Shakespeare's Troilus and Cressida,Footnote 1 many critics have observed, is an especially dark play: “Shakespeare's most overtly bitter testament, nihilistic,” “perhaps the bleakest of all Shakespeare's plays,” “rancid.”Footnote 2 No one denies that the play can be very funny, but the humor is largely aimed at things we cherish and value—honor, loyalty, fidelity, love—as if Shakespeare's aim were to demolish our deepest hopes. A love story set during the Trojan War, Troilus and Cressida appears to teach us that the truth of love is sexual promiscuity and the truth of war is murder. While some might find Shakespeare's deconstruction of heroism and martial glory disappointing, I think most will find it familiar, modern, even appealing.Footnote 3 The view that wars are often fought for frivolous reasons (Helen!), that our vain desire for fame (which may not be rewarded and which, in any event, we will not feel)Footnote 4 requires violence and death, that honor and self-restraint quickly give way to simple brutality on the battlefield, is not the primary cause, I think, of the sourness and depression that many find themselves feeling in response to the play. Rather, it is Troilus's failure in love that most upsets us. An idealistic young lover, Troilus bets his world on a beautiful young woman who betrays him in the seediest possible way. In what Allan Bloom calls “the darkest of the dark scenes in Troilus and Cressida,”Footnote 5 Ulysses intentionally leads Troilus to a spot where he can secretly watch Cressida flirt with and throw herself at a Greek warrior who is not sure she is worth the trouble. As Troilus watches in disbelief, everything he has counted on dissolving before his eyes, Ulysses says: “O, contain yourself” (5.2.178).Footnote 6
Despite, or even because of, his dastardly role in this infamous scene, some critics contend that Ulysses is “the real hero of the play.”Footnote 7 A reality instructor to naive lovers like Troilus, and fame-hungry heroes like Achilles, Ulysses is the only character in the play to see things as they really are. He “knew all the weakness and all the wiles of human nature … saw through all shams and fathomed all motives.”Footnote 8 He practices “a way of life devoted to truth without illusion.”Footnote 9 “He is Ulysses cum Socrates,” says Allan Bloom.Footnote 10 “Shakespeare is Ulysses, or Ulysses Shakespeare,” says Richard Grant White, “and thus it is that Troilus and Cressida is Shakespeare's wisest play.”Footnote 11
I wonder. In what follows, I will argue against this provocative but questionable thesis, and try to make the case that Ulysses is not the hero of the play, or at least that there are some good reasons to doubt that this is so. I will also try to show that Troilus, if not the hero of the play, is perhaps its only sympathetic character.
Ulysses's wisdom might be more impressive if Shakespeare did not make every effort to show how limited all the rest of the characters are.Footnote 12 Agamemnon is a bad general, Nestor old and nostalgic, Achilles a slow study, and Ajax downright dumb. Among the Trojans, Hector is decent but neither shrewd nor thoughtful, and Troilus has such extravagant hopes for love that he sometimes seems not only immature but ridiculous. Everyone, it is true, makes complicated philosophical arguments, but this is a running gag. When Hector plays the Aristotle card in an argument with his brothers (2.2), our first response is to laugh out loud, not to commend him for being a well-rounded hero. Ulysses, then, is wiser than the other characters, but he seems to use his intelligence primarily to manipulate them to his desired ends. That is, Ulysses first comes to sight as an eminently practical man, a superior strategist.Footnote 13 Convinced that Agamemnon is an incompetent general, Ulysses devises a plan to lure Achilles back to the battlefield in order to win the war. Later, as we have seen, he punctures Troilus's idealism about love, presumably to dispirit the opposition, though his motive here is not as clear as it is in the case of Achilles. But if Shakespeare intended us to take a superior strategist as the hero of his play, one might expect it to end with a decisive Greek victory. Instead, the war goes on and we are left with a brutish Troilus vowing vengeance on Diomedes and Achilles, and, in the epilogue, the musings of a world-weary, cynical pimp waiting on death. The play ends, in other words, with thoughts about love gone wrong, not strategy gone right.
