This edited volume's nine essays provide a welcome survey of recent scholarship on people of African descent in colonial Spanish America. Eschewing frameworks that posit the centrality of Africa or the non-Iberian Atlantic world, the African diaspora depicted here is steadfastly rooted in Latin American history. In addition to chapters dealing with seventeenth-century Mexico City and nineteenth-century Havana, fully half of the book is devoted to South America's Pacific coast and the central Andes.
The essays in part I suggest that Iberian precedents, demographic conditions and socio-economic hierarchies in Mexico and Peru played key roles in shaping diasporic African identities. Leo Garofalo demonstrates that people of African descent commonly journeyed from Spain to the Americas as both mariners and soldiers, and as slaves or servants travelling in the company of Iberian ‘passengers to the Indies’. Garofalo's findings provide grounds for speculation that despite their small numbers, Afro-Iberians could have acted as intermediaries for forced migrants from sub-Saharan Africa. In chapter 2, Frank ‘Trey’ Proctor examines marriages celebrated in a Mexico City parish during the 1640s, and shows that west-central Africans there overwhelmingly married other west-central Africans. Since there were few enslaved people from any other region of Africa in Mexico City at the time, social and cultural differences separating west-central Africans from creole slaves may have been a significant factor in the rise of a broader ‘Angola’ identity within the colony. Chapter 3, by Rachel Sarah O'Toole, analyses the last will of a free woman of colour in eighteenth-century Trujillo, Peru. O'Toole argues that Ana de la Calle's self-identification as Lucumí, rather than, say, Arará or Congo, was primarily an assertion of social status, comparable to her self-identification as morena rather than negra.
Part II focuses on the ambiguous position that Africans and their descendants held in relation to the colonial Spanish American church. From Mexico to Ecuador to Peru, free and enslaved people of colour actively participated in an inclusive religious culture that paradoxically also served as a vehicle for colonialist expansion, class conflict and racial discrimination. Charles Beatty-Medina's chapter addresses the Afro-Amerindian community of Esmeraldas, Ecuador, explaining how Spanish diplomacy and missionary activity in the region from the 1570s to the early 1600s evolved in response to maroons’ ‘unflagging resistance’ (p. 98). Shifting our attention back to Mexico City at the close of the seventeenth century, Joan Bristol examines charges brought against a small devotional cult in which people of African descent figured prominently. In the absence of evidence that their meetings were in any way subversive, Bristol suggests that these unfounded accusations stemmed from the anxieties of ‘middle-class Spaniards’ residing in the same neighbourhood (p. 124). In chapter 6, Nancy van Deusen explores the complex spiritual and socio-economic worlds inhabited by free women of colour who laboured as donadas in three convents in late seventeenth-century Lima.
The final section of Africans to Spanish America is devoted to the nineteenth century, with two chapters discussing the limited reach of race-based restrictions in late colonial Havana. In her essay on ‘whitening’ and multi-generational family formation, Karen Morrison revisits marriage records consulted by Verena Stolcke in the early 1970s, arguing that racial attitudes in Cuba remained flexible much longer than previously believed. In chapter 8, Michele Reid-Vazquez observes that midwifery was an occupation traditionally performed by free women of colour in nineteenth-century Cuba. Colonial authorities’ efforts to replace them were largely unsuccessful, and some women of colour continued to derive social leverage from their occupational identity as midwives. Herbert Klein's concluding chapter reminds us of the utility of comparative perspectives for better contextualising the outcomes of diverse slave regimes, including the drastically different ways in which free people of colour were treated in the United States and Latin America during the early national period.
The title notwithstanding, rather than any type of direct exchange between Africa and Spanish America, the book's thematic focus is on the construction, functions and limits of racial categories within colonial Spanish American societies (pp. 11–12). An overarching concern with race and racialisation seems appropriate here, given that most of the chapters discuss people of African descent in places distant from major Atlantic slaving hubs, during an era (between 1640 and the mid-1700s) that was something of a low point in the transatlantic slave trade to Spanish America. The chapters on nineteenth-century Havana certainly stand out in this regard, but in keeping with the rest of the volume, they emphasise racial dynamics as well.
Taken together, these essays raise fascinating questions for further research. Under what circumstances might Afro-Iberians have interacted with sub-Saharan Africans in places like Mexico City, where there was already a ‘social distance … between Africans and creoles’ (p. 66)? As potential ‘go-betweens’, whose interests would Afro-Iberians represent? It might be argued, for example, that a maroon leader, Alonso de Yllescas, used his knowledge of Spanish culture to empower himself as would-be governor of Esmeraldas, as initially proposed by Spanish authorities (pp. 101–2, 106). Also, the authors seem to agree that African ethnolinguistic identities rapidly ‘broke down’ (p. 31), and that ethnonyms such as ‘Angola’ and ‘Lucumí’ – ubiquitous in Spanish American parish and notarial records – were essentially creations of Atlantic slaving networks. Yet chapters 2 and 3 both convincingly demonstrate that African migrants regularly ascribed these ethnonyms to themselves. If their genuine ethnolinguistic and geographical origins were so poorly understood as to be easily exchanged or manipulated in Spanish American contexts, how could vague ethnonyms possibly have served as meaningful markers of cultural background or, for that matter, social status?
In sum, Africans to Spanish America is both useful and provocative, with chapters drawing on a range of methodological approaches to explore the complexities and nuances of racial identity in diverse Spanish American societies. One of the volume's major contributions is its emphasis on the Pacific Rim, an under-studied site of great importance for scholars of Africans and their descendants in the Americas, as recent and forthcoming publications by several of the authors featured here will further attest.
