In his book In Light of Africa, Allan Charles Dawson engages with ideas of Africanness and blackness as they are shaped in north-east Brazil. Although Dawson uses as a main case study the State of Bahia (traditionally known as the ‘African’ heart of Brazil), the author describes how ideas of blackness are constructed transnationally in a dialogic relationship with Africa. He contends that, while mainstream and dominant ways in which black identities are structured over-exploit ‘Africa’ and certain kinds of African-derived culture, the realm of Bahian blackness is better characterised by heterogeneity, escaping a unifying and essentialising logic. To make his point, Dawson carried out fieldwork in Bahia (both in the city of Salvador and in the inland region of Sertão) and in West Africa, interviewing a number of individuals such as African entrepreneurs of ‘African’ culture in Salvador, candomblé practitioners, black activists and street vendors.
The book is useful as an introduction to blackness in Brazil (in Bahia particularly) for people who are not familiar with the topic or the geographical context. Reflecting on blackness as a heterogeneous field, and pointing out its formation in relational and transnational terms is certainly relevant. I agree with Dawson's argument that manifestations of blackness escape essentialisation, being in continuous construction, politically and contextually located, and subject to external influences with unpredictable results. In this spirit, In Light of Africa follows a critical approach to black essentialisation that echoes Stuart Hall and Gilroy in a broadly Atlantic setting. In reference to work already carried out in Brazil, the book resonates with arguments presented by Pinho, Sansone, Capone, Burdick (mentioned in the book) and others.
While acknowledging the importance of the topic and its transnational focus, my impression is that the author does not have sufficient original ethnographic material to shape a more inspiring and coherent monograph. As a Brazilianist interested in race but not specialising in Bahia, I felt that this book confirmed more than broadened my horizons on the topic. Either the book's approach or its conclusions could have been more original, engaging more specifically with angles of the subject that other scholars have not already significantly discussed. The narrative at times reads more as a travelogue containing generic description, while its informative content is too modest in relation to existing work on the subject. Although some informant characters are explored more deeply than others (the African entrepreneur Georgia, for example), they are seldom placed in an ethnographic context that could reveal more about their world, showing their relations and interactions with others, and making these people more representative of a larger sample.
Although the book aims to embrace a multi-sited approach, my feeling is that it lacks focus. The connections and relations between the locales considered (Salvador de Bahia, the Sertão Region, and Africa) lack depth, and the way they are presented seems forced. The choice of Sertão as a place of research, in my view, is not strongly justified, particularly considering that black discourse coming out of Dawson's ethnography in the city of Salvador seems sufficiently heterogeneous without, in theory, the need to look elsewhere.
Each subject treated in the book (religion, art, Africanness in Bahia and black movements) could have certainly been the source of a separate monograph, had they been accompanied by a more original argument and deeper analysis. That said, a crucial actor that lacks substantive attention in this book is the state, including its relations with black movements and intellectuals. To what extent have governments and laws contributed to shaping those ‘African’ discourses that black activists/intellectuals use in Bahia today? This subject has been extensively and well treated, albeit only from a historical perspective, by Paulina Alberto's Terms of Inclusion: Black Intellectuals in Twentieth-Century Brazil, Annadelia Romo's Brazil's Living Museum: Race, Reform, and Tradition in Bahia and Jerry Davila‘s Hotel Trópico: Brazil and the Challenge of African Decolonization, 1950–1980. None of these authors, surprisingly, is cited in Dawson's book. An anthropological reading of this subject would have been admirable and is much needed. Too little reference, in addition, is made to Patricia Pinho's work, notably Mama Africa: Reinventing Blackness in Bahia, which is closely linked to arguments contained in Dawson's book. No reference at all, finally, is made to the work of Ana Lucia Araujo, Public Memory of Slavery: Victims and Perpetrators in the South Atlantic, who is a scholarly expert on the topic of the memory of slavery, UNESCO's Slave Routes programmes, and connections between Brazil and Africa in the South Atlantic.
Dawson devotes some space to Gramsci's idea of hegemony and folklore, particularly in his criticism of the homogenising and Africanising discourses (ab)used by the black Bahian intelligentsia. Sometimes, however, we are left with the disconcerting feeling that, in the eyes of Dawson, Gramsci was directly intellectually engaged with Brazilian blackness (e.g. p. 15). Gramsci's theory was built around a specific historical and geographical context (Fascist Italy) and confusion about this should be avoided. Although this is certainly not the first time that scholars dealing with blackness have engaged with Gramsci, for example, Stuart Hall's ‘Gramsci's Relevance for the Study of Race and Ethnicity’ in Journal of Communication Inquiry 10 (5), a more consistent dialogue between Dawson's ethnography and Gramsci throughout the book (distinguishing where it really applies from where it does not) could have been one of several options to make In Light of Africa a more solid and challenging work.
