the sociology of Sufism, its transnational nature, its diversity of forms, and the origins and causes of its popularity in the West.
