One of the principal objectives of Janet Greenlees' book Female Labour Power is to demonstrate that female workers in cotton production really mattered in the early nineteenth century in that they affected the ways in which businesses operated. In other words, work conditions and the process of industrialization would have been different had those businesses been populated solely by a male workforce. Her analysis provides a different perspective on the cotton industry. Instead of viewing workers, and especially female workers, as passive elements in the production process, we are pushed to consider the ways in which women “sought to control their working lives” and how those actions affected the nature of production (p. 1).
Greenlees employs a comparative perspective by studying the industry in both England and America. This is an interesting and useful feature of her book. We learn, for example, that there were differences in the degree of occupational segregation between Britain and America. On the other hand, family responsibilities were paramount to women on both sides of the Atlantic.
Greenlees draws on many sources for her analysis—manufacturing censuses, individual firm records, newspaper reports, and testimony to government investigations—to name a few. Each provides a different perspective, but, as she notes, many of these sources have significant flaws, especially with respect to sample representativeness. The sporadic survival of company records and the sheer variety of sources employed raises concern about the comparability of the British and American samples and even the comparability of the within-country information. It isn't clear that we should, without qualification, apply inferences about wage rates for males and females drawn from a variety of individual firms to patterns of gendered employment drawn from government committee reports.
The first part of the book focuses on the nuts and bolts of the cotton industries: gender composition of the work force and some of the factors that may have contributed to differences in composition: local economic conditions, technology, firm size, and management. One of the themes Greenlees stresses is that no one could fault factory owners for pursuing a cookie-cutter approach to cotton production! There appears to have been a remarkable variety of outcomes in terms of production, firm size, and workforce composition—a variety that Greenlees stresses has been overlooked by economists relying on more aggregated data. This is quite interesting but also difficult to fully grasp. It is hard to get a handle on the most relevant factors that affected differences in the gender composition of particular jobs because of the limitations of the representativeness of the samples and the absence of multivariate analysis. Can we really be certain that “local conditions” were paramount (as stressed in the book) when there is no mechanism to rank the various factors? Greenlees draws other conclusions that were also puzzling from an economic standpoint. For example, she reasons that “limited labor mobility encouraged manufacturers to devise methods for retaining workers” (such as providing a company store) in Britain (p. 23). While at the same time, scarce labor (and greater mobility) led manufacturers in America to offer such amenities in order to attract and retain workers. How can both be true? If workers in Britain were immobile, why would firms bother to provide extra amenities?
Rounding out the first part of the book is an extensive discussion of pay in the cotton mills. By providing a number of examples from individual firms, and focusing on the particular task, Greenlees's work offers a valuable contribution to the literature on male-female wage ratio. Her approach gives more attention to some of the smaller firms (unlike some of the previous literature) and allows an examination of relative pay that does not simply reflect occupational segregation.
The second part of the book focuses on some fascinating topics: gender differences in work time, collective action, and health and work conditions. Each of these chapters was filled with absorbing information and ideas. I particularly enjoyed the discussion of work time, which includes information on gender differences in days worked per month or pay period at a variety of individual firms. The collective action chapter digs beneath union protests to less structured actions that were more common among female workers. She draws on a variety of contemporary sources, such as letters, government and newspaper reports, and argues that the information she gleans indicates that women were not “a docile group of workers” (p. 147) but workers that influenced their workplace. At times, it appears that this argument in the book is given more weight than the evidence can support, but it is nevertheless an interesting and thought provoking read. Anyone interested in gender and work will find the book a valuable addition to his or her library.