Which raises the question: Is Ulysses a superior strategist? He does manage to criticize Agamemnon's leadership without offending him and to take effective control of the war effort. His primary task is to get Achilles back on the battlefield and when Hector challenges the Greeks to single combat, Ulysses devises a fake lottery to choose Ajax, hoping to make Achilles jealous while preserving him—they could risk the loss of Ajax, but not Achilles—for wider battle later on. He orders the generals to ignore him, and when Achilles can no longer stand it—“know they not Achilles?” (3.3.69)—lectures him on the transitory nature of fame:
Time hath, my lord, a wallet at his back,
Wherein he puts alms for oblivion,
A great-sized monster of ingratitudes.
Those scraps are good deeds past, which are devoured
As fast as they are made, forgot so soon
As done.
(3.3.145–50)These famous lines are immediately followed by another, which might seem to provide a solution: “Perseverance, dear my lord, / Keeps honor bright” (3.3.150–51). But of course individuals cannot persevere forever, and since “the present eye praises the present object” (3.3.179), fame itself is an illusion.Footnote 14 Achilles, as commentators have pointed out, does not notice,Footnote 15 and Ulysses next reveals that he knows about his Trojan girlfriend, the real reason he is reluctant to fight. This dual strategy more or less mimics Odysseus's strategy in the Iliad—if he does not rejoin the battle, Achilles will be denied fame and blamed for losing the war—though Shakespeare adds Polyxena and so makes Achilles's treachery simply selfish.
In any case, it does not work. Hector and Ajax discover they are related and so call off the challenge before anyone is seriously injured. Achilles then receives a letter from Queen Hecuba, reminding him of his promise to spare Troy in exchange for her daughter, and decides he must honor that commitment. Ulysses's “policy,” Thersites remarks, “is not proved worth a blackberry” (5.4.9, 11). Even Ajax, now “prouder than the cur Achilles,” will not take the field (5.4.15). Achilles does eventually return to the battlefield, but only when Patroclus is killed, which was not part of Ulysses's policy.Footnote 16 Achilles's brutality toward Hector—finding him unarmed, he orders his men to surround and then murder him, another departure from Homer—might be due to Ulysses's earlier efforts to separate virtue from reputation and so “liberate Achilles from moral concern.”Footnote 17 If so, it is an odd way to celebrate Ulysses's wisdom. But Achilles's brutality might also be due to rage over Patroclus (as it is in Homer), which Ulysses seems to admit: “Patroclus’ wounds have roused his drowsy blood” (5.5.32).
Ulysses's second great action in the play—puncturing Troilus's idealism about love—is less obviously motivated by military concerns, and almost seems accidental (it is not). Exchanged for Antenor, Cressida joins her father in the Greek camp and Troilus, part of a visiting delegation of Trojans, asks Ulysses if he can see her. Ulysses obliges, knowing Cressida is with Diomedes, knowing what each are like (4.5.54–63 and 278–82), and thus knowing exactly what they are likely to be doing. Since Diomedes had earlier told Troilus, “When I am hence, / I'll answer to my lust” (4.4.131–32), Troilus has reason to worry about what he might find. All depends on Cressida, and Cressida, who flirts shamelessly with Diomedes, disappoints Troilus, if not Ulysses. “Nothing could show us more clearly,” Allan Bloom observes, “Ulysses's intention to demystify the romantic ideals.” But why would he want to do that? To let the air out of Troilus's passion for war: “noble enthusiasm for Cressida, and thus for Helen, and thus for war, has been effectively removed.”Footnote 18 Yes and no. Yes, Troilus's enthusiasm for Cressida is gone, but no, his enthusiasm for war is not removed but invigorated. Bloom makes a plausible connection between love and war, at least this war, by tying both to beauty: “The struggle for the possession of Helen's beauty was supposed to explain or give sufficient reason for the great sufferings and heroic deeds of this war. The love of the beautiful can be considered a noble motive for great dedication and great sacrifices in a way that the quest for money or land cannot be.”Footnote 19 Troilus argued fiercely and persuasively for continuing the war when Hector wanted to give Helen back and end it. His argument hinged on the notion that we ought to be faithful to a cause