Hostname: page-component-7b7567c8c-7pwfn Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2026-11-17T01:47:14.832Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false

Linear stability and nonlinear dynamics in a long-wave model of film flows inside a tube in the presence of surfactant

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  08 December 2020

H. Reed Ogrosky*
Affiliation:
Department of Mathematics and Applied Mathematics, Virginia Commonwealth University, Richmond, VA 23284, USA
*
†Email address for correspondence: hrogrosky@vcu.edu

Abstract

A long-wave model based on lubrication theory is developed for the flow of a viscous liquid film lining the interior of a tube in the presence of an insoluble surfactant on the interface; no thin-film assumption is made. Linear stability analysis identifies two modes; in the absence of base flow, the ‘interface’ mode is the only unstable mode. The growth rates of this mode serve as an accurate predictor of how surfactant concentration increases plug formation time, and the effects of film thickness on this increase are quantified. In the presence of base flow, both the interface mode and ‘surfactant’ mode may be unstable, resulting in a richer variety of free-surface dynamics. In previous work, turning points in families of travelling wave solutions for a falling viscous film lining the interior of a vertical tube with a clean interface have been shown to be a good indicator of $h_c$, the critical thickness past which plugs may form, and this approach is adapted here for flow with surfactant. It is found that turning points in branches of travelling waves that arise from an unstable surfactant mode give an estimate of $h_c$, provided the interface mode is linearly stable. When both modes are unstable, interpretation of these turning points as they relate to plug formation is more complicated. The study concludes by examining the impact of film thickness on growth rates and travelling wave solutions for core–annular flow with surfactant.

Information

Type
JFM Papers
Copyright
© The Author(s), 2020. Published by Cambridge University Press
Figure 0

Figure 1.Definition sketch of the flow variables in a vertical tube with radius $\bar {a}$; $\bar {r}=\bar {R}(\bar {z},\bar {t})$ denotes the location of the free surface; $\bar {h}(\bar {z},\bar {t})$ denotes the film thickness; $\bar {R}_0$ ($\bar {h}_0$) denotes the mean core (film) thickness; $\bar {\varGamma }(\bar {z},\bar {t})$ denotes the concentration of insoluble surfactant at the free surface.

Figure 1

Figure 2.(a,b) Growth rates for the unstable mode in (2.24) and (2.20b) with no base flow for various values of $M$; $S_1=\tilde {S}_2=0$, $\tilde {S}_3=1/16$, $\widetilde {Pe}=10^{5}$: (a) $a=1.11$ ($h_0=0.1$); (b) $a=2$ ($h_0=0.5$). (c,d) Linear eigenmodes for $M=0.1$, $S_1=\tilde {S}_2=0$, $\tilde {S}_3=1/16$, $k=0.7$, $a=2$ ($h_0=0.5$).

Figure 2

Figure 3.(a) (Solid lines) Growth rate ratio $GR_0/GR_M$ for various $M$ and $a$; $S_1=\tilde {S}_2=0$, $\tilde {S}_3=1/16$, $\widetilde {Pe}=10^{5}$. Symbols indicate closure time ratios $t^{*}_{M}/t^{*}_0$, and dashed lines indicate limiting growth rate ratio $GR_0/GR_{\infty}$. (b) Limiting growth rate ratio $GR_0/GR_{\infty }$ as a function of $a$; symbols correspond to values from panel (a). (c) Growth rate ratio $GR_0/GR_M$ in (4.3) as a function of $a$ for various fixed $M$.

Figure 3

Figure 4.(a) Linear growth rates for (2.25) and (2.20b) with $a=1.11$, $Bo=1$ and various values of $M$. (b,c) Linear eigenmodes for $a=1.25$, $Bo=1$ and $M=0.1$. (d) Growth rate ratio $GR_0/GR_M$ for $Bo=0.1$ (dotted lines), $Bo=1$ (thin lines) and $Bo=12.6$ (thick lines) for various values of $a$ and $M$. (e) Phase speed ratio $PS_0/PS_{\infty }$ in (5.1).

Figure 4

Figure 5.(a–c) Time snapshots of $h=a-R$ in solutions to (2.25) and (2.20b) with $Bo=5.71$, $a=1.25$ ($h_0=0.2$), domain $L=16{\rm \pi}$, $\widetilde {Pe}=10^{5}$ and (a) $M=0.001$, (b) $M=0.01$ and (c) $M=0.1$; snapshots shown every (a) $\varDelta t\approx 82$, (b,c) $\varDelta t\approx 164$ in a frame of reference moving with the clean-interface linear mode. (d–f) Film thickness $h=a-R$ and $\varGamma$ corresponding to final shown snapshot of (a–c), respectively.