once undertaken, which is clearly colored by his hopes for, and uncertainties about, Cressida. But if love and war have some things in common in this play, they are also separable. As the play opens, Troilus is not on the battlefield fighting for Helen but at home thinking about Cressida. And this does not seem to be an exception, as Troilus's first line, which is the first line of the play, indicates: “Call here my varlet, I'll unarm again.” His love for Cressida disarms him, and makes him, on his own admission, “weaker than a woman's tear” (1.1.1, 9). After Ulysses exposes the truth about Cressida, however, Troilus is driven by murderous jealousy, vows revenge on Diomedes, lectures Hector to “leave the hermit pity with our mother” and engage in total war, then commits “mad and fantastic execution” (5.3.45, 5.5.38).Footnote 20 Ulysses might have expected as much, as he earlier told Agamemnon that Troilus was “more dangerous” than Hector, “in the heat of action … more vindictive than jealous love” (4.5.104, 106–7). Perhaps Ulysses was playing the long game, confident that Troilus's jealous fury would eventually give way to resignation, or perhaps he intended to speed up the war, confident that Achilles and his fellow soldiers would prevail.Footnote 21 The only thing that is certain is that Ulysses turns Troilus, as he tried to turn Achilles, into a cynical killing-machine.
Allan Bloom suggests an additional motive for Ulysses's “intervention” with Troilus: he needs to see the truth. But Troilus certainly would have figured it out on his own eventually, as he does in Chaucer's story when Cressida fails to return to Troy as promised. Even if knowing the truth sooner rather than later is a good thing, one wonders if Ulysses, who after all is Troilus's enemy, is the right messenger. Bloom admits that Ulysses's action is cruel, though he suggests that delivering Troilus from “false trust” in Cressida “excuses Ulysses’ cruelty.”Footnote 22 Later in his essay, Bloom goes further: “I do not think that he wishes to hurt Troilus. There is evidence that he pities him.”Footnote 23 Bloom does not say just what that evidence is, though perhaps he is thinking of Ulysses's attempt to prevent Troilus from lingering at the scene (“All's done, my lord”: 5.2.12), or the gentleness with which he corrects Troilus's efforts to deceive himself. But it is not clear that Ulysses wants to leave for Troilus's sake, or that he is in fact being gentle in his arguments. He is certainly not gentle at the end, impatiently and callously telling the defeated and anguished Troilus, “O, contain yourself” (5.2.178). Julius Bab's roundabout but devastating comment seems apt here: “it also seems to me to be not altogether kindness of heart that moves him to bring Troilus to so complete an understanding of his betrayal.”Footnote 24
Whether or not Ulysses was simply using Troilus, as he was clearly using Achilles, to advance the Greek cause, his efforts to debunk love and glory take on a life of their own, and are often wrenched from their context and discussed by critics as philosophic set-pieces.Footnote 25 The claim that Ulysses is wise, as we will recall, rests in large measure on the claim that he sees to the bottom of things. Does he? Ulysses's speech about the transience of fame goes further than what is called for by the occasion. In suggesting that fame is not only elusive but ultimately illusory, Ulysses risks engendering (further) alienation and torpor in Achilles, rather than rousing him to action.Footnote 26 But whatever the practical problems, the deeper question is whether fame is indeed illusory. It was suggested above that Shakespeare might think, or at least hope, otherwise. Ulysses would be on stronger ground, I think, had he claimed more modestly that fame is uncertain, which would be jarring enough to those whose lives are devoted to seeking it. But Ulysses doubles down, denying not only the possibility of fame, but the endurance of beauty, justice, friendship, charity, and love, “subjects all / To envious and calumniating time” (3.3.172–73). Nothing lasts but the truth that nothing lasts.
Which brings us to Ulysses's views on the transience of love. Most simply and bluntly, Ulysses shows Troilus that love cannot last because we are frail and fickle. “The error of our eye,” as Cressida says, “directs our mind” (5.2.107). Troilus had earlier expressed such exalted views of love that one wonders whether anyone could satisfy them:
I am giddy; expectation whirls me round.
Th’ imaginary relish is so sweet
That it enchants my sense. What will it be
When that the wat'ry palates taste indeed
Love's thrice-repured nectar? Death, I fear me,
Sounding destruction, or some joy too fine,
Too subtle, potent, tuned too sharp in sweetness
For the capacity of my ruder powers.
I fear it much; and I do fear besides
That I shall lose distinction in my joys,
As doth a battle, when they charge on heaps
The enemy flying.
(3.2.17–28)Harold Bloom is annoyed: “Troilus is fatuous, self-pitying, in love with love rather than with Cressida.”Footnote 27 Perhaps. But he is also young, and this is beautiful. Cressida's more sensible and worldly explanation makes Troilus's extravagance look even more appealing: “Men prize the thing ungained more than it is” (1.3.301). She would know, Ulysses might have said. This is precisely the conclusion Troilus will not draw when confronted with Cressida's infidelity. He cannot believe his eyes—”Was Cressid here?”—and when Ulysses will not play along—”Most sure she was”—Troilus tries to argue his way out of his dilemma:
Let it not be believed for womanhood!
Think we had mothers; do not give advantage
To stubborn critics, apt, without a theme,
For depravation, to square the general sex
By Cressid's rule. Rather think this is not Cressid.
(5.2.126–30)Allan Bloom explains Troilus's problem more generally: “love insists on the universality and eternity of its object, and to the extent that its object is another human being, love is therefore either an illusion or a disappointment.”Footnote 28 But perhaps love is only illusory or disappointing if the other human being is someone like Cressida. That, at least, is how Ulysses replies to Troilus: “What hath she done, prince, that can soil our mothers?” (5.2.131). But if Cressida's infidelity is not representative of all women, then love is at least possible. Ulysses may simply be trying to keep Troilus focused on the ugly reality at hand, but his comment about the faithfulness of mothers undermines his earlier claim that love is necessarily fleeting, subject “to envious and calumniating time” (3.3.171–72). Cressida, not love or time, is to blame here.
If Ulysses pushes things rather far in one direction, Troilus pushes them rather far in another. Ulysses emphasizes the futility of most human endeavors, though it doesn't seem to affect him personally,Footnote 29 while Troilus is a cheerful and passionate advocate of moral commitment and enduring love. One is tempted to attribute the difference to the fact that Troilus is in love and Ulysses is loveless and friendless, though this might be getting things backwards. Troilus's outlook is explored most deeply in his argument with his brother Hector, who wants to return Helen and end the war. In response to Hector's contention that Helen “is not worth what she doth cost,” Troilus utters what is probably his most famous line: “What's aught but as ’tis valued?” (2.2.51–52). Troilus appears to be making the radical claim that all is will or that human beings create value, and this is how Hector takes it: “But value dwells not in particular will. … ’Tis mad idolatry / To make the service greater than the god” (2.2.53, 56–57).Footnote 30 Troilus emerges as the champion of passion, honor, and will over “diminutive” reason, which he basically equates with cowardice:
Nay, if we talk of reason,
Let's shut our gates and sleep! Manhood and honor
Should have hare-hearts, would they but fat their thoughts
With this crammed reason. Reason and respect
Make livers pale and lustihood deject.
(2.2.47–50)But as he continues, it becomes clearer that Troilus is not simply unreasonable or irrational, not only because he makes arguments, but because he argues for something a bit different from what his famous statement about the omnipotence of will might lead one to believe. In response to Hector's challenge that what is valuable or choiceworthy cannot inhere in the will, Troilus provides some examples that seem to show he agrees, at least in part. Initial choices are not arbitrary, he implies, though it is not exactly clear what motivates them:
I take today a wife, and my election
Is led on in the conduct of my will—
My will enkindled by mine eyes and ears,
Two traded pilots ’twixt the dangerous shores
Of will and judgement. How may I avoid,
Although my will distaste what it elected,
The wife I chose? There can be no evasion
To blench from this and to stand firm by honor.