Figure 5

Figure 6.(a) Families of travelling wave solutions to (2.32) in Camassa et al. (2014) (which is a clean-interface version of (2.25) here) with $T=8{\rm \pi}$ and various $Bo$ and $a$ values; red dots denote turning points. (b) Solutions corresponding to turning points in (a). (c) Red dots denote maximum film thickness, $h_{max}/a$, for turning point solutions as a function of $Bo$. Black line denotes (5.2). (d) Film thickness parameter at the wave crest, $a_{wc}$, and at the substrate, $a_c$ versus $\log Bo$; red dots denote turning point solutions, black line denotes (5.2).

Figure 6

Figure 7.Families of travelling wave solutions to (2.25) and (2.20b) with $Bo=88.4$, $T=25$ and various values of $a$ and $M$; $\times$ symbols denote solutions shown in figure 8; black circles denote solutions shown in figure 9. Red dots denote turning points.

Figure 7

Figure 8.(Top row) Travelling wave solutions to (2.25) and (2.20b) with $Bo=88.4$, $M=0$, $T=25$ and various values of $a$ corresponding to black $\times$ symbols in figure 7. The free-surface location $R$ (solid line) and surfactant concentration $\varGamma$ (dashed line) are shown. (Bottom row) The fluid velocity at the free surface in a wall reference frame (solid line), and the wave speed $c$ (dashed line) are shown.

Figure 8

Figure 9.Same as figure 8, but for $M=0.05$; solutions correspond to black circles in figure 7.

Figure 9

Figure 10.(Red) Same solution families as those shown in figure 7, with $Bo=88.4$, $T=25$ and various values of $a$ and $M$; (black) $T=100$.

Figure 10

Figure 11.Family of solutions to (2.25) with $Bo=0.442$, $M=0.02$, $T=10$ and various values of $a$. Black $\times$ symbols denote solutions shown in figure 12; red dot denotes turning point.

Figure 11

Figure 12.Solutions corresponding to black $\times$ symbols in figure 11.

Figure 12

Figure 13.(a) Linear growth rates for (2.27) and (2.20b) with $a=1.25$, $\tilde {C}=0.1$ and various values of $M$. (b) Growth rate ratio $GR_0/GR_M$ for $\tilde {C}=0.001$ (dotted lines), $\tilde {C}=0.01$ (thin lines) and $\tilde {C}=0.1$ (thick lines) for various values of $a$ and $M$. (c) Phase speed ratio $PS_0/PS_{\infty }$.

Figure 13

Figure 14.(a,b) Time snapshots of solution to (2.27) and (2.20b) with $M=0$, $a=2$, $\tilde {C}=0.1$ and domain length $L=16{\rm \pi}$; snapshots shown every $\varDelta t= 0.4$. At final snapshot, ${\max h\approx 1.37}$, ${\max \varGamma \approx 3.00}$. (c,d) Same as (a,b), but shown for $M=0.1$; at final snapshot, $\max h\approx 1.13$, $\max \varGamma \approx 1.35$.

Figure 14

Figure 15.(a) Travelling wave solutions to (2.27) and (2.20b) with $\tilde {C}=0.1$, $T=20$ and various values of $a$ and $M$. (b) Free-surface profiles $R(Z)$ and (c) surfactant concentration $\varGamma (Z)$ of solutions marked with $\times$ symbols in (a).

Figure 15

Figure 16.(a,b) Time snapshots of solution to (2.27) and (2.20b) with $M=0.1$, $a=1.11$, $\tilde {C}=0.1$ and domain length $L=16{\rm \pi}$; snapshots shown every $\varDelta t= 0.4$. At final snapshot, $\max h\approx 3.51$, $\max \varGamma \approx 2.06$.

Figure 16

Figure 17.(a) Value of $R_z$ corresponding to the final snapshot shown in each of figures 5 and 14. (b) Value of $R_z^{2}$ corresponding to the final snapshot shown in each of figures 5 and 14. (c) Value of $\max _z|R_z(z,t)|$ for each simulation in figures 5 and 14; time has been rescaled for each simulation to $[0,1]$.

Figure 17

Figure 18.For the final snapshot of figure 5(c), the terms of each equation are plotted as a function of $z$: (a) (A 1a) at $r=1.1$; (b) (A 1b) at $r=1.1$; (c) (A 3); (d) (A 4); (e) (A 6). Terms that are retained (omitted) in the long-wave model derivation are shown with solid (dashed) lines.