(2.2.260–68)We should not toss aside our wives when they grow old and less beautiful, just as we should not throw away left-over food when we are full or try to return soiled silks to the merchant from whom we purchased them (2.2.69–72). Choices based on beauty and desire should not be abandoned when our desires change, but honored even when it is difficult or inconvenient. As his next example shows, choice can be guided by things other than desire, like justice. The Trojans took Helen, he says, in retaliation for the kidnapping and imprisonment of Priam's sister (and Ajax's mother) Hesione. And they took her to deprive the Greeks of something valuable, just as the Greeks had deprived the Trojans of something valuable: “she is a pearl / Whose price hath launched above a thousand ships” (2.2.81–82). A just decision should not be abandoned when the costs become high. Hector is a bookkeeper, while Troilus claims the moral high ground. Troilus closes with a third argument, that fidelity has its rewards:
But, worthy Hector,
She is a theme of honor and renown,
A spur to valiant and magnanimous deeds,
Whose present courage may beat down our foes
And fame in time to come canonize us;
For I presume brave Hector would not lose
So rich advantage of a promised glory
As smiles upon the forehead of this action
For the wide world's revenue.
(2.2.194–206)Hector now changes his mind and sides with Troilus, presumably because he too covets glory, but perhaps because he does not like to think of himself as an economist. For the flip side of Troilus's crusade for commitment is a life governed by fear, calculation, and the tyranny of ever-changing desire.
This is clearly the argument of a young man in love. It is reckless (Troy may fall) and idealistic (the will has formidable competition); it is insufficiently attentive to justice (to whom does Helen really belong?) and contradictory (if we should stick by our wives, isn't Menelaus justified in coming after Helen?). But Troilus's argument is not simply irrational. Worthiness is not a matter of will alone, as Troilus knows well from his experience, good and bad, with Cressida. But part, a great deal, of what is worthwhile and praiseworthy about human beings is our ability to keep promises, stick by our decisions, control ourselves. The core of his message is optimistic, perhaps too optimistic (and not just about the war), but not so obviously wrongheaded and misguided that he needs a Socratic awakening, if, indeed, that is what Ulysses is offering.
G. Wilson Knight contends that in Troilus and Cressida, Shakespeare is “intensely engaged with purely philosophic issues,” namely, the relative merits of faith (or intuition) and reason (or intellect). These “two views of human life are pitted against each other in the opposing armies, and in the continual and lengthy discussions.”Footnote 31 While he strives for even-handedness, Knight argues that reason often ends in cynicism (especially in Thersites, “the most nauseating character in the play”) and seems to opt for Troilus and faith: “Troilus champions, not only Troy, but the fine values of humanity, fighting against the demon powers of cynicism. … All the fires of human nobility and romance yet light Troilus to the last.”Footnote 32 Making use of the same basic faith/reason framework, Allan Bloom, as we have seen, opts for Ulysses, “who emerges, if in an understated way, triumphant” and “for a few choice viewers or readers … represents the consolation of philosophy in a dark world.”Footnote 33 While theirs might seem to be a disagreement about the relative importance of virtue (Troilus) and truth (Ulysses),Footnote 34 Knight suggests that reason alone leads us away from, not toward, the truth: “the critical intellect by itself, unaided and impelled by intuition or some mode of faith, contains the seeds of its own destruction: it is self-contradictory, uncreative, deformed.”Footnote 35 While in many ways useful and revealing, such “philosophic” interpretations risk distancing themselves from the characters and plot, purifying the contours of the debate in a way that is not always true to the play. Troilus, for example, is not simply irrational and emotional, a champion of arbitrary choice and pointless loyalty. Put differently, he has reasons for choosing love and war, though he clearly prefers the first, which is reflected in the play's title. The fact that neither work out might provide evidence that Troilus is deluded, but only if measuring ultimate value by particular outcomes is always reasonable. Failure in love need not permanently sour us about future prospects, and noble causes can end in memorable defeat. Ulysses, as we have seen, first comes to sight as a strategist, which is to say his reason is instrumental, in the service of an end which may or may not itself be reasonable. Is peace more reasonable than war? It depends on the war. Furthermore, we cannot be sure that Ulysses seeks peace rather than victory. Is being loveless and friendless more reasonable than placing one's hopes for satisfaction in other human beings? It depends on the nature of other human beings. It is not entirely clear, in any event, that Ulysses has final thoughts about these matters: he might just want to manipulate Achilles and Troilus in order to win the war. Insofar as his arguments often seem to go further than what is necessary to achieve merely strategic ends, however, we have some reason to think that Ulysses is more than a strategist. This need not mean, of course, that he is right about everything. While sobering and penetrating, Ulysses's critiques of love and fame, or of the endurance of perennially popular things like virtue and friendship, are not without problems and need not, I think, be taken as Shakespeare's views.
So long as one does not try to fit them into philosophical straitjackets, however, the outlooks of the Trojans and Greeks, particularly Troilus and Ulysses, do point toward different ways of life. Among the Trojans, says Knight, “we find love and honour of parents, humour, conviviality, patriotism: all of which are lacking among the Greeks.”Footnote 36 Of course the Greeks are far from home and family, and the Trojans are defending their city, which might explain some of these differences. And Thersites is funny, if not convivial. But Troilus is all in for love, fidelity, and honor, and Ulysses questions them all. Allan Bloom, as I noted at the beginning of this essay, thinks Ulysses practices “a way of life devoted to truth without illusion.”Footnote 37 Troilus too claims to be devoted to truth: “I am as true as truth's simplicity, / And simpler than the infancy of truth” (3.2.170–71). We appear to have a standoff. Thinking further about the strengths and weaknesses of Troilus's case for commitment, say, or Ulysses's doubts about love, might help us unravel Shakespeare's intentions in this play. But posing a simple question might also prove useful: Who would you rather be, Troilus or Ulysses? This might seem like stacking the deck in Troilus's favor, as there is very little that is attractive (and much that is unattractive) about Ulysses, and we should not equate the truth with what is attractive or pleasing. But should we assume that the truth is unattractive and displeasing?Footnote 38 Shakespeare seems to have had this question in mind when drawing the character of Thersites, to whom I turn in conclusion.
Like Ulysses, Thersites is a debunker. As a fool or jester attached to the Greek camp, Thersites is allowed to say disagreeable and subversive things to and about his superiors.Footnote 39 His observations reach us in a stream of crude and clever insults—about the stupidity of heroes, the looseness of women, and the absurdity of war. Ajax, he says, “hast no more brain than I have in mine elbows” (2.1.45), Agamemnon “has not so much brain as ear-wax” (5.1.53), and Achilles is a “valiant ignorance,” an “idol of idiot-worshippers,” “a full dish of fool” (3.3.313; 5.1.7, 9). Helen and Cressida are whores, Patroclus a “masculine whore” (5.1.17), Diomedes a “false-hearted rogue” and “dissembling abominable varlet” (5.1.92; 5.4.2). As for the war, “all the argument is a whore and a cuckold” (2.3.74–75). Thersites mentions Ulysses twice, each time along with Nestor, who he makes fun of for being old. Thersites treats them as the real generals (“crafty swearing rascals”) behind the figurehead Agamemnon, but does not single Ulysses out, except to call him a “dog-fox” (5.4.10–11). Knight calls Thersites “cynicism incarnate” and thinks “he is blind to man's nobility,” but Harold Bloom's appraisal strikes me as more just: he is “the only character in the play who has an outraged sense of intrinsic value.”Footnote 40 And so he wishes syphilis (“the Neopolitan bone-ache”) upon those who “war for a placket,” and says of Ajax, “Would it were otherwise—that I could beat him, whilst he railed at me” (2.3.19, 21, 4–5). Thersites is bitter and angry because he wishes things were “otherwise.” This appears to be his motive in secretly accompanying Ulysses and Troilus to watch Cressida's betrayal. Thersites knows in advance what he will see (“I'll after—nothing but lechery! All incontinent varlets”: 5.1.102) but insists, like Troilus, on seeing things with his own eyes. He is not disappointed: “Lechery, lechery; still wars and lechery; nothing else hold fashion” (5.2.192–193). “Thersites,” Harold Bloom says, “is by no means pleased to be the savage utterer of hateful truths and I do not think Shakespeare wants us to take Thersites as other than a sufferer.”Footnote 41 But in this particular case, it is not his own suffering that outrages Thersites, but Troilus's. Later, Thersites seeks out Diomedes and Troilus, who have vowed to fight each other over Cressida. While Troilus is naive (a “doting foolish young knave”), Thersites roots for him over Diomedes, who he calls “that Greekish whoremasterly villain” (5.4.3–4, 7).
I am not sure we are to take Thersites to be Shakespeare's spokesman in this play, but he certainly reinforces opinions we already have while reading it: that the war is silly, that Troilus deserves better, that Ulysses is a “dog-fox.” Harold Bloom argues that we can trust Thersites's opinions because “who else in the play is not both a self-deceiver and a deceiver of others?”Footnote 42 While it may not be fair to call Ulysses a self-deceiver, he is surely a deceiver of others. Thersistes does not see him as heroic, nor does he even hint that Ulysses “represents the consolation of philosophy in a dark world.”Footnote 43 Thersites is Greek, but it appears that only the Trojan Troilus has his sympathy.
Late in the play, Hector encounters a Greek soldier in the field and asks him for his armor (5.6.27–31). When he refuses and flees, Hector hunts him down and kills him. Standing above his corpse, Hector says, “Most putrefied core, so fair without, / Thy goodly armor hath cost thy life” (5.8.1–2). “It is sometimes suggested,” the editor of the Arden edition notes, “that the Greek was syphilitic, but what evidence supports it?”Footnote 44 I have asked the same question about the view that Ulysses is the philosopher-hero in this play, or that he is Shakespeare himself: what evidence supports it? As I have tried to show, Ulysses comes to sight most prominently as a ruthless and manipulative (and not always successful) strategist, but insofar as he is more than that, his pessimistic views are not so obviously true that we need unhesitatingly ascribe them to Shakespeare. And as the image above seems to indicate, there is something rotten inside the Greeks, who are, after all, led by Ulysses. On the other hand, there is plenty of evidence in this play that pessimism about the world is warranted. Pick a character, and one is likely to find either stupidity, naivety, deception, cruelty, infidelity, selfish desire, treason, or some combination. The Greeks are worse—Diomedes and Ulysses are crueler than any Trojan, Ulysses more deceptive—but of course Cressida betrays Troilus, and her father Calchas is a traitor. In the largely invented character of Thersites, however, Shakespeare seems to challenge the Ulyssean view that darkness is all. Thersites appears once and briefly in book 2 of the Iliad, where he is described as “the ugliest man who ever came to Troy” (2.2.250, trans. Fagles). He harangues Agamemnon for his selfishness and is then sharply rebuked by Odysseus: “Who are you to wrangle with kings?” (2.2.287). While preserving his abusive manner and righteous indignation, Shakespeare develops Thersites into a shrewd observer of human shortcomings who is nevertheless captivated by love and fidelity. Early in the play, Ajax calls Thersites a “vile owl” (note the nod to wisdom) and orders him on an errand. “I serve thee not,” Thersites replies, “I serve here voluntary” (2.1.96, 98). Thersites is not a slave—to Ajax, to his ugly and deformed body,Footnote 45 to his supposed superior, Ulysses. Perhaps I am making too much of this, but Shakespeare seems to have created in Thersites a character who has every reason to be wholly self-absorbed and bitter and who yet identifies and sympathizes with a young, handsome, and hopeful lover in the enemy camp. Where Ulysses tears everything down and sees appetite devouring all—“appetite, an universal wolf, / … Must make perforce an universal prey / And last eat up itself” (1.3.121, 122–23)—Troilus sees beauty and tries to shape a world worthy of our fidelity. Thersites is free enough to see what Troilus sees and humane enough to wish him well. Looking at the world through the eyes of Cressida or Diomedes or Ulysses, we see weakness, cruelty, and cool indifference toward the highest human hopes. In creating a wise character who cheers for Troilus and opposes Ulysses's unremitting pessimism, Shakespeare seems to be pointing us, however faintly, away from the sour view.
